Software
Houzz Logo Print
indybob68

LED lighting for growing peppers

15 years ago

anyone have any experience growing peppers under LED lights,,immgrowing some ANCIENT SWEET seeds to see if they come true,,just bought some led lights,,intend to make more,,any info on led and pepper is sppreciated...indianabob,, grower of fine weeds and few hosta

Comments (29)

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Got a few links for you to copy and paste, more than enough LED growing info to numb the brain:

    Growing under lights sub-forum:
    - http://forums.gardenweb.com/forums/lights/

    The Hot Pepper forum:
    - http://www.thehotpepper.com/forum/107-hot-peppers/

    LED can work if done correctly, it's nearly ready for prime time, sorta. Much of the stuff on ebay however is either overpriced, or pure junk, so be careful not to waste your money, you don't want gangly seedlings either. Here's a Super Shepherd Rams Horn i grew under a set of blue 4 watt LED Christmas lights:

    The blue LED Christmas lights were installed into a small plastic bin with reflective sides. Some of the bulbs were right up against the plants leaves. Blue LED's promote more green growth whereas RED LED's focus a little more on flowering and less on green growth. I may be wrong but for seedlings i'd say blue is more important but you always want some red in there too, especially after the seedling has grown it's second or third set of true leaves.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    In peppers,blue promotes tall lanky plants and red promotes bushing out-tighter plants.
    Peppers aren't color sensitive for flowering like pot is(which is probably a site or sites you got your info).

    You can't use a candle to grow plants under(christmas lights).
    No where near enough lumens.

    Galopagoense won't grow under star LEDS.

    {{gwi:1140814}}

    Neither will Red Savina.

    {{gwi:1140816}}

    {{gwi:1140818}}

    {{gwi:1140819}}

    Won't bud either.LOL

    Watts for LEDs as a rating for light output is a waste when talking about LEDs.
    Watts is used on incandescent bulbs because they put out the same lumens while burning X amount of watt.
    Fluoros and LEDs can be the same watt rating but put out a lot of different amounts of light.
    I have LEDs that burn 3 watts and put out between 25 and 200LM.
    I have 1 watt ones that put out between 25 and 160 lumens.
    Watts is how fast your meter spins,not a way to measure any other light source than incandescent lighting.

    LED's are mini spotlights.The tighter the beam the farthher away you can put your lights and get closer to the LED's out put on the plant.
    A 120 dgree angle has to be closer than an LED with an 18 degree angle one.
    I use mostly star LEDs and 10mm ones for growing and 5mm ones vertically on the sides to get the wave lengths I can't get with the stars.(no pics yet,I have to find a way to get my camera to take a pic without freaking out-too bright...

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    {{gwi:1140821}}

    {{gwi:1140823}}

    {{gwi:1140826}}

    {{gwi:1140826}}

    {{gwi:1140829}}

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Galopagoense about 3wks ago.

    {{gwi:1140832}}

    Red savina recovering from Mites-4+wks ago.

    {{gwi:1140835}}

    Manzano

    {{gwi:1140838}}

    First experiment-10mm LEDs and 5mm LEDs.
    280,000mcd 10mm Leds were about 100Lumens each in red,blues were about 160,000mcd.
    5mm were all over the place as far as Lumens go.
    Used whatever I could find in Lumens to fill in the 9 or so wavelengths plants use.

    {{gwi:1140841}}

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Stars(lights are on in the room-freaks out the camera. :)

    {{gwi:1140843}}

    400 red 660nm LEDs,200 blue 430nm-475nm.
    2500 red 5mm LEDs,2000 blue in bags.

    {{gwi:1140845}}

    {{gwi:1140847}}

    10mm over Manzano-5mm over starts below -early experiment..
    {{gwi:1140849}}

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Plants started under LEDs

    Red Quintisho

    {{gwi:1140851}}

    Little nubean

    {{gwi:1140853}}

    Morouga Blend

    {{gwi:1140855}}

    Big Bang Naga with mite damage...

