Software
Houzz Logo Print
palimpsest

Thoughts on "Moving Beyond granite (now..)"

13 years ago

The "Moving Beyond Granite (now that it's outdated)" thread, and it's reaction, got me thinking.

The thought is (probably correctly) that this tread was started to get a reaction (a negative one), to be snarky, etc.

But this got me to thinking again about why certain points do cause reactions, are sources of vulnerability, etc.

Granite is no longer trendy, but only because it's become a standard. Same with stainless: it's a standard--some appliances are offered Only in this finish. So these materials can't be trendy and a standard offering at the same time. I don't think quartzite, marble or other stones count as "different"--they are still stone. Lavastone or Pyrolave is too expensive to become standard. Stainless requires too much custom fabrication to become standard.

15 years ago, or so, a flat TV cost about $20,000. Ten years ago, I was thinking about getting one for my kitchen and a relatively small one cost $1500. I said to the guy in the store "I feel sorry for those people who paid $20,000 just a few years ago", and he said "Oh, don't feel sorry for them--they paid the premium to be first...everybody knew the price would drop fast." Now, of course they are cheap. They aren't trendy, they are the standard. They can't really be both at the same time.

So what is going to "replace" it. The answer is probably "nothing". About 40 years ago, Corian was new, about a dozen years ago Quartz as new. But right now there is nothing new. It's a stasis. I don't know that there is a "trend" to replace it--just iterations of the materials already available.

Comments (31)

  • 13 years ago

    I'm waiting for a stainless-lookalike laminate to be available from wilsonart or formica at home despot. They could produce any color of metal in thin, flexible sheets.

    Well, I'm not really waiting, because I'm having a custom stainless counter with integral sink fabricated. But wilsonart has these thin sheets of metal already. All they have to do is make it "suitable for countertops". So far, it's just approved for horizontal surfaces or ceilings.

    I'd like to see mass produced specialty glass countertops drop in price. Not just the green ones that you can buy with integral sink for vanity tops, but nice ones in other colors, seeded, wavy, etc., without going to a specialty store and paying top dollar. The recycled glass terrazzo stuff shows promise, but it's still too hard to find to be standard.

    Standard has to be a bit easier to get. That means the toolers and the distributors have to be lined up.

  • 13 years ago

    Pal, the flat-screen tv analogy is good. Now that most of us have them and they're no big deal, who wants to return to the nostalgia of a big bulbous tv with horrible resolution? Just because something is more commonplace doesn't necessarily diminish its qualities.

  • 13 years ago

    I know you have a thing about design being stuck because there aren't any significant technological innovations to drive new ideas--no radically new materials like plastic was in the '40s and '50s. I don't disagree.

    There is a lot of talk about this very thing among the better economists now, by the way. We aren't innovating very much in the physical world any more, just in the information world. A hundred years ago, dramatic change touched every household in the nation with indoor plumbing and heating, electricity, automobiles, planes, roads, antibiotics, synthetic fabrics and much more. Today we're making only incremental changes to cars and furnaces and airplanes, but a new iPhone is considered a major breakthrough. And information just isn't as important as the other stuff, despite the hype. As the economists sometimes ask, which would you rather give up forever, Twitter or toilets?

    There are a lot of reasons for that. Not to go too deep into it here, but capital used to be focused on economic investment (not financial investment), risk-taking, manufacturing, marketing and sales, and competition. None of these are very important now. Capital wants economic rents (not the apartment kind), which more or less mean an enforced "cut" earned off the top without doing much for it. Royalties on old intellectual property, monopoly prices, patents, commissions, financial shenanigans like high frequency trading, etc. That's where the money is now, not in inventing vulcanized rubber or popularizing consumer cameras.

    All that said, I was discussing the whole granite issue with my architect. It's funny how people get stuck inside a particular model, can't see out of it, and don't even know they're looking at a model--they think they're looking at reality, like the people who used to make the funny gizmos showing how the sun revolved around the earth. Today the model is that you go out and find a big rock as the "star" of your kitchen. Why should you put a rock in your house? Why should you treat that rock as if it's art? As if it's the centerpiece of your home--when it has nothing to do with the structure of your home, or with the natural landscape around it, since it probably came from way overseas? That's one approach to designing a kitchen, sure, but it's not the only one, it's not the 'natural' one, it's not the 'timeless' one. It's just a model that people are stuck in now, and can't conceive of any other.

  • 13 years ago

    How about carbon fiber?

    Think of one continuous surface with integrated seamless sink with that fabric look? Warm to touch, light weight, super thin, durable, cool to look at, no other house has it. It is the antithesis to thick marble.

