Software
Houzz Logo Print
stw954

Aura not as self-leveling as anticipated

18 years ago

Up until recently, I've only used a brush on paint boards to test colors. So the paint dries horizontally...resulting in unusually fantastic self-leveling? Maybe my expectations were unreasonable to begin with, because the test boards are wonderful.

We used a $1.50 cheapo brush from HD for the test boards. I thought that certainly speaks to Aura superior leveling ability because brushmarks are non-existant.

(My husband has often said that we should just buy 300 C2 swatches and glue them to the wall. Not, but gives you an idea of what he is looking for in finish.)

Now, I'm finally rolling some paint on the wall to see a bigger picture. Gah. Roller stipple.

I used 3/8" roller cover and loaded the roller medium to medium heavy. After we saw that the stipple didn't magically go away like the test-board brush marks, we experimented with several sample areas of loading the roller light, medium, heavy, backrolling, no backrolling, and then finally, almost all of that again with a 1/4" cover.

What are we doing wrong? I've heard that Aura makes a special roller cover, I've heard we should try microfiber, I've heard that stipple is absolutely inevitable - and desirable (?), I've heard we should spray, I've heard that spraying is always backrolled anyway, I've heard that good sprayers never backroll...

Is there always some stipple? Do I have unrealistic expectations?

How do we apply this paint so it ACTUALLY comes out smooth?!?

(Does it only level if it dries horizontally...so my walls are just going to have stipple?)

P.S. I've painted before - a lot - BUT I've never painted non-sanded walls before. (Originally from the midwest, where I think sand is pretty common.) I've literally never seen smooth walls - either because of the sand thing back home, or multiple coats of cheap paint poorly applied in rentals where stipple is massive and built up.

Comments (7)

  • 18 years ago

    Yes, there is always stipple. The reason it dries down better horizontally is because you can really lay it on thick and the paint will dry down into itself and sometimes you can get it to come out looking like a sprayed finish. I have used the special Aura roller covers and they don't seem all that special to me. They perform just like the Wooster pro-dooz that I usually use.

    Don't you have stipple on the walls already from the previous paintjobs? You probably can spray and not backroll it but it's hard to lay it on evenly so that it dries down evenly if you are a not a really seasoned sprayer. Plus, the sprayed finish is very difficult to touch up. The ideal texture to me for smooth walls is a very slight stipple. You accomplish this by using a high quality self levelling paint that is rolled very evenly. I prefer a 1/2" nap.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks, paintguy, for that reality.

    It is new drywall. That is why there is no current roller stipple. And I almost killed myself to get a REALLY smooth, flat finish on those walls...all to inevitably have stipple. Who knew?

    I actually do have the opportunity for getting the place sprayed. I hadn't thought about the touch-up aspect, though.

    Then why do people rave about Aura's self-leveling? Am I not understanding that word?

    And how does 1/2" give "slight" stipple? I though the shorter the nap, the smoother the walls? Or does the nap length not really affect the paint's finished surface so much as the roller cover's ability to effectively apply paint to the roughness of the surface being painted?

  • 18 years ago

    Yes some stipple is inevitable but you are guaranteed to get more with longer nap. I've used the 3/16" microfiber, the 3/8" Aura and 1/2" Wooster prodoo z- all things being equal, the amount of stipple increases with nap depth. The MF roller will produce an almost sprayed finish -the trade off is that with so little nap, you need to reload the roller often but if a smooth finish is what you are after, it's worth the effort. You also need to remember that with Aura, you put it on and keep moving - overworking it is sure to generate texture regardless of the nap used.

  • 18 years ago

    "...overworking it is sure to generate texture..."

    Does that mean I shouldn't backroll the column when I finish one? Should I not worry about the "wet edge" thing, because I did notice that the top of the previous column was already drying (though not dry) by the time I did the big up-and-down part and then started the next column. And that first column was definitely even farther along by the time I'm rolling over the entire second column. This matters to your sentence because the roller overlaps that first column by a bit. And I knew I wasn't helping things in those two inches of overlap in the older piece.

    I know Aura dries wicked fast. Didn't they come out with an extender? Or is that only for exterior? Would that concept help or hurt me?

  • 18 years ago

    as already mentioned a slight very slight roller stipple is going to be there, also as mentioned the thicker the nap the more apped one will receive a heavier stipple especially with ones application techniques. overworking will also increase stipple because you are rolling, rolling and rerolling, releasing possible more paint (heavier film in areas just received paint and also at the same time releasing paint to the point of rolling where the nap of the roller just stands up and creates a natural stipple on its own because of the lack of paint on the surface of the sleeve).

    As an example on your next practice board-take a roller sleeve and roll and roll and just look at the nap before you started and after the paint has been distributed to the point of needing to be reloaded and then look at the surface of nap of the roller; the fibers will be separated into little indivudual pieces. this will create stipple.

    if you need to , use an extender for the paint. use either the BM-extender or use XIM's.

    yes, you should roll it on and then backroll to finese and move on; don't start a new section with a loaded paint roller and roll right on top of the previous last column you just painted; you are sure to create a heavier film and also run the risk of the paint you just painted setting up, which can cause it to drag or be lifted, in addtion to more stipple. start over and roll back up to your painted section.

    Aura should lay down and be very smooth and as mentiond with only a very very slight stippled look and that stipple is ONLY when viewed right up on top of it. Really hard to notice

  • 18 years ago

    I'm hopeless also when it comes to painting with a roller and my eyes don't see the mistakes very well either. What I do is keep one of those 4 cell flashlights with a handle nearby and shine it up or along the wall so small boo boos cast big shadows and can be quickly fixed. Working in a semi dark room helps. Also useful for checking when patching and sanding walls before painting.

    When painting areas that have high traffic and oblique lighting/sunlight that will really show a poor paint job I use the roller in one direction only and put on just a thin coat of paint. It may take several thin coats over a few days to get it done. Also watch out for the roller starting to get gummy and have a fresh damp one ready to replace it when needed.

    Good luck from "the incompetent perfectionist".

  • 18 years ago

    OMG, laat2, I think you might be me.

    You should see me drywall...a gazillion micro thin coats on a seam until I finally (finally!) fill in the taper. Looks really nice when I'm done, but SO much work. And I call myself "incompetent" as well, but I'm lucky because my husband is usually on hand to point out quality-over-speed is actually a good thing. (Seriously, you do NOT want to see me do cornerbead. I'm just sad at it. But damn if it isn't all plumb, level, and square when it's up.)

    Painting is in the same boat but there is less forgiveness if you have a not-so-nice-application moment in Aura. (With drywall, you just sand you mistake...maybe a ton of work, but it is fixable fairly easily.)

    Thanks for all that information. Thanks everyone for all the hints. We're taking another whack at the ceiling this afternoon so hopefully it will come out closer to what's in my head. (That, and the painting ceilings is a good place to find your good-enough voice.)