    {{gwi:1140857}}

    5mm LEDs are only for suplimenting light wavelengths I couldn't get in brighter LEDs.
    Not very bright/have to be closer than other 10mm and stars.

    My stars and 10mm LEDS could be a lot farther away but I live in a small apt. and have no room.So I turn the plants around every so often...
    When I finnish my grow shelves I'll have stars above and 10mm and 5mm vertically on 3 sides for branchng and additional wavelengths...
    I have to turn these off before I look at my plants or I see spots afterwards.

    Some plants are curled etc.,I had a mite problem,big time last season.
    Killed 99.9% of my garden-inside and outside.
    You can see some white flies on one too.
    If you can see mites it's already to late to do anything about them.They are allready too far set up to do more than try and keep them at bay,same with white flies but the fies you can kill easily.
    Arachnids (mites)are tough to kill and a lot of bennificials can't keep up with them or even eat them.
    Last year sucked.

    Wavelenths Plants use:

    Plants use basically from 430nm - 475nm in blue and from 620nm to 675nm in red - give or take.

    Here is a link that might be useful: info

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Some info from a site thats down now...

    The visible colors of light from shortest to longest wavelength are: violet, blue, green, yellow, orange, and red. Ultraviolet radiation has a shorter wavelength than the visible violet light. Infrared radiation has a longer wavelength than visible red light. White light is a mixture of the colors of the visible spectrum. Here is a summary of wavelengths (nm). If you are building your own LED Grow Lights it may be of help when selecting LEDs for your project.

    200 - 280 nm UVC ultraviolet range which is generally harmful to plants. LEDs in this spectrum are non-existant or very expensive.

    280 - 315 nm Includes harmful UVB ultraviolet light which causes plants colors to fade. UV LEDs in this range are now available and coming down in price.

    315 - 380 nm Range of UVA ultraviolet light which is neither harmful nor beneficial to most plants.

    380 - 400 nm Start of visible light spectrum. Process of chlorophyll absorption begins. UV protected plastics ideally block out any light below this range.

    400 - 520 nm This range includes violet, blue, and green bands. Peak absorption by chlorophyll occurs, and a strong influence on photosynthesis. (promotes vegetative growth)

    520 - 610 nm This range includes the green, yellow, and orange bands and has less absorption by pigments.

    610 - 720 nm This is the red band. Large amount of absorption by chlorophyll occurs, and most significant influence on photosynthesis. (promotes flowering and budding) The ratio of red (660nm) to far red (730nm) in sunlight is about 1.2:1

    720 - 1000 nm There is little absorption by Chlorophyll here, but Phytochrome uses a nice portion. Flowering and germination is influenced. Near and above the higher end of the band is the Infrared spectrum, which can also be heat and could cause elongation or affect water absorption/transpiration.

    Many of these plant pigments have dual wavelength peaks that can be activated with led light combinations:

    Beta-carotene 450nm 480-485nm dual peak
    chlorophyll a 430nm 662nm dual peak
    chlorophyll b 453nm 642nm dual peak
    phycoerythrin 590nm single peak
    phycocyanin 625nm single peak

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hey Smokemaster,

    Some of that info, if i'm reading it correctly, is an eye opener. With pepper plants, Blue LED's create taller/lankier plants and Red LED's keep them compact and bushy? Just when you thought you learned something it all goes out the window...

    But i have to admit i'm not the only one who's confused because my limited research comes from the two forums i linked (not marijuana grower forums which annoy me in fact for more reasons i care to state here). But if everyone in other pepper forums are just regurgitating stuff they read in "other forums", then i can see where the confusion probably started.

    I should have clarified my post above btw. My thoughts were on getting pepper seedlings started to about ~ 5 inches height. Whereas now that i'm reading the OP's post all over again, he mentions "growing" and not just "seedlings" which is a whole different story altogether. Looks like i have to rethink my current hodge-podge LED setup and add more red to the mix. For my 2011 seedling start i will be using LED + T5 and T8 fluoros, so the LED will probably play more of a supplementary role if anything.

