Software
Houzz Logo Print
biradarcm

Best Tender and Stringless Beans for Oklahoma

15 years ago

I bought a bundle of very tender, green, shiny, string-less, straight, 4-5" long, fresh beans from Sams Club... made excellent stirfry and my daughter liked it very much and ate all. Now she wants to grow them hershelf :-) Please could you tell what type of beans they are? I searched bean picture online, the most closely resembling picture is shown below;

{{gwi:1119608}}

Appreciate someone tell/recommend such type of green bean for Oklahoma which has great flavor, tender, stringless, and heavy producer.

Thank you in advance -Chandra

Comments (28)

  • 15 years ago

    Chandra,
    I wish I knew what bean that is. My favorites almost all have strings.
    You posted in the old thread "Beans for Oklahoma" which has a lot of good info on companies. Unfortunately it is defective and won't come back to the top of the list!
    Hope someone will come along with a suggestion.

    George

    Here is a link that might be useful: Beans for Oklahoma

  • 15 years ago

    Chandra, They may be Bush Blue Lake grown in the Pacific Northwest. Not sure, but I think that is a possibility.

  • 15 years ago

    Chandra, I can't identify those beans. However, I would like to recommend Asparagus or Yard Long beans for stir fry. They produce in the heat long after other beans have petered out. We not only like them in stir fry, we also like to roast them, then toss with a glaze of soy, garlic and sesame seeds.

  • 15 years ago

    They do look like Blue Lake, but I'm certainly no authority on them. Doesn't that one come in a pole bean as well as the bush variety?

    I have a question about my Roma II bush beans. I was ripping out some of the worn-out ones today, and ran across several plants that I thought were gone. However, they are putting out new little leaves. I've never seen that happen. Is it worth leaving them alone to see what they'll do? Most of them are loaded with tiny beans, but I didn't think they would ever mature at this point. Comments?

    The Roma happens to be my favorite, but the pods are much thicker, larger, meatier and more flavorful than anything you'll find in the grocery store. We used to grow a heritage Italian bean called "Bechicca" though I'm not sure of the spelling of the name. Unfortunately, our seed was destroyed and I haven't been able to find any more.

    Pat

  • 15 years ago

    At least some bush beans will put on a second burst of growth if give sufficient moisture. Bill P, who used to post in the beans forum, once ran a lawnmower over a spent row of bush beans. When watered the stems sprouted and produced another crop.

    George

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks, George! I had no idea that could happen. I think I'll inspect the plants and leave any of the ones that are showing new leaves. I only have two little rows. They aren't hurting anything where they are, and it's certainly worth giving them a chance to produce again.
    If they can recover from being mowed, then anything is possible.
    Pat

  • 15 years ago

    George, It never fails that one of us mentions Bill P every year although he died several years ago. It just proves that one persons life can make a difference even after they are gone. I still miss gonefishin and I know Dawn does. He helped a lot of people with his garden ideas.

  • 15 years ago

    George,
    Indeed first I posted at your old thread "Beans for Oklahoma", but it didn't show up here, that made me to created new post. That post is very informative too.

    Carol and Pat, thank you, I searched more, looks like more closest were Slenderette Beans (linked below) and second closet is blue lake.

    Seedmama, thanks for the suggestion, i will look for Asparagus/yard long beans as well. So for I have only southern peas (six types), missed yard long beans.

    Fresh beans are our favorites, we east lot of them in varuous ways... fresh, steamed, stirrfried, deep fried, curry, etc... So I am going to plant all types.

    Regards-Chandra

    Here is a link that might be useful: Slenderette Beans

  • 15 years ago

    Count me in on gonefishin. I cried when he passed.

    Chandra,
    I have some saved seed if you'd like them. I'm trying to find my roasting instructions saved from Fine Cooking. I can't promise those until I locate them.

  • 15 years ago

    Chandra,

    It is most likely the beans you bought are a commercial variety and seed of some commercial varieties aren't even sold to home gardeners. If the package they came in lists a state or country of origin, you could google and find a list of commercial snap bean varieties grown in that state or country and that might help you narrow it down.

