Software
Houzz Logo Print
idiothe

Upright Hostas - assistance please!

15 years ago

Hi, all! I'm working on an article on "vase-shaped" hostas. Surprisingly hard to decide, sometimes, if a plant is truly vase-shaped. I think I'll go with the description "upright" and decide on the details later.

In the meantime, I'd like to generate a list of the top favorites among hosta folks. So... please give me your TOP favorites.

I don't need a long list - Don already did the Large Upright list and keeps adding to to it. I'm looking for FAVORITES.

On the other hand, think creatively. Just because a hosta is upright, that doesn't mean it has to be large. I'd love to have your favorite upright hosta in each of three sizes - like large, medium, and small.

Thanks in advance for your help!

Comments (46)

  • 15 years ago

    I really like Hosta 'Silver Star' for its upright look. It's fairly new here, but looks really good, and it's upright habit really makes it stand out.

  • 15 years ago

    Krossa Regal
    Regal Splendor
    Solar Flare

  • 15 years ago

    Ebb Tide, montana Aureomarginata, nigrescens

    Hey, Jim, do you need a pic of my Ebb Tide? It's certainly not a mature specimen, but the vantage point might show the vase shape really well.

  • 15 years ago

    Large - Nancy Gill, Medium - Kinbuchi Tachi. I don't know of any small ones (yet).

    gesila

  • 15 years ago

    I have to agree with Regal Splendor, and especially Montana Aureomarginata.

  • 15 years ago

    My favorites are~

    Jade Cascade
    Montana Aureomarginata
    Magic Fire
    Sagae

    Wendy

  • 15 years ago

    Giant: Sagae
    Large: Stingray
    Medium: Lakeside Cha Cha
    Small: Beet Salad

    Steve

  • 15 years ago

    Nigrescens
    Regal Splendor
    Krossa Regal
    Climax

    I love M. aureomarginata, but I've never really viewed as an upright hosta

  • 15 years ago

    They don't get any more upright than Praying Hands! My favorite vase-shaped ones are like everybody else's--Regal Splendor, Sagae, Montana Aureomarginata, which is upright but gracefully spreading.

  • 15 years ago

    lol - Praying Hands is upright, alright, but a favorite? It's like a hosta with a punk haircut - lol

  • 15 years ago

    All of the above plus Alex Summers (my current favorite), Sun Power, and Abba Dabba Do.

    Steve-rmore

  • 15 years ago

    Here's my current list of small and medium upright hostas. By the way, it's really hard to determine if all of these are upright or not...some on the list are definately more upright than others. I've noticed that hostas which are grown in shade appear to be more upright than when sited in full sun. Also, some cultivars have very upright petioles, but the leaves cascade downward, often touching the ground. Do you still consider those upright?

    Please give me your input regarding those on my list...are they upright in your garden??? Are you growing them in sun or shade?

    SMALL AND MEDIUM UPRIGHT HOSTAS

    'Applause'
    'Arctic Blast'
    'Atomic Elvis'
    'Beet Salad'
    'Bullfrog'
    'Cascades'
    'Celtic Dancer'
    'Chinese Dragon'
    'Chinese Dragon Streak'
    'Cutting Edge'
    'Elvis Lives'
    'Francheska'
    'Gay Search'
    'Hands Up'
    'Ivory Necklace'
    'Lakeside Love Affaire'
    'Longboats'
    'Ogon Amagi'
    'Pineapple Punch'
    'Praying Hands'
    'Proud Sentry'
    rectifolia 'Silver Star'
    'Red Dog'
    'Ringtail'
    'Rohdeifolia'
    'Sails Ho'
    'The Razor's Edge'
    'Tidewater'
    'Ultramarine'
    'White Necklace'
    'White Triumphator'

  • 15 years ago

    Don,

    This is Lakeside Ninita. It's a small hosta. Would you consider this to be upright?

    Steve

  • 15 years ago

    Steve,
    It's hard to classify a hosta as upright when it's in a nursery container.
    Depending on how the nursery grows their stock, it can kinda mess with the natural form of a hosta.

