Software
Houzz Logo Print
katrina1_gw

what zone is it anyway?

20 years ago

Cactuspaul emailed the great suggestion of why don't we begin a discussion and see what others think about the discrepancy found in some of the USDA zone charts.

I see most of the USDA zone charts as listing Tulsa as 6b. On the other hand, every once in a while during my web searching, I will come across a USDA zone chart which lists Tulsa as zone 7.

Which is correct? Does anyone know?

Sure, we do seem to be in a period of time when our winters have been a lot warmer; than say, 10 years ago.

Is this more recent warming tend during Tulsa's winters enough to assume the trend is now the norm? As a result, is it a wise choice to plant USDA zone 7 rated shrubs and trees if one expects them to survive long enough to reach maturity?

Comments (25)

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The chart was revamped this year and a lot of zones changed. I don't know if this is what you were referring to or not. I know that some people who were previously in zone 8a are now 8b and some who were 7b are now 8a. Actually, what they did was return to the zone map of the 1970s. Check out the winter sowing forum. I think they had a link to the new zone map site.

    Susan

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I don't put a whole lot into climate zones. Depending on ones micro-climate, you can get seasonal day and night variations that might make you think your zone is way off.

    I do think zones are great for people that live in town with a lot of concrete surrounding them. I had 2 nights in a row, Last Thursday and Friday, temps were 22 and 24 degrees for night time lows. Temperature maps on 2 different networks both mornings showed there were no lows like that anywhere in the state. I'm sure most of that is because thier target population is cityfokes :-).

    I have commercial grade thermometers and more than just one, so a bad reading is a non issue.

    randy

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The arborday map is the most accurate and up to date in my opinion. Here's the link: http://www.arborday.org/media/zones.cfm
    It's the same as the most recent proposed map by the American Horticultural Society, which was sent to the USDA for approval and seems to have gone into a black hole there. You can put in your zip code on the arborday map page and it will tell you what zone you're in. There's no "a" or "b", which is unneccessarily complicated anyway, due to urban heat islands and other factors. Sometimes you can just look at what's growing in older gardens and take your clues from there. I have relatives in the Tulsa area, and I would say you're in zone 7.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    After checking the Arborday site, I now understand the reasoning for some considering Tulsa a zone 7. It still bothers me though that the site indicated all of Oklahoma was the same zone. Yes it could be wrong of me, but I still have a lot of difficulty believing that all of Oklahoma is the same zone.

    It is true that several winters have gone by without Tulsa's temps going as low as 5 degrees below 0. Even still, it is just too hard for me to let go of the idea that global warming or what ever is blamed for the warm-up is not a permanant thing.

    Seems like there is a pattern of doubting that prevails in my reasoning, huh?

    Well anyway no matter what my doubts are, I guess I will concede with the Tulsa USDA zone 7 trend and let those doubts go.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Katrina

    That's why I think they are a little silly. Anyone who puts Hollis and Tulsa in the same climate zone needs to get out of the office and see the real world sometime:-).

    The same scientists that are screaming global warming now wanted to cover the ice caps with soot in the 70's to warm the earth and stop the coming ice age.

    You scream loud and scary enough and the feds will fund you for a lifetime no matter how silly it is.

    But that's just my opinion :-)

    randy

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Well, if you look at the arborday map you'll see Oklahoma has zones 6,7,& 8, so it's not really accurate to say the whole state has the same zone. And as all gardeners know, other factors affect plants - like humidity & rainfall, soil type, & wind. That map is also very similar to the old USDA map that came out in the '60's - at least for Oklahoma. And of course there is the AHS heat zone map to consider. Zones are of course not definite lines, but a gradient. When you plant you can play it safe or push the edges.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Global Warming and Ice ages

    An ice age would result from a period of sustained Global Warming. It is rather complicated, but basically, with Global warming the ice caps melt. (we currently have lost over 14% of the ice cap already since 1970). The melted ice dilutes the salinity of the oceans. The salinity of the oceans is what creates our currents, which in turn creates our winds and weather patterns. As more ice melts, the severity of our weather would increase - some areas flooding, some in severe drought. Hurricanes become more severe and more numerous and tornadoes, too. Climate changes would occur as the winds change. Coastal areas would become submerged. More heat and moisture creates clouds of gasses and this would eventually cool the earth. Only a slight temperature change is necessary to trigger an ice age.
    Something to that affect anyhow.

