Software
Houzz Logo Print
kawfeeaddict

AutoCAD or ArchiCAD ~ Is one preferable?

16 years ago

I've hired a recent school of architecture graduate to "draw" blueprints I have of house I want to build in either AutoCAD or ArchiCAD. . The goal is to then be able to get proposals from builders to determine a budget (for land).

He's able to place the drawings in either AutoCAD or ArchiCAD. Is one preferable or are they both widely used. Can saved files be opened in both?

Thanks from someone who's excited to hopefully make a dream finally come true!

Comments (5)

  • 16 years ago

    AutoCAD is by far the most commonly used design program for professional building design (architects and engineers) and is owned by the American company Autodesk. It only runs under MS Windows. It's file formats, DXF & DWG, have become the de facto standards for file transfer between competing CAD programs.

    ArchiCAD is a far more sophisticated BIM (Building Information Modeling) program that creates a virtual building and is owned by the Hungarian company Graphisoft. It is used mostly by larger architectural firms and runs under MS Windows and Macintosh OSX. The program can import and export DXF & DWG files if they haven't been corrupted.

    Both programs began in the early 80's and were the first of their kind. Autodesk purchased a BIM program in '02 called Revit in order to competes with ArchiCAD.

    Each of these programs costs a small fortune and each provides a "viewer" program so others can open and look at the files on their computer.

    Since all you want is a set of plain paper design documents to give to a builder and get permits, I don't see why the choice of the CAD program would matter. Make sure the drafter isn't using a "STUDENT" version of either program and that you have a way to print the files later from a USB flash memory stick, etc.

  • 16 years ago

    Thank you Macv for your most helpful, detailed reply.

    He said he purchased both at considerable expense however, to be sure, what are the limitations to avoid with the STUDENT version? I want to make sure I ask the right questions and get what I need, which is to be able to print the files on my own and send them electronically.

  • 16 years ago

    I believe the AutoCAD student version prints a banner around the edges of the drawing and that the file can corrupt the full version of AutoCAD. I'm sure the student version of ArchiCAD does something similar. Just ask the drafter if he has the full professional versions.

    It is possible to receive and print PDF versions of the CAD files from your computer or you might be able to print from the "viewer" programs (AutoCAD offers TrueView and DWF Viewer) but you will not be able to make revisions. You can email or take the DWG file to a local printing company on a flash drive/memory stick, etc. and and they can print a plain paper copy (blueprinting has been obsolete for 40 years).

    Your drafter should be able to explain all of this better than anyone else. I don't know what kinds of computers are involved, the software versions or what kind of printing facilities are available but your drafter does.

  • 3 years ago

    from 12 years ago?

  • 3 years ago

    The commenter was a spammer RES