Software
Houzz Logo Print
delta2wye_gw

AC brands: which to pick?

16 years ago

All,

I've searched this message board for this question, and have only found partial answers, so here it is:

I am looking to replace my old AC/Furnace with a new one and can't decide which brand to go with! I do agree that correct installation is more important than the brand (as many of the members have posted for earlier questions), but brand must dictate some importance!

I don't have any experience with HVAC, so I invite all HVAC industry members and informed consumers to chime in.

Which brand do you think has the least problems/is the most reliable?

I was leaning towards getting carrier just because they are an established brand.

Thanks,

dw

Comments (10)

  • 16 years ago

    Just to add what I have so far: I got an estimate for York (from a York only dealer) and he claims that York is as reliable as any other major brand.

    The second estimate was from a Rheem installer who claims that York is the lowest rated brand when it comes to reliability (with Goodman), also he claims that Rheem and Trane are the way to go!

    Have yet to hear from carrier installers!

  • 16 years ago

    I worked for a Carrier/Bryant/Payne wholesaler for two years.

    I saw far less problems with Payne, at a lower price point, than Carrier or Bryant in that time.

    Think of them as Lincoln/Mercury/Ford. When the heated seats break on your Lincoln, it's an expensive PITA to fix. However, the Ford has the same engine, etc., just not all of the bells and whistles.

    Payne is the way to go, and is what I will be putting in my own house shortly. Also put a 14-seer Payne AC unit in dad's house in 2008 and he has been very happy with it through close to three cooling seasons.

  • 16 years ago

    I have a luxaire which is made by york and they are good.
    Every manufacturer has lower quality units that were not as good.

    If you get a middle to upper grade product from most manufacturers they will be good.

    I recommend getting a ac/heatpump with a scroll compressor. That is the heart of the unit. Most brands have them but not all.

    I heard in the past York/Luxaire wasn't as good,, but they are now. They are owned by Johnson controls now. Thats a huge fortune 500 manufacturer. That type of company brought in quality control and technology into the York/Luxaire/Coleman brands. They are a pretty good value.

  • 16 years ago

    Hi, it is very natural that all of us get confused when buying a product.This is mainly due to lack of proper information provided to us.It is really very difficult task to choose amongst so many reputed brands.
    But, one thing i would like to suggest some times there is tread off between quality and cost.
    It will be better if you go for a middle to upper grade product from a manufacturer.

    Hope you will soon find best option for you requirement.
    Good Luck !

  • 16 years ago

    There are no best brands,any unit made today will give decent service if properly sized and installed correctly. How long or how well a unit works and lasts depends on the luck of the draw. All use parts, such as motors relays, capacitors, and printed control boards from the same sources. These parts suppliers such as Honeywell, Robt Shaw, Johnson controls and GE to mention a few do not make bad parts for one application and good ones for another. Remember this so many parts are going to fail in each lot produced regardless of who makes them or the name on the unit using them, whether you get one of these parts depends on the luck nothing else. Remember any unit hacked in( poorly and incorrectly installed) will not give good service regardless of the brand. My suggestion is be more concerned about the installer and his skills rather than the name plate on a unit

  • 16 years ago

    I think sometimes it comes to luck of the draw. I have an old builders grade unit from comformaker, who I never heard of and it's lasted fine. I'm about to replace it and run up against the same issue as you. I've researched a lot and found there probably isn't a whole lot of difference in reliability in most of the major brands. So I ended up sorting out by features. I've concluded that Carrier or Bryant is what I would want for the infinity/evolution controller. I want to control the humidity to raise my comfort level and hopefully reduce my costs. I'm paying a little more for efficiency because I'm so uncertain about future energy costs. So reliability, while important, fell a little on my criteria for selection because I just couldn't discern who made the most reliable product. From everything I've read, installation is important as is regular service. Get a 10 year labor and parts warranty. The Bryant dealer I'm dealing with says it's free in my area right now. If you have a 10 year parts and labor you have a hedge against a lemon, which is what we all fear. Good luck! Keep reseaching and you will become comfortable with your selection.

  • 16 years ago

    I did months of research, talking with HVAC contractors, friends etc...picked Trane..it's quiet..which I love, reliable, Goodman would be a second choice if I did not plan on living in the home for more than a few years...but they make more noise...

  • 16 years ago

    Hi, you can go with Trane..it's quiet.. reliable, Goodman would be another choice but they make more noise.
    There are always some trade offs.For a reliable product little bit noise is compromised.
    They are best in air conditioning services, air conditioning maintenance, air conditioning in Florida, etc....

    Before you opt for a brand make a comparative study.Never do a haste.

    All the Best.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Air Conditioning Florida

  • 16 years ago

    We put in two high efficiency Rheem units (A/C and furnace) and have no issues with them at all. They cool well, and are just as reliable as our previous Trane units.

  • 16 years ago

    How long do you plan to live in that home? If shorter time frame, less than 5 years, Goodman might be a good choice. If longer, I like Trane. Then get ten or more bids, options are endless so do your homework so you can talk with the contractor. It is a big cost item for a homeowner so plan it out. Look at your duct work? Old? leaks? maybe replace it with new flex duct or at least get it cleaned.