Software
Houzz Logo Print
jenni232323

Need help choosing new heat pump system

16 years ago

Our 19 year old TRANE compressor died last week (3 ton, 10 SEER). We've been getting several quotes for replacement system. In the mean time, we got a 8,000 BTU window unit that's been keeping our main living areas surprisingly cool.

We live in Central FL (Daytona Beach), so mostly use cooling very little heat. Home is 1600 sq. ft. 1 story ranch with 8 ft ceilings, block home built in 1979. We replaced all windows with impact a few months ago. Our electric bill runs around $180 in the summer (not sure on the breakdown on of the kw hours). Local power company pressure tested our ducts and said we have minimal leaks and attic insulation is R-15, we plan to do blown insulation to bump it up to around R-30. Will also add 2 gable vents and solar attic fan once it cools down enough to go in the attic.

Since we already spent our federal tax credit on the windows, we're only eligible for local power company discount (need to get 15 SEER) and mfg discount.

My husband was interested in 2 stage compressor and variable speed (I think that's what it's called) for energy efficiency, but 9 out of 10 estimators said that our ducts would likely sweat and it woulnd't be worth the cost of modifying the ducts and we really wouldn't save the cost difference in 10 years.

The quotes we're looking closer at are:

Our family friend is an AC installer, can get 3 ton 15 SEER

TRANE 4TWR5036 with 4TEH3542 $3702

CARRIER 25HVC536 with FX4DNF037P $3368

Either one he would replace the lines, new drain pan and float, t-stat, heat strip (didn't know if we needed 8kw or 10kw).

We would add the 5 inch MERV 11 whole house filter (Honeywell F100) for $200 and I would likely upgrade the thermostat to programmable since we use our Ritetemp programmable a lot now (or did when AC worked). Any recs on a t-stat for this TRANE or CARRIER?

We trust this guy's expertise the most as we've known him for years and he's done great work for other family members.

We're also looking at:

BRYANT 215B+FX37 Legacy Series $3985, flush lines, adding 1 main return duct and replacing plenum return, spray components with herasite rust inhibitor, 10yr parts, 1yr labor, Lifetime installation warranty, free 6mo check up

CARRIER COMFORT 25HCC536 with FX4DNF037T $4425, new lines, MERV 11 1yr filter, 10yr parts, 1yr labor (add $721 10yr labor) - as I understand this condensor has the same inners as higher models, just powder coated metal case

CARRIER BASE 25HBC536A with FX4DNF037T $4050, new lines, MERV 11 1yr filter, 10yr parts, 1yr labor (add $721 10yr labor) - as I understand this has metal condensor casing base model

The guy that quoted these above 2 CARRIER units also quoted TRANE TWR536 with TEH3F4ZB $4150, but did not recommend TRANE saying they've been having quality issues

The LENNOX guy was most informative, quoted

LENNOX 14HPX-036 with CBX27UH-036 $3936, standard install new lines, hurricane pad, drain pan and float, etc.

AMANA sales guy last night had my husband thinking about Amana. From what I've read, they also make One Hour Air Conditioning and Heating's unit (got a quote from them too $5500! Although he was the only guy that did a load test counting our windows and all, he came up with a 2.5 ton unit) and are made with Goodman, which is a lesser grade product. He quoted AMANA ASZ14 for around $4000 (paper work's not with me right now), 10 year on parts and labor. The 10 year on labor really interested my husband even though we have a friend that's an AC professional.

So, bottom line - does anyone recommend any of these units? Or think we should look into anything different? If we order with our AC friend today or tomorrow, he can install on Saturday, which would be nice.

Thanks in advance for any help!

Comments (12)

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    jenni

    these are my minimum specs for a new HP system. both outside and inside units should be replaced to have a properly matched system.

    15 SEER, 12.5+ EER, 9 HSPF
    best matching VS air handler
    full BTUs in both cooling and heating for your rated size
    R-410a refrigerant(same as Puron)
    scroll compressor preferred
    electronic demand defrost preferred
    thermostat with "dehumidify on demand" feature
    staged backup heat strips
    new and correctly sized refrigerant lineset

    you want a thorough inspection of your ductwork system. size, overall condition, supply and return lines, insulation qualities, leak test, etc.

    any hot/cold spot issues in your home should be addressed.

    I would only use authorized dealers for the various brands that provide quotes. see mfg websites.

    I would look at Trane/AmStd,Rheem,Carrier/Bryant.

    ...

    for Florida location/climate and high humidity, I would not purchase a new system without a var speed air handler. None of your quotes had that.

    my personal choice would be the Trane XR15 you were quoted with a var speed air handler rather than the 4TEH.

    see below.

    3519776 Active Systems XR15 WEATHERTRON TRANE 4TWR5036E1 4TEE3F40B1 37400 12.70 15.00 36200 9.00 23400

    8KW heat strip should be sufficient.

    I would ditch the Rite-Temp thermostat and install HW 8321.

    IMO

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    the quotes you listed first from your friend were a good price. If you know him well and friends are happy with his work you should most definetly go with him.

