Software
Houzz Logo Print
chlorophylljill

Butterfly Bush

21 years ago

I have had four butterfly bushes (Black Knight) for a couple of years now - I guess about three years. When I got them, they were very small, and for me, they have taken their own sweet time becoming bushes! Not only that, but they seem to have a terrible problem with spider mites every year. This bed has a lot of my milkweeds and other butterfly plants, so I can't really use an insecticide or anything! Anyone else have this problem with their butterfly bushes? I'm trying to keep them under control with jet sprays of water - but it's really chapping my hide! I think they're doing a little better this year, but just wondered if they are susceptible to spider mites, or is it just my particular plants they love? Hmmmmmm...

Comments (13)

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jill,

    Butterfly bushes ARE susceptible to spider mites, especially when under stress. (Of course, being in Oklahoma, when are any of our plants not stressed in the summertime?)

    I only know of three or four ways to "help" the butterfly bushes with the spider mite problem organically.

    The first is with jets of water, esp. on the underside of the leaves, which you are already doing.

    The second is to spray the leaves weekly with liquid seaweed. It is, of course, of the utmost importance that you get both the upper side of the leaves and the underside of them as well. I use a hose-end sprayer most of the time (and every now and then use a pump-up sprayer too) to do this with my tomato plants as mites are such a problem on them. Just dilute the liquid seaweed concentrate as stated on the package. I don't know why this works, but it does. Liquid fish emulsion seems to work almost as well, but smells REALLY bad and will attract every cat for miles around to the garden to find the fish they are smelling!

    The third is to be sure the butterfly bushes are planted in well-aerated soil. This helps with mites, probably because well-aerated soil gets more oxygen to the root zones and produces healthier, less stressed plants. I have found that butterfly bush struggles a lot more in dense, compacted soil and does so much better in loose, well-aerated soil with lots of organic material added to it.

    The final way to combat spider mites it to purchase and release predatory mites that will gobble up the spider mites. This is the only solution that I have found which works long-term. The key is that you must release the predatory mites early in the season before the spider mites are reproducing wildly and are completely out of control. I get the best results with predatory mites released from mid-May to mid-June. They are not cheap, but they are effective.

    Predatory mites are available from many on-line suppliers. Below is a link to one of them.

    Good luck with your spider mites,

    Dawn

    Here is a link that might be useful: spider mite predators

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks Dawn -

    I looked for the Seaweed today at Lowes, but they didn't have it. I've used it before, but I got it at a nursery - so I guess that's where I'll go again! Don't think I can afford the predatory mites - wowza! Those babies are expensive!

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jill,

    They are expensive! I usually release them only once a year and then only if it is looking like a "bad spider mite year of epic proportions".

    Our first few years here in Oklahoma were drought years and we had spider mites on everything, esp. on tomato plants and sunflowers.

    I'm hoping this little spate of cooler, rainier weather that we are having right now will slow down the spider mites a bit. I always see a few in May, and have seen more than usual this year, due to our drought.

    Last year the spider mites were bad in early to mid-May and then we had monsoon-like rains from late May to early July, and I didn't see spider mites at all. Hoping this year will be a repeat!

    Dawn

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Last year the spidermites had a huge party in my garden, that's for sure. This year they aren't as bad, but they're baaaack! I got some seaweed fert. today - it's mixed with fish fert. They didn't have just the plain ol' seaweed stuff. I was going to use it tonight on my plants, but good thing I didn't because we just got a nice showerstorm!

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jill,

    I love liquid fish fertilizer, but when I use it on the garden, all the cats...mine AND the neighbors' cats--hang around the garden and yard sniffing and looking for the fish they keep smelling! And my son is likely to walk into the garden at some point and say "what is that smell?" lol

    Hope the seaweed/fish fertilizer combo sends the mites fleeing!

