There are a lot of rug sellers on ebay. I have never ordered from them but the seller in the link below has 20,000 transactions and 100% approval rating so poking around there might help. Perhaps you could talk to some of the larger sellers directly and see if they could help. I would hold out for wool, possibly paying more if need be.

Here is a link that might be useful: Morris area rug

Thank you skyedog. The Morris area rug you linked to is beautiful and would probably work size-wise. I had already looked at ebay when I was trying to decide if I could find a pattern I could afford that I also liked.

The problem is that after trying a several patterns, I've concluded that to stay true to my "vision" of the house, I need to keep the pattern clean. I have a hand tufted oriental (I plan to return to O.co) whose colors go perfectly with the room, but the pattern really makes the room look too traditional and I'm striving for a cleaner, modern effect. My husband really likes the rug and wants to keep it. It doesn't look bad, but its busyness takes the focus away from more important pieces in the room.

Also, the ideal size is and almost square, which is unusual for a rug (the Morris rug is that shape!. The only way to have all the parameters come together is to get broadloom cut and bound to size, and I'm trying to find a source that's a bit more affordable. The rug I like best is $102/sq yd locally and $88 from the NC retailer.