Software
Houzz Logo Print
61tinkerbell

$15,000 landscape allowance

18 years ago

sounds good... but designer came back with design for $28,000 dollars. The design is very nice, but gee whiz.. doesn't that sound like a ton of money!!? It does include sod (approx. $2500 and irrigation also approx. $2500.00).

I really am clueless at these figures! Any thoughts?

{{gwi:10735}}

Comments (19)

  • 18 years ago

    Maybe get a breakdown on the estimated expenses. Especially note the size of the plants. Bigger plants look nicer quicker but are geometrically more expensive to buy and to install. Be sure there is a good guarantee in place. You are also paying to have boulders placed? 7 of them at how many hundred pounds each? That's another biggie for labor, even if machines are actually used.

    I see "berms" and than often means hand-labor, big-time. Also 20 tons of soil doesn't sound like much, but it can take a lot of time to properly spread, which means $$$ for the labor. I'd really want to look at what he was going to berm; those dashy lines either represent the present slope (in which case, where is are the berms) or how he plans to slope (in which case, it looks like more than 20 tons of soil will be needed).

    That may be a perfectly fair cost estimate -- regional variations can make a major difference in cost of both materials and labor. Nonetheless, I'd get a couple more bids.

  • 18 years ago

    meldy, you obviously know way more about landscaping then I! Yes, there are "berms" (I never heard of them before). The plants are of larger size, 7 gal scrubs, 100 gal trees in front, and $3000 worth of boulders alone. This is the contractors sub, and possibly the price is right in line or even good, but I wonder if this would be a normal cost to landscape a home. Now it's hard to go backwards and scale down after seeing all the good stuff - and scaling down $13000 seems like we'll end up with nothing!

  • 18 years ago

    With the drawing of the rolls royce in the court yard, shouldn't be an issue! :-)

    Cant offer any advise except to say a professional lanscape design and install is the same as any design element of the house, you get what you pay for. Always get numerous estimates w/ referralls/references and go and check out current and past projects they have done.

  • 18 years ago

    I don't think there is a "normal" cost to landscape. Much depends on what is already there and more depends on what is added or taken away. I've seen fabulous, professional-appearing landscapes that were done entirely by the owner with and without the aid of a nursery, and I've seen very ho-hum blah landscapes that cost the owner much moolah. Equally, what may cost $10,000 in Richmond could cost double that in Arlington or half that in Norfolk --- and that's just in my region.

    Your plant sizes are probably slightly to much more on the mature size -- and will look impressive now; That's much easier for the non-landscaper to like than if very small plants were used. A big plant looks like good immediately while baby plants make everything look rather unfinished for a year or two. If you can afford it, and the larger plants are guaranteed, you may very well feel that they are worth the cost of having the landscaping 'finished'.

    Sierraeast has excellent advice; do look at each bidder's past work and listen to what the owner has to say about it. And get lots of bids -- this is going to be a nice hunk of income for the winning bid as well as being something you will live with for quite a while. Look around your neighborhood. It is not unreasonable to see a house with scaping you like; tell the owner you admire it and ask who did the work!

  • 18 years ago

    The rule of thumb is landscaping should be around 10% of the cost of the house.

    It has a lot of aspects that are pleasing to the eye but
    there are too many foundation plants for the space. For example, there are a lot of sweet viburnum right up against the house and depending upon the variety, they can grow 10-20 feet tall.

    If you like the variety of plants offered in this design, you could cut the number by half and still achieve a great look. The plants would do better with out being crowded.

    It appears to be extremely high maintenance. Will you be paying a landscaper to keep everything trimmed within bounds?

    I would get a couple of more quotes.

  • 18 years ago

    28k for both front and back doesn't sound too bad, especially if your home's value is over 300k. I spent several times that on my landscaping, although that involved a lot of hardscape and stonework on the house as well.

