Software
Houzz Logo Print
angelyne_gw

Disappointed

19 years ago

I've started a garden this year using the square gardening method. It was a lot of work, as you all know.

However I'm disappointed with the results so far. I've planted about 20 days ago, and I don't find that my plants are prospering well. For the past two years I've been planting a garden, but using the native soil. My soil was pretty good and I was getting good results, but I wanted to try the square gardening method.

My cucumbers are still only about 6 inches in height. Some of my tomatoes plants have prospered and doubled in size, but some have not. The ones that have prospered are the ones who came in individual containers. The tomatoes I bought that were grown in the same container are still recovering from having their roots disturbed.

My peppers are growing very slowly, so are my beans. The only things that seem to be doing really well are the zucchinis and I stuck them in the shadiest part of my garden!

I seem to recall that my vegetables were much further along last year, at this time.

Could it be that my mix is not up to stuff? I followed the "recipe" but used an unequal mix of compost. I used mostly horse manure, with a couple of bags of mushroom compost, leaf compost and sheep compost.

Also, squirrels have been digging holes in my garden, even digging plants out altogether. They love the loose soil it seems. Because of that, my carrots and beets have lost their nice symmetry and are growing whichever way. To add to my back luck, birds ate my young bean seedlings, so I only have a few left. I re-planted, but no luck so far.


I spread some bloodmeal on the soil to repel the damn squirrels, and I plan to do some trap and release. Hopefully that will fix that. Not sure what to do about the slow growth rate. Any suggestions? Should I start fertilizing?

Comments (17)

  • 19 years ago

    Hi Angelyne,

    Fron what you described, I don't blame you for being disappointed. I have set-up a lot of SF gardens over the years.....for myself and dozens of neighbors and every one was successful. I have never used Mel's Mix.....primarily due to the cost of ingredients. I mix my own growing medium using sphagnum peat, shredded leaves and some cheap compost. Some of my best crops were grown in shredded leaves and sand. I have on occasion used some exsisting soil and mixed a lot of stuff with it. Because I use very little compost, I do use garden fertilizer and rabbit manure.
    As to a possible problem with your garden....I'm going to take a wild guess and blame it on the compost you used.
    I have never used vermiculite in any of my gardens. I used sphagnum peat instead to start with and then shredded leaves each year thereafter.
    I hope you find out the cause of your problem and can correct it....and continue using the SF method of gardening.
    Roln in Iowa

  • 19 years ago

    This is also a guess, but it may just be the weather. We have had a fairly cool, but sunny spring around here. The plants you're describing are mostly heat lovers (tomatoes, zucchini, cukes) and may just be waiting for warmer days. How are other gardeners in your area doing.

  • 19 years ago

    I have to wonder if the soil was good before why anybody would bother making the mix. Thats the biggest complaint I have with Mel's method, why would I buy dirt? Whats wrong with the dirt I have?
    The answer, in my case is pretty much nothing, my plants are about where I expect them to be, which is to say I'm ahead of my neighbors.

    Anyway, are your plants getting enough water? The soil in the garden I have now is much sandier than I'm used to (my folks have clay soil) so it needs more frequent watering as I haven't been able to build up the OM content much yet. I've found when its warm I need to water nearly every day at least a bit and then the seeds come up so much better than they did when I didn't water.

    I also wonder, is that horse manure fresh? Maybe its burning the plants a bit? Again more water might help.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks for the replies and encouragement.

    I did compare notes with my coworker and his cucumbers seem to be a little further along than mine. I am mostly comparing my results with last year. We are mostly getting the same type of weather as last year, so I was expecting comparable results.

    To answer your question curtludwig, I had no problems with my soil, but I was attracted to the idea of the raised beds. Now that I have done it, I like it. They make the garden look neat, and they make it easier to work, as you don't have to bend down as much to work it. But since I made some raised beds, I had to fill them with something didn't I. Unless I was willing to excavate my garden, which seemed silly, I couldn't have used my current soil. Unless I am missing something obvious?

    I've been watering every day that it doesn't rain. The mix do seem to get drier faster that my soil, so I take no chances. The horse manure was sold to me as ready to use. The farmer said it was 5 years old.

    But it could be...what else could it be... that the mix isn't rich enough or maybe unbalanced in its nutrient profile. I'll try to find a home soil test somewhere. In the meantime I'll keep watering and I'll keep fertilizing. Still, considering the work and expense, I was expecting something much more. I kinda regret it now. My soil was really awesome. Full of earthworms. I think the owners before me had been using the garden for like 10 years.

  • 19 years ago

    Do you have a mulch down? I didn't notice that was mentioned.

    V.

  • 19 years ago

    No, I don't have mulch, would that make a difference? I am still unsure of what the best mulch would be.

  • 19 years ago

    I'll admit I'm lazy about my raised beds but mine are above grade. I cut out my squares, removed the sod (into the compost) loosened the ground with my tined spade and spaded in a bag of composted cow manure. That brought everything up to 1-2" above the rest of the yard (which is obviously compacted).
    If I were going to do a higher bed I'd do the same thing but add some more compost (my own if I had it). Just spade the compost into the existing soil which would give me basically dirt with higher OM content. I'd buy as little as possible, I really don't see spending alot on a garden.

  • 19 years ago

    I just put my frames on top of the existing soil, never bothered with a mix. I use shredded leaves for mulch, keeps the moisture constant and the weeds down, esp. in the walkways.

    If it is any consolation my plants haven't taken off yet either but I haven't put alot of effort into it so far this year.