    Now that it is said, lets see how long it takes for the first carbon fiber kitchen.

  • 13 years ago

    Hardwood is just as much of a go-to choice for upscale, functional, and maintainable flooring as it was some centuries ago. The fact that it's more available now and at decent prices doesn't change its desirability.

    I don't think countertops will be any different. And I'd lump quartz in with granite, marble, quartzite, etc., as just another choice in stone countertops.

  • 13 years ago

    I grew up in a former center of the carbon graphite industry and although it's interesting stuff, I think the expense of carbon fiber will limit its use for the time being.

  • 13 years ago

    Marcolo- Excellent post...I miss economics and it's fun to see someone who understands it so well, explain it to the rest of us. It would also be nice if we (as a country) started investing our capital in physical innovations again, rather than just information.

    What I'd like is to find an environmentally-friendly, no fumes, hard as nails material that I could wipe over marble, wood and any other 'natural countertop' to keep it from staining, etching, or being damaged from water, etc. NOT plastic, but something that is easy to use and doesn't stink up the house, when you need to reapply (although hopefully not often). Any ideas?

  • 13 years ago

    Somebody will come up with something new- they always do.
    It may be a completely new product or some sort of amazing improvement in something already known, but it will occur.
    Just because we can't forecast exactly what it will be doesn't mean it won't happen and somehow I don't see Bianco Antico being the hot ticket in 2113.

  • 13 years ago

    I brought up carbon fiber because the auto industry has successfully used it in modern upscale interiors, and for exterior accents. It looks so cool. I was being a little silly, but the truth is, it really is the opposite of marble.

    I think manufactured products with interest and depth will be the next hot thing when durability improves within an acceptable price point.

    I really wanted paperstone, but then found out it was not really durable compared to other similarly priced surfaces. I thought it had "depth" and loved the color choices, and warmth.

  • 13 years ago

    I'd like a paint that, when applied, would be very hard and impervious to stains, scratches and dings. I'd like to get away from the idea of a countertop as a separate "thing."

    Of course I don't know if designers can really predict what they're supposed to be designing for. It's not like the '40s where the goal was kitchen efficiency. People don't cook much, they just like to watch TV shows about cooking and display ready to eat foods in an attractive setting. I'm not sure whether they need countertops at all.

  • 13 years ago

    I don't think carbon fiber is a silly concept...they make furniture out of it--it's very strong, apparently. Maybe someone Will use it for a residential building material/finish, if they haven't already.

  • 13 years ago

    For new counter top materials - what about looking at new flooring materials and what advances are being made there. So many counter materials started off as flooring materials - marble, hardwood, tiles.

  • 13 years ago

    This is an interesting post.

    My first house was a starter contemporary (1992) condo - wide open with lots of windows and three levels. The kitchen was very standard with builder oak cabinets, white tile counters with 6" tile splash, white appliances and a creamy (builder basic) tile floor that was an upgrade..

    I loved that house.

    Over time I replaced the counter with granite (tile), replaced the sink with a single basin and a pullout contemporary faucet. I wasn't in love with granite, but what I chose worked well with the rest of the kitchen.

    At the time, the pictures in my cool-stuff-file looked much different. I've always preferred vintage and was loving a more shabby chic look back then, but the choices I made fit with the rest of the structure, my budget and the neighborhood to a lesser extent.

    Living in a vintage home, on this remodel I was again concerned about building something that was sympathetic to the rest of the structure. I was not concerned with what HGTV was pushing at the time. I had a vision of what this house called for with my unique stamp on that vision. I can't afford to be a purist when it comes to vintage, so I make compromises.

    My pet peeve is when I go into a home and see built-in finish work that is inconsistent with the rest of the house. Like a mid century modern with vessel sinks, maxi-master bedroom suites attached to a vintage home, uber country kitchens in generic new build homes.

    I believe that the permanence of a home gives it a soul of its own.

    I'm not judging others on here, but for me I want the totality of whatever home I'm living in at the time to have a consistent structural vibe because that exists when I'm there and after I'm gone (or before someone else makes a change).

    Then I come in and decorate with the things that define me or please my eye without being completely disconnected to the structure.

  • 13 years ago

    In designing my kitchen, I said I didn't want granite because around here (and maybe everywhere) it's the standard, high-end choice. I guess I didn't want it because it has now penetrated into every McMansion in our area, and has become generic. My thinking is that the person who purchases a McMansion is not the person who is going to think outside of the box when it comes to countertop material (apologies to you creative McMansion owners out there). The builder probably made the choice for them, and the purchaser was probably thrilled to have something so "high end."

