Software
Houzz Logo Print
joellenh_gw

Found out what is wrong with my tomatoes

16 years ago

Tomatoes in two of my older beds were yellowing and dying. I've been pulling them up one by one as they stop producing.

Is this CLUB ROOT? I can't find any info on it affecting tomatoes; most sites say it affects cabbages turnips etc. Any one ever hear of this?

If it is, it would explain why it's only hitting my two older beds and not my new ones, and also why the Daconil didn't help, at all.

I didn't notice it on the other plants I pulled, but they were bigger and I don't remember looking at the roots. This was a small plant so the roots came right up and wwere easy to see.

{{gwi:1120442}}

Jo

Comments (21)

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    it's more likely to be root-knot?

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It wouldn't be clubroot because it affects brassicas.

    It is some sort of nematode, most likely root knot nematodes.

    There is no simple cure, but there are lots of things you can do to improve your soil. Root knot nematodes are a problem in sandy soil and sandy loam soil.

    I've linked the OSU Fact Sheet that provides a basic intro to what you can do when you have Root Knot Nematodes.

    I probably don't have to tell you that this is very, very bad. Nematodes also will bother some of your other veggies like okra, so the long-term solution is to massive amounts of soil improvement including regular solarization of the beds, and to do regular rotation with non-host plants and to probably consider growing in containers. Some hybrid tomato varieties are nematode-resistant, but that only means they resist nematodes not they they don't get them at all.

    Dawn

    Here is a link that might be useful: OSU Fact Sheet on Tomatoes

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Dawn, I grow in raised beds (1/3 compost 1/3 vermiculite 1/3 peat). I add compost yearly and tomato tone from time to time. This is my second year growing tomatoes there: no idea where the Nematodes came from. I just planted pole beans where I pulled the plants. Should I scrap that idea and solarize? And can I just solarize the tomato squares or do I have to get both 4x4 beds in their entirety? I currently have flowers and herbs and stuff growing in the other spots.

    Thanks Dawn. Everything I get is bad. I just (about a month ago) planted some new squashes in brand new beds. Have been checking daily. Today I realized the stems are almost gnawed in half so I thought SVB and pulled them, I must have seen 20 suash bugs run out. So I likely had both.

    Bugs love my garden :(.

    Jo

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jo,

    First of all, you have every ounce of the sympathy I have in my body and soul. For a gardener, there is practically nothing worse than nematode-infested soil, and I am so sorry this is happening to you. I know how serious you are about raising healthy, organic food for your family, and nematodes just make it a lot more challenging to do that.

    Before we go into full panic mode, followed by full battle mode, let's assess the situation and try to figure out if the nematodes are in an isolated area or if they are widespread. Are you seeing the nematodes on the roots of every tomato plant you yank out? If it is only on one or two, or only on some but not on the others, then were those purchased plants? You could have brought in nematode-infested plants. If that happened, you might not yet have a widespread infestation of nematodes. And, if you have clay soil, that would explain why nematodes are being found in plants growing in your raised beds.

    With nematodes, if they are widespread in your soil, then it doesn't matter if you have raised beds and it doesn't matter what you put into those raised beds. If you have nematodes in your soil, they will migrate into your plant roots and/or the soil in the raised beds. Generally, unless your beds are raised 2 or 3 or 4 feet above grade level, roots of your plants grow not only in the raised beds but into the soil beneath them. The only way to prevent that would be to have an impenetrable barrier as the bottom of the raised bed, and it would have to be something like concrete.

    Is your soil underneath your raised beds sandy soil or sandy loam? If so, that is where your nematodes are coming from. If not, they came into your garden on plants, in some sort or soil amendment or mulch or something. Nematodes are microscopic and you can't see them, but you see the damage they can do. Compost is a very common source of root knot nematodes, especially if you purchased the compost. Often, commercially-made compost is bagged and sold before it is fully composted, and this allows the nematodes to survive and then thrive in the area where the compost is introduced. If you are doing your own composting and your compost pile sits on top of nematode-infested soil, then your compost could become infested with nematodes. You have to take special care to get the pile really, really hot if that is the case.

    Green beans are, unfotunately, one of the vegetables that are highly susceptible to nematodes. I wouldn't even try to plant beans in an area where there is an ongoing nematode problem. The reason is that every time you plant a crop the nematodes like, their population increases (imagine those little rascals talking among themselves tonight saying "Hey, Jo took away our tomato plants, but--woo hoo---she planted beans for us!").