    Case in point, a year or two ago, I bought Illicit Affair. There were a couple folks here on the forum who challenged its identity saying "mine grows close to the ground and that one is far too upright to be IL". Lo and behold, the next year, it was quite low to the ground.

    If the nursery grows their stock in very tight quarters (one pot right up next to its neighbor), they will ALL reach higher to compete for sunlight.

    From that very same grower, I bought Old Glory about 4 years ago. I LOVED the vase shape it had in the pot. Um, NO.... no vase shape there! It was quite low to the ground again.

    So, I personally wouldn't want to call it vase shaped till I saw it come up from the ground.

  • 15 years ago

    Smaller varieties of vase-shaped:

    Lancifolia (a real oldie but the perfect hosta for many situations)
    Corkscrew
    and I second Praying Hands, a Hosta of the Year this year

    . . . and many of the red-petioled hosta:

    One Man's Treasure
    Designer Genes

    Actually, it's kind of a waste to have red petioles unless it's upright, e.g. Crumb Cake is cute but the red is never seen.

  • 15 years ago

    small 'Fireworks'
    medium 'Regal Splendor'
    large 'Sagae'

    Les

  • 15 years ago

    Liberty, Band of Gold, Deane's Dream, Salute.

  • 15 years ago

    Jade Cascade
    Ebb Tide
    Atlantis
    Flower Power(slow but a unique green)

  • 15 years ago

    I have had to vote for ones I have owned because a favorite IME needs to perform. So I mentioned Sagae, but I really, really like its sports with the wider white margins-if they perform as well as their Mom has. They look awesome!

    Les

  • 15 years ago

    Steve,

    I suppose that Lakeside hosta would be classified as semi-upright, although the form may change somewhat depending upon growing conditions.

    The best method I've found to make a list of upright hostas is to tour a large hosta garden (1000-2000 varieties) and write down the ones which are the most vase-shaped. Then tour another garden or two in which the growing conditions may be different and see if the ones you wrote down are still upright in those gardens. That's what I did at the Convention this year when I went to the various gardens.

    But I seek input from everyone here as well. So I'm wondering if all those on my list are truly upright or not.
    Don

  • 15 years ago

    Don,

    I checked the library, myhosta.net, and the Hostapedia. None of them describe LS Ninita as "upright." Given Melissa's caution above, I think it's wise to wait until I've seen it in the garden for a year, before adding it to your list.

    Steve

  • 15 years ago

    Small - Geisha (aka Ani Machi)

  • 15 years ago

    I love:
    Nigrescens
    Tenryu
    Sagae

    Jen

  • 15 years ago

    Blue Umbrellas hold those leaves up like umbrellas.
    Bernd

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks to the OP for writing this article. I am currently trying to add upright hosta to my garden and I'm finding it very difficult locating ones that meet my needs (ML to L chartreuse). Is it possible that you might let us know where you publish your article so that others might be able to use it as a tool?

    Thanks to the other posters for providing me with some ideas.

  • 15 years ago

    newwo88.... Look for Gold Regal, Summer Olympics and Golden Sculpture

    I'm pretty certain the OP will submit his article to the AHS Journal!

  • 15 years ago

    My Old Glory is 2 years now in its shady spot, 22 in tall, 40 in dia, is NOT low to the ground, no leaf touches the ground. Mature clumps of Atlantis, Big Daddy, Blue Umbrellas, Krossa Regal are upright in my garden.
    Bernd

  • 15 years ago

    My Old Glory hugs the ground! I think mine is 3 years old and about the same size. It was quite an attention getter in the events I've hosted this year.

  • 15 years ago

    Large:
    Leading Lady
    Komodo Dragon

    Medium
    Cool Hand Luke
    Rising Sun (also the most incredible yellow)
    Kifukurin Hyuga
    Blue Arrow

    Small
    Lizzard Lick
    Daltons Pick

  • 15 years ago

    Well... garden is going to sleep and I'm back to working on the article - anybody have any comments to add?

  • 15 years ago

    I haven't found mention of Hosta 'Salute', which is upright anywhere planted in my gardens. Or I missed it.

