Software
Houzz Logo Print
novice_from__ct

Undermount bathtub vs Drop in?

19 years ago

I was planning to do an undermount tub with a slab surround. I asked for a quote from a local marble dealer and he warned me that an undermount installation would cost a lot more, in terms of the slab, because of all of the extra work for the interior section (smoothing the rough edges). If I don't do undermount, I suppose I could do drop in but I had my heart set on undermount. Also, if I do drop in, then maybe it would be less expensive to just tile the entire surround (we had been planning on a bead board surround with a slab on top). Does anyone have any first-hand experience with this? What did you decide? What were the costs of doing an undermount installation?

Comments (7)

  • 19 years ago

    About 4 years ago I had a customer who wanted an undermount jetted tub with an onyx slab surround and tiled sides. With hesitation I did it. My main concern was if ever a problem arose and it needs to be replaced then good chance the slab would have to be replaced as well (Once slab stone has been set it is very difficult to remove without damage).

    There is a very slim chance anything will go wrong with your tub, enough to yank it out (most can be repaired through access panels), but chance is still there.

    Personally though...I LOVE the look. Very clean, unobtrusive look.
    Many people have done it without problems.
    Yes, it will cost you a little more for fabrication and may take a wee bit longer.

    I also like your idea for bead board on the skirt. I would love to see it. Please post pics when done.

  • 19 years ago

    For a 36" x 60" tub, if you were to pick granite tiles that cost $10 a square foot and the installation also cost you $10 a square foot, and you had a 12" deck all around the tub, the tub deck would cost you approximately $700 (I didn't even subtract for the tiles in the "open space" of the tub). That same surround, done as a slab, you'd be lucky to find granite for $50 a square foot. That'd make the slab cost $1750. Then, they're be the charge for polishing the edge. A bathtub rim is easily as big as 4 or 5 kitchen sinks, and a undermount charge for a kitchen sink usually runs $200-$300. Say they only charge you $600 for polishing the rim and mounting the tub properly. That brings the total for the slab up to $2350, vs. $700. In the scheme of things overall, not a significant difference in price when you factor it in over the years of enjoyment you'd get from it, but it's enough $$ in the short run to make you think twice about if it's what you really want.

    I'd personally go for the undermount. It's a much neater cleaner streamlined look that'd be worth it to me.

  • 19 years ago

    Ugh...I was quoted $1500 for may vanity slab which is 72"x 21". If I add at least another $2500 on top of that for the bathtub slab, it's getting a bit pricey! What do I do with the bathtub then? What about doing the entire thing in the glass mosaice tiles that I have chosen for an accent in the shower? At $26/per sq foot, I still think it will be much cheaper.

  • 19 years ago

    Wow - I think $2300 vs. $700 is a significant difference!

    I remember from my days on the Kitchen remodel forum that people have done undermounts with granite tile - they buy the tools and do it themselves. Am I remembering this correctly or no?

  • 19 years ago

    I'm doing an undermount japanese soaking tub. We did look at slab, but had difficulty finding one in a dark enough brown (without too much pattern) to work in our design. In the end, I'm using travertine on the face of the platform and on the deck we're using a very special 24x24 tile which will be covering the deck and dropped down 3" as a trim. We are using the same tile on the backsplash with a waterfall faucet coming out of it. The 24x24 tile is a very clean look, and I'm using the tightest grout line possible. While I would have done slab if I could have found one, I'm very happy with the change I made in the design. The savings isn't a terrible burden either!

  • 8 years ago

    Very late to be comenting as this is very old. However as opposed to stone (which can be very expensive as pointed out) one alternitive is Concrete. U can cast it yourself. Dye it whatever Color u need. Seal it so it is water tight. And overall its not that expensive. This is obviously easier to do with a square tub but i am sure there is a way to case a round opening if need be. But that solid surface and drop in tub looks soo much cleaner than Tile IMO. And if it breaks durring repair or replacement it should not cost a ton to replace either.

Sponsored
Kuhns Contracting, Inc.
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars26 Reviews
Central Ohio's Trusted Home Remodeler Specializing in Kitchens & Baths