    There are some crops that resist nematodes more than others, and you can see them on the info linked below.

    Once you have nematodes, they can make it very difficult to garden at all. No matter what you do, you'll have to work every single year to fight those nematodes. You can't slack off at all or they'll get the upper hand and drive you out of gardening. Nematodes are so persistent that they've been known to migrate from the ground up into flower pots sitting directly on top of the ground. (With containers, you might be able to keep nematodes out of them by setting each container on top of bricks so the container does not touch the soil.)

    Nematodes here in Love County seem to ebb and flow, being worse at some times and in some years than others. They are at their worst during periods of plant stress---especially heat stress and drought stress. (Gee, guess what you have this year?) Sometimes, after a very persistently cold winter in which the weather stayed really cold for a really long time, they show up later than average, if at all. Most of my friends and neighbors who have sandy soil infested with nematodes have stopped trying to raise plants in the ground and garden in containers instead.

    Solarizing helps but isn't a guaranteed cure. Rotating non-host plants with host plants in alternating cycles will reduce their numbers but not eliminate them.

    The folks I know who have had the best luck fighting them chose to (horror of horrors!) add huge amounts of organic matter and CLAY, lots and lots of clay, to their soil. (What a terrible thing to have to do!) Since nematodes seem to get worse and worse the sandier the soil is, it seems logical that they are less of a problem in soils with a heavy clay content.

    When we were looking for land back before we bought this place, we had only a couple of requirements. We wanted acreage, we wanted trees to make DH happy (he grew up in Pennsylvania surrounded by huge trees and millions of them) and we wanted non-sandy soil to make me happy. I didn't really care what kind of soil we had as long as it wasn't really sandy. So, of course, we have very dense red clay and I hate it, but I'd hate nematodes more.

    Google and read about adding chitin to your soil. It is one of the more interesting ways of dealing with nematodes, although it is a lot easier to obtain chitin if you live near the ocean and don't have to pay to have it shipped.

    Maybe Jay will have some nematode advice. He has sandy soil. However, I think it gets too cold where he lives for nematodes to survive.

    In the olden days when I was a kid, you could use a fumigant like Vapam to kill them in the soil. Unfortunately, Vapam killed everything in the soil and was withdrawn from the home market. I don't know if it or anything similar to it are still used commercially by people with a pesticide applicator's license. Regardless, I wouldn't use Vapam because it kills all the biological activity in the soil which is bad news for an organic gardener.

    When nematodes exist, they are EVERYWHERE. That means they are in the soil underneath your beds, beside your beds, in the pathway, even possibly in the ground where your lawn grows (depening on what else grows in the lawn), etc. You can't improve one area and expect them not to enter it...they will invade any area they can reach, especially if it has plant roots growing in it. So, whatever it is you decide to do, remember they are everywhere and there is no quick fix and no cure-all.

    I'm sincerely hoping you have clay soil and the nematodes came in with a load of compost and are only infesting a small area. That would be the best possible scenario and the one most easily fixed at this point.

    Dawn

    Here is a link that might be useful: Nematodes

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jo - my heart goes out to you. One of the reason's I found this site was my encounters with Nematodes, so it was a mixed blessing. I've had them and you'll have to do LOTS of soil amendments to put them at bay...but it IS do-able.

    Hang in there. It's worth it.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Dawn,

    Thank you so much for the extremely thoughtful and detailed post. This was the first plant I NOTICED them on...not to say it wasn't on others. I have two more plants that need yanking, but I have been holding out for the fruit to ripen first. I will be watching the roots with interest.

    My soil is clay. 100% clay. I could make pots. That's why I started the raised beds: not much was growing in the clay.

    The tom I just yanked was a volunteer. A yellow cherry pear type. they were very yummy. :(.

    I am sure that the original yellow cherry pear was purchased. My garden sanitation practices have been lazy. I cold compost in plastic bins...mainly kitchen scraps (my dogs would eat a compost pile and get sick half dog/half pig)... And now I know why they say why sanitation is os important and I am paying the price.

    So far my plan is to solarize the areas I KNOW were affected, and plant a fall cover crop (rye?) Grr.

    My garden truly is not big enough to give up this precious space but I have little choice. I will also dig and expose soil this winter in an effort to freeze them out.

    When I replant next year, I will plant something that they hate. Maybe onions and rhubarb. I'll have to move my trellises too.

    Jo

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jo, sorry to hear about your Nematodes. I have had bad infestations two times. The first was around 20 years ago when I lived in Ft. Smith. The last time was about 7 years ago when I lived in my old house about a half mile from here.