    Definitely get a few quotes, as you might find another plan that you like better. In my area you generally have to pay $500 or so for a design though (you can probably get someone to quote you based off your existing plan as well). Landscaping, and the assocated hardscape, can really add that extra pizazz to a nice home. You rarely see expensive homes with crummy landscaping, for example.

  • 18 years ago

    Be careful about a Magnolia grandiflora( do I see a Brackem's Brown Beauty Magnolia in the plan?)

    Wonderful tree but gets large and sheds alot of leaves and should be planted far away from grass, in a natural area. Magnolia grandiflora looks best if the limbs are allowed to grow all the way to the ground like a womans long dress... and if I am reading the plan right, they have shrubs planted right under it.

    Alot of the foundation plants, like the burfordi hollys, would do better if the number planted were half as many. They get big quick and will be healthier in the long run if not so crowded.

    My advice is to drive around a bit, look at mature landscapes you like. Note the plants you like and how big they get and then apply lessons learned to your yard.

    Seems professional landscapers get paid per plant so they tend to overcrowd and create difficult to maintain landscapes.

    Terry

  • 18 years ago

    That landscaping plan looks fantastic!!!!

    I have to laugh at myself because our landscaping budget was only $750.00. My must have item was a single weeping cherry tree that cost about $150.00. I thought that was a LOT for a single tree. LOL

    The plan looks great. I'm sure you will enjoy it immensely if you go forward with it.

  • 18 years ago

    I'm amazed that anyone would actually think of paying 10%-house-value for landscaping. And then I realized --oops-- different areas: non-custom built houses in my neighborhood go for $400,000 to $600,000; custom built are in the upper range starting about 600,000. It would be ridiculous to spend 40 to 50K just on landscaping unless one was doing over an acre of grounds. According to my local friends, house perimeter landscaping runs the gamut from a couple thousand to about eight thousand for lots averaging ½ acre; but a point is that my friends are primarily gardeners and would not depend on nor want a landscaper to do more than provide the basics.

    vancleaveterry is right -- some landscapers do indeed get paid per plant, although my decidedly non-professional opinion is that whoever chose Tinker's plants did so for the immediate impact they would provide. My personal opinion does not like trying to transplant near-grown plants due to the difficulties of getting them established in a new site. But that opinion is based on my own experience and acknowledges that reputable nurseries can -and do- plant mature trees and shrubs with a good success rate. And they charge accordingly.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks everyone, your replies were very helpful! The home is over $800,000 - but there is NO WAY in the world I would spend $80,000 on landscaping - I am having a difficult time swallowing my given figures!! LOL I think we definitely should reduce those foundation plants.

    Terry - great eyes, there is a magnolia there, landscaper said they were the smaller version that grows only to 20', not the 50 feet of the other variety.

  • 18 years ago

    My landscaping was beyond the "ridiculous" range mentioned by another poster. Landscaping is much more than plants and grass, and there are both talented and not-so-talented designers. It really can put the wow factor in your curb appeal, and I firmly believe it's an important part of the home's appeal, especially in more expensive homes.

    Here's a couple pics of my back and side yards. You can see that the yard is terraced, plus there's liberal use of travertine pavers, stone siding on the vertical surfaces, built-in bbq and sitting areas, firepit, and beautiful curves. The front yard also incorporates some really nice boulders and stoned, curved retaining walls.

    I'm not saying that anyone needs to spend over 40k on landscaping. I'm just saying that it's not ridiculous. This is probably seriously influenced by your region though. Outdoor living space is a very major consideration in my area. Up in the North/Northeast, I can see that may not be the case. With the pool, my landscaping did run about 10% of the house's price. But it took a crew of 5 guys about 4 months to install (they also did extensive stonework on the house) - there's no way I could've DIY'd it.

    Besides being a great place to hang out for adults, the side yard is kiddy heaven with built-in trampoline, play structure, and grass for running around.

  • 18 years ago

    I believe that the above ridiculous statement was dealing only with plantings/sod...it didn't sound as if hardscaping was being addressed. And, chiefneil...you certainly have some incredible hardscapes!

