Software
Houzz Logo Print
mommyfox

Sick tree and suggestions for bed

18 years ago

Ok, so I have two issues at the moment. We have a massive post oak in our front yard that is doing poorly. The north side of the tree appears to have ants, and a lot of the bark is loose, almost in a straight line up the side of the tree. Is it the ants doing this, or are they a side effect? It's also dropping leaves and small branches. What can I do to help the poor thing? How the heck do you fertilize a tree that size? Seriously, it's about 2.5' thick and taller than our two-story house. I really, really do not want to lose this tree.

Also, on a happier note ... I need to do something permanent with what was previously an annual bed. I'm tired of planting annuals there. It's a square raised bed about 5' x 5', right by my driveway. In the far corner is a 5' weeping redbud. In front of the redbud is a semi-circle of grape hyacinth. In the other three corners are confetti lantana, and there is reseeding sweet alyssum along the borders. It's in full sun, sandy and amended with compost. I've had snapdragons, pansies, zinnias and portulaca there, and I'm ready to put some permanent stuff so I can stop replanting this bed every few months! Anyone have some cool design/plant ideas?

I have a VERY outdated picture of the bed below. The irises are gone, and a lot of the plants have changed, but it'll at least give an idea of the layout of the bed.

Raised Square Bed

Comments (20)

  • 18 years ago

    Mommyfox,
    Perhaps you could consult a licensed arborist about your tree, or at least get an opinion from a horticulturist from a local college.
    Your raised bed sounds interesting, and I agree that annuals are nice, but perennials are better! Have you considered flame acanthus (orange or pink) which attracts butterflies; salvia greggii which comes in pink, raspberry, white or red (ditto the butterflies and hummingbirds); black and blue salvia (color self-explanatory); Jerusalem sage (yellow) which can get pretty big; and perhaps a nice grass like Mexican feather grass or Chihuahuan love grass?
    Even though you are in zone 7, I wouldn't wait around much longer to plant. Good luck, and enjoy your perennials!

  • 18 years ago

    I think I'm too late to plant the bed for the coming summer. I'm going to wait for the fall to plant. Unfortunately I've got to stick with shorter stuff - I don't want to hide the redbud in the back, which is all lush and neat even though it's short!

    I do like the idea of attracting hummers or butterflies. I've got kind of a primary color thing going on around that area - yellow carolina jessamine and dark red mums are nearby, so maybe red and yellow, or blue and yellow.

    I'm going to wait for a few more opinions before calling an arborist, but if more folk agree, I will do that. It's too great a tree to lose. I'd rather spend $200 saving it than $200 taking its dead body down.

  • 18 years ago

    Not sure about your post oak. They're very finicky trees that get stressed and die at the drop of a hat (not like regular oaks). As for your flowerbed, you mentioned that you might like red - how about ruelia elegans? I just saw it on another's blog and it looks so pretty and dainty and wouldn't hide your little tree.

    Here is a link that might be useful: ruelia elegans

  • 18 years ago

    I don't understand why you would not consult an arborist immediately. A tree that size is very valuable, and the cost of a tree specialist would be well worth it IMHO. Post Oaks are extremely susceptible to any type of root disturbance such as digging, etc. A friend paid a large premium for her lot because of the large Post Oak on it. The tree died within a year of building the house because it was not protected properly during construction.

  • 18 years ago

    I just wanted to make sure I wasn't overreacting, you know? I'd hate to call out an arborist and have him give me a condescending look while he said "You have ants. Get a spray bottle of insecticide. Here's my bill."

  • 18 years ago

    It sounds like your Post Oak is being attacked by the fungal disease hypoxylon canker that kills trees. However, it simply finishes off sick trees.

    Trees weaken due to old age, bad soil, soil grade changes such as several inches of soil being added around the base of the tree for flower gardens, exposure to herbicides such as weed and feed products, other chemicals and so forth.

    In the picture I see a raised bed around the base of a tree. Is that your sick post oak?

  • 18 years ago

    Yes, that's the oak in question. The raised bed around it was there when we moved in, 2 1/2 years ago. Should I take that bed down? It's about a foot tall.

    The pictures of the cankers I've seen don't really match it; I'm trying to get my camera to work so I can post a picture. I'm calling an arborist tomorrow regardless.

  • 18 years ago

    I used tree trunk goop and sick tree treatment from Howard Garrett on some of my trees and it really seemed to help. I agree you should call an arborist, tho, since it is a post oak.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Links to trunk goop and sick tree treatment

  • 18 years ago

    The only hope for your tree is to remove the raised bed and remove the soil until you can see the root flare. The roots of your post oak have been effectivly smothered. The lose bark and ants are not a good omen. Regarding the continued advice to call an arborist, if he/she is worth their salt they will tell you to get the soil off the roots.

  • 18 years ago

    mommyfox,

    Now would be a great time to get some salvia and sages at Lowe's on clearance. They look a little rough now but are very cheap and will perk up in the fall and look great next spring. Just make sure they are the perennial salvia and not the big blooming annuals. I usually find lots of great deals as it get too hot for them to water! I just plop them into the bed and sit a lawnchair over them for shade for a few days till the get settled.

