Software
Houzz Logo Print
smitty5952

dual fuel worth it?

16 years ago

What are the advantages(if any) to a dual fuel range? Is an electric oven better for some type of cooking or baking? Consumer reports states there is no advantage to dual fuel. The ranges we have been condsidering at this point are all gas.

Comments (13)

  • 16 years ago

    i'd heard that electric ovens have a tendency to dry food out. we went with dual.

  • 16 years ago

    I was used to electric and concerned. I believe years ago electric was more precise but maybe not so much today. I ended up going all Gas and I am very pleased. I have no issues and I am more pleased with the roasting of meat and veggies.

  • 16 years ago

    A few years ago the "experts" seemed to be saying electric ovens were better for baking as they were more even (no cycling). Flash forward and now the "experts" are saying that current gas ovens, especially convection ovens, are so close to being as good as electric, even for baking, that it doesn't really matter.

    My conclusion -- get a gas range and a countertop electric convection oven or a "speed oven" that combines microwave and electric oven -- so you have a convenient small electric oven for every day and a full size gas oven for major meals.

  • 16 years ago

    I asked my friend about baking bread and pastries in a gas or electric oven at the bakery her family owns. She said she would never use a gas oven over electric because there are enough differences that people would notice. However, she didn't say gas was bad, just different.

    Convection gas ovens must reconcile two design flaws that do not effect electric ovens.
    1. If convection baking with a large cookie sheet or equivalent that takes up a significant portion of the rack, how does the heat transfer from the bottom (bake element) to the top for even cooking? The sheet should impede the heat transfer,

    An electric oven generates the heat at the fan, ensuring even heat distribution.

    2. Does the convected (moving) air affect the flame? I'm gonna say yes.

    Therefore, dual fuel should be better if using convection but not so if just a regular oven.

  • 16 years ago

    I was looking into some gas ranges for a friend of mine.

    The gas ranges that advertise "True European Convection" actually use an electric heater around the fan, just as the Electric True European Convections do.

    In fact whilst doing this search, I found an error in Frigidaire's description of power requirements for their gas range with "True Convection"
    It said it required 120 volts and 15 amps.
    But right under that, it said "Minimum amp reqirements 40 Amps>say what???
    So I called them, and I told them I think that 40 amp requirement was for their Electric Range and not their gas range with true convection. The girl did quite a bit of checking , them finally came back and said, "You're right".

    Anyway a long way to tell you folks that gas ovens with "True European Convection" work just like the electric ones do as far as the convection mode goes, so it wont disturb the flame , or do this or that etc.

    Gary

  • 16 years ago

    I entirely disagree with Aprince's post. His/her ponts #1 and #2 don't make any sense to me. And I re-read them several times. #1 would be the same for gas or electric, and #2, well, I just didn't get what was the conclusion being drawn with #2.

    I have posted before that I have used both electric ovens and gas ovens, and could see no difference in baked goods, though meats come out better in gas ovens. Also, I have a friend who is a professional chef, who went to chef school in Switzerland, apprenticed for years in restaurants in Paris, and is currently working at a high-end french restaurant in Manhattan. For his home kitchen, he bought an all gas range.

    I have also said before that the belief that electric ovens are better has been promulgated by the range manufacturers who add large upcharges for dual fuel ranges. They encourage salespeople to push dual fuel ranges. How else would anyone plunk down that much more money than to be convinced by someone that it is somehow better? Any proof anywhere? Any substantiation anywhere of any kind?

    Even if you truly believe a dual fuel is better, because you have cooked on both, and definitively have gotten better results on the DF, can you justify the amount of the upcharge? Also, don't forget that if you have not had an electric oven before, you may have to install the wiring for it. That could be expensive--you'll need to bring in an electrician, and a lot depends on where your box is located compared to where your kitchen is located.

    If you like a dual fuel cause you like the looks, you like the features, you believe it's better, get one--it's YOUR kitchen. But the title of this posting is "Dual Fuel Worth It?" IMO, no.

  • 16 years ago

    I've worked in the kitchens of several NYC restaurants, most of which use gas ovens for both savory and pastry. I've always had an all gas range in my home and I turn out excellent desserts, no problem, every single time. I always rotate the pans half way through cooking time to insure consistent cooking (most ovens are not even).

    I cannot tell you if gas is *better* than electric but it's always gotten the job well done for me and I'm sticking with it in our new range.

  • 16 years ago

    So the consensus is leaning toward full gas. Those of you that preferred the gas oven for cooking and baking--were you using the convection feature or just traditional? Based on what DODGE59 says if you buy a convection oven it should be "true convection" I have been looking at the GE ProfilePGB918 gas range with convection but it says nothing about "true" convection.

  • 16 years ago

    My gas range doesn't have convection, so that isn't even a possibility for me. My electric wall oven has convection (Dacor 36") and I do use that option frequently when I use that oven.

  • 16 years ago

    Smitty5952 - count me as another vote for All Gas range. Though some All Gas ranges do not offer self-cleaning (e.g. the Wolf AG), if that is important to you. There are certainly All Gas ranges that do offer self-cleaning; you just need to check on the models you are interested in. My All Gas range does have self-cleaning, but I never use it cause I hate the smell, the heat, the energy usage, and the time it takes. So I would have been happy with an All Gas range without self-cleaning.

    Regarding convection cooking, what foods cooks better with convection and what doesn't, and true convection vs. convection, I am linking below a helpful thread.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Thread What is Convection

  • 16 years ago

    Most gas covections ovens are not "true convection" - they just have a fan and they work fine. Some gas ovens do have an electric heating element around the fan. If I were getting an electric oven I would want one with "true convection" but if I were getting a gas oven, I wouldn't worry about getting one with "true convection".

  • 16 years ago

    It must say "True Euro Convection" to have the heater around the fan, otherwise it will be as Weissman describes it, Just a fan blowing the air around.

    I have only used "True Convection"Elux Icon Oven" so I can not tell you how the "Non True Convections" perform, baking wise.
    I do recall some posts from long ago, where "Some folks" insisted that it had to be "True Euro Convection" or is wasn't as good , or this or that, You may want to try a search for TRue Convection, here on GW, or maybe some of our convection experts will (excuse the expression), "Pipe In here"?

    Anyway NOT ALL convection Gas ovens are "True Euro Convection" so if ya feel you need it , look for that!

    Gary

Sponsored
High Point Cabinets
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars21 Reviews
Columbus' Experienced Custom Cabinet Builder | 4x Best of Houzz Winner