    Carol, Jay and Seedmama, I surely do miss Bill P. too. I was just so sad when we learned he had passed away. I can only imagine how much his beloved wife and other family members surely do miss him.

    GoneFishin' was the one who convinced me to order onion plants from Dixondale. He always grew Dixondale and recommended them highly. So, as long as we're buying and planting Dixondale onions, GoneFishin's legacy lives on.

    Dawn

  • 15 years ago

    seedmama,

    I bought many types of beans and peas form Ellison yesterday. They have large stock and seems to much cheaper. Thank for the offer, but I think I have more than enough beans seeds for this year, even I am afraid no space will left empty for the fall season cool crops. I am staggering bean planting 2 weeks apart. I hope to get enough for fresh eating and give away, may be some for freezing.

    regards -Chandra

  • 15 years ago

    Would it be a waste of time for me to get some yard long bean seed and plant in the next few days? I have wondered about them for quite some time but never planted any.

    Our average daily high for July has been 105 degrees with higher temps forecasted for next week.

    Larry

  • 15 years ago

    Larry, my package says 50 days on the beans. The toughest part may be germination but if you can do that they are prolific in the heat. If you email me your address by early Saturday ill drop some in the mail.

  • 15 years ago

    Larry and Seedmama, germination may not be problem for beans/southern peas in this heat. Last week I sown some zipper peas and green beans, all seeds germinated. By the way, I did cover each hole where seeds dipped with peat moss as per the suggestion form OSU fall garden fact sheet. But I won't have any experience whether they will produce in this heat. -Chandra

  • 15 years ago

    Chandra, They may not produce but they still should grow and when it cools off a little they will be big enough to produce.

    George gave me some beans 2 years ago and I planted them late. They grew fast and made a nice crop, but I didn't save seeds. Last year I had just enough for a seed crop so I saved the entire crop for seeds and planted them this year. Since I planted early, I expected them to produce early. Wrong! They grew fine and covered a trellis about 9 feet wide and 7.5 feet tall, then billowed out over the top. The Japanese Beetles came and ate holes in the leaves, but only along the top. They have recovered from cold, flood, beetles, excessive heat, and still look fine but haven't made one bean. They are finally starting to bloom. After all of this, I hope I finally get some beans from them.

    When I first read your question on beans, I thought of Fortex which the folks in the New England states seem to love and they are a slender bean. I tried them a long time ago but they didn't seem to like our heat.

    Last year I grew Kentucky Wonder Pole. I didn't like them nearly as much as the Blue Lake Pole I grew the year before plus the Japanese Beetles seemed to love them. My first choice is always a 'greasy' bean tho, and I don't like the fuzzy ones.

  • 15 years ago

    Since I'm going to have to rip out the two little rows of bush beans I had, it sounds like it might be safe to at least try for a second planting and hope that it will cool down some. It's 109 as I'm writing this, with an index of 113. Nearly too hot for me to be out there doing anything at all. And what about the grasshoppers that want to take over? When I walked to the edge of the veggie garden just now, about 30 of them flew in all directions with every step I took. Will they just chomp down any new little sprouts as soon as they surface? I'm going to begin a treatment for them, but I don't know how effective it might be.
    I also seem to have a bumper crop of red spider mite that has instantly infested most of the giant African marigolds.
    I really do want more beans for the freezer, but I wonder if it's a futile effort?

    Pat

  • 15 years ago

    Pat,

    At this time of year, since none of us are psychic, it is anyone's guess whether we will get a good fall bean crop. It mostly hinges on whether the pests leave the plants alone and let them grow, whether the temps drop early enough for blooms to set beans, and whether rain will fall or whether watering restrictions will be implemented that make it hard to get good seedlings going.

    There's a current thread here on the forum today about fall beans in which I addressed germination issues in the heat.

    I've had great success this year with EcoBran for grasshopper control in my garden. I still have some grasshopper damage in there, but they aren't stripping the plants bare like they did last year.