    I have never seen a built-in trampoline before...interesting idea!

  • 18 years ago

    I don't know if it's reasonable or not, but one way to save money is not to do it all at once.

    I would start with the hardscape and the irrigation, then the sod. Then add a few of the trees, perhaps less mature versions. The smaller plants you can do yourself later when you have money or time. Sure, it won't look "finished", but that's theprice you pay. Also, you may change your mind about the look, so doing some later leaves you options to change.

  • 18 years ago

    I agree that you seem to be getting a fair price for the landscaping. I would use the super small and less expensive trees and plants and let them grow.

    I personally cannot affford anything more than me on a chainsaw and a logger friend's masticator (I look forward to operating it!). We are putting all we can afford into fire protection.

    We will do more when we can, but will stick with the natural forest lanscaping.

  • 18 years ago

    I truly believe in planting smaller trees, they adapt and grow more quickly if planted young than if planted larger sizes. I put in a 2 ft magnolia two Springs ago and it has reached 6 ft so far, despite 2 years of challenging droughts and very little attention.
    I also have a Wye Oak that I planted about 8 years ago which is now well over twenty feet. It was barely 2' when planted, I had nurtured it from a whip distributed from DNR.

  • 18 years ago

    Since I have my license for plant retail, I think that's a lot of money for plant material, soil, and installation (labor). For $28k, I'd expect some hardscape such as flagstone patios, walkways, stone retaining walls, and a nice water feature. We have used the same professional landscaper for a lot of projects here and at our previous house. He does the hard stuff and the large "instant" trees, and we do the small stuff ourselves.

    Around here, a professional landscaper usually charges 3 times the wholesale price of the plant, but you get it installed. So, these are North Carolina prices.

    Indian Hawthornes are pretty nice. So, you'd expect to pay $50-$75 each to a professional, including installation. So your 36 specimen quality Indian Hawthornes around the back would cost $2700 installed. I hope you don't have a deer problem. They LOVE to eat Indian Hawthornes...but, that's another topic.

    A 7 gallon Burfordii Holly Nana would probably run around $20 installed.

    An 8-9 foot evergreen tree such as cryptomeria japonica would cost $200 installed by a professional landscaper, including drip irrigation hoses (without the system to operate the irrigation).

    From all the palm trees listed, I assume you're in a higher priced area than here.

    Viburnum are very nice, but if you get one diseased shrub, you'll loose a lot of stock if you don't get help. So, watch for disease among those and get immediate nursery assistance so that the stock doesn't get wiped out.

    That said, $30,000-$50,000 in landscaping (including great hardscape features) is typical in our area for an $800k house. Pools add a lot more, but that can't possibly be in this quote.

    Hope this helps.

  • 18 years ago

    I would agree w/ other posters re: spacing plants. It may look sparse at first if you cut back on the quantity of plantings, but they will fill in.You could easily remove some of those sweet viburnum on the west side, for example. Good rule of thumb that a GWer shared re: growth -'First year's slow, second year they grow, third year they GO!' (Hope I got that right!)
    I also am curious as to your landscaper's plant placement. Bougainvillea likes it hot and dry, it would do better placed on the west side of the house. Flax lily doesn't do well in hot full sun, so be prepared for some of yours to struggle if you live in, say, Texas, Florida, etc.
    Remember, every square inch doesn't have to be crammed w/ plants! Good luck w/ your plants...just be patient.

  • 18 years ago

    Some of your other prices are close, but i dont know where you get your cryptomeria japonica. Most 8-10ft of that species is going to be Yoshino. I deal with wholesale nurseries in Southeast Virginia and North Carolina all the time and their is no way you will get 8-10ft B&B Cryptomeria Japonica/Yoshino bought at 1/3 of 200 ($66, using your 1/3 formula). I usually see large CJY at around $125-$150 wholesale (just plant). So nurseries/landscape will be up from there - usually 2x to 3x.