Software
Houzz Logo Print
suseyb

Firing the Cabinet Maker

15 years ago

We are doing a complete remodel due to our house flooding in September. The only thing left, other than odds and ends, is the kitchen. I hired the cabinet maker in October. I paid for the bathroom cabinets in November and received them about 6 weeks later. They were stained, but stained poorly, and I was dumb and paid the stainer anyway. I'll have to have someone come in and fix it.

I told the cabinet maker 2 weeks ago that he needed to let me know what is going on so that i don't think the worst of him. A week later, he brought me my pantry door. As soon as it was installed, I texted him. Then, I called. And called. Nothing. This is a pattern. If he doesn't want to deal with me, he just ignores my calls. I gave him a down payment on the cabinets in December. He said they would be installed on January 15. It's past a month later. I'm trying to be flexible, but I think I'm going over the top with this one. Although, tbh, he is having a rough time personally.

However...I have 6 kids. We are living in a house with no kitchen and using a stove/oven in a camper, crockpots, and the microwave to cook. I have a sink set up by my plumber so that I can wash dishes.

The cabinet maker won't even return my calls so that I can fire him!

So what questions should I ask of the new cabinet makers who come to give me estimates? Our funds are low since the current cabinet maker was giving us a good price. Heck, I would have given him more money if he would have just done what he said he would do!

My stove and dishwasher are just waiting to be installed. My tile guys are ready to do the backsplash when I am ready. My granite guy is waiting...as is the plumber.

We've certainly learned our lesson on this one, though we had no experience remodeling and have had to learn on the job. I've learned a ton about contractors and time frames, but gosh, this just seems excessive. My sister comes to take her camper back up north mid March, and then we'll be really in a bind when it comes to our ability to cook. I can cook most anything in a crockpot, though it's taken some time to adjust.

Should I just hire a new cabinet maker and keep trying to contact the current cabinet maker so that I can tell him he's done? I would really like our $ back, but I don't think that will happen. Nothing like kicking people when they are already down. We lost almost everything in the flood and have had to repurchase.

Susie

Comments (6)

  • 15 years ago

    I'm so sorry this is happening. I know EXACTLY how you feel (my GC and cabinet maker have dragged a three-month job into the 11th month and despite now being subject to late fees, still aren't regularly showing up..they've racked up $1100 in late fees already)

    Having just gone through something very similar, this is what I'd suggest.

    If you can't get hold of the cabinet maker via phone or email, send him a registered letter. If you are unhappy with timeliness and quality, you probably should just fire him. But you could tell him that if he doesn't respond to you by X day, then you will consider him having effectively abandoned the job and legally responsible for returning your money.

    He may do nothing and hope you do nothing to get your money back. Or he may call you, plead sickness or something else and say he wants to continue the job. Tell him that you won't consider it, if he won't commit in writing to a finish date...WITH A PENALTY you will withhold from final payment if he doesn't meet it. Then confirm your conversation with him in writing. If he agrees to a penalty and to finish the job (and you are willing to let him), get him to sign a document spelling out exactly what must be done and by when.

    If you end up going with another independent cabinetmaker, I would do a credit check on him (in addition to all the normal, references, samples, etc). My own job has been so badly held up partly because of incompetence on the part of the GC, but to a large extent because it turns out that both he and the associated cabinetmaker are broke. So they are working hand to mouth...whatever money they get, they use to buy materials...if it's leftover after paying their rent, mortgage, utility bills, etc. As a result, I am now fronting the money for the final materials and having them sent directly to my house. I am, of course, deducting the costs from my final payment...and thank god, he is still owed enough money to make him want to someday finish.

    Good luck

  • 15 years ago

    I cannot imagine having a 3 month job last into the 11th month. You have more patience than I!

    My husband is ready to fire the cabinet maker and move on. I've been dragging my feet cause I just want to believe in the goodness of people, ya know? And even yesterday, I felt like it was a good idea to wait him out, let him know that *some* people don't bail when the going gets tough.

    But in the middle of the night, I just get worried and think that I'll never have a kitchen again and I'll never get to use the beautiful appliances I have just waiting. And I'm really tired of doing dishes in the sink all day long...the wining of a privileged stay at home mom..

