Software
Houzz Logo Print
muscat_gw

basic remodel advice needed, pictures included.

17 years ago

I have a roughly 1950's home, 3bedroom, 2bath, but the "main" bathroom must serve as ours and is the one guests use. (The second bath is a tiny add-on to one of the bedrooms that the previous owners built so their daughter would have her own, but it is not as accessable when we have company, unless they are overnight guests using that bedroom.)

So....I'd really like to remodel this bathroom, but here are my challenges:

1. It is SMALL, and both due to budget and floorplan, cannot really be expanded in any direction.

2. Since the other bathroom only has a shower, I dont really want to eliminate the bathtub.

3. It needs to serve as the "master bath" for my fiance and myself, but is also will be for "public" use.

4. I'd like this to be as DIY a project as possible. If it is just a cosmetic job, I know I can do it. Depending on how much has to get torn out and replaced, my confidence wavers.

Here are photos:

this is from outside the door looking in-

{{gwi:1399520}}

This is from the corner where the toilet is, looking into the opposite corner that was not visible in the first pic. The door to the room and the door to the closet are obviously in each other's way.

{{gwi:1400212}}

And lastly, this is the tub, with some sort of solid-surface marble look-alike material lining it:

{{gwi:1400214}}

If any one has suggestions from those photos, great! Specifically, here are the areas bothering me:

1. I'd like to re-grout and preserve the tub, but I wonder if it should be pulled out, in case there is water damage since it is so old. We dont really have a problem with the tub/shower liner or the tub itself, though it BADLY needs re-caulking. The tub is about 60" long, and there is not room to make it bigger.

2. The closet behind the main door, next to the tub is our main storage place for towels, etc. I'd love to take the closet door out and just hang a curtain or something, but my fiance is concerned that the towels, etc will suffer from being exposed to the steam in the room. Are there alternatives to this? some sort of sliding "roll-away" door?

3. The vanity: I'm debating dual sinks. We'd love to have two, but is a 66" vanity long enough for dual sinks? We'd lose cabinet space due to the extra plumbing but that brings me to....

4. I'd like to find wall mirrors/cabinets that could maybe be integrated with wall cabinets/shelves to go over the toilet, to improve the use of space on the main wall. I have not seen anything like this, but it must be out there!

5. How do you know if you should replace a toilet? The one presently there is a Kohler Bemis, with 1.6 gpf. I am not interested in replacing the toilet just for looks, but for environmental reasons I will, or if is inevitable that it will "wear out" I will, but do toilets "get old" and break, or just go out of style?

I'll end this post here, though I'm bursting with other questions, and I appreciate anyone who was patient enough to read the whole thing, especially if you have responses!!!!!!!

Comments (20)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Do you have an idea of what you would like to spend?

    Paint would go a long way.

    You would probably want to replace the toilet with a more efficient one if it looks like it is more than ten years old.

    A sliding door would have to have someplace to slide. I am not sure the closet would be more humid without a door than with one.
    You may be able to get a white cultured marble sink top for the 66" vanity, although most prefabs only seem to go up to 61" (for a 60" vanity) Double sinks can be used in 60 and above and still give you elbow room.

    There are plenty of shallow cabinets that could be placed over the toilet for storage available at home centers.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks. To answer your question, I'd like to spend less than I know it will take, but I dont want to be penny wise/pound foolish, and that is where it gets tricky, since I dont know if it is thrifty or foolish to keep the toilet and bath/shower as is.

    I'm willing to part with a few thousand, preferably under $2000-3000 and expect to do all the painting, cabinet installation, backsplash tiling and flooring myself. I'll hire out the plumbing and electrical, and if the whole tub had to get pulled out, that would be beyond me.

    As far as a sliding door, I was hoping there might be some sort of slider that works like those screen sliders that roll up on one side. Perhaps a pipe dream.

    I'm not clear on what makes a toilet high efficiency, as I have seen them from 0.9 to 1.6 gpm called "high efficiency." I know that the current toilet is at least 6 years old, since that is how long I've had the house.

    The home centers here dont have any sort of selection of shallow wall cabinets/mirror cabinets, except ones that are very small and single unit. I'd like to use the whole area behind the vanity....I was really shocked at the lack of selection, but I may need to find somewhere else to look.