    ~ Annie

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I think the zone maps are very flawed, mostly because they are way too simple in that they are based on only one factor: the expected lowest temperature reached during any winter. So, if your temperature usually does not drop below 0, then you are in zone 7, etc. But, in my experience, the frequency of cold is just as important. Case in point: note my official zone designation (7a)! Yes..and that is indeed Massachusetts (along the south coast). But guess what, I can't grow the same trees and shrubs that grow reliably in zone 7a in Virginia. Why not? Because although the temperature very rarely drops below zero here (hence the zone 7 designation), we have much more frequent cold outbreaks than areas in the same zone further south. So in a typical winter, we have a much higher number of days with low temperatures in the single numbers than does Virginia even though the absolute lowest temperature reached is often not that different. And we sometimes have strong winds ushering in that cold as well. So, I think the best advice is to indeed to just look around your area to see what lives and what does not.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hey sweetannie4u, That was very interesting, Out of it all I did not miss the comment of the trend, at one point, beginning to cool the earth down. Of course that most likely stuck out to me due to my natural bent toward resisting ideas which seem to suggest "What is now is most likely what will be, or at least the beginning of an increasing of what will be,"

    Over the decades it has become easy to remember, urgent fads for the moment, hype. Add to that I have lived for most of my adult life so far in a state where the general sense has steadily been: "don't like the weather now; just wait a bit and it will change."

    rjji and Rockman50, your posts seem to ring more experientially accurate. So this makes it easy to identify with and believe your posts, due more to seemingly concrete issues, as opposed to the what ifs, and the some day mindset trends.

    My lack of contentment with the "What I see mostly growing in my area" is most likely due to my seeing the demise of fad plantings of items, which one easily finds at local nurseries.

    In the early 80s lots of local people found an abundant supply of Cottonless cotton wood trees, Today the ones which are still standing are a serious hazard just waiting for the brittle wood of those heavy lateral branches to give way. Not to mention, those Lombardy Poplar trees so many were also planting in the early 80s. They quickly failed in our extremes and multiple cycled environmental events. The amount of those tree, which could be seen abunduntly growing and sold then, are seldom ever seen now.

    In the 90s it was the Bradford pears. Then more currently, how awful those weak and failing Bradford pears failed. Yet back then so many local nurseries sold and people planted them over the last 10 years. Now, locally, numerous masses of people avoided buying that tree as much as anyone would want to avoid contracting a disease.

    I could go on and on, with examples, which serve to deny any contentment for me to be settled with what I see generally planted or offered at local nurseries.

    Bottom line, please resist the temptation to take up an offense; instead, take note that I can admit that the problems with the trees I just listed is most likely cause because of local climate and weather events, which are not compatable with those tree. Which make what I described true, but there certainly must be some place where each of those discussed trees do just fine.

    Thanks for all the posted responses. They have all offered things to consider.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Katrina,

    I do not understand what you wrote regarding my post.

    I was merely attempting to correct a common misunderstanding about the theory of Global Warming and the scientific community. As I said, it is much more complicated than what I rendered above. The complexity of the geology of this earth is not explainable in a mere paragraph.

    However, after reading further comments, I have to say that I am concerned by some of the fallacies being presented here as facts to justify a position taken. Rude remarks about the scientific community is uncalled for in any case.

    As an involved naturalist and environmentalist since the 70s, I recall no such hair-brained scheme of spreading soot on the ice caps by Scientists to hault an ensuing ice age. That is utter nonsense!