    Also, the Texas Discovery gardens at Fair Park are having their butterfly plant sale next weekend. Great large plants, good prices, hard to find plants and very knowledgeable people. Plus, it is funds their educational programs!

    Here is a link that might be useful: Plant sale info

  • 18 years ago

    Ok, I had a guy out today, and he said we had carpenter ants. He recommended calling a "tree surgeon" to do mineral injections all around the tree (something I've never heard of before) and/or calling a pesticide company to spray for ants. I hesitate to do this because I'm afraid pesticides will also kill the beneficial insects hanging around - butterflies, ladybugs, spiders, bees and the like.

    What do you guys think?

  • 18 years ago

    Hmmm I dunno' ... most of what I read says that Texas carpenter ants aren't damaging as some other species of wood ants and don't excavate areas to build their nest, but use already existing hollow areas just by cleaning them out a bit. So why would the tree have hollow places for the ants, or why are the limbs and leaves dropping? Makes me wonder if the guy didn't really know and is just blaming it on the carpenter ants, which are very common. I see them crawling around on trees and plants all the time.

    I'm with you on the insecticides. I'd go with baits or natural remedies like orange oil (or the white stuff I can never spell and starts with a 'D'), but still the original question remains. Was it the ants that caused the damage or are they just a side effect? I'm thinking the latter. Doesn't seem to me like carpenter ants would attack and damage a large live tree, but then I'm not an arborists either.

    But since you asked the feeling here is that the sick tree treatment mentioned above is the probably the wisest way to go.

    Here is a link that might be useful: TAMU on carpenter ants ...

  • 18 years ago

    When we first moved in 2 1/2 years ago, the bed around it was filled with algerian ivy that had grown up the trunk of the tree. Realizing this was a bad thing, I tore all of it out of that bed. Could the ivy have damaged the bark enough on that side to make room for the carpenter ants?

  • 18 years ago

    Although post oaks are notoriously finicky, it does sound like the soil has been built up too high & the roots are smothered.

    If your tree trunk appears to be a cylinder, like a telephone pole, that's the problem.

    It should have a pronounced flare at the base, where the surface roots spread out.

    If that's the case, dismantle & scrape away the raised bed & use Howard Garrett's "sick tree treatment".

    You can get the recipe on his website, Dirtdoctor.com, or you can get it pre-mixed at any good organic nursery.

    IMO, the only things that should be planted beneath trees are shallow-rooted groundcovers that won't climb.

    Otherwise, you have plants leeching away the water & nutrients that the tree needs, you have soil level building up, & you have a shade bed that will have to be completely re-made anyway-into a sun bed when the tree falls.

    wish every city had an ordinance on what people were allowed to put around their trees...

    So often the second homeowner inherits these problems, not realizing, since the trees look healthy when they buy the house, that there's a lethal condition in their yards/gardens.

    As to the carpenter ants, I bet you can kill them with a mild organic insecticide.

    Best luck!

  • 18 years ago

    The ants are merely a further sympton of a sick tree. Ants and other insects do not infect healthy trees. You have been told repeatedly told what needs to be done. However, IMO, it is probably too late.

  • 18 years ago

    I don't think the tree is so far gone that it's beyond help. Furthermore, it's better to do a week's worth of asking questions and doing research than to run out and start doing things at random. The canopy is still pretty strong, and there's evidence that the bark is healing itself. I have a picture now ...

    {{gwi:1348450}}

    Since there is a root flare visible, does that mean the tree was put into an existing bed 20 some-odd years ago? Is that bed smothering the roots, or is it at a proper level?

    I'd rather do nothing than do the wrong thing and make things worse.

  • 18 years ago

    Well, it looks like a good flare to me, but since the tree is having trouble, I think I'd probe around in there & see if I could find the surface roots.

    If they're several inches beneath the soil, then go ahead & excavate some more, just a little at a time.

    Best luck!

  • 18 years ago

    Thank you Sylvia! I will do just that.

  • 18 years ago

    Ok, I finally got the bed completely gone! Gah, that was a JOB! There were surface roots all over. I can see why the former residents wanted to make a bed over them, but yeah, definitely not good for the tree. Hopefully it will recover. Thank you everyone for telling me what was wrong with the tree!

    The injection method I mentioned above - anyone done it before? Now that the major job of hauling that bed off is done, I can concentrate on other ways to help the tree recover. Spray for ants or just let the tree take care of them as it strengthens?

  • 18 years ago

    I wouldn't use any kind of chemicals. Just go as natural as you can. Spread a thin layer of compost followed by corn meal, soybean meal, kelp meal and alfalfa pellet/meal on the entire property. If you can rent core aerator, it might work better. If you are having pest problems, try beneficial nematodes.

Sponsored
Bella Casa LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars17 Reviews
The Leading Interior Design Studio in Franklin County