    The first time (in Ft. Smith) I bought Vapam, pulled every thing out of that bed and spaded and worked the soil very deep. I tried to get all the roots out that I could. I sprayed the soil surface and also inserted the spray nozzel about a foot into the soil about every 10 to 12 inches, I then covered the bed with plastic and placed landscape timbers along the edge of the plastic. I left the plastic in place for several weeks and did not plant anything in that bed until the next spring.

    The last time I had a Nematode problem was at my old house about 6 or 7 years ago. I pulled up some Okra plants that were badly infested. I started tilling the soil often, even in the winter. At times the soil was frozen, but not solid.

    Both times I found Nematodes I almost went into a panic. I dont know if what I did was good or bad but I had good results both times.

    In Ft. Smith the bed was for flowers and banana trees.

    Okra was replanted in the same spot at the old home place the next year and no Nematodes were noted when I pulled the plants the next fall.

    If I found a heavy infestation here where I live now I dont know what I would do. I think I would try the tilling practice again or just quit gardening.

    I doubt that a home owner can buy Vapam, and if you could I am not sure I would grow food in the soil where it was used.

    My heart goes out to you, I know the empty hopeless feeling you have. Best of luck, Larry

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jo, that is the one thing I don't think I have ever had in the garden. I am so sorry to hear you have them.

    Good luck with the elimination process.

    Sometimes gardening is a struggle!

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jo,

    Well, it is good news that you have clay, at least in the sense that the nematodes you found probably were (a) imported in soil or compost or even, perhaps, were in the soil in which the tomato transplants were grown; (b) likely are confined only to that one raised bed, or if you find more in other raised beds, are confined there; and (c) because of (a) and (b) you likely have an isolated issue with them and ought to be able to get them under control.

    So, think of them as an 'invader' to be dealt with and not as a widespread problem in every inch of soil you have, and consider that a huge blessing. (I am just so relieved you have clay soil. For all its problems, nematodes cannot survive in it.)

    There are several ways to deal with an isolated population of them and since Paula and Larry both have dealt with them, I'm sure they'll be able to give you lots of good advice, beginning with what they already posted above.

    One important thing is that you shouldn't compost any plants pulled out of the nematode infested area because the nematodes can survive and thrive in compost. To a certain extent, you can combat them there by making sure the compost gets hot, hot, hot but it would be better to put nematode-infested plants in the trash and dispose of them that way.

    With clay, your nematodes should remain in whatever improved soil they're in and not migrate out to other areas. That's the best possible news. Well, except for the fact that they are there in the soil in which you want to grow vegetables. However, you can transfer nematodes via dirt clinging to a trowel or shovel, etc., so it is important to clean off tools used in infected beds before you touch the soil in another bed.

    The fact that the nematodes were on a volunteer plant is interesting. Did the plant come up in that bed or did you transplant it from elsewhere? I've heard for years and years that volunteer plants can be more susceptible to disease and lots of folks here don't let them live, but I've never, ever had a volunteer plant that wasn't just as healthy as the plants that I raised and transplanted into the ground.

    If you like that yellow pear-shaped cherry tomato and you still have any fruit left from it, you can save the seed and plant them next year. Nematodes infest only the plant roots, so the fruit and seed aren't affected.

    You can grow any grain type crop, including corn, in that infested soil next year, or you can plant rye as a cover crop in the affected beds in September. Have your read about the rye-nematode connection? The type of rye you need is a cereal rye called Elbon rye and it is not the same thing as the annual and perennial rye grass seeds sold to overseed a lawn in winter. Elbon rye is almost miraculous in its ability to trap nematodes in its root, effectively killing them and preventing them from reproducing.

    I'm going to go find one of the old columns written by Texas horticultural icon and genius Dr. Jerry Parsons, now retired from TAMU. Dr. Parsons has written about nematode control many times over the past couple of decades and everything he writes is so informative and so helpful.

    If I had nematodes, I'd plant elbon rye in the infested areas every single fall. Doing that would allow me to reclaim my garden soil the following spring. Doesn't that sound like a workable solution to you? And, as a bonus, you'll be able to look outside in the dead of winter and see a little bit of green.

    Dawn

    Here is a link that might be useful: Nematode Control by Dr. Jerry Parsons

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks guys. I knew I could count on you. It seems like everything possible has gone wrong with my garden and trees this year.