    There was a scientific comment made back in the 1950's that mankind was spreading tons of soot into the atmosphere around the world from the use of fossil fuel, namely coal which was the predominant fuel burned for heating and for making electricity. Certain scientists discussed testing this theory to see if the soot in our atmosphere could effectively melt the polar caps and might be partially responsible for the evidence discovered that the ice caps had begun to melt.
    Don't believe everything you read on one of those Neo-Con websites where facts are distorted to their own prejudices and purposes, either out of sheer ignorance or for political-economical and socialogical designs.

    Politicians from all sides are playing "hot potato" with this issue, and a great many other issues, because they know it will excite the public into taking sides. They are all playing the same game. We are being duped by them all. Their only reason for anything they say is to get the people to elect them so they will have money and power and influece for their own purposes and for the benefit of their backers and constituents.

    The scientific community has had little if anything to do with politics, although they have always been at its mercy just as everyone else, if not more so. There is plenty of scientific evidence for Global Warming.

    Of course, you may choose to believe it or not, but don't use the distorted facts, tales and hearsay of others to prove your position on a subject that you seem to know so little about.

    But 'nuff said.
    Let's stick to gardening, shall we?

    Peace and Love,
    ~ Annie

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It's a shame you have decided to be so rude about my statement.

    Here is an article from Newsweek magazine April 28th, 1975 where climatiloigists were skeptical politians would take any possitive actions towards global cooling.

    You might read the the couple paragraphs under the average temperature change graph.

    You attack me and then end your post peace and love?

    Grow up, this is not the 70's.

    It might be best for us to leave our political feelings to our selves.

    Guess I don't like being called a liar.

    A somewhat angry old man

    randy

    Here is a link that might be useful: Newsweek article

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Since this came off a "NEO-CON" website, I guess it's not believable, but any reasonable human may choose to word search the title "The Cooling World" and possibly the same article might pop up on a more believable website :-).

    I really thought better of you Annie. It's a shame you had to be so volatile.

    Do me a favor and avoid me like the plague. I'll return the favor:-).

    The Cooling World
    (The next big environmental scare, as reported by Newsweek several decades ago)
    By Peter Gwynne
    Newsweek
    28 April 1975
    There are ominous signs that the Earth's weather patterns have begun to change dramatically and that these changes may portend a drastic decline in food production--with serious political implications for just about every nation on Earth. The drop in food output could begin quite soon, perhaps only 10 years from now. The regions destined to feel its impact are the great wheat-producing lands of Canada and the U.S.S.R. in the North, along with a number of marginally self-sufficient tropical areas--parts of India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Indochina and Indonesia--where the growing season is dependent upon the rains brought by the monsoon.

    The evidence in support of these predictions has now begun to accumulate so massively that meteorologists are hard-pressed to keep up with it. In England, farmers have seen their growing season decline by about two weeks since 1950, with a resultant overall loss in grain production estimated at up to 100,000 tons annually.

    During the same time, the average temperature around the equator has risen by a fraction of a degree--a fraction that in some areas can mean drought and desolation. Last April, in the most devastating outbreak of tornadoes ever recorded, 148 twisters killed more than 300 people and caused half a billion dollars' worth of damage in 13 U.S. states.

    To scientists, these seemingly disparate incidents represent the advance signs of fundamental changes in the world's weather. Meteorologists disagree about the cause and extent of the trend, as well as over its specific impact on local weather conditions. But they are almost unanimous in the view that the trend will reduce agricultural productivity for the rest of the century. If the climatic change is as profound as some of the pessimists fear, the resulting famines could be catastrophic.

    "A major climatic change would force economic and social adjustments on a worldwide scale," warns a recent report by the National Academy of Sciences, "because the global patterns of food production and population that have evolved are implicitly dependent on the climate of the present century."

    A survey completed last year by Dr. Murray Mitchell of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration reveals a drop of half a degree in average ground temperatures in the Northern Hemisphere between 1945 and 1968. According to George Kukla of Columbia University, satellite photos indicated a sudden, large increase in Northern Hemisphere snow cover in the winter of 1971-72. And a study released last month by two NOAA scientists notes that the amount of sunshine reaching the ground in the continental U.S. diminished by 1.3% between 1964 and 1972.

