Software
Houzz Logo Print
amysrq

AD gets reinvented....what do you think?

15 years ago

It's hard to tell, in this era of so much to look at online, whether any "real" magazines stand a fighting chance. I have never been a regular reader of Architectural Digest, but will certainly pick up a copy of the March issue...if only to have a look at the home of Muriel Brandolini, one of my faves. "High Bohemian"...yummm.

I still miss House & Garden and have hardly found Elle Decor an adequate substitute. All that's left is House Beautiful. Maybe I'll have one more mag to crawl into bed with....since computers and TVs aren't allowed in my bedroom. :-)

Here is a link that might be useful: NYTimes article

Comments (33)

  • 15 years ago

    "As one decorator observed, 'Everything looked like a hotel lobby.' "

    Yep. Will be interesting to see the reincarnation.

  • 15 years ago

    I got Architectural Digest for years. First I got it when I was 13 8-l, and then I got it through most of the nineties and stopped. I think I stopped when it became so celebrity focused and the bit of vulgarity became overwhelming in some issues. I wrote a letter to the editor about one of Sylvester Stallone's places calling it "the combination of the worst of the Vatican and a wh*rehouse." It was not published.

    I like Margaret Russell and I liked Elle Decor, mostly because it did not have a set in stone design agenda. When scout pictures of my place were sent to the magazine for consideration, I got an email from her, personally. And when the apartment did not make the cut for publication, I got the sense from that email that they really did take a close look at it, rather than scanning the pics and passing on the work of some unknown that wasn't in the club, and I appreciated that.

    So we'll see --I hate to see real magazines disappear.

  • 15 years ago

    "I wrote a letter to the editor about one of Sylvester Stallone's places calling it "the combination of the worst of the Vatican and a wh*rehouse." It was not published"

    You crack me up.

  • 15 years ago

    pal don't mince words - tell us what you really think ;-)

  • 15 years ago

    I stopped subscribing several years ago. One of my complaints was the lack of sourcing. The article Amy linked mentions a new emphasis on sourcing, so I will check it out, at least. Another of my objections was a trend toward showing "celebrity" homes, whether they were inherently interesting from a design standpoint or not. Buy People or watch Cribs or something, but, please, spare me. Pal, I'm right there with ya'.

  • 15 years ago

    Funny...I think the last issue I bought at the newsstand featured the latest and greatest home of Cher. Deliver me...

    KD, it is interesting to notice the sourcing shift. We inhabit a new era, one in which everyone expects to be able to access everything at every moment of the day -- find, price and purchase with a click. Quite a departure from the To The Trade mentality and the exclusivity that that implies.

  • 15 years ago

    I will be watching the upcoming issues with interest as AD hasn't been on my buy-it list for many years. Thank you, Amysrq, for posting the article.

  • 15 years ago

    I've been a subscriber for the past few years and AD is like a chocolate bar to me...

    Not really nutritionally useful, but oh so good being consumed. LOL

    I'll be interested to see the March issue.

  • 15 years ago

    Glad to see it's in trouble, hope it folds.

    The article breezes over the departure of Domino without seeing fit to mention that that the magazine was folded specifically so that CN could focus added support on AD, its favored failure. Domino, like it or hate it, was targeted younger and middle class, and built up a loyal following quickly. However, the middle class readership was of no interest to Conde Nast, which was desperate to lick and fawn over the heels of celebrities and vulgar wannabees. Domino readers were sent issues of AD to fulfill the remainder of their subscriptions, accompanied with a fulsome letter implying they had snuck into the back door with the help, but would reluctantly be permitted to stay to avoid causing a scene.

    A pity so much chintz gave its life for so little cause.

  • 15 years ago

    I've gotten AD for years, but don't think I've received the newest issue. I would LOVE for homes/rooms to be on the cover again and not celebrities. Please tell me the article says that! That said, there have been beautiful celebrity homes over the years - John Travolta's two homes, more recently Rob Lowe and Diane Keaton's homes come to mind. Oh, and Woody Allen's home (or was it apartment).

    Gotta love Pal. ;)

    I miss Southern Accents, Home and Garden.... probably a few more but I can't see through my Southern Accent tears.

  • 15 years ago

    Where is the "Architecture" in AD?

    It was mostly an overstuffed-decorated-mansions-uninspired-expensive. Nothing innovative, modern or out of the ordinary. They would show maybe one interesting home. Rest were 80s opulent gilded museums.

    WOuld like to see what it is now?

  • 15 years ago

    Thank you for sharing this link, amysrq! I like Commune, am a sucker for their (overpriced) pillows (why I love eBay!). In a recent issue of a shelter mag -- which one? -- there was a spread on one of Commune's homes and I thought it was pretty terrific (boho). In this month's Elle Decor is a lavish (not enough pics) piece on Liza Bruce's riad in Morocco and I am head over heels in love. Thumpety-thump. It took every ounce of strength for me to close the magazine and get back to life. Boy that Margaret Russell is cute as a button! I miss H&G and Domino, though ....

  • 15 years ago

    Coincidentally I started subscribing to AD a few months ago, just before the previous editor left. Only reason was one of those insane $5/year specials on Amazon.

    I'm anticipating a new direction. Agree with the NYT piece that the magazine was pretty stale.

    As for shelter mags in general, I still miss House and Garden and Dominique Browning. She seems to be such a decent person. I read her book Slow Love about the closing of the magazine and how her life changed.

    Still love House Beautiful. It's definitely my favorite and I eagerly anticipate each issue. The new editor seems to have, thankfully, adopted a 'if it ain't broke don't fix it' philosophy and has left Drucker's system in place.

    I also get Traditional Home, which is in fact often anything but. It's definitely changed over the years and now I really don't see much difference in its layouts and any other shelter mag.

    Ann

  • 15 years ago

    I also miss House and Garden, it delivered, month after month.

    I pick up AD depending on a quick flip through it, if I love 2 things, I buy it.
    The last issue I bought had Ralph Lauren on the cover; the Madison avenue store is a thing of beauty, I went for a stroll through in october. I forgot I was in a store actually.

  • 15 years ago

    I love House Beautiful too! Also get Traditional Home. Nice publication, but I agree, not always so traditional really! I too, had the Amazon AD subscription for a very reduced rate (actually mine was offered to me for free when I bought a Breville electric wok from Amazon!)

    I really miss Southern Accents, which was one of the finest home and garden magazines ever created, ime! If it was in SA, it was tasteful, impeccable, just right.

    Will be looking out for the "new" AD! Thanks for the alert, Amy.

  • 15 years ago

    rmkitchen, I saw that Commune spread, and liked their aesthetic but thought the prices on their little items were completely ...well, arrogant is a word that comes to mind. (DH also liked the look, and the idea of displaying more art leaning against the wall, although it's a way to breed more dust bunnies, for sure.)

    As long as "sourcing" doesn't end up meaning seeing "to the trade" all the time, it will be a useful addition. Thanks, Amy.

  • 15 years ago

    Anyone seen Interior Design magazine? I received an offer for $14. Wondering if I would like - Pal, chime in since I'd almost bet you've seen.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Interior Design magazine

  • 15 years ago

    I used to get it since I am semi "in the trade" -- I didn't stop for any particular reason other than I stop getting any magazine for while. I may also have been working on a project for someone at the point I didn't renew, because I tend to *stop* looking at design magazines for ideas when I actually doing a design for somebody--I need to work with what the client wants and I want it to come out of my own head, not what I am seeing at the moment, but a summary of what I have been seeing.

    Its a good magazine, its trade oriented with articles about revenues and business trends, and features a lot of contract design or commercial spaces and some residential design. It tends to be ahead of the curve on some trends because contract projects always hit these first, and some projects will be Very trendy, some not at all you may see something that could have been done ten years ago or today--lots of designers have a signature and aren't fad oriented. Most issues are not thematic like many of the mags, so you may be seeing a real mixed bag of stuff. Not an eye candy magazine with pages of staged photos, really.

  • 15 years ago

    Sounds like one I would like. Thanks.

  • 15 years ago

    allison, I've been getting Interiors for a few years, it's very "luxe" and I love it.
    I love contemporary art and it usually has some of that.
    You can browse whole issues online, page per page. It was originally called
    Shelter then changed to Interiors.
    I save all of them.

