Software
Houzz Logo Print
kbmas0n

I chickened out...&*@#$@

18 years ago

For those of you following my dining room saga, you will remember that I wanted a blue dining room. I had a vision and was excited to make it come true! I found a blue I loved and was all set to make it happen. And then I realized it completely clashed with my china, which I LOVE and isnt' going anywhere.

So, I struggled back and forth between SW Crystal Clear and SW Restrained Gold. I finally chose Crystal Clear, but still agonized over it and truly worried about it being too...aqua.

So, long story short, I bought all of the paint Friday, since the painter was coming on Monday morning. Sunday night, I panicked and changed to Restrained Gold. What I thought was more...safe. She finished the room before 11am yesterday and I ran back to take a look...and I hate it. HATE it. It is NOT me, it's not my decor, it's not going to work.

*Sigh*

So this morning I told the painter to paint it the Crystal Clear. And I figured, if I don't like that either, I can just paint it myself later.

And to top it all off...I forgot my camera at work, so I'll never be able to show anyone just how horrible it looked in my dining room!!

My camera is now in my purse and i'm going to run home on my lunch hour. I'm crossing my fingers that the dining room isn't finished yet and I can take pcitures of the diaster.

OH - and yet another blow...the original blue (SW Hinting Blue) that I decided not to use in the dining room...I used in a guest room. And it looks terrible. So much darker than anticipated, because it's in a north-facing room...and the dining room was south facing. So when I sampled the blue, it looked so nice in the bright sunlight. Why oh why didn't I sample it in the bedroom too? I could have avoided all of this!

I am holding out hope that it will look different with the white trim on. We'll see! I'll take pictures of that too!!!

On a happy note, I love my DD's room, and I LOVE the Cameo White in the rest of the house.

Comments (36)

  • 18 years ago

    Sorry you had to endure that. Painting is so stressful. Hope you are happy with the blue, which I'm sure is beautiful.

  • 18 years ago

    Don't worry.... you aren't alone. I've painted many, many rooms, and can count on one hand the ones that came out JUST like I pictured in my mind's eye. But you are very smart to repaint the room right now. I painted my dining room blue years ago. Hated it instantly. But all that work... so I left it that way for 3 to 4 years, and hated it every day. Can't wait to see the Crystal Clear! What are you going to do about the guest room? If you are going to leave it, maybe some white bedding would do the trick to lighten/brighten the room? Hang in there...
    Lynn

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for the kind words. I am excited to see what the Crystal Clear looks like when it's all finished. My hopes aren't really high, so maybe that's a good thing?

    I'm undecided about the guest room. My DH, who is out of town (of course!!) really wants to see it before we change anything else.

    I do have some lovely crisp, white bedding that would look pretty against the blue...and i could really up the lighting too.

  • 18 years ago

    I'd love to see your dishes.

  • 18 years ago

    Here's a picture of my DD taking a sip from one of my teacups :) Stinker.
    {{!gwi}}
    Photo Sharing - Video Sharing - Photo Printing - Photo Books
    {{!gwi}}

  • 18 years ago

    Oh baby, I feel your pain.

    Just keep telling yourself, it's only paint, it's only paint, it's only paint.

    Paint is cheap, paint is cheap, paint is cheap...

    Compared to a sofa or a rug, I mean.

  • 18 years ago

    Ohhhhh the saga of disappointment that so many of us here have shared, will share & will always wonder "Where did I go so wrong?!".

    Glad you are choosing to repaint now. Like Bestyears pointed out - it's a terrible thing to hate a room but put up w/ it because you are tired and/or have invested $$$ in it (which is very understandable & sometimes it's just not practical to repaint due to the latter).

    I tried RG & Blond in 2 different rms. & wanted to love it so much but just couldn't.

    I think the Crystal Clear will look wonderful w/ your china & dark furniture.

    As for the guest rm: get the trim done & accessorized (sp.?) w/ things that you have around the home 1st & then see what you think.

