Software
Houzz Logo Print
littletwister

Green Beans and Marigolds

17 years ago

I have been reading on the net about companion planting. I have read that green beans and marigolds do not make good companions but no one says what the results would be if they are planted together. I have marigolds planted all through my garden. I also have bush and climbing green beans that are producing flowers but no beans. Could this be the problem?

I have posted this on the companion forum but no one has responded. I am tempted to pull the marigolds. Has anyone out there had any experience with this problem?

Thanks,

P

Comments (6)

  • 17 years ago

    Littletwister, this has been a bad year for beans. Mine are doing the same thing and I do not have marigolds planted with them, though I love marigolds and have them near my tomatoes.

    I think when the weather cools a little more you will have some beans, but I leave it to some of the others who are smarter about this than I to say for sure. Beans just don't set on in hot weather.

  • 17 years ago

    Littletwister,

    Companion planting is a widely accepted traditional form of gardening, but I don't think there's a lot of research to back it up. For every list that you can find on the internet that says "don't plant beans together with marigolds" you can find another one that says "do plant beans and marigolds together because marigolds repel Mexican Bean Beetles". So, which do you choose to believe?

    I companion plant and I have for years, but I don't necessarily match a specific herb or flower with a specific vegetable. Rather, I just interplant a wide variety of flowers and herbs with my veggies, and I choose flowers and herbs that are known to attract beneficial insects.

    It has been an awful year for bean production for many gardeners here in OK. I've planted beans for fall and we'll see if they produce in fall's cooler weather before a freeze arrives.

    Bush beans stop producing beans once the really hot weather arrives, so you'll have the best luck with them in spring and fall, but not so much in mid- to late-summer. Pole beans can be daylength-sensitive, so they won't form bean pods until the daylength is the specific length that variety needs. If your bean plants are healthy enough that they are producing flowers, you should get beans once the weather is cooler.

    Other than heat, the only other things that causes beans to fail to produce (as far as I know) are exposure to cold weather early in their life (if they were planted too early and were exposed to very cold temperatures, they can remain stunted and nonproductive for their entire life), insect damage to flowers or being too dry while blooming. If they are too dry while blooming, the flowers won't form beans and the blossoms will drop off the plant.

    Dawn

  • 17 years ago

    I too can verify this has been a terrible year for beans. And that's one of my favorite garden veggies. In fact, it's the worst year in recent memories for bean production.

    I too have recently re-planted fall beans in hopes I'd at least be able to can some to last through the winter. On a good year by this time, I'd have loads of beautiful beans already canned and in my pantry.

    I'm like Dawn, I wouldn't worry too much about companion planting as long as your planting lots of beneficial attractants in your garden. They not only bring the beneficials, they are lovely to look at and make your garden pretty as well as promoting a balanced eco-system.

    Good luck,
    Barbara

  • 17 years ago

    Yes! You can have marigolds in your green bean patch. This morning I found several little baby green beans. I still wonder why the warning on mixing the two.
    P

  • 17 years ago

    Could be because red spider mites love marigolds...and they love beans. In my garden, they tend to show up on marigolds first and then later move to beans, tomatoes and melons....and sometimes okra and black-eyed peas.

    So, it is likely someone saw them on marigolds first, and then on beans, and then decided it was the marigold's "fault" that the spider mites were on the beans. That, of course, is just a guess on my part.

    Here's how I handle them. In a year when spider-mite populations are low in my area, I leave the marigolds in the garden all year. In a year when spider-mite populations are high in my area, I pull the marigolds up by the roots once they are heavily infested, bag them into a tightly sealed trash bag and haul them to the dump. Using a type of plant like this to 'capture'a garden pest is known as trap cropping. This year, the marigolds had a heavy infestation of spider mites by mid-August, so I yanked them out. By then, though, there were mites on virtually everything else anyway. I'd say we have a bad mite year here about once every 3 or 4 years, so most years, the marigolds last from spring until the first fall freeze.

  • 17 years ago

    I've got a book on companion planting, sometimes I follow it and sometimes not.

    I did find it interesting that, in the information on the potato famine disease that is spreading on tomatoes in the Eastern parts of the country, it lists preventive measures and one of them is not to plant Marigolds with your tomatoes. Companion gardening information says they're good to plant with tomatoes. So there you have a conflict. I guess it just depends on what diseases and insects you're dealing with in your own little micro-climate, eh?

    I don't have a lot of gardening space so I tend to plant things where I have a space. Sometimes it's a space between tomato plants where one died. Other times it's where cabbage was that I've already harvested, and so on. I do love to mix flowers and herbs and vegetables though, because I like the looks of it.

Sponsored
Urban Upkeep LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars6 Reviews
Columbus High Quality Painting Expert