  • 15 years ago

    I'd rather hold it in my hands. lol At $14, I'll give it a whirl. I used to buy World of Interiors, but it gets to be a PITA getting to B&N to buy when it first comes out, or they run out.

    Thanks!

  • 15 years ago

    That's why I subscribed, I always had to track it down at a few places; they only had a few issues at a time.

  • 15 years ago

    Allison: "I miss Southern Accents, Home and Garden.... probably a few more but I can't see through my Southern Accent tears."
    Stinky-Gardner: "I really miss Southern Accents, which was one of the finest home and garden magazines ever created, ime! If it was in SA, it was tasteful, impeccable, just right.
    Me: YES!!!!!!!!(and the covers? sigh!)

  • 15 years ago

    I still look through my old issues.

  • 15 years ago

    Years, well, OK, decades, ago I subscribed to AD and Home magazine, AD for unattainable inspiration, Home for a more down to Earth perspective, I found the "traditional" home mags hopelessly boring and granny like. Home, of course, went the way of all flesh, but I was a subscriber to the end. AD lost my interest when it started all that star worship stuff, I really don't care about the homes of famous people.

    Fast forward a few years, H&G and HB were my house porn of choice, then H&G folded (I am a total Dominique Browning fan gurl, I liked the mag, but I really miss her monthly columns), and now I am left with HB and New England Home (which has gone downhill since it was sold). So, I, too, will pick up the new and improved AD to give it a test drive. Thanks for the tip, amysrq.

    sandyponder

  • 15 years ago

    Sandy, I enjoyed Dominique Browning's opening essays, too. (Her books were sadly disappointing...I think she was only good for a page at a time.)

    But, I was crazy about Mayer Rus, both editorially and in his end page columns The Testy Tastemaker. I think I will go spend some time with my old issues of H&G this week, if I have time.

  • PRO
    15 years ago

    I forgot about the Testy Tastemaker! His columns were a riot!

  • 15 years ago

    I miss Cottage Living. They showed some real houses, not mansions. I liked how it was sometimes "Cottage" style and sometimes working with a cottage size. I have owned 2 normal sized houses, but I loved seeing how they made great use of space and I always drooled over the decor.
    After this reno, I hope to tackle small projects as they come and not do any large overhauls. I find this forum as good a place as any to get ideas ;)

  • 15 years ago

    Leahcate and Allison, I still look at (& treasure) my old issues too!

    There's a magazine swap shelf at my local library and I regularly drop off magazines there. Once in a while I see something I want to bring home, like the day when there were 3 (count'em 3!) issues of Southern Accents, tossed on the shelf, discarded and abandoned with so many issues of Ladies Home Journal. Imagine! They're in my stash now! Felt like I'd struck gold!

  • 15 years ago

    i worked as an art director for seventeen years hopping from book to another so i've seen them all and worked on most. AD was never of interest; not because of the design but because every issue i picked up had stories on the most expensive and overdone castles one could only imagine in a nightmare. i remember sylvestor stallone's "home" -and many others, dripping with gold leaf and other treatments created solely to display ones wealth. i never saw real life spaces, where people lived. to me, AD was a bomb from the first issue i ever held. i have no interest in it as a redesign or anything else.

  • 15 years ago

    I've just spent the last two hours reading the March 2011 AD. LOVE IT! The homes/apartments are all interesting and different. Eclectic, modern rustic, bohemian, Southern and luxurious. My least favorite was the cover story - a Michael S Smith NYC apartment.

  • 15 years ago

    That's good to hear, Allison. I have it sitting here still in the plastic. Guess I ought to make some time today to look at it...

  • 15 years ago

    I'm not sure how I could have forgotten about The Testy Tastemaker, to me, he and DB bookended the mag to perfection; one at the beginning, one at the end, and you could always count on both to entertain, amuse and provide food for thought.

    Thanks for the tip on DB's books, amysrq, we're going on vacation and I was toying with getting one, will have to do more than a casual riff thru at the bookstore. I have the attention span of an ADD afflicted gnat, and I don't read a lot of books, I just can't sit still. On a plane, I have no choice, so I have to find a book that will keep me occupado for a few hours. But, at the very least I'll be able to pick up the new issue of AD at the airport and have something to keep the fidgeting at bay.

    sandyponder