    To the layman, the relatively small changes in temperature and sunshine can be highly misleading. Reid Bryson of the University of Wisconsin points out that the Earth's average temperature during the great Ice Ages was only about seven degrees lower than during its warmest eras--and that the present decline has taken the planet about a sixth of the way toward the Ice Age average.

    Others regard the cooling as a reversion to the "little ice age" conditions that brought bitter winters to much of Europe and northern America between 1600 and 1900--years when the Thames used to freeze so solidly that Londoners roasted oxen on the ice and when iceboats sailed the Hudson River almost as far south as New York City.

    Just what causes the onset of major and minor ice ages remains a mystery. "Our knowledge of the mechanisms of climatic change is at least as fragmentary as our data," concedes the National Academy of Sciences report. "Not only are the basic scientific questions largely unanswered, but in many cases we do not yet know enough to pose the key questions."

    Meteorologists think that they can forecast the short-term results of the return to the norm of the last century. They begin by noting the slight drop in overall temperature that produces large numbers of pressure centers in the upper atmosphere. These break up the smooth flow of westerly winds over temperate areas. The stagnant air produced in this way causes an increase in extremes of local weather such as droughts, floods, extended dry spells, long freezes, delayed monsoons and even local temperature increases--all of which have a direct impact on food supplies.

    "The world's food-producing system," warns Dr. James D. McQuigg of NOAA's Center for Climatic and Environmental Assessment, "is much more sensitive to the weather variable than it was even five years ago."

    Furthermore, the growth of world population and creation of new national boundaries make it impossible for starving peoples to migrate from their devastated fields, as they did during past famines.

    Climatologists are pessimistic that political leaders will take any positive action to compensate for the climatic change, or even to allay its effects.

    They concede that some of the more spectacular solutions proposed, such as melting the Arctic ice cap by covering it with black soot or diverting arctic rivers, might create problems far greater than those they solve. But the scientists see few signs that government leaders anywhere are even prepared to take the simple measures of stockpiling food or of introducing the variables of climatic uncertainty into economic projections of future food supplies. The longer the planners delay, the more difficult will they find it to cope with climatic change once the results become grim reality.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I did not attack you Randy. I was on the defensive and a bit miffed that comments were made about scientists. I was taken aback that what I wrote about Global Warming was sniffed at and urinated on.

    What I wrote had nothing to do with the topic of this post (the confusion with all the different zoning maps). It was merely to try to clarify (in very simple terms) what the theory of Global Warming is about as I felt you (all) did not quite grasp.

    I called no one on this forum a liar. I said the article was written with distorted facts. That you found it in Newsweek doesn't change my opinion to any variance.

    The article, "The Cooling Earth" is talking about the results of Global Warming. The end results would be that the Northern Hemisphere that is now a temporate climate would become a much colder climate.

    With Global Warming, high concentrations of Co2 that have reached the upper atmosphere traps the earths heat and creates "a greenhouse effect". One of the affects is that the polar ice caps are melting. Geologists have discovered through ice core samples that this has happened several times in the earth's long history, but never did it occur so rapidly. Hence this and other data seems to concur that air pollution created by mankind is contributing to the excelleration of Global Warming.

    As the ice caps melt, the salinity of the oceans is diluted with the fresh water from the melting ice. The reason this is significant is that it is the salinity of the ocean that affects the density of the water and thereby affecting the rate by which the warm and cold waters rise and sink, which is what creates the currents in the oceans. If this action cannot take place, the currents would change or even cease to move at all. The currents could change or stall out. This would effect the warming of the Gulf Stream that determines the climate in Northern Europe and North America. The Gulf Stream is the only reason why Great Britain isn't frozen like a popsicle! The Gulf Stream is what keeps the whole northern hemisphere (North America, Europe and Great Britain) from being much colder. Therefore, it is conceivable that the end result of Global Warming would be the return of a much colder climate for all the northern hemisphere.
    That is it in a nutshell.

