Software
Houzz Logo Print
hostales

Parallel poll for 2012

14 years ago

I am glad I am not a cat because I am really curious about respondents to the popularity poll. If you have posted a reply to Paul's poll would you post a reply here and I will tabulate the results.

How many hostas have you listed in Paul's poll, and how many of those do you already have in your garden. Please post your reply as my example below:

-I'd listed 20 hostas in Paul's poll

-I already have 19 of the 20 hostas I have listed growing in my collection.

Paul-honk the horn when you are ready to close the polling. I would like the parallel poll to be as close as possible to yours. I believe my email is available.

Les

Comments (37)

  • 14 years ago

    WHAT parallel poll? Where have I been? Not seen it. DON'T CLOSE IT YET.....I'M ON MY WAY....

  • 14 years ago

    Paul asked for not more than 20. I wouldn't post a Hosta that I didn't have in my yard.

    20/20

    Steve

  • 14 years ago

    Yes, same as Steve. I posted 20, and I have those 20 here.
    A bird in the hand.

  • 14 years ago

    I posted 20 and I am growing all 20 of them.

    Linda

  • 14 years ago

    I posted 8 and am growing all 8 of them.

  • 14 years ago

    Posted 20, grow all 20.

    tj

  • 14 years ago

    I have all 20 that I posted.

  • 14 years ago

    20 of 20

    Paul

  • 14 years ago

    20 of 20 too

  • 14 years ago

    Also have 20 of the 20 I posted.

  • 14 years ago

    Same same....20 20
    John

  • 14 years ago

    Listed 20
    Have all 20

  • 14 years ago

    I couldn't list a hosta just from a picture. The pictures certainly do make me drool though!

    20/20

    chris

  • 14 years ago

    I have:

    20/20 in my yard

  • 14 years ago

    LOL

    I guess that is enough of a sample base to get a good read. Since I am the only person who ISN'T ALREADY GROWING ALL of my listed hostas, I had better make it a priority to get myself a couple of Journey's End ASAP.

    I think it was Paul. or Steve that posted pics of JE a while back. The photos were spectacular (as theirs always are) and I thought "my- what a beautiful hosta"! I have simply not seen one I could buy. I couldn't order on-line this spring 'cause no one would be home to receive them.

    I am now, so we might as well consider I will shortly be a 20-20. However, if peeps want to keep replying to the poll, have at it. I sure won't be spending much time compiling the results. (R-R LOL) This must be why we call ourselves HOSTAHOLICS

    While I certainly can't say it is a FACT that all polled in the original poll are growing every hosta that they list, I feel safe to treat the hypothesis as FACT with a reasonable level of confidence.

    But I will continue to monitor this string to see if it has a kink in it!

    THANKS

    Les

  • 14 years ago

    Also 20/20

  • 14 years ago

    20/20 too.

  • 14 years ago

    Ditto 20/20

    For some reason my message was rejected. I clicked the "not squirejohn box" and signed in again in order to respond to this post - no problem with other threads.

  • 14 years ago

    20/20. Though I have only several Dorothy Benedict xOp seedlings, not the Mama.
    Bernd

  • 14 years ago

    12/12

    Although two of them, Paradigm and Inspire Greatness are only 2nd year tissue cultures. All the same, even in their immature state, they are handsome hosta.

    I forgot one for my list--Tokoduma Flavocircinalis. Mine is a long ways from mature but it's great looking even with only 4 leaves!

  • 14 years ago

    Ci, were you wanting to include it in the poll? That would be the other thread.

    Les, you are performing the same function as the election night commentators, right? The CNN channel could use you.

    Love Paul's picture of the punch card ballot, and the reference to Broward County. I bet we have only one respondent from Florida, our Jax lady, ILOVETOGROW!! Not enough of a count to swing the election either way. :)

    Love this whole deal though. Our selections have overlap for sure, but not a totally homogenized plantings. I would really like to see a list of the individual hosta nominated, even if only ONE VOTE for it. I betcha I'm the only one to vote for The Razor's Edge. Something about that particular plant just grabbed me. For one thing, it GREW, and it makes no fuss. There are prettier hosta, but I'm all about dependability.

    Someone nominated Eskimo Pie, and I'd love to grow a nice one of those, but mine died a horrible death about two weeks ago. I won't be replacing it--although it is a beauty. For now I'm falling back on another one which turns white in the middle, White Elephant. Maybe I'll have better luck.

    Anyone else have a comment?

    Oh yeah. I'm hoping even more of the new posters participate, and we can welcome them to the forum. Welcome, welcome, one and all. VOTE early and vote often....who posted that? About Chicago politics, I think.

  • 14 years ago

    20/20

    Steve

  • 14 years ago

    17/17

    I have them all and just posted the ones that year after year grow well..out of the 60ish I have.
    For me-no more ones with white, they all go downhill when the weather is not perfect other than Fire and Ice. It is 5 or 6 years old and gets bigger every single year.