    Of course, I may end up with granite because I'm a novice and maybe it really is the best choice for me, but that was my thought process.

    This post was edited by Kitten1313 on Fri, Jan 4, 13 at 18:35

  • 13 years ago

    I just don't see natural materials going out of style whether it's for a countertop, flooring, cabinets or furniture. Man-made alternatives will flow in and out but will never fully replace the natural materials.

  • 13 years ago

    1929
    "I had a vision of what this house called for with my unique stamp on that vision. I can't afford to be a purist when it comes to vintage, so I make compromises.

    My pet peeve is when I go into a home and see built-in finish work that is inconsistent with the rest of the house."

    I agree !!! I put in SS because although I'm not in New England it just felt right for the space.

  • 13 years ago

    The issue may indeed be that people like having the hot new visual feature, in combination/contradiction with the fact that many people are indeed cooking seldom if ever. And if you do actually like to cook, what is at the pinnacle of style may not be the best for that.

    So you can end up with the kitchen equivalent of a Trophy Wife. Costs you a fortune, high maintenance, and maybe your old one was not so bad after all.

    This leads to an unbalance between visual design and actual function.. You have a situation where people spend a small fortune on a fancy stone countertop, and then can't trust a guest with a glass of wine without growing eyes in the back of their head. What a stress nightmare.

    I think Marcolo's idea might just happen....the new nail salon polishes that use the UV lights to harden them may lead to a coating system that would be workable for countertops and sinks....

  • 13 years ago

    While I agree with Marcolo about "Economics" and the real lack of anything "Really Technically New",(except computers and the like), I do disagree with him as far as granite or other "Natural Materials".

    I do not want a Chemistry lab in my kitchen,
    (Man made countertop, Painted cabinets, etc etc).

    Some things just can't be beat, and never will be!
    Mother Nature for One!!! We've had our granite counters & backsplash for 7 years now and luv them just as much as the day they were installed. Ditto for our Oak cabinets, drawers and panels for fridge and dishwasher.
    Same for the Onyx surround for my fireplace----Yea the stone may have come from
    "Tim Buck Two", but "To ME", it beats anything created in a Chemistry lab!

    (We aren't keeping IPhones, TV's, Computers etc out of our homes because they are built elsewhere)? Same for Appliances and especially Light bulbs since our beloved Govt saw fit to give all the light bulb business to the Chineese!

    Gary

  • 13 years ago

    Timbuktu is an actual place in Mali, West Africa.

    I don't think anybody is discrediting natural substances like stone, but "what's next" is going to Have to be something either man-made or man-altered--the natural products that are applicable are already in use.

    This post was edited by palimpsest on Fri, Jan 4, 13 at 20:52

  • 13 years ago

    Not the ones from other planets.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Planet made of diamonds

  • 13 years ago

    Wood stain involves just as much chemistry as paint. I suppose one could put raw wood cabinets into a kitchen, but I don't think that would be particularly durable.

  • 13 years ago

    What's next may (hopefully) be something that doesn't require stone carved out of poorly-regulated Third World countries, shipped in containers on diesel-fueled cargo ships most of the way around the world, to be installed in ordinary American kitchens and baths. That goes for marble and soapstone, too. (Though marble is still commercially mined here in the US; soapstone only to a minimal degree, most is from Brasil and Asia). Yet we have plenty of rocks in this country, many might even be slam-damn gorgeous, too. There is one mine in Western Mass that is producing a beautiful (one kitchen posted here on the forum has it) schist. If I was planning on granite, I would definitely be looking at regionally, if not locally quarried stone. If customers don't ask about and purchase local stones, few will be stocked or offered.

    The idea of shipping decorative rocks tens of thousands of miles makes me cringe. I am not swayed by the argument that it's a green "natural material". From the nature it may be, but the carbon cost of extracting it and then getting it here make it unacceptable, to me. It's right there with non-sustianably harvested tropical hardwoods for floors or cabs.

    Just can't see it.

    L.

  • 13 years ago

    I'm with Lirio on this one. I know it's kind of a downer thought when we so enjoy celebrating the use of stone in our kitchens. But when I stare at the slabs at the stoneyard I think pretty hard about all the effort required to get the stone from the place where it formed all the way to my house. I can't quite stomach the thought of cutting up one of those perfect slabs just for my own fancy.