    Here's some pictures of that Super Shepherd Rams horn, roughly two weeks later (Christmas lights):



  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Meant to also say:

    Now that i look at it, my Super Shepherd pepper plant does look a little spindly at the bottom, but the top appears so lush with new growth just pouring out of the top constantly. Growth patterns seem so much different under LED (this was not my first venture into LED btw, half my 2010 pepper and tomato crop began under LED's, my first year using them).

    Still so much to learn, but these little experiments are great fun during the winter downtime, and this particular experiment only cost me 4 watts of energy use.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thats IF you were to use only blue or red light on Peppers.

    I'm sure you could get different results by mixing different ratio's of red and blue and peppers might be different than other plants etc.

    For me with peppers (only thing I grow),using Blue only makes my plants taller with bigger leaves where using red only makes shorter tighter plants with smaller leaves-more branching.
    I use horizontal and verticle light sources,I think it makes a big difference with the Leds I put together.

    Thats just the results I've gotten when I played with using different wave lengths of just 1 color on peppers.

    Also not all plants aren't light specific like peppers.

    Some plants definately ARE influenced by wavelength and day hours for growth maturity and fruiting.

    To me LEDs are so missrepresented by snake oil salesmen that sell LEDs in a way that makes the crap they are selling sound like it's something it's not.

    A ton of people try using low lumen LEDs and then expect great results.
    They wouldn't try and grow plants under a Fluoro fixture from ceiling mounted fixtures but think they can with LEDs.

    Watts for instance being used as a measure as to how bright an LED is.
    I can run my LEDs on a power wasting supply and claim my pannels are a gazillion watts even though they only put out a couple lumens.
    Watts is Voltage X amps.-nothing to do with Lumens in LEDs.

    Incandescent bulbs use pretty much the same type of fillament so watts can be used to measure their output-they burn 75 or so watts to put out about 1700 Lumens.

    Now they have power saver bulbs that have different power needs so watts isn't going to be a good way for much longer.
    IE bulbs that say they use 50 watts but put out the same lumens as a 75 watt old style buld-it uses a diffent material for a filament...

    Or guys Advertise a 400 LED pannel...But it's made out of 400 5mm LEDS and won't grow a plant by itself.

    These , below,total out to 700+ 5mm LEDs(they could be called a 9X12 in. pannel if put together...)All different angles , wavelengths , Lm and mcd amounts...

    Covers a 12X12 in. close up(6-10 in. away) area with enough light to grow sprouts only or use to suppliment other lights.

    {{gwi:1140864}}

    I can't find it now but different wavelengths actually turn on and off some varieties plants genes...
    It was a university study I read from a year ago or so...

    I also don't think you need as many Lumens with wavelength specific bulbs as you do with other light souces.
    Other sources put out a large percentage of light that is useless to plants.

    I'm making my LEDs to just cover grow shelves right now.
    No plants bigger than 18in. square.

    If and when I get more room to grow in , I'll see how far away these LEDs can be from my plants and still grow them ok.

    I do think that I'm way overdoing the amount of light I'm using in general.
    Also,just because an LED says it's 660nm or whatever doesn't mean thats all it puts out in wavelengths.
    Use a CD like a prism and you'll see other colors too,in lesser amounts but they are there.
    I don't know if it's in plant usable amounts or whatever but I think it could add to making their light spectrum closer to the mix they would get from the sun.

    These are just observations from the stuff I've played with so far.

    Your milage may vary.
    I use cheep Chinese LEDs (can't afford U.S. made ones)so they might not even be putting out what they are advertised to put out in their spec sheets.

    What I wrote is worth exactly what you paid for it. LOL

    Who knows I might find out something else contrary to what I think now with the new LEDs that come out every year.

    Just like computers and cell phones-the tech changes by the min.

    A side note I read about using christmas lights.A lot of them are white LEDs with tinted bulbs.They aren't really blue or red bulbs-the plastic bulb is making white light look red or blue.
    So I guess you gotta take a CD with you to check out the ones on display or you'll get something you can't use. LOL

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ya, those fake colored LED Christmas lights with tinted caps are easy to spot. Buy the clear looking ones (but labeled red or blue) and you'd be good to go.

