Software
Houzz Logo Print
meowracer

Can pool builder file lien on your house?

18 years ago

Can a pool builder file a lien on your home? The pool is completed and has been paid for. However, a certified letter came and states the intent to file a lien on the home. Can a PB do that even though work is not finished? Once work is finished, the balance will be happily paid in full. It doesn't make sense to completely pay for work that is not completed, and has been hanging in the balance, unfinished, for months. I appreciate any legal input and/or experience with this sort of thing. Thanks.

Comments (15)

  • 18 years ago

    I need to add - the intent to file stated that the lien would be for work completed months ago, and that payment for that work was over 120 day past due. That work has been paid in full, and then some. It is very confusing and frustrating.

  • 18 years ago

    Very strange indeed. I can understand if a sub did not get paid, but the PB is the guy that received your check!!

    I am not a lawyer, but you may need one. But first, get your cancelled checks and photo copy them. Then send them to the PB with a letter stating you've paid what was owed.

    As an aside, it is easy in most states to file a lien... almost anyone can do it.

    -Gorilla

  • 18 years ago

    Meowracer
    Each state is different in the treatment of these liens, which commonly are referred to as mechanics liens. You can go to wikipedia for a description of what they are and how they work, but you'll have to go to your state's statutes to see the specific rules governing you. The big problem with a lien is that it will affect your ability to get further financing for your house and it certainly will affect your ability to sell the house until the lien is removed. I'm no PB, but generally contractors dont file liens unless they feel there has been a breach of contract---in other words, he thinks you owe him for work he has done. You think otherwise. At the risk of being overly simplistic, have you contacted your PB and talked to him? Sometimes a polite conversation (no matter how much it kills you!) goes a lot further than a sternly worded letter. Just my two cents.

  • 18 years ago

    Makes no sense. Liens are filed when a contractor didn't get paid for work on your house by someone that you hired to pay him. You paid your PB directly, and you have proof of that. Unless he has proof that you owe him money, the lien is not justified.

    I'd call the pool builder and just ask him.

  • 18 years ago

    meowracer,
    What you have received is most likely a Preliminary Lien notice. These are generally sent out within a certain number of days after work is completed and money is owed. This pre-lien preserves the contractors right to Lien your property in the future. If their is a contractors board in your state, go to the website for info. It's a division of consumer affairs in some states. Good luck.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for all of the feedback. I am not having the problem - I am posting for a friend, but tried to write it as generically as possible to avoid any issues down the road should the PB read this. The remaining outstanding payment is for work that has not been completed. All pool, decking, equipment, etc has been completed and paid for. The kitchen is what remains to be finished and therefore paid for. Some of it has been paid but it seems foolish to pay for all of it, especially when the builder seems to have problems finishing projects.

  • 18 years ago

    What the ????. Why would a pool builder file a lein on unfinished kitchen work?

  • 18 years ago

    Go back and look at the contract. PB's have a habit of getting paid in Houston before doing the work. If the contract states the payment required clearly before or after a said point of contruction your "freind' owes.

  • 18 years ago

    If they truly do not have lien rights your friend can sue them for slander of title.

  • 18 years ago

    Repair guy - I have to assume it is an outdoor kitchen, and part of the pool contract.

  • 18 years ago

    I read a good strategy against this is if there is one PB and a bunch of subs, write the check payable to the PB AND the sub for each sub on the project so both PB and sub have to endorse and cash together and you have proof they were BOTH paid since they BOTH signed. (goes for any contractor not just PB's).

    Around NoCA one PB went bankrupt last year, took homeowners $ and ran and left unfinished. Now the subs are filing liens since they didn't get paid. A friend of a friend is going thru this and doesn't sound pretty as they have to fight to keep their home even with an unfinished pool out of foreclosure. Part of the fine print of any contract unfortunately, you sign that you are responsible to pay any subs EVEN IF THE MAIN CONTRACTOR DOESN'T PAY THEM. Then it lists said strategy above to guard against it.

    Has anyone tried this and worked/not worked? I plan some replastering when I can save the $$ sometime in 1-2 yrs and will apply this strategy.

  • 18 years ago

    He can in Texas. Plus any sub contractor he didn't pay for work at your home. Get a lawyer and sue him, and report him to the BBB. We don't need anymore pool builders like that in the industry.
    Here in Texas a telephone and a business card get you in the pool biz. You don't even have to have a General contractors lic.

  • 18 years ago

    To all - thank you so much for the information! As far as I know, the subs have been paid for what has been finished. That actually makes this even more frustrating. All along in the contract, payment was made after work was completed. Why now would the home owner be required to pay for work not completed. There isn't much work to finish up. And yes, it is an outdoor kitchen but was not part of the original contract.

  • 18 years ago

    Meowracer,

    I agree with golfgeek in terms that I believe what you have is a preliminary 20 day lein notice. Depending on what state you reside in, the laws vary. In Arizona for example, a contractor, sub contractor or material supplier cannot file a lein on an individuals property unless they first issue one of these 20 day preliminary lein notices. At the point in time you receive this notice you are required to act in one of two ways: 1. If you retain the notice without sigining and submitting you are agreeing that you are the correct party of which the work or materials are being supplied for.....or 2. sign the paperwork and submit it to the issuer stating that you are not the correct party and have been contacted in error.
    It's important to remember that a real lien against your property cannot be filed unless first this 20 day notice has been issued to the property owner.

  • 18 years ago

    I think a call to the PB who filed the lien is in order.

    I learned the hard way about liens. Hired concrete guy to do a patio. I did not know that if he did not pay the concrete truck company they could file a lien. We paid our contractor in full, he took the money and paid the concrete company. He had an account with then so they applied MY money to the contractors prior jobs that were outstanding. Contractor went awol and so we went after his bond. They did pay off the lien for us but did not pay to the over $7,000 in damages the contractor did to our property while doing the job- concrete splattered on house and yard, don't ask!

    So when we hired the PB, Premier, we got the whole lien/sub issue figured out. I even got lien releases at end of job even though they told me all was paid. I made sure I knew which jobs were sub and which were not. I literally asked the electrician if he was a Premier employee that day or a sub, then verified with PB. I did not let anyone enter property without getting all this stuff figured out.

    Unfortunatly, sometimes we have to learn the hard way. Again, sounds like a call in required here.