    Thanks!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    We used a 12"d x 42"h x 27" wide kitchen wall cabinet over the toilet. Because of the depth, you have to hang it carefully (a little higher) so nobody bangs his head when standing up from the toilet. But it worked really well and gave far more storage than any over the john cabinets we could find.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    i used ikea cabinets - very flexible

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I did not see any ikea vanities on their website that were 60" long and double sinks. Though that was odd.....is this one of those times you have to alter what they make?

    Does anyone have towel/linen storage that is "exposed" to the elements of a bathroom- ie, steam, etc? I'd really like to get rid of the closet door if I can!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If your vanity is sturdy, consider painting it and getting a new top. If you use drop in sinks (overlap the countertop) you could use a laminate top and that could be cost effective. You may need to get it made but it shouldnt be too expensive.

    Many closets in the place you have yours have louvered or ventilated doors so they are essentially "exposed". I think you would be fine to have a curtain there rather than a door.

    Maybe try Home Decorators Collection for shallow wall cabinets for bathrooms

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If the tub looks to be in good condition and you don't mind the surround, then leave it be. Just because it's old doesn't mean it's likely to have water damage. Re-caulking is pretty simple.

    I don't see any problem with removing the closet door, as long as it looks presentable when removed. If it's got ugly shelves or isn't very organized, then you might want to reconsider (or use a curtain). You can always save the door and not fill in the hinge dents for a while to give it a test drive before you make a more permanent decision.

    You'd lose both counter space and drawer storage if you went with dual sinks. Only you can decide whether the trade-off is worth it. Your best bet might be to get 2 30" sinks and use a 6" filler (or 3" if it doesn't leave a hole in your flooring) between them.

    I can't quite picture what you're talking about with the integrated cabinet thing. But two medicine cabinets and an over-toilet cabinet should give you lots of storage.

    Keep the toilet. If it ain't broke, don't fix it.

    Do you plan to keep the floor?

    If all you're really changing is the vanity, then your budget should be more than enough to DIY.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks!

    Palimpsest-- yeah, the vanity has to go. It may not look it, but it is really dinged up, the inside is falling apart, and I think it'll fall apart when pulled away from the wall (I'm looking forward to demolition more than I should) :) I think I can do a reasonable 60" vanity and solid surface countertop with integrated sinks for about $1300-1500 max, so that is the plan for now!

    (I had a small slab of granite left over from the kitchen, which I was hoping to use, but due to my lack of diligence and the granite fabricators' error, it got toosed out or lost.....sad, but moving on to other options.)

    weedyacres- thanks for the advice. I don't love the tub or surround, but it is not offensive, so it and the toilet will stay. I hate waste.

    I've looked a bunch in stores and online, and I think youre right that a cabinet over the toilet and two medicine cabinets will be fine. I kinda wanted a more built- in look, but the more I think about it, the simpler I want it.

    We will redo the floors- I wanted to do tile (which I can do myself, but my fiance likes solid sheet material, so I'm going to look into marmoleum.) So could that be DIY, or is it better just to let the flooring guys install it? I have never done it, or seen it done. Seems simple, ut it also seems like experience could be the difference between a good job and a mess.

    Thanks!!!!!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Closet door - I'd take it and the hinges off and replace shelves with thick shelves that look little substantial and intentional. The towels will be fine exposed to the humidity, but it might be worth it to add a little bit of ventilation if you have enough crawlspace in your attic.

    Tub - try to keep it. I'm a little curious if there may be some kind of water damage back there. The only reason that is that most of the late 50's and 60's homes that I've lived in all have tile surrounds. Maybe it's fine.

    Toilet - That is a low-flow toilet, so don't replace unless it is too loud or something.

    Vanity - I'm still thinking about this. I don't know if it's true, but I've heard that kitchen cabinets are sometimes cheaper than bathroom cabinets. It might be worth looking into some simple, modern cabinets that could be used there. Still thinking.

    Floor - What is the current material?

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    elizgonz- We barely have a crawl space up there, but that is a thought. Definitely adding a fan- there is none now!

    I am also curious about water damage behind the tub. I have no reason to think that there is.....but I also have no proof that there is not. We're on a slab, so at least I dont have to worry abut rotting floorboards. I think this bathroom may have been remodelled in the late 70's since that is about how old the kitchen was that I just tore out, and the cabinets matched.

