Software
Houzz Logo Print
thenewmidwestchilehead

Dammit, why all the hybrids?

Ok so I burned up a few of my chile plants before I got them planted and looked for some replacements at grocery stores and home centers. I saw some interesting looking chiles I had never seen nor heard of, like the Cherry bomb, Holy Mole and the Apache chile. I took them home and dutifully planted them, but then researched them and found they are all hybrids. If I understand it correctly, it isn't worth saving seeds from a hybrid because the offspring will not be true. So, is it a general rule to enjoy hybrids for the season but don't plan on planting their seeds the next year?

Comments (10)

  • 16 years ago

    well, yes, that is how it works - there's no point in saving seeds from hybrids. that is a draw back. There are upside to hybrids, though. One is, many of them are more disease resistant. Two, they've developed some incredible hybrid plants. For example, the hybrid Biker Billy will blow away just about any jalapeno you will find, and the Italian Roaster II hybrid is far superior to other similar cultivars. So...there's upsides and downsides, obviously if you want to save seeds than hybrids are not the way to go.

  • 16 years ago

    I am a seed saver, but I just cannot do without my Kung Paos. Great flavor, heat, they outproduce anything else, and are pretty much uncrackable as far as diseases go

  • 16 years ago

    I think the seed companies and nurseries spread the half truth about Hybrids being usless for saving seeds so they can sell more plants and seeds each year.

    Some don't grow true,some are sterile but a lot are stable hybrids and produce true from saved seeds ,at least for a few generations.

    Sometimes it takes generations for a hybrid that is self polinated (isolated so it only polinates itself)to start to go back to it's origins.

    It also seems it would be a lot of work with all the hybrids out there for companies to have to make sure they had the crosses they needed each year , and to make sure each cross grew the desired plant.
    They would have to cross pollinate 2 or more plants each year to get the hybrid they desired.
    Some hybrids are several crosses of several different plants through generations of crossing and growing the seeds out to get the end product they desire.I think it would be too labor intensive to do each year for so many hybrids as they have these days.

    I'd save seeds from isolated plants/buds and grow them out to see what you get.
    If you don't isolate the buds you want to get pods from you might be making another hybrid by crossing with other plants in your garden.
    Your wierd plant might not be caused by an unstable hybrid but the new one you just made.

  • 16 years ago

    I agree with smokemaster. In order to get the hybrid result that they are seeking they must have stabilized the seed source so they could mass produce this. Otherwise production would not be viable. Thus, I am willing to bet the majority of true stabilized hybrid peppers would breed true at least for a couple of generations (if not) at least one generation.

    Just my thoughts.
    Danny

  • 16 years ago

    If you LIKE the hybrid pepper, you can always take cuttings or bring the plant inside for the winter, and keep it going that way.

  • 16 years ago

    Exactly!
    Start cuttings or simply keep the plant alive over winter.
    When you find a plant you like, don't let it go!

    Josh

  • 16 years ago

    Lots of ways to go, But F1 hybrids are produced each year. Todays varieties frequently use in bred breeding lines so the F2 generations may be not be as divergent as the older hybrids. BUT bottom line F1 hybrids have to be just that or government regulations come swinging in. Most production takes place in low wage countries. Nothing wrong with saving hybrid seeds, if you do not need consistency in production. If you are growing for a living, you are betting the farm on a plants performance. Growing as a hobby, you have little to lose.

  • 16 years ago

    Interesting posts. I have several plants that I plan to overwinter, so my space will be limited, but I will try saving some seeds from Hybrids (I do isolate my chiles) and see what grows next year.

  • 16 years ago

    I would try to sow the seeds and see what happens. After all hybridization happens in nature and many hybrids produce fertile seeds. you have little to lose.
    stefano

  • 16 years ago

    Ok, now I have questions on cloning. Is the rooting hormone or gel absolutely essential? And every time I've tried this, the cuttings just wilt and die. From the reading I've done, you either have to use a humidity dome or some kind of spray that stops the leaves from transpiring. I assume that either a dome or the spray is essential since all of mine have withered and died. And are peat pots good for this purpose?

Sponsored
The Creative Kitchen Company
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars52 Reviews
Columbus Area Kitchen Remodeling and Refacing Professional