Software
Houzz Logo Print
slahgirl

Do I want flat or textured drywall?

19 years ago

Builder needs to know. I thought I wanted the orange peel look, now I am questioning every single decision I make. All of my walls will have some type of color on them. Which do I want??? Help!

Comments (23)

  • 19 years ago

    Matter of preference I suppose, but I love the orange peel texture. It is subtle, yet covers small inconsistencies.

  • 19 years ago

    I like orange peel and light knockdown also. Here in Colorado those finishes are common, at least in houses from 250,000 to 400,000. My granddaughter, who lives in Atlanta, has smooth finish walls in a medium tan. It looks lovely and soft, but she says it's really hard to keep clean.

  • 19 years ago

    In much of the country, perfectly smooth walls are the norm. Here in the northern Rockies [and it seems, most of the NW] they are an upcharge option.

    My list, from least to most favorite:
    -smooth: just isn't visually interesting to me. It also exposes every flaw of every type.
    -Orange peel: its a machine finish, and looks it. Hides imperfections well, and easier to patch if needed than anything else, but a little more uniform than I like.
    -knock down: This is a fun one to do, but leaves the wall very rough and difficult to scrub, should it be needed. Turns the surface into a giant Rorshach test.
    -Imperfect trowel: the smoothest of the roughs. Looks very hand finished. Some areas will be quite smooth, others pretty rough, no real pattern per se.

    Sadly, this one isn't shown on 'Drywallshool.com', but its a very useful site all the same.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Drywall School

  • 19 years ago

    Drywall texture is a regional thing and most people in Wisconsin where I live have texture. We have orange peel texture and really like it.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks, oruboris, for the drywall link. I found it very helpful!

  • 19 years ago

    Wow, oruboris I had no idea there was various types of texture! I love the website. I am going to ask my builders about this. I can almost gaurantee they will be cussing you this weekend for telling me about the imperfect trowel, LOL!!!

  • 19 years ago

    Orange Peel walls and Knock Down ceilings (they called ours Brocade) are pretty common where I live in the Pacific NW too.

  • 19 years ago

    Textured is the norm in my area, too!

    So WHERE are smooth walls the norm?

  • 19 years ago

    We wanted a very light hand troweled finish so the texture guy got a piece of drywall and just kept making swirly patterns until I saw what I liked. Talk about custom!

    Here is a pic:

    Our walls aren't pink I just increased the contrast of the pic so you could see the finish.

    {{gwi:1443483}}

  • 19 years ago

    Everywhere I've lived, smooth was more expensive, and thus also has the perception of higher quality.

  • 19 years ago

    I drove my drywall sub and builder crazy over texture too. Knockdown is the norm here, but we're hardly doing anything norm it seems. We went with a light hand troweled finish, even lighter than in the pic shown above. But we also added sand to the texture. I told the drywall sub that I was trying to build a house reiminscent of the 1930s-40s (since we're doing a tear down in an older neighborhood). He went to the library for several hours and researched what textures were used back then and came up with the idea to add sand and do it by hand. I really like it and have never seen anything quite like it ... but until now I never noticed drywall texture.

    The sub did cuss me and informed me that he had a $40,000 machine just sitting at home that would have allowed him to spray on an orange peel or a knock down texture in one afternoon and he spent more than a week with trowel in hand at our house. Oh well! I'm sure I'll pay for his extra effort. I told him he was more than welcome to use his machine in our detached garage. He just glared at me!

    I initially told him I wanted a smooth texture, but was informed that was the most expensive. I quickly moved on from that idea.

    We got to the texture by the sub doing two different closets one day and me tacking post-its on the walls that evening saying "I like this area very much" or "Yuck! Too much texture" or "Way too splotchy" etc. etc. Once I "approved" the texture, I sang his praises every time I saw him and gushed over how much I loved the texture. I felt soooo bad about how high maintenance I was. In the end, though, I love it.

  • 19 years ago

    Having grown up in CA with textured walls (and popcorn ceilings) I loved the smooth walls of the houses we had in the east where smooth is absolutely the norm.

    Now we are back in CA in a 1970's house with textured walls and when we remodel the walls will be SMOOTH!!! So much nicer. It just takes more work so the drywallers don't want to do it.