    My solution has been to use remnants. Granted, I don't really want stone throughout our kitchen so it's not a huge sacrifice. The slab yard has an enormous selection of remnants that offer lots to the imagination. And yes, I know that using remnants doesn't absolve me of my share of the responsibility for the rock. But so far we've had good luck finding what we need in the scrap pile and I can live with the idea of having stone accents rather than full slabs.

    As for future countertops, I like the idea of recycled glass. Our state (MT) has stopped recycling glass so some artisans are making it into various objects. I could imagine some neat fused glass counters. Maybe we could save up our wine bottles and then recraft them for everlasting life in the kitchen!

  • 13 years ago

    The "greenest" option is pretty much always living with the kitchen the house came with and replacing the appliances with more efficient models when necessary.

    "Green" is a very complex and difficult term, and very misused and misleading when it applies to replacing something existing with something new whether it be processed in a factory, torn out of the ground or part of the earth. Some things that are very "green" and inert in themselves and at their end use have major environmental impact at their source. (and, probably vice-versa).

  • 13 years ago

    I have noticed alot of individuality in kitchen design and choices again lately. For most of the last three years all the kitchens in magazines and here in GW reveals blended into each other and were very similar. In the end of last year and the beginning of this year each kitchen reveal stands out on its own merrit. No two have been the same and I am loving this! Maybe the new norm is to create a unique space by choosing the best materials for your design rather than using the go to finishes that everyone else used. I am not knocking granite at all for I do believe it is sometimes the perfect finish for many designs just like painted cabinets are the right design choice for many homes too but they are not the only right choices and it seems that that is now appreciated.

  • 13 years ago

    I vote for glass...

  • 13 years ago

    These decisions wrt counters, cabinets, etc are so regional and then even within that neighbourhood specific. Yes, we have granite counters while most people in our neighbourhood are putting in quartz and we have painted white cabinets while most people, when renovating are choosing stained cabinets. So, in my neighbourhood I went against the grain which makes my kitchen interesting (to me) while here my kitchen would be now (apparently) be considered boring.

    We have other areas that are more adventurous in their choices with glass counters, slab high-gloss cabinets, etc. Those seem to be more small downtown condo-specific perhaps because of cost or because of the clientele.

    We made our choices for a variety of reasons mainly having to do with living beside forests that go on forever and living in a post and beam house. Speaking of which for just a sec - post and beam has often been disparaged because of it's simplistic form and probably still is in many markets but, here, it is now in high demand in the real estate market. It's a construction form that I have always loved.

  • 13 years ago

    How about kevlar counters! Talk about bullet proof! :)

    Since we just got rid of our old huge tube TV for a flat screen, we are obviously behind the power curve. So I'm looking forward to putting in granite countertops. I've looked at all the options, and that's what I like best. I've never had granite, only formica in every home I've ever lived in (we were active duty military so lots of base housing, apartments, and rental homes in our past).

    I know I'll like what I get and that's what counts. You can't please everyone, so at least please yourself!

    I still think the cool factor of carbon fiber counters would be awesome, though!

  • 13 years ago

    I vote for recycled glass countertops too, I think we might see more of it.

    I agree with you roarah, I'm happy to see a bit more individuality (which you can have even with a white kitchen). blfenton is correct about regional disparities though, and the kitchens we see here are GW aren't necessarily reflective of the general population. White is still king around here though, I've had three neighbours renovate their kitchens over the last couple of years, two white kitchens, one cherry, one quartz counter, two granite. One family chose local granite which is great.

  • 13 years ago

    Having worked with carbon fiber for a race car, I'll tell you that it's not quite as bulletproof as you think. It's biggest advantage is it is lightweight and strong, which you want in a race car. It's downside is the gel coat top coat is your standard polyester resin just like you use with most fiberglass cars like a Corvette. It will show scratches and abrasions, even though they don't penetrate the actual carbon fiber. Now it looks as cool as can be, and we did a side table in the office out of MDF covered with it. I'm not so sure that I'd want a counter out of it. I'd rather have the FOrmica laminate look alike that was the design contest winner a few years ago.

    And I do think that I agree with Pal that laminate is the new hot product. I've delved into Abet Laminati offerings and absolutely love all of them. I'm just having trouble finding a local fabricator who will work with them, even though I can order direct.

  • 13 years ago

    The problem with the old Formica counters was that they scratched and got discolored/worn-out, and ceramic tile counters had that ugly/discolored grout. Granite lasts! My kitchen granite is 8 years old, and it looks as good today as when it was new. And it is so easy to care for. Why do we need something new or better? Of course, there will always be new styles- new colors, and probably new materials. However, if you put in granite, it will always look good and beautiful.