    Again, I was not attacking you Randy or anyone else on this forum, but I was saying, rather strongly I guess , that you should not make comments about things you don't know anything about. I am sorry I was misunderstood.

    And the Peace / Love thing was only to say that although I may have stong feelings about what I am writing, I am not attacking or angry with anyone. I have used that all these years, and have used it on other forums, but never have on the Oklahoma one that I can recall.

    Peace and Love are the words of Jesus.
    Love is the most important Commandment Jesus gave us.
    Love GOD first with all your heart and soul and then love you neighbor as you love yourself. If we kept that law there would be no need for any other Commandments. And if our hearts could become pure, we would find the Peace He spoke of.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Oh, please do not let my original question get lost in the focus of the initial post. I am sorry if any of my previous posts led away from the initial focus.

    I just spent the last three hours searching for statistics on Tulsa's yearly high and low temps, and specifically, when did Tulsa last experience temps below 0 degrees F. (USDA Zone 7). All I could find was what I think concerned a 2003/2004 National weather document issued from The National Weather Service's Tulsa office. That issue stated that as of 2004 the Christmas of 1983 was the coldest ever in Tulsa with a morning low temp of -2 degrees followed by a day time high of 12 degrees F.(definately zone 6b.)

    Then later I found a statement, in what seemed like a 2005 report, which indicated that December 2004 experienced some low temps which dropped into the single digits. Of course those single digit temp. drops were not lower than zone 7, but it was awfully close. Neither did the 2005 report mention any December temps after 1983 actually falling below 0 degrees F.

    The above research also made me realize there were many more winter days over many more years where the wind chill factor had fallen to -5 degrees (zone 6b.) That made me wonder; if I just simply had not kept in mind the concept that those wind chill factors were never factored in when experts designed the USDA Plant Hardiness Zones.

    That assumption error found in my initial conclusions along with the 1983 Christmas, and 2004 Dec. low temp reports put just a small glimmer of suggestion in my mind that maybe the National Arboratum (sp?) map which listed Tulsa as a zone 7 was right.

    Yet I still can not be certain; there is still January, which for most years seem to be the coldest month in Tulsa, to be considered. Since no data came up in my search for January yearly statistics, I knew such lacking data, prevented my complete acceptance that the Zone 7 listing for Tulsa is right.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Annie

    It's a good thing we have you here to explain to the " don't know what your talking about crowd" the complexity of what it is that we don't know :-). How condescending.

    As I said before, please leave your political views at the house. It doesn't belong here.

    I enjoy interacting with you about weather, animals, plants, and family. How about we get back to that?

    Still a somewhat miffed "don't know what I'm talking about" old man

    randy

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Remember, the what zone is it anyway focus?

    Yikes, Once again, who to believe? the National Arborday map site, which I checked again today, pulls up a Tulsa zip code as an USDA zone 7.

    The National Arboratum on the other hand, which I saw listed as developed in 1990 by comparing previous daily lows and highs temp statistics covering a 12 year period, and which included the 1983 year (note: if you did not want to read my last really long post, where I described a report I found which documents an extreme weather event: cold Christmas that year when low morning temps dropped to -2 degrees F. and the high that day rose to 12 degrees) does not.

    I now am left wondering if since the National Arboratum distribution (via website)of an USDA Plant Hardiness Zone map from 1990 with data base statistics and comparisons covering at least 12 years prior to that and, which concluded Tulsa to be a zone 6b, makes them the ones contibuting to this confusion delima.

    Who is right? I just do not know! The last 2 winters certainly tend to confirm the National Arbor days zone map; even if, they neglected to acknowledge the extremely different climates one can find between certain compared regions of Oklahoma. That, though, does not seem to cancel out the informational indicators, which still seem to offer reasonable considerations for suggesting that the National Arboratum is right and the recent warm-ups will definately not stay.