    I'll check on some of the "stock" brands of kitchen cabinets- that it a good idea. I think a regular bathroom vanity may end up being better because of the configuration of 2 sinks, but it is worth a look.

    The floor is currently some sort of vinyl or linoleum, that curves up the wall a bit. I have not started digging to see if it is directly on the slab or if there are other layers under there.

    :) Love all the ideas!!!!!!!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Muscat, I think your bathroom and a bathroom in the house I'm looking to put a bid on to buy are laid out about the same way and I too will be looking to renovate not only this long narrow bathroom, but the even smaller master bathroom, should we get this house.

    Would love to know what you come up with and when/if you do the renovations, please post some pics.

    Here's one pic of the bathroom similar to yours.

    Here is a link that might be useful: long bathroom

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    do you have a HD or Lowe's near you? I know HD has bathroom cabinets. you could fit 2 sinks in there w/ doors underneath and drawers down the center of it.

    they have medicine cabinets that match - with wood trim if that's what you want. they also have one that would go over the toilet I think. (will look in my book later and post).
    they also have a 6" deep cabinet that would fit between the sinks if you'd want that. it's about 12" wide and 30" tall. I'd set it up a bit higher - like on an extra piece of silestone (or whatever you use) to keep water from harming the bottom of it. wouldn't be good with kids around tho.

    laminate would be good in there also. Formica and Wilsonart both have some nice laminates (I've been checking those out for wks now). I'd like silestone myself but not sure I want to put the money into it!
    HD also has solid surface counter tops with sinks as part of it. You'd have to pre-order it to fit the cabinets you get tho. I think they're probably a reasonable price compared to something like silestone plus sinks as separates.

    they also have sheet vinyl that you float. no gluing down. let's see... earthscapes ? makes some - so does- well, it'd dupont or congoleum i think... that's what I'm thinking of putting down. I can't tolerate the glue smell. check one of those big surplus flooring stores for a remnant - your bath isn't very big. yrs ago I did that and got a great piece of vinyl for half of the bath (toilet/ tub area) for 50.00! a mid range price is about 3.00 or so per sq ft for sheet vinyl. HD sells it also. (I'm sure Lowe's does too, I just haven't been there yet to check it out).

    put in a fan/lite and new light over vanity and you'll be about set!
    the closet - how about cabinet type doors? or even full length - but 2? then they only open at half the width. you could also split them up - like 2 for the top area and 2 for the bottom. only open the area where what you want is stored.
    I hate louvers - had a bunch in a house and yuk to cleaning those things! lol!
    the tub/shower - if it looks ok leave it - maybe put new hardware on it maybe to update it. Could always do that later also.
    they have moisture meters also to check on any dampness behind it. maybe you could rent one? (saw it used on a home show)

    new paint,new curtains, new shower curtain...you'll be spiffy!

    and they make slide out things for under the sink areas. I was looking at those the other day online. if it's too much expense right now, you could add those down the road for better use of storage space. they can get expensive.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You mention that the amount of steam and moisture in the bathroom concerns you regarding the closet door. Definitely just add a fan. It's not the most fun to install, but it will make a world of difference. I put a few Panasonic fans in my home. They're so quiet and keep up perfectly with hot, steamy showers. I put mine on touch-button timers so I don't forget to turn the fan off.

    Replacing the vanity should be one of the easiest things. Home Depot and Lowe's sell the base cabinets (some with and some without tops) as well as separate tops that you can pick from. Some have sinks already installed. I can't remember how much they run, though. Then you can just disconnect the sink lines and hammer away at the old one until you have it gone. I would use this as the time to install the new floor. Don't forget that you will have to remove the toilet to put the floor in. It's no big deal, but you'll want to make sure to have a replacement wax ring on hand before reinstalling it.

    If you can clean up the caulking on the old shower surround, the next step that may not be so difficult would be to replace the shower faucet with something updated. That would give you a chance to match it with the new sink hardware.

    Don't let any of it scare you off. Just go slow at it and you'll do fine. DIY projects that would take an experienced person a couple hours will take me all week. In the end it's worth it!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks for the more recent posts! I was away on vacation......

    Hopefully this project will get done next month. Its gonna be a "Semi-DIY" in that I have someone to do the plumbing, electrical and drywall work, replace the window, and probably install the vanity. I know that I could install the vanity myself and probably even plumbing and drywall, but at some point, it is easier not to get in the middle of the other phases of the project, and work a few extra shifts at work instead.....

