Software
Houzz Logo Print
tom_p_pa

Miele versus Bosch Dishwasher

17 years ago

The upper end Miele is too overpriced for me, so the only one I would consider is the Inspira series which is in the same relative price range as the 800 Integra series Bosch. So, is the low end Miele still better than the upper end Bosch? I am not a bells and whistle person, and every time I go for more money for more options, I find myself consistently not using the extra options...cars, electronics, etc, whatever. That being said, I did much manufacturer internet reviewing. I have not been able to determine...is the lower end of these machines the same as the upper end machines. I can see obvious differences with upgraded trays etc, but is the cleaning and mechanical parts (motor, pump,etc) just as good?

Comments (21)

  • 17 years ago

    I think the only way to answer your specific qustion is if Consumer Reports has done a sidy-by-side comparison of the specific models you are considering, which is unlikely, because they do not generally test a whole line of upscale appliances. But you might check them out. The testing they did do may give you hints about the models you are considering.

    Besides, in the last analysis, the choice you make depends on the specific features that are most important to you.

    I am not at all familiar with Miele DWs, but I can say that the top of the line Bosch DW we got a little over 2 years ago is terrific. Its performance is first rate, and it is quiet, so quiet we can set next to it and talk on the phone, listen to the radio, whatever, without a problem. Some people on this forum have complained that the Bosch lacks the capacity of other machines. I cannot comment on that, because we have never compared it to other machines and because we are just 2 empty nesters. We generally fill the machine over the course of the day when we're alone. When the grand-kids come and there are 6 of us, we need to run the machine twice a day. I doubt that any machine can accomodate all those dishes with one wash.

  • 17 years ago

    I have the Miele Optima. Best DW I've ever owned. Cleans the dishes so well and it is so quiet you have to feel it to see if it is on. Has a nice large capacity and I love the flatware tray on top. At first I was unsure of how I would like having to place my flatware on a third rack, but it gives so much more room in the rest of the DW and the flatware gets so clean. I would highly recommend it.

  • 17 years ago

    Consumer reports rates the Bosch as the most reliable. Thats one big plus!

  • PRO
    17 years ago

    The miele is the better built machine but in terms of features a bosch 800 series will have more bells and whistles.

    Also have you looked at the upper cutlery rack? I find it to be a love it or hate it feature depending on the clientele. It's really a very useful and very efficient way of doing things.

    All in all if you are a press normal and go user(most of us are) the miele will do everything you could ever need and they are fantastic machines

  • 17 years ago

    Other than the possibility of a "lemon", I don't think you can go wrong with either. I would go by which one has the features you want and do you think you would like the silverware tray or not?

  • 17 years ago

    I have 2 Inspiras- very efficient, quiet as can be, excellent customer service when I needed an installation part. Couldn't be happier.

  • 17 years ago

    I have had my Bosch for 7 years with - knock on wood - no problems.

  • 17 years ago

    joboxes must be correct about the love/hate of the Miele upper cutlery rack -- pluckymama apparently likes it, but my GF hates it. Her Miele does a good cleaning job, and is unbelievably quiet, but it has a very very long cycle time. That, and the tedium of loading and unloading the cutlery, would keep us from getting another at any price, much less the price it commands.

  • 17 years ago

    attofarad must not have actually used a Miele much. The whole point of the cutlery tray is that Miele lovers take "the tedium of loading" in return for the lack of tedium in unloading. Spend a bit more time up front, but then unload and put away silverware in a few seconds. The alternative is the opposite: save time loading by throwing cutlery into a basket, but then lose it later when you have to sort out all the stuff to put it away.

    Like many others, I was not sure how I'd react to it, having come from three Bosch DW's previously, but it's now one of my favorite features. I take a perverse pleasure of getting all my forks lined up just right--DW thinks I'm OCD.

  • 17 years ago

    Part of the Miele program is that they offer both silverware options. Their standard tray, or you can order a unit with conventional baskets that go in the bottom rack like every other DW.

  • 17 years ago

    I had never heard of a "Miele" When we were at Pacific Sales, comparing appliances, I chanced upon the Miele--this was 2005. Saw that silverware tray, nobody else had it.
    That was "IT" had to have it and we luv it. I just toss the siverware up there, no biggie, comes out clean and I sure don't miss bending over and retrieving the silverware outta that low freaking basket.--I guess you can remove the basket and fetch the silverware, but we never did.

