Software
Houzz Logo Print
athensmomof3_gw

Hardwoods on split landings - direction question

14 years ago

The hardwood guys are working at our house and we have several landings (back hall stairs and basement stairs) where they split the landings 1/4 turn to make the stairs work better with high ceilings and in an attempt to take up a little less space. This means on both staircases we have two treads (really a split landing) where the stair nose is on a diagonal. The hardwood guy ran the floors on the diagonal on those stairs only - the rest are horizontal. I think it looks goofy to have them on only a couple of stairs. He says it is traditionally done by following the stair nose but he can do that or run them horizontally and miter them in.

This is a very traditional, new old house and the diagonal floor, even in that small area, seems more contemporary.

Do any of you have these split landings with hardwood? I'll post a picture tomorrow - didn't have my camera or phone today. . .

Thanks!

Comments (21)

  • 14 years ago

    Hi there, we, too, have a couple of split landings and the hardwood runs parallel with the noses. If I'm understanding you correctly, I think it's the same situation you have, and in our case, it doesn't look "off." Here, it's as if it was a larger square landing that has been split diagonally with one step up...is that what you have? As we walk up, it seems natural that the wood runs along the nosing all the way up the stairs. Hope that helps.

    (I remember you from the end of our build... you must be nearing yours! I have been coming for info on the garden forums and lurk a little here to remember the building process. It seems so long ago already! I hope you have had a good experience and I am sure your home is gorgeous...I remember you have excellent taste!)

  • 14 years ago

    So very helpful! I remember your house too - very beautiful and classic! My hardwood guy did say that is how it was usually done . . . Sounds like you have exactly what we have. I am going to take pictures tomorrow and post so check back :) I think what threw me off is that we have 3 stairs going into the basement, kind of in a stairwell , and you see the three stairs and then the diagonal right away . . . The alternative may look worse, actually, except we will likely have a runner on these, even if it is just sisal, so the "edges" would match better if they were mitered in. Do you have a runner on yours? I am afraid with boys and no runner in a tight stairwell, people will be crashing into walls!

  • 14 years ago

    Yes, I'll check back and make sure I'm reading your design right. No, I thought I would end up with a runner right away, but I have been loving the simplicity and I haven't found the finish (waterlox) to be slippery at all. I also don't have three boys! :) I hear you that with the runner you might like the orientation to be consistent. I'll check back for your photos tomorrow. Good luck!

  • 14 years ago

    Here is a terrible picture - with iphone, no lights in the house, dust everywhere. . . These are stairs going into the basement. The stairs running above (which are open) have the same issue . .

    {{gwi:1403513}}

  • 14 years ago

    Looks correct to me... I don't think you would want butt end seams running perpendicular to the nose. You might create a catch that could trip someone.

  • 14 years ago

    Looks right to me. I think it creates a nice visual "transition" from the boards running horizontally to the vertical.

  • 14 years ago

    I have a winder that has three stairs on 180-degrees (winder ont he landing). We mocked it up both ways; one with the hardwood parallel to the stair nose and one with the hardwood parallel to the wall and mitered in to the stair nose. I can tell you that in my situation parallel to the wall and mitered in to the stair nose looked better.

    Throw some hardwood scraps on there in a different direction, decide if you like the look better, and if so change it. It really doesn't have to be complicated, will take about 5 minutes, and the materials are already at your site. My install wraps around a full 180-degrees, so all boards on the entire stair are parallel, just worked differently.

    I can tell you that I find that trim piece in the lower left corner of the diagonal stair is what I would be more concerned about. That is NOT aesthetically pleasing.

    Looking at your situation, I prefer the parallel to the stair nose that is installed now. However it only takes a minute to mock it up another way and make your own decision.

  • 14 years ago

    Good idea to mock it up. I'll do that tomorrow. The trim piece doesn't bother me but maybe there is a better way? What would you suggest? I know I would not like it diagonal all the way down. It seems the only way I can think of to maintain the baseboard height and transition to the diagonal portion of the baseboard.

    Do you have a picture of what you suggest?

  • 14 years ago

    This is another option I found but that looks worse with the baseboards not even all the way down the stairs. It seems like what is shown in my picture is the traditional way it is done - at least from a quick google search. Open to other options though!

    Here is a link that might be useful: {{gwi:1403512}}

  • 14 years ago

    {{gwi:1403514}}

    width="120" height="120">

  • 14 years ago

    Worthy - your picture didn't come through on my end . . .

  • 14 years ago

    The picture is of a winder (tapered angle step) not a platform.

    On a winder step the wood is parallel to the nosing of each winder.

    On a platform it is normally set up to match the stair direction from the public space.

  • 14 years ago

    Brickeye - do I have a winder? Or a platform? I can't see worthy's picture . . .

  • 14 years ago

    Now that building codes have limited the depth of the narrow end of a winder tread to 6 inches, the use of a single winder actually adds 2 inches to the overall length of the stair so there is little reason to increase the complexity and reduce the safety of a stairway by adding a single winder.

    As far as I can tell, the only layout advantage of a single winder compared to a conventional square landing (under 2009 IRC rules) is that it adds 6 inches to one end of the stair and subtracts 4 inches from the other end which might help a bit if the floor plan were tight on one level but not on the other.

    As far as headroom is concerned, the winder doesn't help at all if there's a winder in the stair above and when there is not one above any small advantage it might provide is offset by the need to start the stair 6 inches sooner. Starting another 4 inches sooner would allow the use of a square landing with even more headroom.

    In short, under modern codes, it would be a very rare stair layout that would benefit from a single winder tread.

  • 14 years ago

    I think, Renovator, that we have a winder because they screwed up the concrete forms on that area (staircase spans two levels and it bumps out slightly into the garage). Something about putting them in backwards? Don't know but when they got to building the stairs they wouldn't fit. This was their solution. It sounds like the issue is the one you raised - less space on one level than on the other . . . At any rate, they are built and in so it is too late now.

  • 14 years ago

    Bummer, I would have made them correct their mistake.

    To answer your question about how a winder tread should be treated, the traditional way is to use the same material as the other treads since these are two large winder treads, not landings. Normally multiple matching tread boards are edge jointed with splines/wafers, cut to fit, and installed like the other treads.

    On the other hand, finishing the treads in a different pattern might make the winder nosing easier to see. For that purpose, the more unusual the pattern, the better.

  • 14 years ago

    I was wondering why a winder was put in in the first place, as it lengthens the run and invites accidents. Now I know.

    My pic showed an absurd set of winders that reversed 180 degrees. And as Renovator8 explains, would be contra Code. (It was Australian where everything is upside down to begin with.)

  • 14 years ago

    So how would you handle the trim piece on the winder? I don't know if there is a better way to do it?

  • 14 years ago

    A winder does not lengthen the run as much as a landing.

    In a winder you get a rise in the platform location that otherwise would require a longer run to incorporate.

    It saves the length of an extra step (at least) not 'adds to overall run length'.

  • 14 years ago

    A traditional single winder that tapers to a point saves one tread in the overall length of stairway but where the IRC applies, the smallest dimension of each of the two winder treads is 6 inches and that adds 12" to the stair length for a net increase of 2 inches in the stairway overall run length.

    I believe the intention of the code was to make unsafe winders pointless but somehow they still get built.

  • 14 years ago

    You are forgetting about the ~8 inches in rise that each winder also produces.

    It saves on overall run for a given required rise.

    Landings have zero rise, meaning you will need additional run for the stairts to make rise numbers.

    Using a single area for two functions still saves space.