Software
Houzz Logo Print
tulsa442

Carrots-First Timer

17 years ago

I started my first large garden this year and have had great success. I have more tomatoes and cucumbers than I know what to do with. I also tried carrots this year and I'm pretty sure I messed them up. I seeded per the directions, but I did not thin them out when they started sprouting. It's been almost 3 months, they are still very green, and a few I pulled up look good, but are still very small. Is it too late to thin them? is this normal? and if so, when do I harvest?

Thanks

Comments (8)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Tulsa442,

    You should have thinned them out shortly after they started sprouting. You can try thinning them now, and then water them well to settle down any disruption to the soil caused by the thinning, but it proably is too late in their growth cycle for them to size up and get much larger.

    Here's how to do it next time.

    If you grow in rows, sow 3 or 4 seeds per inch of row. After they sprout, let them grow until they are about 2-3" tall and then thin them to about 1" apart by gently pulling out the excess plants. Let them grow on a bit longer and thin them again when they are about 5-6" tall. At that point, thin them to their final spacing of 2" in between plants. Each time that you thin, water lightly around the remaining carrots to settle the soil back down around the remaining plants.

    If you broadcast your seed and grow them in blocks instead of in rows, you thin the same way, but it can take longer as you kneel there on your knees and eyeball the plants and try to make sure they are 1" apart in all directions, and then later 2" apart in all directions.

    The only other common reason that carrots wouldn't achieve their proper size is that the soil might have excess fertility which leads to all greens and not enough root. If you garden organically and have amended your soil with compost or cow manure or other organic matter, that organic matter should give the carrots all the nutrition they need to grow. If you garden with chemicals, a fertilizer with a 1-2-1 (like 10-20-10) ratio is usually adequate, scattered at the rate of 1 lb. per 100 s.f. for broadcast sowing or 1 lb. per 35 feet of linear row.

    The only only reason carrots wouldn't size up might be a soil pH that is too acidic or that the carrots were too wet during their formative weeks (the 4 to 6 weeks after they sprouted). If you keep your carrots just slightly dry (but not dry enough that the foliage wilts or yellows) during the first 4 to 6 weeks after the plants emerge from the soil, they'll stretch down deep to search for water and that will give them better length/size.

    Normally, you can harvest your carrots whenever they reach a usable size. I try to harvest when they are the approximate mature size for whatever variety or varieties I am growing. On the seed packet, it generally will tell you if the carrots get 7" long, or 8" or 10" or whatever. The 'days to maturity" on the seed packet help too. If your seed packet says your carrots mature at 80 days, then they should more or less mature at that age, give or take a few days.

    Dawn

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I am also growing carrots for the first time and have been using this as my guide.

    My carrots are up about an inch but have not been getting any bigger. I think I need to fertilize them with something. I am trying to use less chemicals this year so do I use fish emulsion? Or is there something better?

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Okla garden gal,
    I'm not sure of your temps there. I'm a lot further north than you are. Here things are germinating well due to the warm soil temps but just the last few days growing more. This is due to the cool nights we have been having here. Even the weeds that have come up around aren't growing much yet. I'm sure others will add their input. I don't worry about slow growth early in the season. I threw some carrot seeds in my cold frames with the greens. They are really growing in there. Will be eating a few shortly. But anything outside unprotected is growing slow here yet. If temps hold and night time temps stay in the 50's like the last few then that will change. Till then patience is the best virtue a person can have in my opinion. Maybe some in your area that know more what your conditions have been will chime in. Jay

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I use home made seed tape to sow carrots. This accomplishes several things. First it gives me a gardening task in the dead of winter. Second, it helps to achieve proper spacing, which is more important for carrots than other things. Third, it makes sowing faster which is good for the back given that spacing is tedious, yet important. Lastly, I believe that extra little bit of moisture retained by the paper towel tape aids in germination in my excessively well draining sandy soil. (On my list of questions to ask the Big Guy some day is why are carrots designed to grow well in the same sandy soil that makes it so difficult to germinate them.)

    Making seed tapes is simple. Use a cheap, poor quality paper towel and water soluble, washable school glue. Cut strips about an inch wide, apply dots of glue and drop on seeds. Sometimes it helps to gently nudge the seeds into the glue with a toothpick. Allow to dry then store in a ziploc bag until ready to use.

    Although my raised beds are 4 feet wide, I find I'm more successful with 2 foot lengths of paper towel. Otherwise, the wind at planting time can make my life miserable, fighting the strips.