    Most also have a cover that allows you to remove them or examine them more closely, just got to be careful you don't go blind staring into them =)

    Note that i'm NOT recommending people that use Christmas lights btw, they're only good in a supplementary role unless you use a ton of them in a lighting project like this one: http://www.thehotpepper.com/topic/6945-my-cheap-diy-led-light-box/

    That $10 you spend on a string of LED Christmas lights would be better spent on a dual T8 4ft Fluorescent shop light (Lowes, HD, walmart etc).

    Here is a link that might be useful: LED Christmas light grow project

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I am sorry I baught T8's last year.

    Mine (Homey Depote shop lite) get a lot hotter than my T12's and screw up my smaller sprouts.

    Bulb selection is smaller than T12's were too.
    I like using a couple different K bulbs in the highest Lumens I can find.
    I think the ballasts get hotter for whatever reason.

    For 10 bucks you can buy 3-5 thousand 5mm LEDs-if you are into soldering.
    Takes an hour to make one of the 3X4 boards above-100-120 leds.

    You have to have a lot of time to kill like I do.
    I solder them at work-14hr shifts,7 days a week).

    You never know what wavelengths the christmas light are either-some work ok,some don't. ...

    1 watt stars are about a buck each in 25 lumens up to 160 or so lumens.
    Bright enough if used in the #'s I do.50-60 on a 11X16 sheet of 1/8 aluminum.
    Come in 425nm - 475nm blue and 620nm - 660nm red.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Very interesting post. I'm fascinated with the idea of using LEDs to start my plants. I have a Google alert configured to let me know when new articles are posted on this subject. Thats how I found this posting.

    I'm very interested in seeing any numbers you might have as to the cost of LEDs vs florescent lighting. I'm betting the florescent lights are cheaper by a long way.

    Watts are not a measure of light. A few seconds in wikipedia will teach you that. This idea that watts equals light is everywhere. Recently I have been searching for info on aquarium lighting and it got to the point where I would be reading a post and they would start talking about watts per gallon of light and I would just quit reading.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Watts was first used as a referance because all incandescent bulbs used the same filament.
    A 100 watt bulb puts out about 1700 lumens.

    Here is a calculator for an estimate of mcd to lumens in LEDs.below link

    The wider the angle the less accurate it is.

    Comparing LEDs to other light sources is kind of a waste as far as Lumens etc. go when comparing different light sources.
    leds put out mostly what colors and wavelengths plants need.
    Maybe plants don't need 2000+ lumens of plant specific light.

    Since you are going to be counting lumens of light from other sources that includes wavelengths of no use to plants and since LEDs put out mostly light wavelengths they are rated at.
    So I think LEDs don't need to be used in the high amount of lumens required when using other light sources.

    Depending on what source you use the percentage is different for the amount of non usable lumens.
    I guess you should also consider how far away each source of light can be as to your specific application too.

    I have been looking for info on how many lumens of just red and blue light a plant uses but haven't seen anything about it yet.

    I guess you could use the calculator to figure ball park lumens for a specific pannel of LEDs and get your lumens per watt ratio-more or less but you still don't know the requirements plants need of just red and blue light.
    Then if you are into the $ part you have to factor in bulb life...