  • 18 years ago

    I am glad I am not the only one. The same thing happened with my master bath. The paint did not come out looking like the chip. It clashes with the tile. But DH did the work and he refuses to do it again. So am going to live with it for years. Every time I go in there I hate it more and more! Hope you love the next color. Painting can be so stressful.
    Clare

  • 18 years ago

    Did you paint a sample board first? I find picking paint colors very difficult that I now make DH buy a large sheet of drywall, plywood, or grab a scrap out of the garage so I can paint it. Before any paint goes on the wall I already know how it's going to look in the room. I hold up the board against every wall and piece of furniture to see how the light and colors play off each other. Since the china is important to you I would paint a sheet of lumber or even poster board and then set a plate on the board to see how the colors work with each other (after the paint has dried of course, lol)

  • 18 years ago

    Just keep telling yourself, it's only paint, it's only paint, it's only paint.

    Paint is cheap, paint is cheap, paint is cheap...

    I need that in writing! Lol, we only went through 3 colors for the master bath. But now we have the rest of the house. Dh doesn't have the angst I do about color and mood so he just has to grin and bare it.
    Susan

  • 18 years ago

    I guess it is good that people like different colors. I love
    the SW Restrained Gold.

  • 18 years ago

    I can share in this agony.

    I bought two gallons Martha Stewart's "Butternut" paint for our bedroom. Even before opening the cans I decided I could not stand that color in the bedroom. I gave both cans away on Freecycle so I wouldln't have to look at them. I chose a lovely sage green to use instead.

    Then I had the Benjamin Moore "Lemon Freeze" fiasco. It's not a bad color; it's just not yellow. I tried adding a quart of "Spiced Butternut," (yellow-orange) that I had on hand to brighten it a bit. This turned the BM paint a nice, soft yellow, but still not what I wanted on that ceiling. Now I have another can of paint for Freecycle.

    But wait! There's more! By now I'm scared to use the "Lavender Ice" BM paint I purchased to go with the Lemon Freeze. It's similar, but a shade darker, to a Dutch Boy color I've used and love called "Lilac Vapor. I went back to town, bought two gallons of the Lilac Vapor and they're already on the walls.

    Now I have another gallon of "mistake" paint. I'm also adding a gallon of ceiling paint that turns blue. The first gallon was awful; I didn't care for it at all. Now I'm using regular paints, eggshell finish, for my ceilings. They look great.

    Someone is going to make out on Freecycle this weekend. I know I have a three or four unopened quarts to get rid of too.

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with flyingflower. I always paint on a scrap of drywall and move it about the room. In fact Lowes sells a smaller square of drywall that you can use for patching. I would buy 2. I use both sides and you can reuse them unlike poster board.

  • 18 years ago

    oh, my Caroline. You understand my agony...and then some!

    And cpccarolyn - I really do love, and can appreciate, the color of RG, but truly, it didn't fit our personality. We needed something casual and light.

    And thank you to everyone for commiserating with me! I needed that.

    So....I went home at lunch...and my painter came out to meet me with a big smile on her face. She said, "you're going to love it." and I LOVE LOVE LOVE it. It's gorgeous...soothing...airy...fresh...perfect.

    I did take pictures, but I can't download them for some reason! Anyone skilled in the workings of a canon???

  • 18 years ago

    I went through lots and lots and lots of samples of blues...my dining room looked like a quilt when I was finished searching for the right blue.

    But I stupidly panicked and chose the RG without sampling it. Why, oh why didn't I just go with my gut???