    I always dispose of any sick or diseased looking plant in the trash (bagged), I never compost it just in case, so I am good there.

    In my searchings yesterday I did seem to recall something about cover cropping with rye, I will look into the elbon rye...it sounds like the answer to my prayers. Will also be reading the articles you linked.

    The volunteer, thankfully, came up in the same bed as the parent plant. I am pretty sure that I got the parent plant at Atwoods when they were having a great sale this spring, little tomato plants were something like 39 cents. My bargain suddenly got alot more expensive. One of the tomatoes must have dropped into the next square, because that's where the volunteer sprouted. It's funny how I can always remember bargains and what I paid for them but can never remember plant names (blushing).

    I am going to pull one of my other sick plants this morning just to look at the roots, because now I am dying to know. Even though it still has about 50 cherry tomatoes on it that aren't yet ripe, I think it's a sacrafice I'll make to really see the extent of my problem right now.

    Good point on the garden tools. I always dip my pruners in a bleach solution while I am working, but I almost never use a trowel or shovel (I usually just poke holes in the soil with my finger to plant seeds or push it aside with my hand for plants), but I do occassionaly use a small trowel, and now I will carry around a bucket of bleach water to dip that and my hands into as I work.

    I am also grateful that the volunteers I gave Kelley came from a different bed entirely. I am hoping and prayingthat I didn't infect the soil in her containers.

    I'll keep you all posted.

    Thanks,

    Jo

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jo, If you pull the plant and hang it upside down in the garage or on the porch or somewhere that it will be in the shade, the remaining cherries likely will go ahead and ripen for you I do that all the time in the fall when the first freeze is coming....pull plants and hang them upside down in the tornado shelter (to avoid freezing temps). Sometimes fruit will continue to ripen for several weeks after the plant is pulled.

    Let us know about the roots on the next one you pull.

    I'm just feeling so relieved you have clay soil. There aren't many reasons to appreciate clay soil [except it is highly fertile] but the fact that nematodes do not thrive in it is a huge plus.

    Dawn

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Both of my older beds that had tomatoes are 100% affected. Tomatoes: badly. Bush Beans:badly. Parsley: somewhat. Sunchoke: somewhat (I think. The choke had a couple of weird hairy roots with knobs growing on them).

    Unaffected: Basil, marigolds, dill.

    Still, the infected plants were spread throughout both beds so I think it's safe to assume that the entire beds are infected.

    I spent 2 hours pulling plants and getting every bit of root I could find. I probably need to spend at least 2 more before I can solarize. Leah kept dipping her hands in the bleach and Adam kept getting his kite stuck in my fence, so it was slow going. TGIF and Dave can watch the kids tomorrow while I finish disaster control.

    Since it is two beds, I am guessing it came in on infected bag compost. I knew I hated that crap they sell at Home Depot, it is always chunky and never seems finished. This year, in my new beds, I started to use Back to Nature and better compost that I found at garden centers (to supplement my own very meager supply).

    Now here is the bad news. My raised beds are 6" tall, and I dug through that dirt and another several inches down. The soil underneath is actually now pretty good and loamy. I guess all the compost and mulch I added worked its way down to improve the soil below. In this case, a very mixed blessing.

    I did a couple of test digs around the roots of plants in other beds, and so far they seem okay. So all in all I lost two sixteen square foot beds. I have a total of just over 250 square feet in raised beds, so I lost about 13% of my raised bed gardening space. Not horrible, but it still makes me very sad. Now I wish I had purchased a couple of those Earth Boxes when they were sale.

    This year between people stealing my peaches, racoons stealing my nectarines, losing pumpkin and squashes to SVB and squash bugs, and losing 8 tomato plants plus countless herbs, beans, and flowers, I feel like I've lost about 1/3 of my useful harvest. Oh, and Dave hit one of my little apple trees with the lawn mower and knocked off the three beautiful apples that were growing on it. LOL.

    Still, we have had many delicious things from my garden. It's a good thing I am ornery and stubborn. No microscopic worm is going to get the best of me. This means war.

    Jo

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Anyone know where to buy Elbon Rye? Cannot find it online.