    So far I think the LEDs are cheeper to run compared to my Fluoros but I don't pay my electric bill...
    I know my fluoros used to blow the breaker every so often and the LEDs don't.The room is a lot cooler too in the summer by 20 or more degrees.
    I guess I could see how many watts my power supplies are and add them together to see what they use compared to my fluoros but I still wouldn't have a lumen comparison just a watt comparison.
    Seems like a waste of time.
    My sprouts are a lot happier under LEDs than the fluoros in general.
    I do notice different peppers like different red and blue ratios than other plants do.
    Manzanos for instance like more red than some of my other pepper plants.
    I've played with red to blue ratios of 3 to 1 up to 8 to 1.
    Red being the higher number.
    Most plants seem to like between 6 to 8 to 1 ratios best.
    Only been playing with LEDs about 2 or 3 seasons so I'm still learning by doing.
    Most of the stuff I've read about LEDs is just repeated stuff by people who don't really know much about actually using LEDs.They are repeating the sales crap from the internet.
    A lot of the stuff is geared towards pot growers too.
    Large scale grow outs etc.
    I think LEDS are too expensive to buy right now for that kind of operation.
    I also think commercial pannels aren't ,for the most part worth buying.
    Over priced and not what they are advertised to be.
    The only people I seem to get good data from are people who are making their own setups.
    Still costs $ but you end up with exactly what you need eventually.
    LED's are like computers and cell phones.The tec is changing all the time.Especially with all the go green crap these days.
    I could spend a lot more on newer brighter LEDs but they cost a lot more than I want to spend.
    Last years stuff is a lot lower priced and you can haggle with the sellers if you buy a couple hundred to thousands at a time.Depending on what LEDs you want etc.
    I'm thinking about getting different white LEDs and seeing with a prism if they have a decent red and blue band to them.
    They are a lot cheeper for higher lumens than blue or red in general.
    Maybe they can replace Fluoros-run cooler and use less juice.
    Just gut a fluoro fixture and put a 4in. X 4ft. strip of LEDs in them.
    I'm looking for a setup where I don't have to raise the lights as a plant grows on my shelves.
    Just mount them at 19-20 inches away and set the timer.

    I like LEDs in general and will keep playing with them for a while longer until I get it right. LOL

    Here is a link that might be useful: Lumens/mcd Calculator

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    OH MERCY!!! I just read all these post!! Went down stairs and looked at my peppers growing under lights and just said, "you guys are boaring!!" LOL!!! (meaning the pepper plants!!) Never knew that about different colored lights! Learn something new here every day. :)

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If you want to play with your Fluoros and are using several bulbs with different K ratings.

    Take a CD and hold it up to each bulb individually and you'll see a rainbow on the CD like a prism does.

    Different K ratings means different bands of light.
    You'll see some bulbs wider red or blue bands than other bulbs do.
    See even you can play with your lights,you don't have to have LEDs. LOL
    I can see it now,everyones going to grab their favorite CD's and start checking out every light in their house.
    Swap out the kitchen lights or whatever because they have a wider blue or red band than what is over their plants now.
    Go for it! :)

    Here is a link that might be useful: Homemade Spectroscope

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    >>Quote smokemaster>>>I can see it now,everyones going to grab their favorite CD's and start checking out every light in their house. You bet i am, i have at least 5 different brands/models of fluoro bulbs that i could check and i better see lots of blue and red in them!!!

    Thanks for letting us know it was even possible to check!! :)

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Well?
    Did you make a Spectroscope?
    Start checking out all your bulbs for more plant healthy K values?
    I found an easy one made from a peper towel tube.
    A match box,cereal boxes etc.

    Just google Homemade spectroscope...

    Here is a link that might be useful: GW Post about Plant lights

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    At $1200 dollars for that grow light, you can buy a lot of other pepper growing stuff to include a couple T14 Floro bulbs and a lot of KWH's.
    Yikes!!!!!!

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I used an inexpensive 5 band 120w LED with two HO T5 bulbs in a 4x4 tent to start my peppers. They did very well, although I did have some issues with whiteflies and some watering issues that took me awhile to get used to. The plants were moved outside end of May and I have loads of peppers on sweet green to bhuts doing very well. They are far ahead of other years where I started under a window. I intend to try overwintering under LED to see if they will continue to produce. I will definitely do better next year growing from seed as I now use the 5-1-1 mix from the container forums which drains much better then the potting soil I was using previously.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I've acquired 4 grow light LED panels, each with 225 lights. They are red and blue, red-630nm, blue-455nm in a ratio of 11:4, red to blue. I'm just guessing this was optimized for another type of plant but was wondering if anyone knows how these would work with peppers over the winter.

    Thanks,

    John

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Number of lights doesn't tell much. Wattage is important, as many of the LED's panels with a ton of microwatt LEDs, usually only amount to a few watts.