  • 18 years ago

    Would another "I feel your pain" help make you feel any better? I can honestly say "I HATE PAINT!" :o And I really don't think you can ever know exactly what it's going to look like until all the walls are covered :( I had a vision of a blue bedroom with a chocolate accent wall. SEVEN sample quarts later, I chose my blue to go on the master bedroom walls and the master bath ceiling. Horrendous on the walls, beautiful on the bathroom ceiling (sigh). After months of begging, DH finally let me change the blue but not to another shade of blue. HE chose a brown shade. Looked great with the carpet TILL we but it on the walls :( It's got a pink undertone (sigh again). I've given up. I think that Chrystal Clear color is to die for and probably what I should have gone with in my bedroom. Can't wait to see it in your dining room walls!
    Monica

  • 18 years ago

    Oh I'm SO happy for you!!!!!! Can't WAIT to see the pictures.
    Lynn

  • 18 years ago

    The road to good decor is never straight -- is it? I painted my bedroom five different times in two years and I'm still not happy with it yet. Why should *you* get off easier than the rest of us? hehehehehe

    Seriously, keep on truckin' till you get what you want, and it would be good to learn to do your own painting, since like a lot of us you're very particular about what you want. Good luck with it and we really do want pictures!

    Here is a link that might be useful: It could be worse - this could be you

  • 18 years ago

    Ahh blue rooms! I got lots of panic attacks because I wanted to paint my LR light blue but it was not the safe choice. After lots and lots of sleepless nights and after finding this forum, I finally painted all the walls, LR and DR light blue. It's great! Light, fresh, airy.

    Due to health reasons I stopped with looking for accessories and finishing off the rooms. As soon as I'm better, it's going to look as I imagined it.

  • 18 years ago

    Ohhhhh...I posted about my blue problem in my bathroom. I still have not decided either. Although my living room, dining and kitchen is restrained gold. i love it. It takes awhile to get used to but does so well with reds. I would of picked blonde or ivoire at 150% also

    Ali

  • 18 years ago

    The ONE time I ever let a wall be painted without sampling first, was in my eensy weensie master bath, two years ago when we hired real painters (HAH!!) to re-texture the wall while we were away for the weekend. The painter had some light taupe paint on hand and told me that he wouldn't even charge if we wanted that used. So, I went with it.
    Oh My Yuck. Awful. Then, I compounded my mistake by bringing home 67 chips and finally settling on a caramel color. DH said, "Just go buy a gallon and get this done." So, I did. Again. Yuck. Poo in the bathroom.

    I've bought sample quarts for years, painted whole stretches of wall first before buying real paint. Sometimes I've painted an area 7' tall by 6 or 7 feet wide, even hung a picture back on a nail, pushed a chair and table back into place....practiced walking in to the room and being surprised by the color. I've left a room in that state of 'undone' for as long as a week before finally buying paint. So I can really feel your pain. If you only care about 'new' you can buy what you think you will like and get it done, but if you care about a room looking and feeling awesome when you walk in, you need to try it out.

    I hope your soft blue will be great. The rest of you, go get the right color and repaint. Even good quality paint usually doesn't cost more than about $50 to paint an average room. It's so worth it.

    Monicakm..........You are the poster girl for great DIY projects. Repaint that bedroom. Your DH is so handy. He needs a new job to do.

    Aptosca.............don't live with clashing paint. Find a tile piece leftover from your job and get it somewhere where they can help you choose a color--a real paint store.

    Red

  • 18 years ago

    Red, that's exact;y what I do w/ paint - hence all of my test qts. piled up in the basement! Too funny.

    Oceanna, I am sooooooo glad that there is somebody who paints more than I do! There should be a paint support group.

  • 18 years ago

    LOL Oceanna!

    I just drove by a house a couple days ago and thought they absolutely must have had the paint store color match Pepto Bismal. It had to be the exact color.

    A bit more jarring of a color IRL than in pictures, yeesh.

    kbmas0n - looking forward to pics, and yay for a happy ending.

    I completely felt your pain when I first read this post. I'm in the throws of paint color issues right now, with of all things a nice neutral tan. We went with BM's Shaker Beige in one of our rentals and love it everywhere except the guest bath - which has yellow tile - it looks terrible in there :-(. Have to sort that out today as the tenant is coming through tonight to take a peek. Ack, I was on here avoiding dealing with it, lol!

  • 18 years ago

    Ttodd -- I thought everybody did? Seems natural to me to paint a room ten times to get it right once. hehe

    Acoreana -- oh yes I've seen that Pepto color on houses. Eeeooowww!