    Jo

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jo,

    Haven't been posting or online much. I know how you feel. I've never had any trouble here or even seen it till this summer. One of the plants I pulled had minor nematode growth. It was close to dark when I pulled the plants. Didn't really notice it till I had mixed them and was disposing of them. Feel it might of been from a container but not sure. Wasn't for sure it was till I did some research later. I can tell you with in 5-6 plants which one. I'm sure it was a purchased plant. Which makes little sense given it was in potting soil when I bought it. The other 15-16 I've pulled all the roots have looked fine. Some in the same area. I replanted plants in all of the holes where I removed plants. I always pull and inspect the roots on every plant. Also have been told we are too cold here for them to survive the winters. Especially if you till the mulch in and turn the soil over which I did last fall. And know this is the first time I've ever seen them. So sure they came in on something. When I determine the hole or container I will see what I added to that hole or container that may of carried it. I did use a compost made in OK in my containers this year. Might be possible it contained it. I'm attaching a link to a thread on another GW forum about the nematodes. Looks like some good info but haven't had time to read it all yet.

    Post what you learn and do. I'm in the holding mode till I determine which hole and how extensive the damage is in my garden.

    When I have more time I will post more. This is just one of several set backs I've experienced this summer. Best of luck. Jay

    Here is a link that might be useful: Soil Nematodes

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jo - Dawn told me to look at my local Farm stores. Here in Norman we have Ellis Feed & Seed. They carry just about EVERYTHING. I'm not sure what's up around Jenks but let me know if you can't find it. I'm going to need some this winter also so I can pick some up for us both.

    Paula

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jo,
    I found a source for the seed. I sent you an email. If you don't receive it please let me know. I will share some of mine with you. As I will be getting extra if it works out. Will know soon. Any one else wanting some small amounts I should have extra. Just let me know. Jay

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jay, I got your email. I would be absolutely thrilled to split an order with you. I don't need much (enough to cover at least 32 square feet) ;), I read that you need 10-12 pounds per THOUSAND square feet, so if you want to part with a pound or two, I'd be more than happy to reimburse you for the cost of seed and shipping.

    I actually went out and finished pulling plants awhile ago. It broke my heart to pull 20 or so HEALTHY basil plants. I'm going to dry them in my dehydrator. It also killed me topull up my beautiful marigolds, which added a splash of color here and there and were unaffected.

    I SOAKED the soil and covered it in 3.5 ml clear plastic (which I already had in the garage). Weighted down the edges with bricks. Will probably leave that until at least mid september. I feel really bad for the earthworms and good bugs, and hope they have the sense to dig deep and escape being baked.

    I also found a couple more interesting items while researching today:

    1. Nema-gone marigolds. I wonder if a thick planting for awhile would kill off any remainder? Food for thought.

    http://www.burpee.com/flowers/marigolds/marigold-nema-gone-prod000268.html?catId=cat100016&trail=

    2. Beneficial SF Nematodes from Garden's Alive...claims 100% success in killing root knot nematodes...hmmm.Interesting.

    http://www.gardensalive.com/product.asp?pn=5004

    Like I said, I am waging war on these little %$@$@$!!!*@'s.

    If I have to buy every bullet in the armory, I will. They killed part of my beautiful garden, and I am MAD.

    Jo

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jo,
    I'm attaching a link to the site of where I found the seeds. Talked to Mr. Lorenz himself. A great person. Although they sell mainly truck loads he says they sell 50 lb bags to those who need small quantities for gardening ect. That sounds like a lot. I have about an acre I sow to wheat every fall. I'll sow it all to rye this year. But will have extra. A family from Okeene has a flying service here. Hopefully I can pay them to haul a few bags up here for me. And save on shipping. If not. I like to visit that country and they have good sales in that area. May have to take a little vacay and pick up the rye seed while I'm down there. It was the only source I could find online that would sell in smaller amounts. Jay

    Here is a link that might be useful: Elbon Rye seeds

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jay, what is the difference between grain rye and Elbon rye? I have bought grain rye or cereal rye at the Farmers Coop and used it for a cover crop. I may try it again, but if I do I will mow it with the lawn mower before I try to till it in. My tiller is not great at tilling in a cover crop.

    Larry

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Larry,
    Elbon is cereal rye. That is what you want. I will attach a link which talks about it some. If you can buy it from your Coop that would be a good deal. Here ours doesn't sell it. The only rye seed that is sold around here is annual rye. Everything I've read says it must be cereal rye. Jay

    Here is a link that might be useful: Cereal Rye

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Seeds of change sells cereal rye in small quantities. However I am confused. Are Elbon and Cereal rye interchangeable terms ie all Cereal Ryes are Elbon Ryes? Or is Elbon a very specific TYPE within a larger cereal rye group? Thank you!

    Jo

    Here is a link that might be useful: Cereal Rye

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting