Software
Houzz Logo Print
eileen_schulz

granite vs quartz countertops

14 years ago
Curious what others think about these two options. I love granite countertops but am being scared off by others saying how they stain; can't leave any citrus on them, (will ruin finish and will need sanding and repolishing) having to seal once per year, every 6 months, etc. where quartz is easier to take care of; hard surface, no sealing, etc. I like the many irregularities of granite where all I've seen of quartz are very uniform patterns. thoughts?

Comments (6)

  • PRO
    14 years ago
    I too love the movement of granite. I would recommend that you look at Cambria Quartz. They have wonderful new patterns that mimic that feature of granite that we all love. I personally have granite in my kitchen and the "upkeep" is minimal. It takes quite a bit to stain the surface and there are easy ways to remove the stains. Had it for 10 years and Never had a problem.
  • 14 years ago
    We were struggling with the same issue recently and wound up going with cambria quartz in the canterbury style -- it looks stunning and very stone like versus a lot of the synthetic feelings we got from most quartz, like silestone and Caesar etc - granite is quite tough and durable though you need to really consider how light or dark you're going to go as we'll.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    Hi Eileen,

    We sell both granite and quartz, but we definately sell more granite than quartz. Most of our customers who purchase quartz are those looking for a minimal, consistent pattern who do not like the movement that granite offers.
    As Kitchen Art said, it is very difficult to stain granite. It is not a very porous stone. Marble, on the other hand, is where the staining is concerned. Your fabricators and installers should seal your granite for you, and then you are responsible for sealing it once a year after that. It is a simple process--wipe it on, let it sit overnight, then clean it off the next morning. It will take you 5-10 minutes. You clean granite with a natural stone cleaner ONLY. We recommend Stone Care International's Marbamist. It's about $10 for a quart size spray bottle. Spray it on the stone & wipe it off with a paper towel. If there is a stubborn stain, it can easily be removed with poultice.
    Quartz you generally clean with soap and water. Silestone can be cleaned with Windex.

    If you like the movement that granite offers, I would not rule it out. Cambria does make some patterns that look like stone, but nothing is going to beat the real thing. Granite also generally tends to be less expensive.

    Best of luck & keep us posted!
  • 14 years ago
    I have granite tops for years. Never had a staining problem. Whether you choose granite or quartz makes little difference in upkeep (both are zero to minimal) if properly sealed. Good luck, there is so much to choose from.
  • 14 years ago
    Thank you all for your imput, it has been very helpful! I am going with my first love, granite! Love the comment, '..You are the only one that has that slice of earth! ' Kitchen Art.
Sponsored
Bella Casa LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars17 Reviews
The Leading Interior Design Studio in Franklin County