Software
Houzz Logo Print
christopherh_gw

What Would Your Reaction Be?

19 years ago

I have a good friend on Cape Cod that relayed this story to me last weekend.

His friend just built a $500,000 home on Cape Cod near the water. He spent almost two years building the home himself, and was obviously very proud of it.

He was in the house less than six months and there was a knock on the door. An oriental gentleman was standing there and said "I buy your house".

"It's not for sale, sorry."

Two weeks later the guy comes back, knocks on the door and says "I give you one million for house".

"I said it's not for sale!"

One week after that the guy's back and knocks on the door. "I give you two million for house."

Well, that made him stop and think. So he agreed to the sale. He moved away and came back two months later just to see the place and it was GONE! The buyer lived across the way and wanted to have a VIEW of the ocean so he bought the "obstruction" and razed it!

Yeah, he had two million, but his sweat and tears were simply destroyed for somebody's view.

What would your reaction be if you had put yourself into something only to see it taken away by somebody that simply wanted a view?

Comments (32)

  • 19 years ago

    When I decided to sell, I knew that the house would no longer be mine. The owner could do what he or she wanted to with it. He was willing to make a huge profit on the house, so although I'm sure it upset him, he sold it for 4 times what we paid; he should be happy. Now that's an investment!

  • 19 years ago

    When he sold the house, he decided that the profit was more important than his "sweat and tears".

    You ask: "What would your reaction be if you had put yourself into something only to see it taken away by somebody that simply wanted a view?"
    I don't know WHAT my reaction would be as I probably would not have sold my house in that case.... (ocean front and two years to build sounds like a forever house to me!)

  • 19 years ago

    Assuming that this is a real situation...

    I'd build another home.

    With $2M, I could find a *really* *really* nice view.

  • 19 years ago

    ^ I agree.

    No matter how small or large your house, the next owners are going to change everything you've done to it.

  • 19 years ago

    My reaction would be one of laughing all the way to the bank with the $2 million. I'm sure that all of the homes I've sold in the past have been changed and by now some of them may be razed to the ground, that's what happens when you sell a home, it no longer is yours and the new owners can do with it what they may. If your friend's friend cared about the house so much, then he wouldn't have accepted any amount of money for it. So to him money was more important than sweat and tears.

  • 19 years ago

    1st, I wonder why he didn't know the man lived across from him to begin with.

    I agree he sold out to begin with. He had a price as does the old man, it was worth 2 million to him to own that property so that he could have a view. Now, no one will build there.

    I would be a bit sick to my stomach but as others have said, when he sold the land at his "price" he should be happy he laughed all the way to the bank.

  • 19 years ago

    I have a question. Why would this buyer raze a home that's CLOSER to the water. Wouldn't the view have been better from that house?

    If this buyer moved into the view-obstructing house, he could have sold his old house an recouped some of that $2 million.

    Just wondering...

    Ellen

  • 19 years ago

    I have a question for y'all...What did it matter that the person who bought the house was an "oriental gentleman?"

    Was that supposed to make a difference to the feelings of what happened to the house?

    Just wondering.

    mary

  • 19 years ago

    I'd be doing the happy dance, what with my $1.5 mil profit and all.

  • 19 years ago

    Mary, don't look too much into the "oriental gentleman" part. There are worse things the original poster could have said.

  • 19 years ago

    Sounds like an urban legend in the making.

    The story was relayed to her by a friend, who had a friend who had this house...........

  • 19 years ago

    "oriental gentleman?" in this story implies filthy rich sheik. Regardless, this has urban legend written all over.

  • 19 years ago

    For what it's worth "oriental" tends to refer to carpets and old fairy tales, not people.
    I think the gentleman in the story was probably asian, since that is the most common North Amerian association with 'orient'.
    "filthy rich sheik" is actually more precise albeit more politely expresses as "affluent middle-eastern"

    words, words, words...

    Urban legend, probably.
    Has all the ingredients: events happen in threes (the guy came back three times), the unlikelyhood of not at least recognizing him as a neighbor (if the properties are THAT huge, I doubt that house would make much of a difference in the view), and the bit about the buyer not being (visibly, anyway) American.

    Even better if the 'oriental' actually referred to 'middle-eastern', given the current political climate. "The rich foreigner throws his money at the working-class man". Classic. If it ain't an urban legend, it ought to be. :)

    Check out Snopes.com Interesting info about how urban legends grow, and many examples of it.

  • 19 years ago

    I highly doubt the story, but I would be laughing all the way to the bank!

    I winced a little at the word oriental. However, until recently that was the polite term for an Asian person. A lot of people still use it and don't realize it is no longer PC.

  • 19 years ago

    Urban myth or not, I would be laughing my a** off, scratching my head, and at the same time saying, 'that SOB!' ;o)

    patty_cakes

  • 19 years ago

    i also find this story to be unlikley..If the purchaser wanted the view, why not, as others above said,move into the new home? If it didn't meet the needs, he could just spend some more $$$ on renovation,as it seems this gentleman has loads of $$$...

  • 19 years ago

    I've already called this out as an obvious urban legend.

