Software
Houzz Logo Print
garya505

Looking for dual fuel recommendations.

16 years ago

Hey all,

I am looking for recommendations for dual fuel split system with tax credit (on at least the HP). I'm not looking for high-end stuff, just the best "bang for the buck".

Location is Albuquerque NM. I am removing an exaporative cooler and putting in a heat pump and new gas furnace. We have a lot of very mild days here where a HP would do nicely for heat. I haven't decided yet if I want a 80% or 95% furnace (opinions welcome on that). We plan to stay in the home for a long time so that will be a factor in my decision. Sizing has already been done using Manual J.

Details:

Single story, 1800 sf.

Furnace in the garage.

Condenser on the roof over the garage (line length ~15ft)

Cooling: 2.5 tons single stage or 3 tons 2-stage

Furnace: 80-90MBTU for 80%, or 60-70MBTU for 95%, 2-stage, variable speed not required.

Flexibility in setting furnace low constant fan CFM is very desirable.

Humidification is needed most of the year (yes, sometimes even in summer).

I am using a White-Rodgers 1F95-1291 stat that I like. ;)

What else can I tell you? I'm sure I'll think of more as soon as I post this!

I'm pretty good at looking at specs and such, but I would greatly appreciate some direction based on your experience.

Regards,

Gary in Albuquerque

Comments (4)

  • 16 years ago

    gary

    a correctly sized carrier infinity furnace either 80% or 95% with infinity controller paired with Performance 15 or Performance 16 heat pump.

    sister company Bryant has identical equipment.

    IMO

  • 16 years ago

    tigerdunes - Thanks for the suggestion. Looks like good equipment. I reviewed my size calculations again, and I think the best fits are going to be either a 80% in 80MBTU or a 95% in 70MBTU. Unfortunately, I see that Carrier/Bryant sizes are 60 & 80 in 95% furnaces and 70 & 90 in 80% furnaces.

  • 16 years ago

    gary

    so a 95% at 80 KBTU has 76 KBTUs on high stg of the MVC(three stg).

    and an 80% at 90 KBTU has 72 KBTUs on high stg of the CAV(two stage).

    what do your heating load calcs say?

    so what is the issue? being undersized or oversized?

    here is a snapshot of your climate.

    Climate averages for: ALBUQUERQUE, NM, 87102
    Hot weather Cold weather
    Average days per year above 75: 153 Average days per year below 40: 62
    Average high temperature: 92.3 Average low temperature: 35.7

    IMO

  • 16 years ago

    tigerdunes-

    My heat loss is calculated at 45000. BTW, I was real lucky
    last winter and had some temps right at the low design
    temp for this location so I took the opportunity to get
    cycle times on my current 125K BTU, 50% 1-stage furnace (I
    call it "the beast"), and the results confirmed the
    calculated heat loss. Also, based on the cycle times I
    calculate that my current furnace is about 45% oversized.

    >> Note that I am at 5000ft, and the furnace output must
    >> be derated by 4% per 1000ft, so output at 5000ft is
    >> only 80% of output at sea level.

    I looked at the calculations again.

    --95% 70K--
    70000 * .95 = 66500 (for AFUE)
    66500 * .80 = 53200 (for 5000ft altitude)
    53200 / 45000 = 1.18 for 18% margin above heat loss

    --95% 80K--
    80000 * .95 = 76000 (for AFUE)
    76000 * .80 = 60800 (for 5000ft altitude)
    60800 / 45000 = 1.35 for 35% margin above heat loss

    --80% 80K--
    80000 * .80 = 64000 (for AFUE)
    64000 * .80 = 51200 (for 5000ft altitude)
    51200 / 45000 = 1.14 for 14% margin above heat loss

    --95% 90K--
    90000 * .80 = 72000 (for AFUE)
    72000 * .80 = 57600 (for 5000ft altitude)
    60800 / 45000 = 1.28 for 28% margin above heat loss

    Please tell if I did something wrong here. IMO, the best
    fits are the 95% in 70K or the 80% in 80K. Maybe the 80%
    in 90K, but not the 95% in 80K. Do you agree?

    If somebody has a 95% in 75K or 80% in 85K, those might
    work too.

    The MVC is 3-stage? Sweet!