    Dawn

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hello Jill,
    I don't live in OK, but am a neighbor in central Arkansas. This is the first year I've planted butterfly bushes. I'm out in the country on a dirt road and my yard is hard clay. I've not had a whole lot of luck with gardens in the past. This year, though, I took straight horse manure from my horses paddock, piled it between two railroad ties and put my plants directly into it. My butterfly bushes have more than doubled (maybe even tripled in size) and have been blooming for weeks. I don't know about mites, don't even know what to look for, but the bushes seem to love the manure.
    On another note, my husband planted our tomatoes and cukes directly into the uncomposted manure, also. Of course, they seem to love it, but I'm concerned that growing food in uncomposted manure isn't the smartest thing he's ever done. Does anyone know if you can get sick eating food grown in this fashion? I sure would like some reassurance because we have tons of tomatoes setting and the cukes are beginning to flower and climb their "trellis" (this is a first for us trying this method).
    Thanks in advance for any help you can give.
    Donna
    PS...everything I've planted in the manure seems to like it. Problem is, it's not very dense and all of my gladiolas are falling over even before they bloom. Callas love it! Anyway, live and learn!

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi Donna!

    Regarding your question 'Does anyone know if you can get sick eating food grown in this fashion', the quick answer is 'yes, you can get sick'. Of course, that doesn't mean you WILL get sick, only that you MIGHT.

    I am not an expert by any means, but I am an organic gardener and I use lots of composted manure in my veggie and herb gardens, as well as with ornamental plants. You know that there is a reason we go to all the effort to fully compost manure to begin with, right? And that reason is safety--both short-term (bacterial contamination issues) and long-term (the build-up in your soil of certain chemical salts that can damage future plantings). I'm not saying that to be mean or discouraging, just want to be sure you know!

    For ornamental plantings, you will find you have extremely lush growth as the nitrogen overload will make everything grow like crazy. As you've already observed, the plants grow so tall and lush they will fall over. Sometimes, they get so much nitrogen that they won't bloom. However, since your butterfly bush is blooming, you obviously don't have that problem at this point.

    But for edible crops, there's a lot more danger. Under the National Organic Program guidelines, the use of raw, uncomposted manure is discouraged and, depending on the circumstances, may be completely banned. (Since I am a home gardener raising produce for my family and not for commercial purposes, I don't follow NOP regulations, but am aware of them.)

    When you grow edible crops in manure, you are exposing those crops (and the people who eat them) to everything that the animal ingested, which can include hormones or antibiotics that may have been in the animal feed (and which may not be approved for human ingestion), other medications used on/in the animal, any disease organisms in the animal's digestive tract, and bacteria like E. coli (many strains are deadly) and salmonella.

    The worst danger in eating crops grown in uncomposted manure is that they may be contaminated with the bacteria, E. Coli, Salmonella, and others. I would think the greatest danger would be with leaf crops and root crops. However, even crops like tomatoes or cucumers might be contaminated when it rains or when you water with a hose or sprinkler, as the water could splash up off the ground and onto the fruit, contaminating them with the bacterias.

    Washing the fruits well might help, and peeling the skin off of them might help (although since your hands and knife are touching both the outside of the fruit as you peel it and the inside of the fruit during the peeling process, it might not help), but I don't know if it will guarantee the food will uncontaminated.

    The quickest 'fix' I can think of would be to mulch heavily around the tomato and cucumber plants. That layer of mulch ought to lessen the chance of water splashing bacteria up onto the tomatoes and cucumbers.

    As to the question of whether or not anything dangerous from the manure is actually taken up directly into the plant tissues, I just don't know. I'm sure research has been done on that issue, but I've never read any of the research.

    While typing this response, I asked myself, 'would I eat produce grown in uncomposted manure?' and, honestly, I couldn't come up with an answer. I had a fierce internal argument going on in my head between 'it would probably be OK if well-washed' and 'No, no way.'

    I know there have been cases in the USA where people have been infected with bad strains of E. Coli--the type that can kill--and also by salmonella from eating raw produce, including onions, from restaurant salad bars. Subsequent investigations have revealed the produce in question was imported from outside the US and was grown in a manner where it was contaminated by manure. So, I guess the question is how much of a chance do you want to take?