    Out at the west end of our county at a fire last weekend, I was looking at a pasture that looked severely overgrazed. They guy looking at it with me told me his cattle had not overgrazed it because he rotated them to another pasture before they could overgraze. He said the grasshoppers had come in huge swarms and eaten every bit of grass the cattle hadn't already eaten.

    I haven't had huge swarms like he has---I saw them there and they were in epic 'horror movie' numbers there. I'm about 20 miles further east so we're still a bit greener and don't have as many grasshoppers yet as they have out west. I hope our luck holds, but feel like the hoppers will eat their way east over the next few weeks.

    Dawn

  • 15 years ago

    Speaking of "heat loving" green beans. My rattlesnake beans are nearly 8 feet tall and they're not setting fruit. I think there is a point where enough is enough when we're talking about beans--even the ones that do better in the heat.

    I would think that 95 or so would still work, but 105 is just too dang hot! I only got one picking from my beans. I could have probably gotten another one, but they were setting in very small numbers. A few beans a day-hardly worth messing with.

    I'll give them another chance next year. They tasted great and the plants grew better than any beans I've ever grown before.

  • 15 years ago

    Most years 'Rattlesnake' will stay healthy through the hot part of the summer (if the grasshoppers don't eat them) and produce heavily in the fall even if they don't produce in the heat of the summer. Rattlesnake, Tanya's Pink Pod and McCaslan are some of the beans that produce best for me in the typical hot summer weather. I harvested the last of my Tanya's Pink Pod just the week before last. They produced better than any other bush bean this year.

    I was going to plant Rattlesnake for fall beans, but it is too hot and too dry here. Maybe next year....or, if we suddenly were to get about six inches of rain, I might change my mind and plant fall beans, but I don't think that's going to happen.

  • 15 years ago

    I've planted long beans in July with our typical 110 degree heat. It germinates and grows like wildfire. If you have enough days, I'd say that is your best bet.

  • 15 years ago

    I am currently growing "Blue Lake Pole Beans" after I did a little research on different types of garden beans. From what I understand Blue Lake Pole Beans are some of the only, if not the only type of beans that are completely stringless. Mine seem to be growing tremendously well, although this is my first year gardening and I got a very late start. My beans are at least 6-7 feet tall and producing flowers but its too hot and dry to really have any beans right now. I'm hoping in a few weeks we get some relief and shortly thereafter some beans!? Also my soil is a little too clay based and is going to take a little time to develope by adding organic matter in order to support the plants sufficiently.

    The pole beans are all the way on the left growing up the galvanized wire cages.

    Also I would recommend you direct sow the seeds into the ground. Starting pole bean seeds early and planting the seedlings did not work out so well for me. I had way better success with the seeds I just pushed into the dirt. Next year I will sow them into the ground after the last frost. I did not have the garden bed built early enough to do so this year.
    I also did not do much planning and kind of threw everything together on a whim. Looking back I wish I would have taken a little more time to plan, but hey then I would be even more behind in the growing process. :P

    Make sure you give youre beans something tall to trellis up!
    Simple things will work like planting next to the fence and attaching some nylon string trellis you can find at any local nursery or big box store. I am growing some morning glories up some hemp twine I wrapped around the tops of fence post.

    The strings are anchored lightly in the groung with some cheap metal garden stakes that look like a really long staple. (got them at atwoods 98 cents for like a dozen stakes they will rust however they are not stainless).

    I'm rambling... maybe I should have just said, "do a little research on blue lake pole beans. I think they are what you are looking for!"

  • 15 years ago

    A note on rattlesnake........(and I posted this early in the summer)...spotted cucumber beetles LOVE them. These little buggers ignored my cucumbers that were 3 feet away and dined on these beans all summer. Have NEVER had this problem before.

  • 15 years ago

    I purchased a few bean towers (the kind that burpee and gurneys sells). These are very nice. They don't rust and you can use cotton twine or jute twine and just cut them off and throw it all on the compost pile. Very easy to clean up @ the end of the growing season.