    Gary

  • 17 years ago

    The latest August 09 Consumer Reports...rates Bosch in the top 2 spots. Miele is way down on the bottom at 26. Bosch takes top spot in rating and repairs consistently. This is worth some weight.

  • 17 years ago

    Of three people I know with Bosch dishwashers, TWO of them needed major repair at less than four years. The cost was high, both opted not to do it.

  • 17 years ago

    "The latest August 09 Consumer Reports...rates Bosch in the top 2 spots. Miele is way down on the bottom at 26. Bosch takes top spot in rating and repairs consistently. This is worth some weight."

    That is the performance rating not reliability. For repair and reliability, Bosch and Miele are given as 8 and 9 respectively.

    OTOH, if you read the user reviews (linked at the online CR site), I found inverse relationships between CR's performance ratings and owner experiences.

    That is very frustrating when doing research for a new appliance.

    For the top ranked Bosch (SHX98 model tested), here's a quick summary of the pros and cons based on 33 user reviews (and 2.5/5 star rating):
    Pros:
    Quiet(28), Easy to load(14), Attractive design(9), Cleans well(9), Multiple settings(8)

    Cons:
    Doesn't clean thoroughly(13), Long cycle(9), Awkward loading(7), Unreliable(6), Doesn't dry well(4)

    The Miele (G2142 Inspira) only had one user review with a 5 star rating. Not enough user input to be valid, IMO.

    As one who is presently researching dishwashers, the lack of consistent information is maddening.

  • 17 years ago

    This clearly illustrates why CR cannot be taken as gospel. Miele only has one representation ? this generally tracks w/ CR's overall pattern. Expensive and (realatively) obscure brands are not well represented by their readership, therfore have little sample size in which to accurately gauge performance or track records, AND more importantly don't warrant a test in their view because their readers won't/ don't buy them so why should we buy them to test ????

    It also shows how fickle the public is. The answers are all over the board on the Bosch: it cleans great, no it's a turkey, It's well built and reliable, no wait - it's a piece of crap, It loads well or it doesn't................

  • 17 years ago

    From a servicers point of view, both machines are very good. But so are most of others on the market. Anyone who follows what is posted on the web will end up with analysis paralysis and go crazy.

    Dishwashers have the most varied results because of a number of factors when installed in a home. Consumer Reports levels the playing field by following the same tests with each brand and model. So it is a good reference point.

    The problems we see with dishwashers of all brands are:

    poor installations; fill and drain hoses incorrectly hooked up. Machines not leveled or anchored. Sand or dirt not flushed from the incoming water line, clogging up the dishwasher water inlet valve, inadequate electrical wiring and on and on.

    Much of this leads to poor cleaning results that owners blame on the machine. Often the user can't be bothered to learn how to use the machine. But complain when things don't go well. Then when we are called upon to fix the problem, we educate the owner on simple stuff like using good detergents and rinse aids, making sure their disposer is empty before using the dishwasher and on and on.

    All dishwashers except the very basic builders grade models will do a decent job if they are installed and used correctly.

    Our advice, ensure that the machine is properly installed. Follow directions on loading and machine care. Use quality detergents and rinse aid.

    Viola.....you'll have clean dishes. Even from a $350 machine.

  • 17 years ago

    What antss said!

  • 17 years ago

    I certainly agree about not taking CR's advice as gospel. It is just a data point. But useful in many ways.. much like Carfax when looking to buy a used vehicle.

    Analysis paralysis... yeah, got a bad case of it.

    I have some other questions that I think I'll start a new thread on as I haven't seen it addressed but in passing in the various DW threads here.

  • 17 years ago

    miele gets the job done; i scrape and knock off loose food and in it goes; sometimes play a game trying to see how many things i can stack on top of each other in the top rack; things come out clean, period. upper tray makes great sense, i'm another one of the weird ones who take pleasure of lining up the cutlery, have a system, it goes fast in & no sorting n the way out;
    sister had a Bosch (my recommendation) burned out and almost caught fire at about 4yrs old; it was a fluke but she wouldn't buy another; tried electrolux, hated it sent it back; finally bit the bullet, got a miele, lived happily ever after
    still think bosch is a good diswasher, but its not a miele, nothing is

  • 17 years ago

    I decided to get a top end Bosch (SHE68E15UC). While I like the Miele, the cost savings were too significant to pass on the deal.

    All else being equal, I would have opted for the Miele as I like the features in the Optima and Excella lines. But I was not willing to pay the difference.