  • 14 years ago

    Moccasinlanding, I'll give a complete list at the end. And also a list of the 100 from 2008 (actually 120 due to ties) for comparison. As of right now there are 138 with a single vote. So a very broad range of what we all think are 20 top hostas in our gardens - probably why hosta are so popular.

    Paul

  • 14 years ago

    I grow all 20 I listed. Looking forward to the results.

    mark

  • 14 years ago

    Steve-I am willing to bet I am the only one who nominated Undulata Marginata. It wasn't a joke. If treated as it should be as an individual it truly stands out in a well laid out hosta bed.

    BUT that is not the only reason I have nominated it. When viewed for its dependability, durability, height of scapes and abundance of flowers, resistance to slugs, yada--yada--yada, it stands out as a special hosta. As far as I am concerned I would nominate it for the 2014 HOY.

    Moc-I nominated Eskimo Pie: but I only THINK I have it. Its my NOID that I now believe was mistagged On Stage. When I posted it as On Stage everyone told me it wasn't and I now agree. I have followed all the suggestions given me about its true ID and only EP has held up. But I am still waiting for it to bloom. It is my ONLY hosta not yet to grow a scape this year. (Wouldn't you know it! It is a watched pot not boiling yet!)

    IF it really is EP, it deserves nomination. If not, it still deserves nomination,but I couldn't nom an NOID could I. It sits out there with my Sagae, takes mid-day sun without dessication, grows through my field of poppy (maybe THAT is what I should name my front garden; "FLANDERS FIELD".)

    I am truly enjoying everyones using this string to comment on you noms. I know I was itching to comment on my top 20 but didn't want to contaminate the poll. So I have accomplished two things with it:
    -We've listed what we grow
    -We love to talk about what we love the most and wanted to add comments

    Neither is exactly a revelation, is it?

    Les

  • 14 years ago

    20 and 20.

    Chris

  • 14 years ago

    squirejohn, I had tried that earlier today, didn't work. So, I am trying it again with fingers crossed.

    For Les
    16/16

    Wahoo!!!!!!!!

  • 14 years ago

    20/20
    Cher

  • 14 years ago

    6/6 (or was it 7/7?)

    Those are the only ones I'm sure I would buy again and recommend to someone who lives in a similar climate. But, I have many that are still young enough to be question marks.

    bkay

  • 14 years ago

    have 20 for 20 here

    jill

  • 14 years ago

    BKay, you are a much more reserved person than I. I've already replaced a couple of plants which sort of croaked or looked like they'd croak. One was Stained Glass--and then the original one rallied and looks really nice, so I have two of those. Then I had a venusta, tiny little thing with only one root when it arrived, so I ordered a second from somewhere else, and the first one croaked for sure so I now have the tiny venusta blooming--which I wanted to see it for myself. And then the first pot of Masquerade kept fading away, so I got another one and both pots kept fading away. However, one of them is trying to grow some new tiny leaves, and I hope it gets to live. I like the small ones with the white centers OR margins, and that is why I got both White Dove (5 of them just in case) and 1 Little Jay. I think you'd like Little Jay. Very pretty, and growing nicely, if you want some small hosta. I have all the small White Dove and Little Jay pots sitting on the soil of a big ficus benjamina pot where they get early morning sun. I listed White Dove as one of my favorites but not the others, because I will replace it if it tries to croak on me. However, I figure with FIVE of them, I'm hedging my bets that I won't lose it. Cross fingers.

  • 14 years ago

    I think if I were a developer of hosta cultivars my next to be named would be H.'Crossed Fingers'. Then moccasinlanding could be 1/1. lol

    Les

  • 14 years ago

    I keep typing a post and clicking Preview, and then the whole thing disappears. Third time.
    Lets do it again.

    Crossed Fingers sounds like a good name to me.

  • 14 years ago

    I'm very happy this poll is taking place. I've come to respect the opinions of folks on the forum, and it takes the place of personal experience. All I get to see of most hosta are the pictures, certainly they are not growing in the average garden in Mobile! We joke and say how the forum enables us, gets up to expand our hosta garden. But it is true that we know someone is pleased with a plant because it is growing nicely in THEIR GARDEN. If a hosta is a slug magnet, and you have slugs everywhere, you have a pretty good idea that hosta will not work in your garden! We learn who on the forum likes the same kind of plants we do. And this is the first such poll in which I participated. Perhaps by the second poll, I will be more focused in the kind of hosta garden I keep. Or not.....but basically, I am fond of the plantaginea family which comes from the most southerly hosta-growing parts of the Orient. Oh yeah. And I also love the tough substanced hosta. It takes a lot to wilt one of those like Rhino Hide or Stiff Upper Lip or Lakeside Pebbles.

    I cannot wait to see the tally at the end. Shopping list.
    :) Thanks for running the poll.

  • 14 years ago

    20 of 20 for me.

    Kent

  • 14 years ago

    20/20

    Jodi