    Okay y'all, go write on the blackboard 100 times:

    I love to paint.
    I love to paint.
    I love to paint.
    I love to paint.
    I love to paint.
    I love to paint.
    I love to paint...

    C'mon, keep writing!

    {{!gwi}}

  • 18 years ago

    I keep logging on in hopes of seeing that "Crystal Clear" painted dining room! kbmas0n, helllloooo?

  • 18 years ago

    Rebazel - your quote " I've left a room in that state of 'undone' for as long as a week before finally buying paint." just cracks me up! As long as a week! There are paint splotches in my upstairs hallway that have been there for over a year! I only just finally decided on the color (for sure, really, honestly, truly, this time) this week. Now I have to decide which paint, Graham or Duron. I've got some rooms that are already painted in each paint brand and I have been smearing up the walls on purpose trying to see which is easier to clean. My dh thinks I've finally gone off the deep end. Maybe he's right.

  • 18 years ago

    I'm so glad you're happy with SW Crystal Clear. We just did our bathroom in it this winter and love it every day! It is soft and soothing and lovely. Here it is before we put in our granite countertop. It should be a perfect background for your lovely china.

  • 18 years ago

    So Crystal Clear is a very soft blue? That might work for our LR...it faces east and gets a VERY strong light in it and that might help cool it down. Dark blue leather sofa...I want a sort of beachy theme in there w/o being a theme as such....we'll be moving in about a year and that is the exact color that I want in the 1/2 bath off the laundry room...it serves for the house and shop space. The guys are superb at keeping it clean. The walls/trim are the same blue with original brown cabinets in there...trim painted white and softer blue...and I THINK I can talk hubby into tearing out the cabinet and replacing it with a pedestal sink OR building a new cabinet for there...I'd rather have the pedestal sink with two tall narrow cabinets on either side for hand towels, soap, tissue and TP.

  • 18 years ago

    I love the SW Crystal Clear on the walls so much! Thanks Karenforrosess for sharing. I think the poster is going to love the color.

  • 18 years ago

    I'm trying, TRYING to get pictures downloaded! I spent 40 minutes on the phone with the Canon support people and even THEY couldn't figure out what the problem was with my camera. They finally decided it was my computer's problem, not the camera, so now our "help" desk is "helping" me fix my computer.

    Stay tuned!!

    And regarding the SW Crystal CLear, I STILL love it, and my DH came home from traveling and loved it too!!! *happy dance*

  • 18 years ago

    Add my name to the list of those waiting to see the pix.
    I love it in the bathroom with the white beadboard, but I would love to see it in another context. I do have it on the sample strip from SW, but as we all know painfully well (all toooooo painfully so) those little strips are not always so easy to judge by.
    Glad you love it though!!
    Anxiously awaiting...sheila

  • 18 years ago

    Bump....you still playing with that camera? *tap*tap*tap* waiting to see the Crystal Clear dining room :-) If you can't get those pics off the camera you could just have us all for dinner!

  • 18 years ago

    Hi mimi!!

    See my other post "You want Pics, Here you go!" I have posted them all there!!!!!!

  • 18 years ago

    oooops never mind me I see the other thread now, going to go look!

  • 18 years ago

    A few suggestions for your unused paint:

    you can post it on craigs list, there are thousands of people selling used paint on there and it wont go to waste. You can also go to reusepaint.com and donate it or sell it.

    As far as a way to avoid this problem in the future always buy a samll test can of the paint first. you can either go the store that sells your paint and get a tester if they have it. I like to go to Myperfectcolor.com to buy a pint. They have every color matched from every brand and they use Benjamin Moore. The pint is great becasue there is less waste and they are cheap.

    Here is a link that might be useful: sample cans

  • 18 years ago

    I forgot to post a link to the brands they have color matched

    Ralph lauren
    Sherwin Williams
    Martha Stewart
    Benjamin Moore
    Pottery Barn

    This is much easier then wasting gas and time running from store to store to test colors in qaurt sizes.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Popular brands