Software
Houzz Logo Print
paulns

Swale sceptic - sandy soil

19 years ago

My wife is concerned that a swale dug in sandy soil will act as a water sink, rather than a water slower-down and distributor. The land in question is rocky with a fair bit of gypsum in it. We're getting it cleared and leveled late this week. It is 100'x50', at the foot of a 45-degree treed slope. The swale would run straight along the 100' length. My idea is to have the guy dig a trench a foot deep and 2-3' wide, piling the dirt along the downslope side, and then we backfill partway, loosely, and plant in grass.

The garden is on a plateau above our other garden and will be something of a challenge to irrigate, so I'm thinking a swale would help. What we're planning to plant in the garden is blackberries, strawberries and greens in compost-amended trenches, which has worked very well elsewhere.

Any opinions on this welcome. And any suggestions about what best to plant in such a swale? Should the swale be deeper than 1'?

Comments (3)

  • 19 years ago

    g'day paul,

    yes a swale would help and the job of the swail is to capture run off and cause that water to infiltrate the sub soil which is the end result you want.

    you say sandy soil? we had sandy loam it would go like cement when very dry, so when we decided to swale we didn't use the classic copy book swale, we used a ripper attached to a tractor (your going to have a bloke ther with a machine he should have a ripper put in as many rip lines as you want/think you want it doesn't matter if you go overboard they are low landscape impact by design, also he will rip a whole lot quicker than building the classic swale which will need the use of a leveler thingy like surveyors use) whatever to rip along the contours in single rips, the reason being we didn't want to have a the permanent and very visible impact of the classic swale.

    and also the classic swale needs to be dug all but perfectly level along the contours or it will dam up in heavy rains and over flow causing a berm washaway. with ripping the need for that exactness is not necessery and the rips can be as permanent or temorary as you like and you can every couple of years put the rips in areas that you haven't done yet.

    we also found planting our trees in the rip lines gave us faster growth. ripping opens the soil up down to around 20"s and allows for oxygen to get in necessary if your sub soil is going to become healthier, and allows for organic matter to get in also, plus it puts the water down where you want it.

    if you go the calssic way i would suggest you lay mulch ahy along the bottom 1/3, 1/2 of the swale so that water absorbtion will be maximum at all times.

    to help even more with getting this moisture into the sub soil plant you trees along the contours and mound mulch hay along between them and around them this is another form of swalling, you could lay a thick layer of mulch along the contour even on the bottom side of the rip this will act like a berm, as it will if you lay bales of hay end to end.

    with ripping you can redo the rips every couple of years if you wish you may find you don't need to we found it was a good idea to do each rip twice once from either end to ensure we had a good deep open rip.

    don't plant in the swale as such would be m suggestion plant alont the berm or just below the berm or on the above side of the swail.

    use raised beds built along the contours the best plan is do everything along the contours.

    len

    Here is a link that might be useful: len's garden page

  • 19 years ago

    Hi Len,
    Thanks for the tips. I'm going to check out your website and look into ripping. Where you live sounds desertlike - drought/flood conditions. We don't get big floods here, and the slope is covered in vegetation - groundcover, shrubs, trees - so no real worries about erosion and I don't foresee water damming the swale and washing out the berm. I like the idea of a whole long row of haybales instead of a berm....What I pictured was the swale and berm creating an underground reservoir that slowly feeds the garden. I saw a diagram of this somewhere on the web...

    The great thing about this slope and garden is that the slope comes down to a flat plateau - where the garden will be - so it should be fairly easy to make the swale level.

    Wouldn't planting trees into the swale defeat the purpose, at least for anything you want to grow further down? Ie they would take up a lot of water.

  • 19 years ago

    g'day paul,

    you mentioned you were having the block cleared? you may need to excercise caution or care as this activity could start degredation problems from errosion and loss of soil moisture due to removal of vegetaion in an all of a sudden way.

    any swaling will do what you want it to do we just think rip or lines of bales is more efficient way of doing it and there is no need for the exactness of the classis swale, simply it's too easy hey?

    we turned a degraded block around in short order and to this day i will promote rip swalling and row mulching/bales as the best easiest options.

    no we aren't quiet in desert you may say just we are experiencing a pretty bad drought, and no its not climate change it is the drought that was destined by nature as we have had them before, just that there is at least twice as many people living in aus' now than what was here when there was a last bad drought in the early 1900. in my lifetime once as a child and then as a young adult i remember 2 severe droughts just we had a whole lot more bio-diversity around then to create rain for us.

    have we made it worse (i say we as collectively, us beings have to take responsibilty no good will come out of finger pointing)yes it has been made worse due to massive habitat clearing for residential, commercial developments and especially agriculture with the advent of broad-acre or factory farms. so this is at least our 4th bad drought in 1k years.

    planting tree along/in/or about the swale won't defeat the purpose of the swale they will enhance the purpose as the large tree roots provide galleries for water to get into your sub-aquafa and soil.

    in true sense swales are a tool we have to do the job of missing trees and bio-diversity.

    if you wish i am glad to offer ideas as you go along, i don't pretend to know everything i just have a good grasp of waht works especially when it comes to good old common sense land management.

    i would suggest you take time to read the essays i have on our site there is likley to be some ideas there for you.

    and feel free to e/mail us using that e/mail addy or i think i have our hotmail one listed in our details here.

    len

Sponsored