Software
Houzz Logo Print
okiedawn1

Tomato Grow List for Spring 2009

17 years ago

I have struggled with compiling this list because I fear that southcentral OK's drought, which really began in August 2007, will continue.

The list of tomato varieties I'd grow would differ markedly if I "knew" for sure that the drought would continue. So, finally, I decided to compile two lists: the first is a list of varieties that produce well in drought, and the second is a list of varieties that I'd plant in a normal year.

If rain does not begin falling soon, then the Drought List is the one I'll use when I start seeds Super Bowl Sunday.

If rain begins to fall in Dec.-Jan., then the second list is the one I'll use.

IF THE DROUGHT CONTINUES:

Cherry/Grape/Currant Types:

Black Cherry

SunGold

Tess' Land Race Currant

Grape

Paste/Plum:

Opalka

San Marzano Redorta

Martino's Roma

For Earliest Tomatoes (Plants in containers):

Better Bush

Bush Early Girl

New Big Dwarf

For Slicing/Beefsteak Types:

True Black Brandywine

Indian Stripe

Nebraska Wedding

Momotaro

Neve's Azorean Red

Royal Hillbilly

Brandy Boy

For Production in July/August:

Sioux

Homestead

Box Car Willie

Porter

Ramapo F-1

Supersonic

Prime Time

Arkansas Traveler

IF THE DROUGHT ABATES:

Cherry/Currant/Grape Types:

Black Cherry

SunGold

Tess' Land Race Currant

Grape

Husky Red Cherry

Ildi

Dr. Carolyn

Orange Santa

Paste/Plum Types:

Amish Paste

Black Plum

Martino's Roma

Opalka

Polish Linguisa

San Marzano Redorta

For earliest tomatoes (in containers):

Better Bush

Bush Early Girl

New Big Dwarf

For Slicing/Beefsteak Types:

True Black Brandywine

Indian Stripe

Black Krim

Cherokee Purple

Estler's Mortgage Lifter

Earl's Faux

Tennessee Britches

Valena Pink

Stump of the World

Brandywine Sudduth

Momotaro

Brandy Boy

Neve's Azorean Red

Porterhouse

Bucks County

Little Brandywine

Nebraska Wedding

Dr. Wyche's Yellow

Jaune Flammee'

Little Lucky

Lucky Cross

Royal Hillbilly

Jumbo Jim Orange

For July/August Production:

Ramapo F-1

Sioux or Super Sioux

Supersonic

Prime Time

Moreton

Arkansas Traveler

Dr. Wyche's Yellow

For Fall Tomatoes:

Livingston's Paragon

Livingston's Favorite

Livingston's Dwarf Stone

Livingston's Stone

Livingston's Perfection

Sun Leaper or Sunmaster or Heat Wave II

For Long-Keepers:

Red In, Yellow Out

Winterkeeper

Old-Fashioned Garden Peach

Sunray

Obviously, whether I go with the "Drought List" or the regular one, I'm planting fewer varieties.

And, honestly, I do expect the drought to continue and, therefore, I'll significantly cut back on the number of varieties planted and the total number of plants as well.

If the drought is moderate to severe, as it was in June-August of this past year, I won't plant any new plants for fall. Instead, I'll get what I can out of the spring-planted varieties. It is just too hard to get fall tomato varieties established in July unless I am getting rain, and even then it requires a lot of supplemental water.

And, if less than 1" of rain falls in December and less than 1" falls in January, I may even cut back and plant fewer varieties, and may plant them all in containers.

So, what tomato varieties are y'all planning to grow in 2009?

Dawn

Comments (2)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have to plant Celebrity and Early Girl every year because of how productive they are all year with good disease resistance. Most of the people I give or sell them to think they taste really good, so who am I to argue. I also pick a couple of commercial varieties from my local nursery for the same reasons. My most pleasant surprise this year was Brandy Boy, and Better Boy was good when I gave it good care, so I will include those again.

    I think I will try Laroma this year instead of the Roma I can find everywhere. I was not happy with my Romas this year and last year the Laroma was better when grown side-by-side. (To let you know how poor I am at appreciating the taste of various varieties, I actually liked the salsa I made last week from store-bought Romas as much as any I made all year from all my other varieties - mostly due to the thickness and the other stuff I added, though.)

    Every heirloom variety I tried last year was mostly a failure due to temperature swings and wet weather. I got 3 fair-sized tomatoes from the six pink brandywines that I planted, for example - and those were in the fall from August fruit-set.

    I now have 9 raised beds that are 4' by 16' and I tried putting 16 plants in each last year. I will probably go with 16 per bed for determinates and 12 per bed for indeterminates next year. I will probably also cover a few of them and try to get some plants in during the first half of March.

    So I guess I am just going with the 4 to 6 popular hybrids, adding a few commercial varieties, and then trying 8 or 10 heirlooms. If you know of any that are especially resistant to cracking, that would be great for my conditions until I get the soil improved more. I also will look for the good summer-setting ones and long-keepers from this and other threads. Lastly, I want a few that will produce really early.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Scott,

    First of all, with all the rain you had, it is remarkable that you had any tomatoes at all!

    We had that kind of rain here in April-July of 2004 (believe it or not) and I was the only person here among our "gardening circle" of friends, neighbors and acquaintances who had tomatoes at all. Our raised beds saved the day for us, because the folks who had their plants at grade level lost them when 12" of rain fell in the month of June and drowned the poor plants. I did have a lot of concentric cracking, and some vertical cracking as well, and to me the flavor of the tomatoes was not as strong as usual, but....the people with whom I shared the tomatoes were just so thrilled to have any tomatoes at all.

    Non-gardeners always think that rain is "always" a blessing for veggie gardeners, but the truth is that too much rain is, in some ways, more damaging than too little rain. If I had a choice (and I couldn't have "normal" weather"), I'd choose raising my veggies in drought over raising them in flooding rains.

