Software
Houzz Logo Print
penaddict

Tile vs Hardwood for Kitchen

16 years ago

For months and months (and months) my husband and I have been going back and forth on what to do about our kitchen and breakfast area floors.

Currently, we have red oak (probably not so great quality) as it needs to be refinished badly and is separating in places and just not looking good. We also have the same hardwood in the dining room and entryway (all on the first floor). We wanted to add hardwood to the living room (take out the gross carpet).

But we're still debating on tile for the kitchen and breakfast area or rip out all the hardwood (as I don't like the quality) and install engineered hardwood all on the first floor. By the way, we have to large Basset Hounds (drool and long nails).

We're having a hard time finding tile to match the various elements of our kitchen area (tan brown granite tile counter and travertine with granite inset for backsplash) so we thought about just ripping out all the hardwood and putting in engineered.

So lots of conflicts, tile in kitchen and hardwood throughout or all engineered hardwood (how does it hold up in kitchen and breakfast area that has direct access to a deck with snow in the winter).

Here was an idea we had with the kitchen tile but it was too busy (color and design).


Here is what some of the areas look like (most traffic is off the breakfast area, where dogs go in and out).



Comments (2)