    Best to have panels that use less LED's of 1 watt or more as they are much more efficient. You will still likely need a minimum of 90w to grow anything to maturity. This is also dependent on other factors as well, such as coverage area, distance to plants etc. The 14W panels and such will not do much for you, from the research I have done. It's just not enough light.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Watts means nothing with LEDS or most other light sources as far as Lumens go.
    Watts is voltage X amps.How fast your meter spins.
    It has nothing to do with Light output any more.

    I have 1 watt LEDs that put out 25Lumens and other 1 watt LEDs that put out 160LM.Both run on 1.9-3.5volts at .350miliamps.

    I have Fluoros that put out 2000LM and others that put out 3000+LM,both are 32 watts.

    Also a string of 6,1 watt LEDs isn't 6 watts.
    If each LED uses .350ma the string is .350 ma-about 1/3rd+ amp.

    I have panels that use 4 amps at 12 volts,48 watts +/-.
    They put out a minimum of 2100 lumens to a maxumum of 13,600lm.
    Thats with 1 watt LEDs.84 LEDs per 16in. X 16in panel.
    2100 is for all 25lm LEDS and 13,600 is for all 160Lm Leds.
    My panels are a mix of LEDs from 25LM to 160LM so the lumens they put out is above 2100lm. and below 13,600lm.

    Quote from above:

    "I've acquired 4 grow light LED panels, each with 225 lights. They are red and blue, red-630nm, blue-455nm in a ratio of 11:4, red to blue. I'm just guessing this was optimized for another type of plant but was wondering if anyone knows how these would work with peppers over the winter.
    Thanks,

    John"

    Those panels would be ok for supplimental light at best.
    No high end red,red and blue in the panels is only in the wavelength ballpark.
    I think you need more blue(430nm + 470nm) and high red(660nm).
    See post above with wavelengths plants use.
    Sometimes close doesn't count.
    Post how they work,I'd be interested what you get out of them.

    I'm building some 10mm LED panels, 7in X 12 in. LED growlights in Blue 430nm ,465nm, 470nm , 475nm and red in 625nm , 630nm , 635nm ,636nm , 640nnm , 660nm.
    Along with star LEDs in 430nm,440nm,445nm,450nm,470nm blue and red in 625nm,627nm , 630nm,658nm,660nm,662nm.

    Maybe I'll post a tutorial as I assemble them.
    If anyones interested.
    Home made panels put out exactly wavelengths you want in more Lumens for the $ in general.

    I'm waiting on the last parts to come in.
    Maybe next week...

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I wasn't comparing watts with other lights. Only the total watts of LED power. My point was that if you have one of those 14 watt lights with hundreds of microwatt LED's, it won't be enough. I meant that you will probable require a total of 90 watts or more of efficient LED's to get to a healthy maturity, with the right combination of colors. We also agree that panels with 1 watt or higher LED's are the best to use due to efficiency. Lumens are definitely useless when measuring LED panels since it is biased to the green which plants just reflect and don't use.

    The real point of my previous post, is not to bother with those microwatt panels and get or build panels with efficient 1W or more LED's.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Watts still means nothing in general as far as lumens go.

    Watts was first used as a referance because all incandescent bulbs used the same filament.
    "It used to be"
    A 100 watt bulb always put out about 1700 lumens.

    All 100watt bulbs were the same,all 50watt bulbs were the same,each burned X amount of watts and put out X amount of Lumens per watt.

    "I have 1 watt LEDs that put out 25Lumens and other 1 watt LEDs that put out up to 160LM.Both run on 1.9-3.5volts at .350 miliamps. "

    If I'm using Red LEDs that use .350MA each and my power supply is 12 volts X amps I can run several different LEDs with different Lumen outputs and use the same amount of watts.

    Example:

    Blue 1watt star LED - runs on .350ma at 3 volts each.
    Each puts out 106lm.
    Thats 4 LEDs in the string(12 volts) , putting out 424lm per string. using 12volts ,at .350ma total= 4.2watts(12v X .350ma).