    I certainly would like it if, I could find some statistics on the January temps from at least 1983 through the present. Maybe that missing data is what I need to help me come to a more steady conclusion.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Katrina

    I admire your locked on focus:-). Sorry to have hijacked your thread. Hope you find the answers you're looking for.

    randy

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I genuinely was only wanting to explain the scientific position on the theory of Global Warming. I was not the one who brought political slant into this forum discussion.

    Isn't it just too ironic that the comment about "scientists spreading soot on the ice caps" and the 1975 article in Newsweek both just happened to be posted at PoliPundit.com website in the same column...just a few numbers apart where the term "Enviro-Nazi" is applied to those who care about the earth and all it's life forms???

    PoliPundit.Com
    Thursday, May 26th, 2005
    Idle Time, Idle Minds
    (Posts about Global Warming - pros and cons)

    # 28 Excerpts

    Newsweek April 28, 1975

    The Cooling World

    There are ominous signs that the earths weather patterns have begun to change dramatically and that these changes may portend a drastic decline in food production.

    The evidence in support of these predictions has now begun to accumulate so massively that meteorologists are hard pressed to keep up with it.

    In England, farmers have seen their growing season decline by about two weeks since 1950...."

    Comment by Oak Leaf : Email : 5/26/2005 - 6:42 pm
    ----------------------------------------------------
    and then...
    ----------------------------------------------------
    # 35 "Likeable Liberal, ...
    Just remember, that only 25 years ago, scientists "proposed melting the arctic ice cap by covering it with black soot or diverting arctic rivers.

    The global climate has been changing constantly. Remember, first cause no harm. I personally do not like scientists talking about tinkering with something that has been occurring on its own. If the earth is getting warmer like it was 500 years ago, maybe that is how it is suppossed to be.."

    Comment by Oak Leaf : Email : 5/27/2005 - 11:42 am
    ----------------------------------------------------------
    Isn't it ironic that both your comments and that article supposedly published in Newsweek in 1975 (does anyone have an actual copy of that magazine to read and compare?) are found right on the front page of this website? Isn't it?
    Go take a look for yourself. I included the LINK

    Yes, let's not bring politics into the GardenWeb. My garden and the GardenWeb forum are the only places I have been able to go and get away from it. End of comments.
    -----------------------------------------------------------

    Katrina,

    Thanks for all your work looking up the info about the zones. Interesting and perplexing to say the least.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Here is the relevant data for Tulsa International Airport:

    The coldest day in the period 1938-2006 was -11 degrees F on February 4th, 1996. The long term averages indicate that Tulsa has 0.9 days each year (on average) with a minumim temperature below 0. That means you can expect approximately 1 day each winter with a sub-zero temperature. Of course, many years may pass without any. Then you might hit a stretch of a few years in a row with multiple days below zero. So the average is 0.9 days/year. And when the temperature does drop below zero in Tulsa, it is usually in the 0 to -10 range (zone 6). So with this data, it seems reasonable to place Tulsa in zone 6 (to play it safe). However, with sub zero weather being so infrequent (1 occurrence per winter on average), I think you could easily push for zone 7 as well. So Tulsa is indeed a tough call. As I said in a earlier post, frequency of cold is VERY important to plant hardiness. I have provided all of you with a link to the NWS site that has everything you ever wanted to know about Tulsa weather records (and other Oklahoma sites as well). And one final comment: I am indeed both a geologist and oceanographer (as a profession) as well as an amateur meteorologist. All I can say is that we know that Earth's climate in the past has fluctuated greatly between cold and warm stands, largely infuenced by regular changes to earth's orbital parameters around the sun, which changes the amount of heat earth receives from the sun over time. So, with that said, it is not at all contradictory to talk about global warming in the short term (whether it be natural or anthropogenic) and global cooling in the longer term.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks again for all the posts.

    It is nice of you, rockman50, to track down the facts that you list. I have not had the time or maybe even enough training in the fields you mention, to navigate that NWS-climate Info site as well as you must have to get those facts. Thanks again.

