Software
Houzz Logo Print
soonergrandmom

Let's talk peas.....please!

16 years ago

In the past, the only pea that I have ever grown was a snow pea or sugar snap, which I grow every year. Last year I tried planting cowpeas but I got them in too late.

I have asked Dawn and George several questions and have learned several things, but I'm afraid I still don't really know enough. George tells me that long beans are a summer crop and to plant them in warm weather like southern peas. When I look at the OSU listing that Dawn posted on another thread, they also have them listed under "Southern Peas". Johnny's has them listed as beans.

Now here is the part I don't understand. I have always read that long beans or asparagus beans are best if sauteed, not boiled. However, the only way that I am going to cook black-eyed peas is boiled, so why are these in the same group.

I have only grown long beans one time and it was the year I broke my foot shortly after I had planted my garden, so I didn't even realize they had produced beans until after summer had ended and I could finally get into the garden to clean it up. This year I have lots of beans, garden peas, edible pod beans, and several kinds of long beans.

So I think I have figured out how to plant them all, I am not to totally sure I know when to harvest them all, and obviously I don't know how to cook them all. Any help out there?

Comments (6)

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Carol,

    I don't grow long beans, which are not beans and are peas, botanically speaking (more about that in a minute) so I can't say anything about how you can or should cook them. The beans and peas are grouped botanically based on the taxonomy guidelines the botanical world uses, and the botanical world doesn't care if we steam, boil, fry, sautee', pickle or bake them since the don't classify them based on how they are ultimately prepared for human consumption.

    The best way I know to describe it is just to say that all true beans are classified as phaseolus vulgaris and all of the bean-like warm-season peas commonly called southern peas and yardlong beans/asparagus beans/noodle beans are classified as vigna unguiculata, so they are.....well, not close relatives, but more like distant cousins.

    Both the beans and the southern peas (including those erroneously named 'bean' instead of 'pea') are in the same Kingdom (Plantae), Division (Magnoliophyta) Class (Magnoliospida), Order (Fabales), Family (Fabaceae) and Subfamily (Faboideae). (I don't guarantee I spelled all those correctly either). Then, they diverge, and the beans are in the Genus 'Phaseolus' and the species 'vulgaris' (which in this use means 'common', not 'nasty'); while the southern peas are in the Genus 'vigna' and the species 'umguiulata'.

    Phaseolus vulgaris includes all the beans grown and eaten as green beans, snap beans, shellies, and as dried beans, and a small group of nunas that are popped like popcorn. Vigna unguiculata includes all the southern peas (blackeyes, pinkeye purple hulls, crowders, zipper and cream peas) as well as common field peas used for forage (cowpeas) or soil improvement, red peas, asparagus peas and yardlong beans, which technically ought to be called yardlong peas.

    I haven't looked at them in Johnny's but I assume he lists them as beans because that is what they are commonly known as---asparagus bean, yardlong bean, etc.

    The warm-season southern peas and the rest of Vigna u. and Phaseolus vulgaris are distantly related to the cool-season English (shelled) peas, edible podded peas or snap peas, which are Pisum sativum, but which are in the same kingdom, division, order and family and subfamily as the first two but are in their own tribe, genus and species.

    I hope this all is at least as clear as mud. You can prepare any of them any which way your want....

    Finally, I didn't even mention Scarlet Runner Beans which are beans but are in their own species, Phaseolus coccineus. They differ from Phaseolus vulgaris in several ways....they're from Central America and are perennial there, and I believe George has told us before that they are daylength sensitive. They are usually grown as annuals here, but I've heard of people clipping up the foliage and digging up/overwintering the tuber-type roots in a cellar or something and replanting them in the spring. There's also issues with them being considered toxic and having to be prepared carefully if you're going to eat them. And, even though they are called "Scarlet" runner beans, there are varieties that flower in other colors including white and yellow.

    Dawn

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I am not that technical so guess I will just plant long beans and experiment with cooking methods until I get it right. After I posted this I googled and found a little of everything. One lady even said she canned them like green beans. Maybe I am making this too difficult.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    yup ... thanks dawn clear as mud!! hehe

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Carol, I don't think I am very technically or scientifically inclined either, but the only way I know to understand the different peas and beans is to figure out which species and genus they are in.

    I'm really, really not a techical or scientific person at all, and when people who are scientifically/technically inclined start trying to explain something to me that sounds impossibly difficult for me to grasp, my eyes glaze over and inside my head I am silently singing "la, la, la, la, la, I am not listening to you!".

    Here's an example. All my life, I knew you "couldn't" or "shouldn't" plant corn until the leaves on the white oak trees were the size of a mouse's ear. Does that sound ridiculous? Perhaps, but I know that if I abide by that rule, my corn doesn't freeze out because of 'late' cold weather. However telling someone else to use that as a planting rule seems sort of silly and archaic...and not everyone has white oak trees to look at anyway. So, I learned that sweet corn can go into the ground when the soil is at 50 degrees and the newer supersweets need soil temps of at least 60. Now, some people will say I'm using temps that are too low and that it ought to be 60 for regular and 70 for supersweets, but if I wait that late, I may have corn pollination issues if the heat arrives too early in late spring or early summer.

    I've always avoided planting long beans because I didn't whether to treat them as beans or peas in the kitchen, but I have toyed with the idea of planting some this year just for fun and as an experiment.

    Jeff,

    I could have made it even more complicated by mentioning blue beans, which I have grown before, but they are more of a novelty grown for the metallic blue bean pods. Despite their name, they are not in the phaseolus genus or the vigna genus either. They are Decaisnea fargesii. LOL

    Dawn

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Carol, I raised one of the Oriental long beans from Baker's last spring. It was long--up to 18"--but not very productive or tasty IMO. so I didn't even try to remember the name. It was pretty too; the bean pods were a lovely red--burgundy, not fire engine. I sauteed them and we ate a few messes and then I ignored them for the rest of the summer. That's my experience for what it's worth.

    And Dawn, you may not think you are scientifically minded, but you post more technical information than anyone else except George. All I can contribute is my experience since I really am not technically minded.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Dorothy,

    Thanks for sharing your experience with long beans. I've always wondered about their flavor in terms of whether it was good, great or so-so.

    And, you said "All I can contribute is my experience since I really am not technically minded." Dorothy, your experience is worth more to me than any technical explanation ever would be.

    I'll use the OSU listing of recommended varieties as an example. Even though I know those lists contain varieties (mostly hybrids) which have done well in trials or otherwise received good reviews here in Oklahoma, I'd rather know what varieties grow well in your garden or George's or Carol's or anyone else's garden here in our region of the country. There is no substitute for hands-on real-life experience.

    If I can understand the technical reasons behind this or that, it's all good, but the technical explanations do not trump real-life experience.

    Dawn