Software
Houzz Logo Print
flchad

salt cell replacement frequency

18 years ago

I am getting an intellichlor and was just reading thru the datasheet/owners manual and stumbled across something. the datasheet says "...rated for more than 10,000 hours of operation  five years of reliable chlorine output under normal operating conditions."

So, the real number is 10k hours - 5 years is only at 5 hours a day run time.

My question(s) for those of you with salt generators:

does the salt generator run the enture time the pump is on?

How often have you had to replace the cell?

What is the cost of a new cell?

The whole idea of running the new variable pumps for longer (I am getting a VF 3050) seems counter productive to making the salt cell last. At 15 hours a day run time on the VF, that would eat up your 10k hours in about 2 years.

Comments (10)

  • 18 years ago

    Most salt chlorinators including IntelliChlor have % output settings. For example, on my 20,000 gallon pool, I had it set at 55% during the summer months to maintain about a 2ppm chlorine level. Just today, I dialed my IC40 unit back from 20% to 15% output because the chlorine level was 3.8ppm. The % output is the percentage of the time the pump is running that the chlorinator is making chlorine. So at 15% the chlorinator is only making chlorine 15% of the time that the pump is running.

  • 18 years ago

    I believe they are typically connected on the same timer as the pumps...but they don't have to be. You can always put them on a separate timer if you wanted to. You would have to make sure the SWCG is timed to be on while the pumps are on but that would just be like having to set a pressure cleaner.

  • 18 years ago

    It's always a good idea to connect salt chlorinators to the filter pump relay. I believe most manufacturers dictate this in their user manuals. This ensures that the chlorinator is only working when there is water flow. One of the byproducts of salt chlorinators is hydrogen after all. Not a good idea for that to be accumulating in PVC pipes with no water flow!

  • 18 years ago

    All the SWCG's have flow switchs for that task. If there is no flow, they won't turn on.

  • 18 years ago

    Barco, never rely on the flow switch. I have seen everything from rocks to socks stuck on the flow switch causing it to always be on. The only safe way to wire a SCG is to the filter pump relay so that it only comes on while the pump is running. Any other setup is asking for trouble.

  • 18 years ago

    Replaced at just under three years. The housing split. $400 to replace :(

  • 18 years ago

    So using salt, is it cheaper than using chlorine or is it just the convenience? I'm still trying to figure out which route to take, i've had chlorine pools my whole childhood, which I had to take care of and it was pretty simple, just trying to figure out if it's worth the money to go "salt".

  • 18 years ago

    cbrown22 - had I not spent time in a salt pool, I doubt I would spring for the extra ~ $1,000 it costs. However, I grew up in chlorine pools too. I visited my cousin and had no idea he had a salt pool (or that there was such a thing at that time) and I immediatley noticed the water wasnt as harsh feeling. After about an hour, I asked him what was different about his pool water and he told me about the salt thing. I said at that time, if I ever get a pool, I would get one.

    Landa mac - thanks for that info. It sounds like the 10k life doesnt get used just because the pump is on.

  • 18 years ago

    cbrown22 - I have a salt pool and love it, but I've always recommended people not choose a salt pool because it is cheaper, because it is not, in the long run. It is all about convenience and the feel of the water with a salt pool.

    However, as far as convenience is concerned, keep in mind that you will have to regularly dump muriatic acid into your pool to keep your pH levels down. The SWG's operation will cause the pH of your water to rise naturally, and at least for me, in the summer when my SWG's output setting is highest (65%) I have to dump 32oz of acid into the pool every week. It's not terribly difficult, but it's still something you have to do on a regular basis.

    I have never owned a chlorine pool, so I don't know how different this is from walking around with buckets of chlorine tabs and refilling the dispenser on a regular basis.

  • 18 years ago

    "So, the real number is 10k hours - 5 years is only at 5 hours a day run time. "

    This was kind of answered by others above, but not specifically, so let me clarify. You will rarely (if ever) run your SWG at 100%. The actual run time is not "pump on" time, it is when the SWG itself is on. So for example, if it's set to 50% and you run your pump for 10 hours a day, then that would be 5 hours of SWG run time. Ours was running at 45% for 10 hours a day in the summer but now that fall is here we're having to cut back on the percentage because it's making too much chlorine. So year-round average run time is going to end up being far less than 5 hours/ day for us.