  • 15 years ago

    I am so glad this thread was started. It motivated me to finally get my Asparagus yardlongs in. I sent Larry seeds on Saturday, then set to work reclaiming my neglected kitchen garden from the Bermuda. By the time Sunday came to a close I had dug "all" the Bermuda, double dug composted leaves into the soil and laid down thick cardboard and pine needles. Knowing that I had a home for them, I decided my best best for germination was to do it inside.

    On Tuesday, I sowed a 36 cell pack with seeds and put them in a warm dark place in my house. This morning I planted out 26 germinated seedlings and couldn't be happier. I expect more sprouts in the coming days. Thanks for the motivation!

    Seedmama

  • 15 years ago

    I hope I did not mess up, I planted in the garden. I planted the day I got the seeds, ran the row east-west, piled mulch high on the south side trying to shade the ground (this time of year cant get it that high). I have been able to keep the soil damp with an irrigation tube, but no beans yet. I did save some of the seed for next year just in case I strike out this year.

    Thanks, Seedmama for the seed.

    Larry

  • 15 years ago

    I haven't planted any bush beans for the last few years. And had no plans to this year. Till the hail and continued drought along with my work situation led me to wait till now to plant. I just planted beans this past week. I used mainly what I had on hand and could find around locally as I didn't want to wait for seeds to arrive. Some of what I planted are listed as stringless. I planted a mix of op/heirlooms and what I call more readily available commercial varieties. I tried to stay with varieties with shorter DTM's. Although we all know that is only a guideline. I planted two sweet corn varieties. One with a DTM of 65 days and the other a 79 day DTM. They tasseled on the same day. I am experimenting with a couple along a fence where I had nothing with 2 that may not have enough time to make before frost. What I ended up planting was Kentucky Wonder Bush, Tendergreen Improved Bush, Dragon Tongue, Cherokee Wax Bush, Tarahumara Bakamina, Tongue of Fire and Hopi Pink. Will see how they all perform. They are saying a few degrees cooler overall this week and next week. So hoping that holds true. If so maybe they will do ok. Jay

  • 15 years ago

    Jay,

    They are saying that it will be cooler and you believe them?????

    I've decided the weather forecasters keep sticking that 'cooler days are coming' thing in the forecast just to give people hope, because when those 'cooler days' get closer, the forecast changes and they are just as hot as they days we've been having. It seems like they keep sticking a '99 degree' day in our forecast and it usually is 4 or 5 days away. However, by the time that day arrives, the forecast suddenly changes and the 99 becomes a forecast of 101 or 102, and then the actual temp will be 104.

    We've been 100 or higher every day this month with no end in sight. For a while, the TV forecastes pretended the string of 100s was going to break any day now, but now about all they'll say is that we're going to be hot and dry for the foreseeable future. I appreciate their honesty even if it doesn't offer us much hope.

    I hope your beans do well. I have a lot of bean plants hanging on and hoping for cooler weather so they can produce. The southern peas, especially the pinkeye purplehulls, are producing great in the heat though.

    I'm trying to keep the spring-planted beans watered enough that they can hang on until fall, but the longer the drought hangs on, the less likely it seems they'll make it through August.

    Dawn

  • 15 years ago

    Dawn I haven't believed them enough that I sprayed with a bloom/rooting spray again. Did that a few weeks ago and the cool down didn't happen. And the plants suffered some. But at least all 3 are predicting it. But look at today. It is cooler here now than it was supposed to be. Still only 85 degrees at 1:20. Went over to Hugoton to eat. Saw where some showers came through last night. Some areas got from 3 tenths to an inch and a half. They are saying a 40% chance Thurs and Friday. Again sure that will change numerous times. Humid here today also. If that hangs around with no rain it may induce more disease issues.

    I planted several things late even okra. They keep mentioning rationing here. Although I use less water than most. I try to do my share. So far most things are germination well. Have been able to keep most things at least moist. My thought on planting late is that it may give them a chance. And even if I had planted right after the hail they would be like the tomato plants and would be just trying to hang in and wouldn't be producing anyway.

    Have you ever grown the Cherokee Wax Bush? It is yellow. Many say it is the earliest bush bean they grow and one of the best. I planted all of the seeds I had on hand. So hopefully can eat a few and save a few seeds. Jay