  • 19 years ago

    Smooth rules in our area of the South. There have been a couple of new homes that I've seen lately that have knockdown/slapbrush ceilings in the bonus rooms, but not in any other room in the house. It was a nice look in that area.

  • 19 years ago

    As a lifelong New Jerseyan, I think I've seen only one house here with textured walls, my uncle's bungalow down the Shore (yes, that's how we say it). Everywhere else in these parts, smooth as a baby's....well, you get the picture.

  • 19 years ago

    Textured is the rule in this part of Florida. If it stands still long enough they will texture it! I had a long battle with our builder and the drywaller to keep our walls smooth. They were full of dire warnings that every imperfection will be seen, including the difference in texture between the paper faced drywall and the mudded areas.

    I am sure they are right but I also think texturing means that less skill and care has to be taken during the framing, drywall and mudding stages.
    We have only primer on the walls so far, apart from the master, which is painted and looks great. No imperfections to be seen! We are careful with the prep, sanding before and after priming, and using good quality paint. The fact is, in this house at least, I would rather see some imperfections than see texture all over every wall and ceiling!

  • 19 years ago

    Here in Minnesota, smooth walls with some kind of texture on the ceilings is the norm. I'm having orange peel done in my workshop because it's cheaper, but wouldn't want it in the house.

  • 19 years ago

    Up here in my part of the Great White North (Montreal) any kind of textured finish is only used in lower-end housing. When we built new out in the country, there was no question about texture - all walls and ceilings are level 5 smooth. Properly primed and painted there are no imperfections that can be seen.

    I'm in the process of a large DIY remodel of a 109 year old house (in town) and all the drywall I'm putting up (walls and ceilings) will be smooth. To my eyes, texture (such as popcorn and orange peel) has that "cheap motel" look and screams "lack of skill". Any idiot can slap up drywall and spray it with a machine to cover the poor quality workmanship.

    I'm originally from the UK where the norm is to use real plaster (actually it's a lot faster to do than taping and mudding drywall). Textured finishes were popular in the 1970s (particularly on ceilings) but they looked like crap when done DIY and again were just to make up for a lack of skill. Otherwise smooth finish was the norm there too. When I see anything else but a smooth finish, it just makes me think of this! Of course, if all you're used to is seeing texture, then smooth probably looks strange.

    Paul in Montreal.

  • 19 years ago

    It really must be a regional thing. I would have never guessed that.

    My dh is a GC here in South Carolina. He's building custom houses in the 500K range and we haven't seen any texture. I take that back - we had one that did the orange peel, but it was much smaller. I disliked the look.

    We updated a 1920's bungalow a few years ago. The original walls were all textured in sort of a bumpy, sandy look. We matched it by mixing sand and plaster. I disliked the look when we first moved in there, but came to really like it. It just had that old feel to it. Don't think I'd put it in new construction though.

  • 19 years ago

    Maybe it is what you are accustomed to, too. Like pyropaul I am originally from the UK, and have the same strong feelings about texture!

    pyropaul - were you in the UK when Artex was the fad? Impossible to clean or paint, and the designs made your eyeballs dizzy!

  • 19 years ago

    In the cental midwest, it's almost not even an option. Most everyone does texture. I am sure 9/10 people who walk in my house will ask why I didn't get the textured walls!
    Does anyone know what kind of walls they had in old midwest style farmhouses, so I can sort of stay true to period? Unless it's ugly....then period is out the window!

  • 19 years ago

    Sis3 wrote:

    "pyropaul - were you in the UK when Artex was the fad? Impossible to clean or paint, and the designs made your eyeballs dizzy!"

    Oh gosh, yes, I was there during the Artex craze! What horror! I had a friend who bought a beautiful stone house in the Peak District and proceeded to slap artex onto every surface. It made me feel physically sick when I was in there. He become know as "Artex John" after that. I felt sorry for any subsequent purchasers who'd be faced with the nightmare task of removing that crud! Seemed like everyone and his uncle ran a small business putting up Artex back in those days! I left in 1993 and ended up in Montreal which seems to have been mostly spared that plague!

    Paul in Montreal.

  • 19 years ago

    Hey Trudy - I saw some smooth walls in Austin during a $1M - $3M Parade of Homes tour and it was a burnished & waxed plaster finish . Is that what you are referring to?