  • 15 years ago

    Question: Is vase shaped the same as upright? For example, Sagae is vase shaped, but is that true of Sun Power?

    Sun Power

    Sagae

    Steve

  • 15 years ago

    Although I have neither, two "vase-shaped" hostas I plan on ordering in the spring are Unforgettable (24"H) & Gold Regal (33"H). The vase-shape description and height came from Zilis and/or Grenfell.

  • 15 years ago

    First of all, there's Sun Power. Then everything else.

  • 15 years ago

    About the 1st of Sept., I looked over the trial gardens at the Dallas Arboretum. I made notes on some of the varieties that included "upright". This doesn't mean that others were not upright. I didn't make that note on all varieties.

    Lakeside Meadow Ice
    Robert Frost
    Praying Hands
    Victory

    bkay

  • 15 years ago

    Fat Cat is an upright, gold hosta. Mine is only 3 years old, but it is looking like it could get some real size on it. Cool, puckered leaves that are quite horizontal.

  • 15 years ago

    I just took pictures of hostas before another cold night might do them in for the year, and noticed that Sum and Substance was standing upright in shade, but the one in more sun had older leaves close to ground. My Key West is upright.

  • 15 years ago

    I missed the "favorite" part. I was so impressed with Victory when I saw it at the arboretum, that I came home and started looking for it immediately (it came today). The photo isn't great. It's September, after one of the hottest and driest summers on record and is under crape myrtles. We also had two hail storms this spring. But you can still see what a great plant it is for our area. (I see this photo was taken in August and that I can't spell Victory, but it still looked good in September.)

    bkay

  • 15 years ago

    I love the upright hostas and have been adding more varieties to my garden. Some of my favorites include:

    Venetian Blue

    Key West - check out how upright!

    Iris Frazier

    Miss Linda Smith

    Alex Summers

    Masquarade (an upright mini)

    Plus - recent additions to the garden that are not photo worthy yet:

    Nate the Great
    Gentle Giant

  • 15 years ago

    HB,

    That Iris Frazier is a 'Wow' plant. Is it generally available? Can you give us more info? How big is it? What amount of sun do you give it? Where can I get one?

    Steve

  • 15 years ago

    Hostabuff, is that little mini Masquerade the one that was being used as a border filler in some picture I saw recently here on the forum? I've looked everywhere for that picture again, not found it. It is such an impressive plant featured in multiple mini clumps....

  • 15 years ago

    Here is Sun Power, upright and showing off between Journey's End and Blue Angel.

  • 15 years ago

    Steve,
    I agree with you, Iris Frazier is a wow - however it took four years before I realized it. I acquired this plant through a New England Hosta Society Plant sale in 2006. Are you a member? It is supposed to be a large plant, however it looks more like a medium size hosta after five years. Bob Solbert - the originator, was the source for NEHS club plants. You might be able to get it from Solberg's Green Hill Hosta. I'm growing this plant in dappled shade with a couple hours of morning sun. This is the real color of the plant and not the result of a lot of sun.

    Iris Frazier in July:

    Iris Frazier in September (after I weeded):

    Moccainlanding - the Masquarade above is one of the group of Masquarades you saw in another post. I originally had one eye of this tiny plant. I've been growing and dividing that single eye since 2001 to get the group I have today:

  • 15 years ago

    Robyn,

    I do think IF is medium based on what I've read about it. The registry lists it 20x32, but yours looks a little bigger than that. Bob Solberg (Green Hill) doesn't list it for sale, but John O'Brien does. I'll have to make a trip down to CT in the Spring to pick one up. Yes, I just joined NEHS this year.

    Steve

  • 15 years ago

    This Cannuck just fell in love with Iris Frazier!!! Wow is right! Am a hosta collector with huge problem...not enough room on small city property but have 41 hostas anyway (nuts). Collecting minis now and have 8 so far.

    Anyone have a pic of a mature Flemish Sky?

    Most favourite vase-shaped hosta is Sagae followed by Krossa Regal. Striptease might join the uprights as well, at least it is rather upright here.

  • 15 years ago

    Time well spent on the Masquerades, Hofstbuff. Very effective to see them lined up that way.