Software
Houzz Logo Print
uroboros5

Dream Weaver vs. Great Expectations

18 years ago

Dream Weaver vs. Great Expectations

I have killed GE 3 times. This hosta will not grow for me. Dream Weaver looks similar. What are the differences in their appearance? Will I kill DW just like I killed GE?

Comments (17)

  • 18 years ago

    I have GE, DW, Dream Queen, and Thunderbolt. GE is the parent, I guess, but the offspring all look quite similar. All are doing fine, although they seem to be slow growers, especially Thunderbolt. If I were picking just one, I think it would be Dream Weaver or Dream Queen which are virtually indistinguishable.

    This forum has had a lot of useful information about GE. Some folks grow it without trouble, but a lot of others have the same problems you have experienced. Don't plant in deep shade and not too deep.

  • 18 years ago

    I'm on my second GE,and it is OK,but doesn't knock my socks off,so far. I have Dream Queen,and so far is a better grower than GE. Phil

  • 18 years ago

    You won't know till you try it, right? :-) I grow them all, no problem whatsoever.

  • 18 years ago

    Dream Weaver is similar to my H.'Lyman' a GE that grows. I had GE in TC and most did not do so well. Out of 1000's I found H.'Lyman' that grows, Dream Weaver is probably the same phenomena.

    IÂve talked about why but it doesnÂt matter why, if you have one that does in fact grow you will like it. If you donÂt it will frustrate you, if my theory is right then it doesnÂt matter where you move it or how deep you plant it that individual plant will probably not grow well. I did find that H.ÂLyman grew really well in my bog in full or almost full sun so I think a constant water reservoir helps a good one do well.

    I have 3 H.ÂDream Queen that are similar but not quite the same and they are growing well, Dream Queen may be cultivar of GE that does well.

    Here is a photo of one of 3 Dream QueenÂs that went backwards but is not putting out 3 new eyes, everyone will tell you that G Expectations wonÂt usually do that.

    Different view showing new growth, you canÂt see the 3 eyes from this angle but they are there.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks you guys!

    I just ran out this morning (30% sale on hosta at the nursery) and picked up DREAM QUEEN.

    Also, HANKY PANKY while I was at it.

    ;-)

  • 18 years ago

    I also found and bought WARWICK DELIGHT.

    I'll be comparing WARWICK DELIGHT, DREAM QUEEN and SUMMER MUSIC (all large white centers with deep green edges) in a fairly sunny spot. I'll be on the lookout for slug resistance.

  • 18 years ago

    Don't know about Warwick Delight but Summer Music doesn't compare to Dream Queen at all, I mean they look so different.

    Be on the lookout for ammonia for slugs!

  • 18 years ago

    This is really interesting! I thought I was the only one who had a certain type of hosta that wouldnt grow no matter what. Its so frustrating to see the rest so beautiful and one dying for no reason. The one I kill time and time again is Elegans. This years plant will be my 4th and final attempt.

  • 18 years ago

    "The one I kill time and time again is Elegans. This years plant will be my 4th and final attempt."
    upnort

    Of course there is a reason, you just don't know what it is.

  • 18 years ago

    I'm going to TRY to post a picture...

    They look a bit dishiveled I know, but they've only been there a week!

    Also, I don't believe Warwick Delight keeps those spoon shaped leaves.

  • 18 years ago

    Warwick Delight does keep the cupping in my garden.
    Yours looks a lot like Warwick Comet, which I like as well.
    In Warwick Comet, the white splash is closer to the tip of the leaf.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with Dave, looks like Warwick Comet. WC is a great grower for me and the leaves hold their shape, a great plant.

    Deb

  • 18 years ago

    I have 74 hostas on my property in Wisconsin, and to me, Eskimo Pie is the one that resembles Great Expectations the most. And, Eskimo Pie does grow better for me than Great Expectations.

  • 18 years ago

    Wow. My two Elegans grow like weeds! And I have them on the north side of the house in sandy soil. My German Shepherd even digs into their roots to lay when its hot out, and they still grow well.

  • 18 years ago

    Great Expectations, Dream Weaver, Dream Queen, Thunderbolt, Lyman, and J.D.'s Luck...it would be great to plant all of these right next to each other to evaluate growth rate and compare characteristics. J.D.'s Luck introduced by John Orlando in 2001 is said to have "a wider and more intense green and blue margin than 'Great Expectations', more substance, faster growth, very little burning." Don

    Here are some links that may be helpful:
    J.D.'s Luck (photo on Hosta Library)
    J.D.'s Luck (Lemke's Hosta Database)

  • 18 years ago

    I can't get off suggesting that one look for a division of a H.'Great Expectations' that has proven it grows well in someone's garden. Anyone who has ever seen or has a good one likes it. My sport H.'Lyman' looks good and grows well, I haven't registered it or sold but I wish one like this for anyone.

    H.'Dream Queen' is also growing well in its first year for me.

    H.'J.D.'s Luck' has one feature that should help, more green and less yellow than H.'Great Expectations'

    Here is a link that might be useful: H.'Lyman' photo

  • 18 years ago

    Great Expectations is harder to grow than most hostas. It needs morning light...additional water...some shade...etc. I also have lost a couple, but now has one that grows well.
    If I were to choose however, I would get Dream Weaver which is stunning at maturity. I's an eye catcher with the round leaves.
    Summer Music when grown in the sun, loses its appeal when the white center melts down. It can even get ugly. In full shade, Summer Music is wonderful hosta all year.

    Papou

    Here is a link that might be useful: Papou's Hosta website

Sponsored
Haus Studio
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars28 Reviews
Franklin County's Preferred Custom Cabinetry & Design Studio