Software
Houzz Logo Print
osomom_gw

Choosing Range hood, please help!

14 years ago

After reading the previous posts and my own need, I am narrowing down to 2 choices: Proline PFLW 115.30 and Cavaliere AP238-PS13. they seem to be the exact hood (even the manuals are 99% identical) except Proline give you a stronger halogen bulb with extra year (total 2) warranty and the Cavaliere stated theirs have a 30 hour cleaning reminder which I don't really care one or the other. Neither disclosed where they were made.

However, the stainless steel material got me confuse - Proline''s weighted 68 lbs use 430 stainless with no disclosure of the gauge; Cavaliere said theirs are 304 with 19 gauge SS, no wt info provided. Price are very compatible. Which one is better?

Any comment, suggestion is appreciated. Thanks.

Comments (4)

  • 14 years ago

    General comments are possible but the "better" question cannot be answered with just the information provided.

    With the caveat that metallurgy isn't my field:

    300 series corrosion resistant steels (CRES) include nickel and chromium with the iron and are non-magnetic. They may take a better surface finish as seen on stainless flatware.

    400 series CRES do not have nickel. They are more corrosion resistant under some conditions, not normally applicable to a kitchen hood. They may allow better (less brittle) welds. They are magnetic.

    Color may differ due to the nickel, which by itself is yellower than chromium due to lower reflectivity in the blue end of the spectrum.

    My Wolf branded, made by Independent, Pro Island hood is non magnetic and presumably a 300 series stainless steel. Welds look good to me, but the cost was high enough to pay for quality work.

    I have a decades old magnetic Revere Ware pan that works on my induction cooktop. It is presumably made with a 400 series steel. The steel is less shiny inside than similarly old Farber Ware pans that are non-magnetic, presumably 300 series stainless, and not usable with induction.

    (Note that stainless steels are not truly stainless, just stain resistant. I had to use phosphoric acid to clean the hood extension of factory supplied fingerprints. Brushed stainless is harder to clean with polishes than smooth stainless.)

    kas

  • 14 years ago

    My comment is about the company. I had a VERY disappointing experience with ProLine. The model that I originally ordered never arrived. I had to settle for a different one to be able to finish the kitchen. The model that I received did not have one of the advertised features (dimmable lights) or it simply doesn't work. There is no documentation to support their '2 year warranty' claim

  • 14 years ago

    Thanks for the info. During my research, I found out Cavaliere's hood is actually 201 stainless, not 304 as listed in some website. I confirm with Cavaliere and told build.com, venting,direct.com. They agreed and thanks me for that, however, it still shows 304 SS in the website. That's misleading.

  • 14 years ago

    201 stainless steel has less nickel (replaced by manganese) but Allegheny-Ludlum claims the properties and appearance are nearly identical to type 304 (Use google to find "Why Make The Switch To Type 201 Stainless Steel?"). I don't know how nearly is nearly.

    kas