    Red 1watt Star LED - uses .350ma at 2 volts each.
    Each puts out 25lm.
    Thats 6 LEDs in the string , putting out 150lm using 12volts , .350ma total= 4.2watts.(12vX.350ma.)

    So which panel would be brighter,the 4.1 watt one or the 4.1watt one?

    Watts only tells how fast your meter spins.And can tell you how efficient your LEDs are IF you know the ma,voltage and Lumens your LEDs are in the first place.
    which you don't with store baught panels.
    I've never seen all 3 stats advertised.
    Most say 225,1 watt LEDs are 225 watts.They aren't necessarily.Depends how they are wired.
    You can say 225,100Lm LEDs are 22,500Lm. total.

    You can't go by a panels total watts to determin how bright it is.
    It depends on how efficient of an LED you are using in your panel.

    Since most grow panels are at least a couple different LEDs that use different volts and ma per LED that probably put out different lumens per watt,it makes watts as a measure of possible lumens even less accurate.

    Only way you could use watts to compare different panels would be if ALL LEDs used the same voltage and MA to put out the same Lumens in that panel.Which,unless you made the panel,you don't know.

    Then to make things even more mixed up you can throw in that LEDs are Mini spotlights.
    The wider the beam angle the less Lumens per sq. Foot,Sq.In. etc. you get from the farther away the LEDs are to the meter,plant or whatever.
    With some LEDs the angle can change with heat and the power you are running them at...

    In general Red LEDs are less lumens per watt compared to Blue or white.

    But an older LED of any color could be less efficient than another of any color thats newer/newer tech..

    You can say the same panels are 660watts if you ran them on a 55amp , 12 volt supply too if you really wanted to get creative. LOL

    LEDs only take what they need.
    But a 12volt,55amp. supply will use 660 watts if you run 1 string or a bunch off it.

    Assuming my math is right...

    I don't see what you are talking about with-

    "Lumens are definitely useless when measuring LED panels since it is biased to the green which plants just reflect and don't use."

    Lumens is the measure of ALL VISIBLE light.
    Has nothing to do with color.
    If you can see it,it can be measured in Lumens.
    Check your Funk and Wagnell...
    Lux is Lumens per sq. Metre.

    I do find that a lot of light meters have a problem with some shades/wavelengths of high red and low blue.
    My cameras filter freaks out all the time when I try and get pics of my LEDs when they are on.

    Once again I dissagree with you.

    1 watt LEDs aren't neccesarily less efficient than 3 watt LEDs.
    I use mostly 1 watt LEDs because for the price and lumens per watt the strings burn added up are cheeper and brighter per $ in general.

    I have 3 watt,60Lm Leds that run on .750ma,3.2-4volts.
    I have 1 watt,160lm LEDs that run on .350ma,3-3.4volts.

    You can't generalise about all LEDs being the same by using watts as a measure.

    It depends on the specific LED you are using at the time.
    Voltage,MA. and total lumens have to be considered for each individual panels efficiency.
    There are too many variations of LED power requirements per Lumen out there.

    As posted above,most of my stuff burns 48watts and puts out between 2100 and 13600Lumens.Depends on the mix of LEDs I used at the time.

    So using 90 watts as a rule of thumb doesn't work if you are using the LEDs I use now.

    There are brighter ones out there(more expensive)that use the same voltage and MA mine do.
    My 3yr old LEDs are less efficient than the ones I just baught and cost less too.
    For my use , lighting individual shelves,I don't need them in higher lumens than i have now.

    In general,if I remember right,plants need a minimum 2000lm of light from a flouro to grow ,in between 5000k and 6500k.
    Less lumens of LED,plant specific light.Less useless wavelengths are being produced per Lumen.

    I think you have some stuff mixed up,don't understand,I'm not trying to hassle you.
    I do enjoy discussing LEDs as growlights for peppers.