    I"ve heard trane's are better near salt-water coastal environment but I'm not sure. Variable speed fan is an improvement over non-variable speed but the non-variable speeds are pretty energy efficient too.

    The $3376 price your friend quoted for the carrier is an amazing low price for all the stuff included. What line carrier is that (performance, comfort, or base)? Is it the 15 seer model?

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks.
    Tigerdunes -
    If scroll compressor is preferred, then we should go with Carrier right? Trane's is Climatuff Compressor, which I don't think is scroll?
    I'll ask our friend about the 4TEE3F40B1 and why he didn't recommend it.
    We would change out our t-stat - I just didn't know which one to look at, thanks.

    neohioheatpump -
    I just don't know why none of the 11 companies that gave us estimates didn't quote variable speed for our home. We are in a high humidity area and about 4 miles from the beach.
    The Carrier $3376 was Comfort series I think. I may have wrote the model down wrong, I thought he said 25HVC536, but I think it should be 25HCC36 - I'll check with him tonight. And yes, all are SEER 15.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Side note -
    On the Amana quote we got last night, he did quote a 3 ton 14 SEER with variable speed blower to get to 15 SEER $4885 compared to the $3976 for the 3 ton 14 SEER with high efficiency blower. I think the way he did the math, for us to make up the $900 difference, it would take over 10 years. I don't know excatly how he figured that out.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    jenni

    Trane's Climatuff compressor for a three ton XR15 may or may not be a scroll compressor. Trane's compressors are proprietary and in fact are highly regarded in the industry. Whether it is scroll or not should not be a concern or an issue.

    I would prefer the Trane three ton XR15 system with VS air handler over the Carrier Comfort system.

    IMO

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'll mention that since you have replaced your windows and will double your attic insulation 'soon', a 3-ton replacement may be too large. In a choice between a two-stage compressor and a variable speed blower, I would pick the blower.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'd stay away from the Amana. I would go with either the trane or carrier from the first guy. Thats an amazing price for the Carrier. If your trying to save money I would go with that carrier quote in a second.

    You might want to consider going down to 2.5 tons if your adding more insulation. Do you notice a big difference with the new windows? How did your old 3 ton do?

    Its not a bad thing to run constantly at 2.5 tons. You would have lower humidity. Running constantly is better than stopping and starting I would think too.

    I've been to daytona in March before, and it gets surprisingly warm there early in the season. Your new AC will save you alot of money in electricity.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    jenni

    I am going to take a contrary view to the above post. Unless your old windows had holes in them and were without the old type storm windows, new DP windows while nice and look good do little to reduce your cooling load. I would not go down in size without a written load calculation in hand. For Florida, I do not want to be in a borderline situation for cooling. While I do prefer the Trane over the Carrier, by all means please get the VS air handler.

    IMO

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks again for your input.
    I think we've decided on a Trane. The Carrier our friend quoted was the base model 25HBC536A with FX4DNF037T and even at $3368 it'd be a few hundred more for permit and hurricane pad, which would make it close to the cost of the company who quoted 25HCC536 and 25HBC536 models. Also with our friend, we'd need to pay it all by check. we have the funds, but Carrier is offering zero percent for a year or so - minus well use thier money for a year! Both the Carrier Comfort and Trane XR15 seem comprable in function and effeciency, so then I had to decide which one looked better to me. That's a woman for ya! :)

    I'm going to try to get the company who quoted the 2 Carriers and the TRANE TWR536 with TEH3F4ZB $4150 to come down a few hundred and see if he'll include the $125 for the MERV 11 1 year filter.

    Is it common to ask for lower price on this type of service?

    The only company that even asked about our windows was the One Hour AC franchise that did the only load calculation. He factored our house needs 2.5 ton unit. We had the windows in a few months before the ac broke and there was not really a significant change in our electric bill. We did go from aluminum single pane 30 year old windows to impact laminated insulated glass vinyl windows. You could feel the heat coming in on the old - the new you can barely hear any outside noise and it's got a coating that helps block the solar gains.

    neohioheatpump - it's always hot here in Daytona! ;) I think we're only expected to not hit 90 today because it's raining.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    so have you made a decision? Is it going to get installed. When does heating season start in Daytona?

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    jenni

    it is quite apparent you are getting extraordinary pricing. you do want to make certain Trane 10 yr parts warranty will be in effect. with that said and unless this is strictly a budget decision, you are making a mistake not getting the VS air handler. why not take advantage of the special pricing you are receiving.

    Sorry. Had to say it.

    IMO
    Good Luck!

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If a properly performed load calculation determined that your home only requires 2.5 tons of cooling for the peak summer conditions, then installing a 3 ton unit doesn't make much sense. Bigger is not better, either for comfort or efficiency. Granted, 1/2 ton is not a large difference, but many ductwork systems are undersized to begin with, so it could be that 2.5 tons is the better match. With the new windows, did the 3 ton unit ever run short cycles (which are inefficient) during days where the temperature was not extreme?

Sponsored
Miller Woodworks
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars23 Reviews
Franklin County's Trusted Custom Cabinetry Solutions