Software
Houzz Logo Print
jrabbot_gw

replacing baseboard heat with fan convector - good idea?

17 years ago

Hi, I am new posting here. I have searched the forum and haven't found the answer to our problem. We are in the process of an addition and are making some changes to our current heating system. We upgraded our old boiler to a new efficient Buderus. In our LR due to cuts in the wall from the addition we need to remove the baseboard heat in those areas. And we also are converting 2 windows to doors onto decks. So we will have minimal wall space available for baseboard heat. Our heating-plumber contractor first suggested a high output baseboard that we were planning to go with - it is only a little larger than what we currently have. In light of changing both windows to doors he then offered using a product called a fan convector in place of the baseboard heat. He said he would remove all the baseboard and replace it with the product in the link below. This is the one he recommended for our space - LR measures 24' by 15' and has a vaulted ceiling in approx 2/3 of the space. There will be 2 french doors on exterior walls with no other windows. Other 2 walls are interior walls.

http://www.smithsenvironmental.com/profile-psu30-brochure.pdf

My questions?

-has anyone used these and how did it work out for you?

-how loud will it be? It is described as whisper quiet but I would like to know in advance about the noise level. I will call the company to ask what the sone is for this unit.

Thanks in advance for any advice. Please let me know other information necessary to answer my questions.

Here is a link that might be useful: Fan Convector PSU30

Comments (5)

  • 17 years ago

    Seems like an acceptable solution

  • 17 years ago

    This is just a wall mounted version of a single package heating unit--not unlike portable heaters. Biggest drawback is likely to be operating noise from fan. If using a heat pump, a ductless minisplit system would be more efficient and quieter. Would cost more so that is likely to be decision factor. Pricing varies greatly with efficiency and brand.

    A remote control thermostat is also a plus if putting out this much heat at one source( no ducts). If thermostat too close to heat source, temperature accuracy and stability poor.

  • 17 years ago

    Hi zver11,
    Thanks for your reply and addressing my questions. I am concerned about fan noise so that would definitely be a drawback for me. I don't know what you mean by the ductless minisplit system - could you elaborate?

    For clarification, the rest of existing house will remain baseboard forced hot water heat. The LR would also still be forced hot water from the same Buderus boiler. (The addition will be radiant floor heat)

    Thanks in advance for any further information from others as well. Would the old standard radiator be an option?

  • 17 years ago

    any other ideas on this? zver11, if you read this please see my questions above.

    Someone on the kitchen forum suggested radiant floor heat - installed from the ceiling below. Does anyone have a thought about that? Is it efficient and effective? I wonder how costly that would be?

    Hydroair was suggested but unfortunately the only ducts from AC for the room are at the top of the vaulted ceiling. So that would not work.

  • 17 years ago

    http://www.mysoninc.com/store.asp?pid=17945

    wonder if this may be an option for you. I was looking into these for myself but just starting out and really don't have any inside info.

    I currently have big steam radiators but a small house and I think these would work for me.