    Too many things are missing, the most obvious of which is the fact that any existing homeowner with 4 million dollars to throw around would have sued to stop the construction during the permitting phase. Certainly he would have raised objections during the framing phase. (See any number of "bad neighbor" threads in the Home Disasters Forum.) Why would they wait 2 1/2 years before objecting to the obstructed view? (In the original post, the builder took 2 years to build it himself, then lived it for 6 months.)

    And if they "oriental gentleman" moved in *after* the house was built, did he buy it factoring in 4 million dollars worth of improvements so that he could have a better view?

    Fiction, fiction, fiction.

    And I was also tempted to point out that *things* such as rugs, lamps, and art from Asian countries can be referred to as "oriental", but people are referred to as "Asian".

  • 19 years ago

    What about the capital gains? After replenishing his initial investment, he would only have around $700K. It is possible that a similar property would have increased by that amount in 2.5 years (especially during the boom). I would have held out for 4M...

    BTW - its BS...

  • 19 years ago

    AH but if he takes the 1.5 million and buys property with it then he owes no taxes

  • 19 years ago

    It is BS but to answer your question

    About 10% of potential homebuyers would tear my house down. I am ok with that although no one is giving me even 1 Million for it

  • 19 years ago

    We sold a lovely house when we moved to our farm. It was so beautiful that it was the subject of painting by a well-known artist. The next owner put in inappropriate new windows and vinyl siding and generally "uglified" it.

    When we drove by and saw it, I felt sad, but I didn't have many proprietary thoughts about it. It wasn't mine and I no longer live within 500 miles of it, so I don't have to look at it regularly.

  • 19 years ago

    I would hope I would be thinking -- How else could I make $1.5 mil in 2 years!

  • 19 years ago

    saphire: "AH but if he takes the 1.5 million and buys property with it then he owes no taxes"

    Ah....not unless you know of some double secret section of the tax code that no one else has ever heard of. (Either that or you're thinking of a long ago provision that was abolished circa 1998.)

  • 19 years ago

    bethesdamadman;
    saphire: "AH but if he takes the 1.5 million and buys property with it then he owes no taxes"

    Ah....not unless you know of some double secret section of the tax code that no one else has ever heard of. (Either that or you're thinking of a long ago provision that was abolished circa 1998.)

    1031 Tax exchange allows you to reinvest your real estate gains without capital gains.

    KC

  • 19 years ago

    Thought I might want to put some info in there concerning the 1031. Here's a web site for some more info but you can run your own search.

    KC

    Here is a link that might be useful: 1031 Tax Exchange

  • 19 years ago

    Having lived on Cape Cod, he should thank his lucky stars he is out of there...and made millions on his investment.

  • 19 years ago

    saphire: "AH but if he takes the 1.5 million and buys property with it then he owes no taxes"

    bethesdamadman: Ah....not unless you know of some double secret section of the tax code that no one else has ever heard of. (Either that or you're thinking of a long ago provision that was abolished circa 1998.)

    harley rider: "1031 Tax exchange allows you to reinvest your real estate gains without capital gains."

    Buzzzzzz. I'm sorry, that is an incorrect answer. 1031 exchanges pertain to business and investment properties only. Someone who sells their personal residence and has a capital gain in excess of $500k is not able to shelter the additional amount in that manner. But thanks for playing and don't forget the lovely going away gifts on your way out.

  • 19 years ago

    1031 is for investment property, not a personal residence. Also the tax is deferred, not eliminated. He would also need to purchase $2mil in like kind.

  • 19 years ago

    And since there was a "he" instead of a "they," it might only be $250K tax free for an idividual after 2 years of living in a house. The fable states he was in the house for 6 months. Sounds like all gains will be taxed...more like $800K after he pays back the initial $500K. Not too shabby...even for La La Land...

  • 19 years ago

    bethesdamadman;"Buzzzzzz. I'm sorry, that is an incorrect answer. 1031 exchanges pertain to business and investment properties only. Someone who sells their personal residence and has a capital gain in excess of $500k is not able to shelter the additional amount in that manner. But thanks for playing and don't forget the lovely going away gifts on your way out."

    I'm sorry, I assumed (not good to do) that in this fable the property was not a primary residence. I work in an area where our waterfront properties are not the typical primary home. I have been involved in several 1031's in my area.

    Also, you don't have to purchase another $2 Million property with the money. I don't know if cmarlin20 was saying that but you can split it up to an equal or greater amount. It can be several properties to equal, or exceed, the amount of the gain.

    KC

  • 19 years ago

    I agree with others who say this has "urban legend" written all over it. However, I'll pretend for a moment.

    What would your reaction be if you had put yourself into something only to see it taken away by somebody that simply wanted a view?

    That he was living on Cape Cod. Land is everything here. Houses rarely factor much into the price equation.

    That said, "taken away" is not the phrasing I would use. If he didn't want to sell, he shouldn't have sold. If he's really crying all the way to the bank, that's no one's fault but his own.

  • 18 years ago

    My reaction is why didn't he say yes to the first million????