Software
Houzz Logo Print
myrtle_59

Toilets - since 1989

16 years ago

Would someone bring me up to speed. We have 3 baths each with a cheap contractor grade toilet, short, round Elgin's. They work fine. I don't remember using the plunger more than once or twice in 20 years.

Now I am remodeling one bath and I want a comfort height, elongated toilet, I like the Kohler Memoirs.

I started reading on this board and at first I thought, we never have plumbing issues so it doesn't have to be a super efficient model. THEN I read that toilets now use half the water they used to. Is this why my old ones never have issues? Do I need to worry about the new expensive ones having clogs I never had before?

What do I need to know? Is the Kohler Memoirs Comfort Height Elongated going to do a good enough job or do I need to pick something else? We are not moving the plumbing any more than might be necessary to fit the newer larger one in the place where the older smaller one sat.

Thanks, I hadn't given this a thought and now I am confused.

Comments (12)

  • 16 years ago

    You are so right that the old toilets had less problems with getting stopped up because they had a strong decent amount of water to flush through the toilet and plumbing. I hate the low-flow ones, you really have to flush them twice to be sure that there is a good flow through the system. Same thing with the low-flow showers...I have to stay in them twice as long to shampoo my hair properly and rinse off. Seems to me we have to use more water to get the job done.

    I like the elongated and prefer the seat not be really low as I have a bad back and the lower the seat the harder it is to get up...OK...TMI...but just sharing.

  • 16 years ago

    Myrtle, do a few searches on this forum for the three major brands: Kohler toilet, Toto toilet, and American Standard toilet -- you'll find a number of threads from within the past few months which will give you a wealth of information and a bunch of opinions. We recently purchased a low-flow Toto toilet and couldn't be happier with it. (And we haven't had to flush it twice yet -- not once!)

    -- Eric

  • 16 years ago

    Is it possible to get a NEW toilet that is not low flow where I don't have to deal with this issue or is that a standard now ? I do not live in CA, I live in the east where water abounds, too much sometimes.

  • 16 years ago

    Low-flow toilets were federally mandated quite a few years ago. Check out Terry Love's site - just google his name and the word 'toilet'. He does tests on various models and posts the results. There's a number of low-flow toilets that work quite well.

    We've had them in CA since 1989 and it saves a LOT of water. Using a good toilet, you should not have to flush twice, unless you're using a lot of those triple-thick TP rolls - we use a soft double-thick TP national brand and in 20 yrs have had two clogs.

    Although it may seem that in other regions you have sufficient water, it's a fact that the world overall has a shortage of fresh clean water. The less we use to flush toilets, the better.

  • 16 years ago

    My own personal experience is that low-flow toilet technology has improved greatly in the past decade.

    Our house had two Kohler low-flow, pressure-assist toilets rear discharge circa 1994. Nothing-not even a few sheets of toilet paper- flushed with one flush, which sort of defeats the purpose of low-flow.

    We recently replaced them. Because they are on the second floor of our home and below them are wood box beam ceilings, we needed to stick with rear discharge toilets. So, we got new rear-discharge Kohler toilets (I can't remember the name, but they only make one.)

    It is like night and day. These easily flush anything and everything in one flush-and they use slightly less water than the old ones. I wished we'd replaced them years ago.

  • 16 years ago

    Myrtle - The newer low-flow toilets were completely re-engineered to actually flush with the allowed amount of water.

    American Standard Cadet 3 or 4 - about $300 and really excellent flush. Elongated seat or round models.

  • 16 years ago

    Yes, low flow toilets were federally mandated to 1.6 gallon flushes and thus newer toilets have less water to wash down (lubricate?) solids. Additionally, (at least in the past) round bowls flushed better than elongated bowls (centrifugal force maybe?).

    Don't worry. There is a LOT of information out there about toilets and I believe there are several brands that people have been very happy with. I do recommend doing some research (consumer reports, Terry Love, this forum, etc) before making a purchase. Also I would recommend prioritizing your desires (solid flushing, bowl cleansing, skirted model, elongated bowl, comfort height, price, etc) in the event that you find some toilets that meet nearly all of your wants but not all.

    Additionally, make certain to check your rough in measurement (measurement from the center of the waste hole to the wall). Most are 12" but some (like mine) are only 10". This may limit your options.

  • 16 years ago

    THanks everyone. I am going to the Love site.

  • 16 years ago

    Still interested if anyone has used the kohler memoirs comfort height elongated.

  • 16 years ago

    My friend just installed one in her new bathroom and I saw it in live action myself!

    It works.

    She has had no problems over the last 3 months.

    I love love love the new low flow toilets. They really do work. I have a Kohler, a Toto and an AS, all are just fine! In the country we have a dinosaur that is so many gallons and frankly doesn't even flush down that well- pretty ridiculous considering the 5 gallons!

  • 16 years ago

    Nowadays, you have to be clear when talking about "low flow" toilets. The *old* low flow was when toilets were mandated not to use more than 1.6 gallons per flush. But that's been the standard for awhile now. Today, when you talk about low flow toilets, most people are referring to the ones which use 20 percent less water, or 1.28 gallons. These toilets, which meet the government's "WaterSense" standard, are the emerging standard -- mandatory in some areas now, and likely to become the only choice sometime in the future. If you look at a manufacturer like Toto, all their new releases are either 1.28 gallon models or dual flush 0.8/1.6 gallon models.

    And if you had experience with low flow toilets a few years ago, be aware that the newer models have been vastly improved in the past few years. In our limited experience with a new Toto 1.28 gallon toilet the past two months, the smaller amount of water -- which I had worried about -- is simply not an issue.

    -- Eric

  • 16 years ago

    New low flow toilets work well. Terry Love Toilet discussions are here: http://www.terrylove.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?3-Toilet-Forum-discussions

    There is even a 3/4 gallon toilet coming to market. http://www.handhtoilets.com/Proficiency_UHET_english.pdf