    As more time opens up for me next week, I may investigate the site further to verify your calculations and discover what other helpful information they might supply.

    I also liked the reminder about the earth's orbital parameters around the sun, which fluctuate and result in cause/effect issues contibuting to earth's weather, included in the mix of the other comments.

    Welcome to all those who have brought to the original post reflections from experience, and also those who have brought reflections on this posting's subject with scientific theories, facts, and documented statistics.

    Out of all, there is a desire to ultimately gain information from this topic which benefits a wide range of gardening aspects in Tulsa, and maybe even with other areas getting insite for the gardening and landscaping issues in each of those regions.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I am going to continue to plant things as I have (zone 6-7), and if indeed we are beginning to see our climate growing warmer, it will only extend my growing season. Because of where we are geographically, we most likely would still continue to have erratic weather, summer and winter, and that could be enough to kill more tender vegetation.
    Most of my Tropicals and sub-tropicals are kept in the greenhouse all winter. It would have to warm up to a zone 8 before I would consider planting them out into the garden.
    At any rate, it will be interesting to see if it does.

    SweetAnnie4u

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Well considering it was less than twelve years ago when in the first week of Feburary 1996 the NOWA station at the Tulsa International Airport reported low temps of -5 one day and -11 another, I still think it is foolish to spend a good deal of time or money to plant trees and shurbs whose coldest temperature zone tollerance is the USDA zone 7.

    Even so, I must admit that just last week I did go against my better judgement; when I spent just over $100 on some USDA Zone 7 - 9b evergreen azalea shrubs. peat moss, and the acidic mulch they needed.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The hard-core right-wingers set out (circa 1970) to create a network of "experts" who would serve as sources or "facts" for the politicians claims. All of those institutes and thinktanks are NOT innocent. The same fine folks that created the strategy for going into Iraq in the mid-90s (and wound up in the Pentagon under the current Prez) supported a policy of "keep saying it as if it was true; one day people will accept it as truth".

    These folks discount global warming wholesale. Nutcases, and frightening that so many otherwise decent citizens fall for their hubris (if they'd spread it in my garden it would have some value, eh?!).

    Lost in all of this is that climate shifts can contain anamolies that don't fit the trend. This winter brought a few really cold nights to my yard--I lost some so-called hardy kiwi vines (not the whole plant, fortunately) and a fruit tree.

    Your individual yard or neighborhood can create a full zone shift. There are places in Tulsa where bananas and tropical palms are left in the ground without a problem. How? The local micro-climate produces enough warmth to keep the plants from dying. The plants are located in close proximity to buildings that radiate heat.

    I can't confirm personally, but a friend claims that he has a pineapple tree that hasn't died back because its near his hottub that leaks warm, humid air all winter long. He uses it daily during the winter and has even used the lid as an overhang to the pineapple plant to funnel warm, moist air to the plant.

    I'm just uneducated in the garden to buy that last story, so I'll offer up that caveat!

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "The same scientists that are screaming global warming now wanted to cover the ice caps with soot in the 70's to warm the earth and stop the coming ice age.

    You scream loud and scary enough and the feds will fund you for a lifetime no matter how silly it is.

    But that's just my opinion :-)"

    randy

    This is the dude that started the slant. But that's what the elephants, no?

    as ever
    GQtaste

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    For years and years Tulsa has been 6B and Ok City 7A. About a year or so ago they changed Tulsa to 7A.

    That jinxed it. We then had the worst spring we have ever had. I don't think it matters how cold it gets in the middle of the winter (with roses) once they are dormant. What is really devastating is to get freezing temps after the weather has been so warm that the pulp has gone up the stems of the roses. This has been a very bad year this year for roses.

    I am not sure who announced that we are zone 7A, but it was an official source, and does fit well with the zones for growing roses.

    SAmmy

Sponsored
J.Holderby - Renovations
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars4 Reviews
Franklin County's Leading General Contractors - 2X Best of Houzz!