    Maybe you should get a soil test, not a ph kit but a real soil test. May (no, it will) save you some serious trouble, money, and guess work.

    HTH,
    Gumby_CT

  • 19 years ago

    This is my first year also and I was feeling the same way as you. I posted a question about it and was told that the first year Mel's Mix has not yet established living organisms, so they suggested using some organic fertilizer the first year. So,I've attached a link about the organic fertilizer. I ended up using liquid fish emulsion and seaweed and it really did work. I also used Alfalfa meal on the leafy vegetables like lettuce and spinach. About a week later, my plants started growing faster. Give it a try. They recommend repeating it every few weeks.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Might be helpful

  • 19 years ago

    I posted my travails in another area on the forum, but I've had the exact same problem. I followed Mel's directions exactly, and wonder why I'm having such bad luck with plants. In reading the book, I thought I would have such wonderful plants with the expensive Mel's Mix! Instead, they taste bad, they're yellow, stunted, straggly, and just like Angelyne said. My garden center recommended adding fertilizer, so I bought some organic fertilizer plus fish emulsion. I don't see any change yet, and it's been a couple of weeks. I'm so disappointed because that Mel's Mix was really expensive! I live in San Diego and we have really bad soil so using my soil wasn't really an option without amending it for a few years. I don't really know where to turn next because I don't want to give up the SFG method, but Mel's Mix isn't working forme.

  • 19 years ago

    I asked about mulch because I wondered if the dirt was drying out.

    I agree -- take a sample to your county extension office for a full test before you try other ammendments to the soil.

    Apart from veggies in square foot gardening style, I'm also dabbling in self-watering containers.

    In the book "Incredible Vegetables From Self Watering Containers" by Edward C. Smith there's the soil recipe of....

    One 20 qt bag mature compost
    One 20 qt bag of homemade or bought planting mixture (sphagnum peat moss, vermiculite, and limestone)
    1/3 cup blood meal
    1/3 cup collodial phospate
    1/3 cup greensand
    1 tbs azomite

    I don't know if that recipe helps you any, but there it is. I haven't tried it yet, because my tomato container came with dirt (gardener's supply.)

    GL!
    V.

  • 19 years ago

    "I used mostly horse manure, with a couple of bags of mushroom compost, leaf compost and sheep compost."
    The symptoms you described make it sound like the roots of your seedlings are being burned. Was the horse manure composted (or given a chance to age in-soil) before planting? I also have to let mushroom compost sit for a bit to finish cooking, but that might be my source.

  • 19 years ago

    I'm in the same position you were in bonniecat. My soil is very hard clay and amending it would take a very long time. That's one of the reasons I am planning a SFG. I was planning on using Mel's mix, but after reading through this post I am having my doubts.

    I do my own composting, so that part of the mixture is not going to be an issue. I was planning on buying the vermiculite and peat to mix in, but it really is expensive. I have access to rabbit manure, which I usually put in my compost (I know I don't have to though) Any suggestions?

  • 19 years ago

    Seraki,

    Other than cost it's really hard to go wrong with Mel's mix. Lots of nutrients, drains well and holds water well. Doesn't crust like many soils, contains few to no weed seeds initially etc.

    Still, there are many sq fters who aren't using Mel's mix. A lot depends on how good the local soil is.

    To grow plants close together with a little to no fertilizer input requires a really good growing medium.

    My own soil is clay and rock and has tons of weed seeds in it and I have given up on it.

    Other areas have a nice loam soil and that's better.

    Still others have lousy soil, but a phone call to a landscaper/nursery later a truck with good soil shows up and the problem is solved.

    By far the compost is the most important part of a square foot garden. Make your mix (whatever it is) 1/3rd or more compost (of good quality) and you are all set.

    The nice thing about a contained, raised bed is that if the soil mix you start with doesn't work out well, one can always alter it with minimal labor/expense for next year.

  • 19 years ago

    First, thanks for writing back so quick, I really appreciate it! :-)

    Well, I do my own composting, so I know that the quality is good. I use a great mixture of leaves, coffee, kitchen waste, rabbit manure and other trimmings from the rest of my yard.

    I guess my biggest concern is that it is just so darn hot and dry in Phoenix. I worry that it will dry out too fast, or get to hot in the soil. I will definitely make sure I use a lot of compost.

  • 19 years ago

    From what I've read in other places in the forum, Mel's Mix might sometimes benefit from additional compost. As for me, I spent considerable effort searching out five different types of compost to combine for the mix. I used steer manure, worm castings, and three other different types of compost, all store-bought. Perhaps the compost I bought wasn't good. I don't know. I'm not giving up on square foot gardening, but I sure am disappointed with my results this first year. I bought a ComposTumbler recently and am about to make my first load of home-made compost. No doubt that will be better than some of the store-bought stuff since I will control what goes into it. So I will amend the SFG with my own compost and see what happens. It certainly was a major disappointment, though, to follow the rules exactly and have such unfortunate results. It sure helps to read about others' experiences, though, and to have my own confirmed.

  • 19 years ago

    Well I posted a thread about this in the soil forum. I'm hoping someone there will have enough knowledge about soils, etc. I'm thinking it must have something to do with the heat.

    Doing your own composting is rewarding though. It's nice to know that you're not wasting anything, and fertilizing your gardens to boot!

    I must say I am glad I have these forums to ask questions on.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Soil Forum Thread

Sponsored
Industry Leading Kitchen & Bath Remodelers in Franklin County, Ohio