    There is a ton of miss information out there advertised by snake oil salesmen that confuses things about lEDs in real life.
    Lots of stuff posted by people who never built or used LEDs or baught an LED panel that was junk and post ALL leds are useless for growing plants under in general.
    Lots of people also miss use their growlight then say that it was junk.
    Tried putting it a mile away or too close to the sprouts and can't figure out why it didn't work.

    Too close matters sometimes.
    LEDs are spotlights.
    Close can = 2LEDs on the plant.
    A little farther away means 6 LEDs+ on the same area,the beams overlap.They have a sweet spot.
    Changes with the angle of the LEDs beam.

    I just got off a 14hr work shift...time for watching the inside of my eyelids.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I agree with most of what you say, actually. The point I was making was those cheap low wattage panels will not work very well. As far as lumens? Yes, that's a measure of visible light, however many light spectra that plants use are on the edge or outside visible light. Also, light with a lot of green can show a lot of lumens, but not be very useful to a plant, the reason I say lumens is not a good measure. It is based on the sensitivity of the eye. Maybe better measures might be related to PAR (photosynthic active radiation) or radiant flux which is not based on eye sensitivity.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm on LED for a couple years now. They work. I do recommend at least one flouresent... cool white works fine for me.

    Start almost all my peppers and tomatoes under my light rig. I have had potted peppers under the lights do fine but they also do fine in my window so why waste the electricity.

    LEDs are cooler then other types. All this talk of lumens... get the bulbs down an inch above the plant tops. Only light that counts is light that gets to the plant. Pictured rigs could probably benefit from better reflectors... I use cheap mirrors to build a grow box.

    Using Sunshine Systems I bought off Amazon... about $130 for a 28watt 1'x1' square of blue/red combo. Tried one of the cheaper 14watt and was disappointed... it worked but weak. Started with one 28watt and after 6 months was happy enough to invest in 3 more. One died under warrenty but no problem with the others... never returned the broke one as I'm lazy.

    Grew both habs and cayenne until they had peppers. I had flouresents from my old rig and added one fixture back... plants are fuller and greener... just cheap hardware store 32 watt cool white bulbs.

    Yes... there are better set-ups/way but I can say my way works and works fairly well. I'm happy and doing more growing then tinkering. Don't miss out on tinkering... part of the fun.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Agree with the fluorescents. I mix my LED with T5 HO's as well. The plants seem to have better color with them. I also use a reflective grow tent as well. One thing I've noticed though is that peppers really like heat under the pots. They tend to linger without it, unlike most other plants including tomatoes that grow fine at room temperature.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My goal with making my own growlights out of LEDs is because I haven't found any commercial panel that worked very well for my needs.
    I want my lights to have every wavelength I can get between 400nm and about 690nm.
    I want to use only plant usable light for the most part.
    I get the guys using the different halides bragging about 70,000+ lumen,a zillion Watts etc.
    Problem with them for me is the heat and that only part of that 70,000 lumens is plant usable.
    My apt. is only 2 rooms,i have a limited amount of space to grow in.
    I start all my plants on shelves then the ones I want pure seeds from stay inside under LEDs until I get the seeds I need.
    Why should I Deal with it if I get the same or better results from my home made stuff.
    To me there is no difference how I measure my LEDs output in general.
    As long as my plants are happy it makes no difference what I used to measure my light output with.
    A 12 inch ruler,a yardstick or tape measure.
    As long as all my readings were measured accurately with the same tool for all the light sources I've messed with.
    PAR doesn't make sence to me either,in general.
    You would need to know what percentage of your light source was Plant usable - percentage of the actual light output was in the 400-700nm range that plants use the most portion of light to grow.
    I don't know why that because plants use a very small amount of non visible light that they toss out Lumens as a bad way to measure LEDs.
    I do know since my LEDs put out mostly the wavelength they were made to put out , that the Lumens or Lux readings I get are in mostly plant usable lumens where the gazillion Lumens a halide or whatever put out is a lot less lumens of plant usable light.
    Thats why you need all the lumens from sources of light that are less plant specific.
    I'm replacing my Fluoros because of heat issues now,Halides would be rediculous for me to use for my needs.

    Here is a link that might be useful: PAR discussion

Sponsored