    I thought about growing Celebrity, and there is NOTHING wrong with its flavor, but I am spoiled by the unique flavors of the heirlooms, so I usually don't grow it. I do, in fact like the flavor of several hybrids, among them Better Boy, Big Boy, Early Girl, Porterhouse, Little Brandywine and Bucks County. Every heirloom tomato is NOT superior in flavor to every hybrid, although a lot of them are.

    Roma was my dad's standard go-to tomato for sauce and salsa, so I grew up eating them and I like them. I do like LaRoma better (and so did he, once he tried it), but I quit growing it when I found Viva Italia, which is similar but has better flavor and much better disease resistance. THEN I found San Marzano which put the others to shame and I was sure it was "the" best paste tomato ever, until I grew San Marzano Redorta. At that point I was sure there couldn't be a better-tasting paste tomato, and for me, there probably isn't. And, yet, I love the flavors of Amish Paste, Martino's Roma, Grandma Mary's Paste and others like Heidi. Growing tomatoes is such a "journey" and it always amazes me when I find a "new" (to me) tomatoe that supplants one I had previously thought was the best. LOL

    And, guess what? In the winter, when grocery store tomatoes are all that are available, we happen to like salsa made from store-bought Romas just fine too! With salsa, it really isn't the tomato that contributes the most important part of the flavor....the tomato is just the base, and it is the peppers, onions and seasonings that make salsa taste like.....salsa!

    I always say to myself in winter that I won't "waste" garden space on Brandywine ever again, because 3 out of 4 years, they are very poor producers. Then, I think of their incredible taste and end up sneaking one or two into the garden somewhere. Brandy Boy has been a huge improvement, though, and gives tomatoes that taste almost as good as Brandywine, but not quite. I grow it because its' taste is close and its productivity is so much higher. Earl's Faux (grown from seed saved from Brandywine that had clearly crossed with something else, or at least that is what most people think) is close to BW in flavor and is more productive, but is not as productive in my garden as Brandy Boy.

    True Black Brandywine from Baker Creek Heirloom Seeds was a great new find in our garden this year. It outproduced all my other blacks and purples, and the flavor is great, although it is not quite as good as Brandywine Sudduth. It may be the only Brandywine I grow from this point forward.

    If you garden on level land, the best way I know to get early tomatoes is to plant them using Wall O'Water or Kozy Koat devices. Unfortunately, I garden on a slope and I can't use them because they tip over and the water spills out. Gordan Graham (now deceased), the gardener from Edmond, OK, who holds the world record for the largest tomato ever grown, liked to use WOWs to get an early start.....and he started his plants so early with them that he had to stack a second WOW on top of the first to protect his plants until all danger of frost had passed. I'll try to find a description of how he did it and post it in a separate thread.

    Since I can't use WOWs, I mulch heavily to keep the ground warm, and cover my plants with buckets and blankets during cold spells. For a couple of years I wrapped the cages of the early-planted tomatoes with plastic, but that is a huge job and interferes with air flow. So, now if a severe cold spell with several consecutive days of sub-freezing temps threatens, I build a quick hoop house over the plants using 6mm plastic. I've managed to protect the plants from late sleet by doing that.

    Some of the older tomato varieties that are most resistant to cracking (some are true O-P heirlooms but some are just really old hybrids from the 1950s or earlier) include Sioux, Super Sioux, Homestead 24, Santa Clara Canner, Carnival, Mule Team, Champion, Box Car Willie, Earl of Edgecombe, Akers West Virginia, Traveler 76, Arkansas Traveler, Rutgers, Zogola, Porter (barely larger than Large Red Cherry), Porter Improved, and Bradley Pink. Most of the processing tomatoes that have "Heinz" or "Campbell" in their name are very crack-resistant, and so are some of the newer hybrids like Cobra and Amelia. If enough rain falls, though, or if you over-irrigate (and I know you wouldn't), any tomato will crack though because the excess moisture makes the inside flesh grow faster than the outer skin.

    I've never had any of my heirloom Livingston tomatoes crack either but I've never had the kind of moisture that you do. My favorite Livingstons are Golden Queen, Gold Ball and Paragon, but Stone and Perfection are outstanding too. Victory Seed is the only company I trust for authentic Livingston tomato seed. One thing about the Livingstons that I adore is that they grow and produce in the worst of our droughts. I don't know why they are so much tougher than other tomatoes in drought years--perhaps it is superior genetics

    Early tomatoes can be quite vexing. There are many years when some 70-75 DTM tomatoes give me ripe tomatoes before Early Girl does, and I have no idea why. Among the better ones for early tomatoes are Bush Early Girl, New Big Dwarf (slow in some people's gardens, but an early producer in mine), Sophice's Choice, Matina, Kimberly, Stupice (pronounced stoo-PEECH-ka, by the way), and Glacier. I use Better Bush as an early, but it is only early because I buy it when it is already quite large--clearly started by the growers in November to give early-bird gardners like me large plants in 6" pots in mid-Feb. to mid-March. Among the cherries, both Grape and Black Cherry produce very early for me.

    Finally, if you are looking for tomatoes that produce in our climate, one of the best (and few) "local" seed sources is Wilhite Seed, based in Poolville, Texas, west of Fort Worth. Although Wilhite's specialty is watermelons (oh my, their selection boggles the mind), they cater to market growers, so if they offer a variety, it is a good producer. Since Porter and Sons Seed went out of business in either the 1980s or 1990s, Wilhite is the only company in Texas that I buy seed from.

    Dawn

    Here is a link that might be useful: Willhite Seed Co. website

Sponsored
Bella Casa LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars17 Reviews
The Leading Interior Design Studio in Franklin County