    I found a cabinet maker to make a fairly simple but solid wood knotty alder vanity for $800, then I'll do all the finishing work and door/drawer hardware. I found a scrap of marble for $27, and though fabrication will still cost a lot, I think the end result will be classier than some of my other budget choices. We're going to re-grout the tub and leave that part alone, do the flooring ourselves in vinyl or linoleum, and also do the backsplash, painting, wall cabinets, and I can make new curtains. The toilet wont be replaced.

    *Hoping* to start and finish next month, and there will be pics. THanks for the ideas!!!!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    i just want to say that our bathroom has the exact same layout! i was deciding whether to keep the closet door too - but i have time to think about it. we just have a tub now, but will be adding a shower to it, and will need to re-tile the whole place since the tub is not waterproof right now. tile work (hiring out) will be done later this month, will be adding a fan, and i can't wait till it's done!

    i've attached a pic of what it looks like (with the previous owner's stuff on the counter and towels etc). we'll be replacing all the tiles. the left side of the room is just like yours with the closet next to the door, and the tub.

    we're not going to change the cabinet/vanity top (out of budget and it's still in good shape). and we don't need to have 2 sinks, as we do have another 1/2 bath downstairs. i like the counter space! as you can see our sink is more towards the left than yours. we do have a soffit above the vanity with 2 recessed lights. we're going to put another recessed light above the tub. and taking the wallpaper border down! :)

    can't wait to see how yours will turn out!

    Here is a link that might be useful: our bathroom

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Do you have any "bath fitters" type businesses near you? They could create a tile look for all the walls (and the tub surface too if you need it) around your tub in white so it looks integrated, and I think it ends up "seamless"? No personal experience with them though, just a thought.

    Personally, closets are great because you CAN close them and hide all the mess...curtain might look cheesy--sometimes half open. You could make the closet (and entry) doors "disappear" more if you painted them either white or same color as the walls....would have to sand lightly (at least) and prime first of course. We had those types of doors in our old house and improved the look of the house by painting all of them. New doors (MDF types are pretty inexpensive) another possibility, but want to stick with what's in rest of house in style.

    YOu can google medicine cabinets, vanity cabinets etc. and find TONS of options. I like recessed medicine cabinetsbut that would involve more carpentry (headers above and below to support the studs you'd very likely have to cut into) than you might want to do. And if it is a load-bearing wall, it involves considerable care--better know what you're doing! (I personally know someone who very carelessly renovated an 1800s house and watched it become a pile of lumber over the course of a few hours).

    Remember if go to two sinks the additional plumber costs. You'd get the money back on resale of house though, two sinks best in a master bathroom if you can afford it.

    I'd be skeptical about toilets less than 1.6 gallons' ability to flush well. If not having trouble with current, may as well keep and could always change it in the future.

    Best wishes on your project!

    Lainie

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    We have a built in vanity that is 72" It was going to be too much to get a new one, so we painted it, took out the faux marble top and did granite tile with drop in sinks.

    I am sure you can configure a vanity from stock pieces, like someone said use 2 vanities with shelves in between. Granite tile was easy, I guess I should say it was easy for my contractor, but I did watch and it didn't seem hard.

    Here is a pic. Before


    After

    Good Luck

    Laura

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi Muscat,
    I was wondering how your bathroom remodel turned out. I can't see the "before" pictures but was wondering if you care to put updated "after" pics as well as give us an update as to how things turned out. Thanks in advance!
    Nancy

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi Nancy! I just finished it last month, and posted pictures, but I think the thread has fallen back a ways..... My old before photos vanished because I reorganized photobucket, so here they are again.

    I decided to keep the closet door and just paint it. The tub and toilet stayed, and the tub just got dressed up with new caulking and decorative tile. The vanity is knotty alder, natural finish, and the flooring is vinyl. One decision I regret just a little is the surface mount medicine cabinets: I still like that that the wall is an intact sound barrier between the bathroom and our bedroom on the other side, but recessed cabinets would have looked more finished. It was the *easy* option!

    Before:

    {{gwi:1400219}}

    AFTER:

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks for the quick reply. The remodel came out quite nicely and sounds like you didn't break the bank!