Software
Houzz Logo Print
shmomey

Type of wood deck??

14 years ago

We will have a covered wood deck that covers one side and back of house. The builder budgeted basic wood decking. I asked for a quote on composite and it was $10,000 more. Should I question the type of wood? Also, should he stain it? The deck is budgted in the lumber yard costs at $104,000. I realize that also includes other wood material. This is a cost plus home builder project. He does not recomend staining a new deck. Should I ask for the warranty paper work? The deck is the focal point of the house. It includes a 12 by 18 sitting area and wrap around. Should I be happy with the basic wood decking? I think he said it was wood tempered??

Comments (15)

  • 14 years ago

    There is a deck forum if you really want to delve into this.

    The deck costs $104k?!?

    Wood usually means PT Pine in this part of the country for a basic deck. But in other parts of the country, it could mean cedar.

    The deck forum tends to be very Ipe (type of wood) friendly. And for good reason, it is beautiful. We have it and I do recommend it. It is costly however and still requires maintenance to keep the original appearance. The maintenance in a covered area is pretty minimal though.

    Ipe tends to fluctuate a lot in price and when we bought it, it was about $4.50 a sqft which compares to $.75 for PT pine. Composite tends to be about $4-5 a sqft.

  • 14 years ago

    PT pine tends to be a pretty eco-responsible and budget friendly choice. An upgrade I like is to use 2x material(1.5" vs 3/4"). It has a more solid look and can be refinished many times much like 3/4 solid flooring inside.

    PT pine needs to dry out before staining. Semi-transparent stain is great because it reduces prep work on the next application. I really like the Sikkens brand. The darker the color, the better the protection.

  • 14 years ago

    The $104,000 was all inclusive. He did not separate the wood for the deck. It was all combined . The labor to install the deck was $4500. Obviously I am new to this process. We are on a cost plus system. Thus the mark up is 8%. Due to the fact the better choices were a $10,000 upgrade we decided to stay in budget. We are getting treated wood. I asked if it should be stained but he did not recomend a stain for new wood. I said it might need to be replaced in 10 to 15 years. I am thinking I should ask for the warranty and see the invoice for the deck wood. I would assume at cost plus I can get what ever I want. I just hope he does not pick the cheapest wood possible for our deck.

  • 14 years ago

    Even all inclusive, that is very high for a PT deck.

    I feel like we paid $24k for a 12x15 screened porch and a 12x16 deck done in Ipe with a staircase. That included some decorative work on the pilings (but didn't include the pilings).

    Treated wood to me is basically a basic spec house item and really has little place in a custom home. That is just me. Obviously location changes things dramatically. We just built a $250k home for rental that we used PT wood on and that I feel was appropriate.

    But I can never do the math and find $104k on a deck where PT wood be appropriate. Not in this area.

  • 14 years ago

    In a Cost of the Work Plus a Fee contract (without a Guaranteed Maximum Price) you would pay the actual cost of the wood plus 8% so there is no reason for the contractor to propose the cheapest wood.

    Ask him to price 3 different materials with comments on their advantages/disadvantages with warranty information, etc. and then you can select the one you want.

    He proposes; you choose. That's how the work of this kind of contract should be purchased; it is one of the primary advantages of using a Cost of the Work contract in the first place so take full advantage of it.

  • 14 years ago

    I may be wrong but it seems david_cary that she is saying the 104k is for all the lumber for the entire house, including the deck. I read it as the 104k is the entire lumber yard costs.

    That being said, what is the break down for the deck?

  • 14 years ago

    Ah - I hadn't thought of that. But still $104k is not a basic house and I wouldn't put a PT deck on that.

  • 14 years ago

    $104K for lumber on a house? Holy Expletive. Our 5,500 sq ft house was about $45K for lumber, including lots of LVL for open spans and the 2x10 PT joists for the deck (12" OC with PT Plywood for tiling on top of) and 6x6 posts. Either you're using gold infused trees for lumber or are having a 10,000 sq ft mansion built.

  • 14 years ago

    I would never have a PT deck. My last house we had composite decking but PT railings. After 3 years the railings were ripped out and replaced with composite, they looked horrible.

    A friend of mine spent all summer 2 years ago building a beautiful PT stained deck. It was breath taking. Went to his daughters birthday party last week, boards are curled up one board looks like a ramp, sticking up 2 feet off the floor.

    I know you can do proper maintenance and keep them nice, but it is a lot of work and I think most people dont do it and end up with what I mentioned above.

  • 14 years ago

    The lumber yard bill is irrelevant. It may or may not include wooden siding and interior finishes. So forget about the $104K sticker shock, guys.

    For the deck, PT pine is really low end stuff. To keep it nice and useful, for the expected life of 10 to 15 years, and then to consider the cost of replacement on the 10 to 15 year interval, South American hardwood is a more economical choice. If you are OK with the deck turning a silver-grey color, definitely use a S. American wood.

    My Ipe deck gets swept with a stiff push broom once in a while, or whenever the kids make mud pies, and that dirt dries up. This is the only maintenance I've done for 7 years.

    After just one year, unfinished Ipe looks and feels sort of rough, even a few splinters. That will wear smooth after a few more months, just walking on the deck hepls polish the wood. Sanding with 60 to 80 grit, coarse paper, is also advisable for Ipe. Finer sand paper is useless on Ipe.

  • 14 years ago

    Well I appreciate the in sight... I cannot get my significant other to understand that pressure treated wood is cheap and the builder will probably make a buck on us. I guess when he told us it would be $10,000 more for Ipe or composite we were overwhelmed with the sticker shock. I think my goal is to get it treated bya a professional deck company every a few years and tell my wife I told you so. It is sad condsidering it wraps around half our house including the back. On the plus side the deck will have an a covered roof at all ends. Thus reducing exposure to the elements (i.e.) rain down pour and snow. It stinks because our well and septic system that went over budget at $7,000 could have paid for a better deck. I did ask the builder the break down the cost of the deck out of the $104,000 total lumber costs. No response yet... labor is separated for the deck at $4500. I will also ask for the paper work related to the warranty. That is not too much to ask.

  • 14 years ago

    I will never, never, ever do a wood deck again. Years ago, we used the old type of Trex for our decking. Horrible stuff. Molded like crazy. Ugly. So next house, I said no more composite, and we went with wood. Worse mistake. Had to stain it every year, what a nightmare. Boards cracked, etc, and I just hated it.

    So on the new house, we took a chance with the new Trex, and we really are happy with it. I know there are other brands, but this is the one we could get locally. Very happy with it. Can't tell you what it cost.

  • 14 years ago

    On our new home the wife said 'no more wood!', that even meant comp, which is what we have now. We're having an 800 sq ft covered deck (living space) off one end and a 6' covered porch all around the house (additional ~1000 sq ft). We're doing the whole thing in light weight stamped/colored concrete. Cost wasn't all that much over decking and building the structure was only minimally more that a normal deck. It still needs sealed occasionally but since it's covered it won't be bad. IMO a big improvement over 'decking' and you have a number of options for color and texture/patterns.

  • 14 years ago

    I havent seen a composite that I liked yet. Its possible for IPE and composite to have just as short of a life if the framing below is not protected well.

    IPE could be considered a very poor environmental choice.

    A lot of the PT concerns above are addressed by using 2x material as the decking. Proper maintenance can give PT a life as long as Composite or IPE. With good prep and product , reapplication every 3-5 years (depending on conditions) can still be much more cost-effective and eco-friendly in the long term.

  • 13 years ago

    How about cedar?