    Maybe your county's agriculture extension agent could tell you what they recommend with regards to eating foods grown in uncomposted manure. When you ask the agent the question, be sure to specify the type of animal the manure was from and what percentage of the growing medium it comprises.

    Uncomposted manure used in a garden is just like steroids used by athletes and body-builders--it causes great growth and everything looks really good--but there are unseen dangers.

    Finally, there's a link below on using manure.

    Good luck,

    Dawn

    Here is a link that might be useful: using manure

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Dawn,
    Thank you so much for your answer. I don't feel good about it, didn't feel good about it when he did it, and I still don't feel good about it. I will let him read your response and see what he says. I just don't know if I can make myself eat it.
    The plants are very well mulched with straw. If it's only the outside to be concerned with, maybe we can put some soil on top of the straw to make sure nothing can get on the plants. The cukes are growing up a trellis, so they could be OK. I do have a concern about something getting in the food. It's too late to transplant them.
    Oh well, the first year we've gotten anything to grow worth a darn and it's done all wrong! I planned to compost the manure, but the pile was so large and it was planting time, so my hubby just filled up the bed and planted.
    Again, thank you so much for your response.
    Donna

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi Donna,

    I really struggled with that answer because I didn't want to be too discouraging, but wanted to be honest. I hope you will continue to enjoy gardening. Please ask your ag extension agent what he would recommend with regard to eating the produce--he might even be able to send some of your tomatoes and cukes to be tested at your state's agriculture lab to see if contamination is present. At least that way you would have peace of mind.

    Above all else, I hope you will view gardening as a long journey where you will learn many new things along the way. I have been gardening since I was a small child, and I still learn something new almost every day! That is part of what makes it so much fun to be a gardener. This is just one of those learning experiences.

    Now that you see the benefits of using manure, all you have to do is compost it and incorporate it into your soil in the proper amount before next year's growing season. Think how well everything will grow--and safely too!

    Stay in touch with us and let us know how it goes.

    Dawn

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jill- Glad I came across this post. I was asking myself the same question. I have had two butterfly bushes (White Profusion and Black Knight) for two years. Every year, they have looked terrible and always seem to get spider mites. They continue to decline despite all of my efforts: moving them, more or less water, more or less sun, horticultural oils, etc. I trashed my white one this year, and was not sad at all. I will probably also trash the purple one this year or next and select some other butterfly attracting plant.

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi Turtlegirl -

    I've considered trashing mine - they've looked pretty pathetic every year - this year including. They're a bit bigger because I've been fertilizing, but they still had the dreaded spider mites. I just can't spray with anything because I'll hurt all my good guys. So - they might be going, going, gone pretty soon!

    Thanks for your input - for a while I thought it was just MY luck with these bushes which I had wanted so BAD! Now, judging from others' experience, I know better.

    Jill

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hmmmm, I wonder if we had spider mites on our butterfly bush? It bloomed really great for about a month, then started looking pretty blah. I hadn't been watering it a lot, so I started doing that so. I've never grown one before, so I had no idea how long blooms should last or anything else...

    What do I do with it this fall? Cut it back (if so, how far?) or just let it do whatever it's going to do?

    And out of curiosity, since nobody is cutting stuff back out in the wild, how do these plants grow elsewhere? Or are they food for some animal that in effect cuts them back?

    I'm as close to a labor-free gardener as possible, and have never cut my hostas, glads, or anything back. I suppose that's why the mums that were here when we moved in only last 4 or 5 years?

    Of course, since I found these forums this summer, I am lots smarter than I used to was...

  • 21 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My problem with my butterfly bushes is it seems the ants or gophers or SOMETHING has gone underneath and the plants just wilt and die. The roots become gnarled and I threw one away because of that. There is a white chemically smelling substance down in the ground also. I have no idea what that is!! I have two more, one that is not doing anything at all and the other one is trying but it wilts daily despite being watered well. I am very discouraged. I have a friend who just bought a house which has the driveway lined with huge butterfly bushes all of which are blooming profusely without being watered in this heat and drought. Go figure.

Sponsored
NME Builders LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars2 Reviews
Remodeling Company in New Albany, Ohio