    I'm pretty sure that the money I gave for materials is long gone and never to be seen. I don't know what I can hold over his head to have him finish the job. I worry about the quality of the finished job. The more I look at what has already been done, the less I am happy with it.

    Registered letter is a good idea. He will probably answer the phone when my plumber calls him. They were friends before this and he was referred by the plumber. I do so love my plumber; I'm sad that this kitchen cabinet mess has become so, well, messy. My biggest nightmare is having new cabinets ordered and he walks in with the ones I contracted with him to make. He has talked about other people not paying him for work done. If it takes this long to do the work, no wonder.

  • 15 years ago

    Do you have a written contract? If so, does it say anything about the January 15th installation date? How much deposit do you stand to lose?

    If you do decide to hire another cabinet maker, you should let the first cabinet maker know so that he doesn't show up one day with your order. You can fire him in the certified or registered letter. Ask the post office for return receipt requested, so you have proof that you mailed it and keep copies of everything. Tell him he has breached your contract by not providing the cabinets as promised and you assume he has abandoned your job since you cannot contact him. Be very clear that it is because of his actions that you are hiring another cabinet maker. In the letter, tell him that you expect that your deposit will be refunded (less a reasonable amount for the pantry door and anything else he has already delivered to you).

    If he does not return your deposit, you can contact the Better Business Bureau or take him to small claims court to try to get your money back. You do not need to hire an attorney to go through small claims court and in the same claim, you can sue him for any costs and fees to file the claim. Also, many BBB agencies have different dispute resolution options, such as arbitration or mediation (less intimidating than court may be). By any chance, did you put the deposit on a credit card? If so, you may be able to dispute the charge with your credit card company because you paid for cabinets that you didn't receive. If this is an option for you, I would do it right away because many credit card companies have a time limit for disputing a charge. Hope this helps!

  • 15 years ago

    UCK! So Sorry for your utter pain! And yes, he's out of money.
    You Certainly can get your custom cabinetry from a retail Kitchen Design and Cabinet Shop in your area... Factory custom cabinets are made to order. You can draw a picture of a piece, and they will make it for you ... It is true custom. You know you will only get the best quality in materials and finish, without the worry that the manufacturer is on their last leg.
    Companies such as Omega Cabinetry are Fabulous, and reasonable - with a great finish. Their high mid-line Dynasty cabinet might as well be custom, and at a fraction of the cost of custom. Finish is always great. Delivery is very predictable at 4 weeks for the Dynasty and 8 for the full custom Omega branch ... They have all the bells and whistles. If you want it now... Wellborn a strong semi custom, will get you a new kitchen in 3 weeks ... If you don't require a full custom application.
    Small custom shops are all struggeling right now. Our economy has really hit them hard, and they are all hand to mouth. We've noticed the custom shops on the verge of going under are selling jobs so low, that they are barely making a profit... A tell tail sign of desperation. You must turn a profit to stay in business - can't give away the shop. Always keep that in mind when you are tempted to go with the lowest bidder.
    You have some great suggestions on firing this fellow and getting your money back from previous posts. Hopefully you have enough $$ to get started with somone else. Good Luck! You need to tell us how it turned out, and the path you took!

    Here is a link that might be useful: ACW Kitchen & Bath

  • 15 years ago

    I know it's silly, but I keep hoping that my cabinet maker will show up with our cabinets...

    We did not have a contract. He does not do them routinely, as he does most of his work through word of mouth. I did not take the time to find a contract to have him sign. So, I'm out $. :( It makes my budget for the new cabinets extremely tight.

    We chose him, not only because he was the lowest bidder, but because he knew our plumber. I should have queried more. OTOH, I had just lost my house to a flood, was very pregnant, and taking care of 5 young children. It's not an excuse, just one of the myriad of reasons I didn't do my homework like I normally do.

    We'll have to get a registered letter sent. I'm just sad it had to come to this.

    Susie

  • 15 years ago

    You may not be out the money even though you don't have a written contract. Depending on your location, a verbal contract may be valid. Do you have proof of payment in the form of a cancelled check? If you paid cash, did he give you a receipt? Do you have any e-mails or phone messages from him? These can all be used as evidence in court or through the BBB. In any event, even if you decide not to pursue the return of your money, you may still want to file a complaint with the BBB, just for the benefit of other consumers. Hope it works out!