    I have found the best place to store my carrots is exactly where they grew. The raised beds are right outside my kitchen door, so as I need them over the winter I just run out and pull what I need. Any that are left as spring approaches need to be pulled and stored in the basement. Otherwise they get tough as they start to produce seed.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Okla garden gal,

    How long ago did you plant your carrot seed? I consider carrots slow starters, so if I seed them in March, I don't worry about their growth rate at all in March and April. Like Jay said, slow growth early in the season is normal and not a cause for concern and not an indication that they need fertilizer. May is usually the month that my carrots make their best growth. If carrots are not making good growth in May in Oklahoma, then something might be wrong...something like soil that's too cold, too wet, too low in pH or soil that's very low in fertility.

    Keep in mind that carrots are mostly making the below-ground growth for the first few weeks, so they likely are growing and making progress right now but you just can't see it. After I plant carrots, I largely ignore them until it is time to thin them.

    Carrots perform best in a deep, well-drained sandy loam soil with lots of organic matter mixed into it. The organic matter (compost, chopped leaves, grass clippings, etc.) helps sandy soil hold moisture and nutrients and, if you happen to have clay soil, the organic matter loosens it up which enables carrots and other root crops to grow better.

    Without knowing how fertile your soil is or how recently it has had fertilizer (organic or chemical) added, none of us can tell you if your carrots need fertilizer. Based on my experience with carrots, as long as they're in soil with adequate levels of organic matter (3 to 6% OM is considered adequate), fertilizer generally isn't necessary. If feeding them with something mild like liquid seaweed or liquid fish emulsion would make you feel better, then go ahead and do it. It won't hurt them any and might help them, but they likely don't really need it. You know the old saying "A watched pot never boils", well it could be slightly amended to say "A watched carrot doesn't grow". I would avoid the use of chemical fertilizer high in nitrogen because they'll give you all green top instead of the root (carrot) part of the plant.

    Research at Texas A&M University has shown that carrots make their best growth, in terms of length, during the first 4 to 6 weeks after their topgrowth emerges from the soil, and they grow best if their soil is slightly dry during that time. So, it likely would be best to leave them alone right now and let them put down their length. Later, after they've gotten about as long underground as they are going to, then they'll start making more visible above-ground progress.

    I am assuming that you have soil with the right pH for carrots because they do not grow well in soil that really acidic or extremely alkaline. They will grow in a soil pH in the 5.8 or 6.0 thru 7.5 or maybe 7.7 range, but they're happiest in a pH between 6.5 and 7.6.

    Seedmama, When the day comes that I can ask the Big Guy my gardening questions, I'll be asking why carrots grow best at air temps between 40 and 85, but germinate best at temps around 77-80. I just wonder why he didn't make them germinate best at 40 degrees so they could germinate fast enough to grow when the best air temps exist.

    Some years I make seed tapes. This year I just scattered sowed. I haven't thinned yet. Mine are only an inch or an inch and a half tall.

    Dawn

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks Dawn and others....I think I will give it a try if it will not harm things.

    I planted March 16th and have already thinned once. Most of the seeds washed to one side and were not really in rows anymore. Next year I will broadcast seed or make seed tape.
    I dont have very good soil so I amended with peat to make it more fluffy.

    Carrots and pole beans are the two "new" things IÂve tried to grow this year.
    I guess I didnt expect them to grow so slow...

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Okla garden gal,

    You're welcome. Carrots can be tricky...they only want a couple of things....perfect soil, perfect temperatures and perfect moisture levels. Other than that, they aren't picky at all.

    Three things about peat moss that you might not know....
    1) It is highly acidic, so unless your soil is highly alkaline, peat moss is not necessarily good for carrots.
    2) Peat improves drainage when added to clay soil or rocky soil, but it is 'dead' and doesn't add nutrition. For nutrition, you need compost, composted manure , an organic fertilizer like Espoma Garden Tone, or something that is 'alive' in terms of biological life and nutrients.
    3) Peat moss is hard to dampen once it dries. It doesn't dry out well once it is wet. Peat moss can be difficult to use properly....it isn't you, it's the peat moss!

    Lots of cool-season plants grow slowly earlier in the season and then take off quickly once the soil temps and air temps hit some magic number. When the soil and air temps hit that magic zone that carrots like, they normally zoom up from tiny to big practically overnight. I think the carrots will be fine. They've only been in the ground a month, and it can take them practically that long to sprout, so don't worry about them...and relax, if you can. Gardening is supposed to be relaxing and stress-relieving, although at times it is the total opposite of that. : )

    Dawn

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    This thread has been a comfort. I planted mine on March 26th and was getting worried I was not seeing more action. They are in a raised bed, good soil, same with my radishes in the same bed. I am hoping the rain we are getting helps with moisture.