Software
Houzz Logo Print
ideamom_gw

Is 12' deep shelves deep enough??

19 years ago

Planning on having built in bookcases on either side of the fireplace and wonder if 12" deep cabinets will be sufficent? Will not be having the TV on the shelves, they will basically be more for display. Would love to see pics of similar.

Comments (18)

  • 19 years ago

    Oops...title says 12 ft deep...I meant to say 12 inches deep.

  • 19 years ago

    All our bookcases are 12" deep (actually 11 usable inches. There's *plenty* of room for our largest books and for display of family photos and decorative stuff. I think its pretty standard-- anything deeper and things get pushed back and can't be seen.

    The bigger question (and the one that drove me crazy) is how far apart those shelves should be... still don't have a good answer to that one :-)

  • 19 years ago

    I am glad you all are asking that question. Our trim guy is starting on Monday and that is definitely a need to know. I dont want to have to eyeball it and tell him nor do I want to ask him what is industry standard, I have went wrong enough in this building process asking the subs whats typically done!

  • 19 years ago

    We are planning a library in our build, and they (my DH and the GC) are planning 12 inch shelves on 3 walls, I think that is pretty standard. On one wall they will do some 15 inch shelves for my DH textbooks and larger books that we have.

    Amy

  • 19 years ago

    We're having built-in bookcases on either side of the fireplace, and ours are either 11 or 12 inches deep. I have other pieces I put on them, though, so ours are going to be adjustable shelves. The bookcases are a paint-grade lumber. If you aren't doing them in something other than paint grade, adjustable is a good option so you can decide later how you want to place things. You have to put up with grooves or holes on the sides of the vertical boards but to me that's not so noticeable after a while, and I keep buying more books so we really need to be able to change the shelves around.

  • 19 years ago

    Hi Ideamom! You are doing such a great job getting all of our things picked out. I see your posts on all the different forums. Great taste, too! I wish I was as far ahead in things as you are! Have you broken ground yet?

    Anyway, I just measured our built ins in our current home's family room. We use one side as the computer area with books above, storage for DVD's, CD's etc. and the other side of shelves,(there is a window in between), for just display for books, pictures, etc. The top shelves are only measuring 9" and the bottom half shelves are measuring 12". Haven't had a problem with spacing though. I can pack lots on them. But, in the new house, we will probably go with the standard 12".

    Good luck and keep up the good work!

  • 19 years ago

    "...4 shelves can be made from a 48 inch wide plywood panel."

    Except that plywood is one of the worst materials for shelving for books.
    At the very leas it ends up requiring some edging on the front to limit sag and fastening to the back also..
    Hardwood shelves are still the best, with oak and other very stiff woods leading the pack.
    Do a search for 'sagulator' to get an idea of sag for common woods and spans.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks everyone for giving me feedback that 12" shelves are fine! There really won't be many books on the shelves. I will probably be displaying vases and other decorative things on the shelves. Thinking of having the centers of the shelves glass so that the accent light at the top of the bookcases will shine down and accent all my pretty things!
    eventhecatisaboy: Thank you so much for the compliment! It is fun picking out everything but at the same time so stressfull! I'm glad there is this forum so I can ask questions and get advice and such! We have not broke ground yet but did just put our house on the market. As soon as it sells we will get to start the building process but for now we are just trying to get all of the bids from all the trades and finalize our choices so that we know what we want exactly and will know how much this house will cost us. Know anyone who wants an English Tudor home on the lake?? LOL

  • 19 years ago

    "Hardwood shelves are still the best, with oak and other very stiff woods leading the pack."

    Interestingly, Doug Fir is actually better than most hardwards. Joint and plane a vertical-grained piece of 2x12 down to 1" or 1-1/8", and you've got yourself a really great shelf!

    Whatever you use, 3/4" thickness isn't really stiff enough for a 3-foot shelf. It may be OK for 30". For 3-feet, I'd go with inch-thick material.

    If you really want a stiff shelf, try Ipe. A 3' Ipe shelf, 1" thick, will only sag 0.03" with a 110-pound load of books.

    I also recommend playing with Sagulator to get a feel for how different materials and thicknesses of selves behave. Small changes in thickness have a HUGE effect on sag. Google "sagulator".

  • 19 years ago

    Sorry to butt in on this thread, but my quesiton is about wood shelves and I'm hoping Brickeyee and solarpowered are still following this thread. I want to make 24" x 72" shelves to hold a TV. What material would you woodworkers recommend for that? I was thinking that veneer plywood would be what you used, but now it sounds like that would be a bad choice. This is for a recessed entertainment center. I want the trim and the selves to be stained oak. But you can't get oak 24" wide, which is why I thought plywood would be what was used. Thanks.

  • 19 years ago

    How much does the TV weigh?

    A 72"-wide shelf is going to need to be fairly thick (for a starting guess, I'd say 1.5" or so). I can run some numbers after I know the weight of the TV.

  • 19 years ago

    Thinking about this a little more, you'd probably need more like 2" to keep from sagging. I would recommend revising your design concept to get away from 72" shelves.

    Also, what kind of TV are we talking about that's 24" deep? Without knowing much about what you are thinking about, the prices of plasma and LCD flatscreens has gotten so low that it just might make more sense to get a new flatscreen than to try to build a cabinet around a deeper TV.

  • 19 years ago

    solarpowered--I'll have to check out the weight of the TV. It's a 36" Sony tube TV. We already have a 60" flat screen TV in our basement. We're keeping the 60" down the basement until both kids leave home, and will then move it to the living room, which is why we made our TV hole 72" wide. However, in the meantime, we're going to put the 36" in there as it is only a few year old. But we will have more shelves under the TV shelf for DVD player, stereo etc., so we can put supports under the TV shelf as we were thinking not one continuous shelf for these components but cubicle shelves. So how apart would the supports need to be to hold up a heavy TV? Thanks!

  • 19 years ago

    Hi, Carolyn.

    A 36" CRT TV can weigh in excess of 300 lbs. You'll definitely want to make sure your shelf can support that weight.

    Kevin

  • 19 years ago

    Carolyn,

    If the TV is more-or-less centered, then a single support under the center should be OK in conjunction with 1"-thick shelves. If the arrangement you want for your cubicles has more than one support, then you should be pretty much home free with any reasonable arrangement.

    For a 24"-deep shelf, you're pretty much forced to go with sheet goods. (I once lived in a house built in the 1920's that had 24"-deep shelves made from solid redwood, but I don't think you can get that anymore ;).) I believe that "Applyply" plywood can be had in 1" thickness, although it's probably a special order. Baltic Birch plywood may also be available in 1", although I think it normally comes in 5'x5' sheets, so 72" may not be possible with BB. You possibly could laminate two pieces of 1/2" plywood to get to 1".

    If the TV is really 300+ lbs, you might want to go even a bit thicker than 1". Consult Sagulator to see what your specific weight, shelf material, and unsupported distance will do for you. Applyply is made in thicknesses up to 1-1/4", so there should be something there that will take care of you.

  • 19 years ago

    P.S., I see that I need to "read four times, post once!" I meant "Appleply", not "Applyply".

    And as a general FYI, Appleply is just a tradename--it contains no wood from apple trees. The core laminations are alder and birch.

  • 19 years ago

    Solarpowered--Thanks for all the help!