I have two large shoestring acacias in my front yard which were included with the builder landscape package. Although they grow quickly, they make such a mess in the yard with dropped strings and seed pods. One got damaged in a wind storm, so I am replacing them.

I am replacing one with a flowering plum tree, but I would like to replace the other with a tree that stays green all year. I have a choice between an African Sumac, a Chilean Mesquite, or a Honey Locust. I am looking at the least messy, and hardiest of these varieties. My other option is a Holly Oak.

Can anyone tell me of their experiences with these trees? Thanks.