Software
Houzz Logo Print
slflaherty

Is marble worth the trouble?

14 years ago

Hi all!

My husband and I are in the midst of planning a kitchen reno in a house we recently purchased (we'll be moving in the first week of June).

We LOVE the look of white marble countertops (either calacatta or cararra), but we know that it is pretty high maintenance and we also have 2 kids, so spills and other "incidents" are inevitable. If we're going to put the money into a marble counter, we obviously want it looking its best for years to come.

For those of you who have it, is it worth the trouble it takes to maintain it?

Comments (40)

  • 14 years ago

    Yes, it is. My Vermont Danby Olympian White etches, but I've had no stains. It's gorgeous, totally makes my kitchen, and is well worth being a little more tidy in the kitchen. Actually, it forces me to be a little more tidy-- my former brown granite hid stains and crumbs so well, it allowed me to get a little lazy sometimes...

    You might want to consider Vermont Danby white marbles. They're significantly less porous than calacatta and carrera, so they stain less readily (although most on this forum with well-sealed calacatta/carrera counters have no staining problems at all). We do all have etching, though.

    I almost got calacatta gold, but was looking for a quieter slab with a little less movement, and found the perfect slabs in Danby.

    Here is a link that might be useful: http://www.vermontquarries.com/danby-marble/olympian-white/

  • 14 years ago

    Mine is being installed in 2.5 weeks, so I can get back with you!

  • 14 years ago

    It depends on your personality. If you are the type of person who (1) doesn't mind the etching and (2)is fine with the idea of attempting to wipe everything up immediately, you'd probably be fine with marble. If you have issues with the etching and the idea that it will develop a patina, and/or you don't want to deal with the high maintenance that comes with marble, you will probably not be as happy with it as the people in the first group.

    We don't have a marble counter in the kitchen but we have a marble shower seat in the bath. I absolutely hate the etching and having to make sure no stray shampoo or soap or other bathroom substance falls on it. Every time I see another etch in on that marble I am grateful that I'm not dealing with it in my kitchen. Again, this is neither for nor against marble, just a statement that you need to be honest with yourself before making a decision.

  • 14 years ago

    Google the forum and you will see lots and lots of discussion.

    I have it on one of my islands, because i love it and it is beautiful. I baby it and avoid using it when I cook. I have enough other prep space so I can use it for display, entertaining, etc.

    One warning - many say they love patina. I love patina too. But it takes years to get a nice patina. IMHO the first dozen mishaps will just look ugly.

  • 14 years ago

    We opted for granite. I wanted kids to be able to do whatever on the counter, alone or with me, without me stressing about counter care. I may put marble in our MBR sometime and am considering it as a partial BS still. For the counters, though, I have been so happy that they are worry-free.

  • 14 years ago

    I second waterdamage's comments. I also love the soft look of marble and wanted it for our island (which is not a cooking surface). But I have two kids and wanted them to be able to hang out and eat and drink lemonaid, koolaid and applejuice and color, etc without me having to worry. I wasn't as worried about the times when I would be there. But the few times a year when I travel for work or when the kids and I go to my parents for the weekend and DH is on call at home and has friends over watching sports...I'd be wondering what the heck was happening to my counters. I knew I didn't need them perfect and could handle etching. It's when I started reading about the dings from tossing keys and banging dishes while washing them and things like that that got me. The staining would be in the back of my mind a bit too. Could the kids use a certain type of paint or marker at the island, etc? I didnt want to end up upset over something that happened at our island which is supposed to be a place for us to gather and eat and do activities because I chose too porous of a surface. And I know that nothing may ever happen ever. But I knew that I would get a bit nervous about it in the back of my mind.

    I did put it in our bathroom though. It's beautiful. But there's less people in there to worry about....usually! Ha!

  • 14 years ago

    I had all marble counters in our apartment. It was gorgeous, sealed and even had a minimum of etching. But it did develop a couple of knicks and scratches, particularly because of the way the ss sink was undermounted.

    Did I love it yes. Was it worth the trouble? Yes but if I did it again I wouldn't have the sink done the same way.

    OTOH, we moved and in our house I have stainless counters. Those are completely carefree, though they too have scratching and patina. I don't mind. I would do marble again but I wouldn't trade what I have now for all marble because it's less maintenance (also around the range).

    If you have pause, perhaps think about doing area of the kitchen. Or, if you think you won't love anything else, go for it. Seal it and enjoy it. We used to pet our marble -- sounds funny I know. But there's nothing else that look and feels like that.

  • 14 years ago

    Just wanted to mention that I don't feel compelled to wipe up everything that spills immediately.

    Etching is an instant chemical reaction, so yes, naturally you wipe up the lemon or tomato juice quickly, but the etch occurs instantly so there's nothing that can be done about it.

    As far as stains, with Porous Plus 511 and Danby marble, I've had small amounts of substances like coffee and ink sit on the counter for hours and wipe up perfectly. I have to say, I haven't had a puddle of coffee or red wine sit overnight, but if you search the forum you'll find at least one fabricator who says while etching is inevitable, he's never met a stain (on Danby) that couldn't be removed (typically using simple cleaners or poultices).

  • 14 years ago

    I have Danby Marble-- it has been in about a year now. A couple of little etches and even some tiny dings, but no stains. I really love it and feel that nothing else would have been as "right" for my old kitchen. It just works with the aged surfaces of the old wood and the tile, also chosen for its aged feeling. I think that if you like the idea of a surface that will develop a used feeling over time you will like honed marble. If it were to get really unevenly etched or stained, we would just re-hone it with an orbital sander as we had to do right after install because the installer did such a terrible job. It is a surface that you can renew yourself.

  • 14 years ago

    I have Danby, too. Etches, no stains. The thing is nothing really shows because of the veining, pattern, splotches which are naturally inherent in the stone. Dirt doesn't even show much either.

    I had a solid white formica counter before the reno. There, dirt showed. The formica was very tough.

    The marble just doesn't show the etching and you have to bend down and look at it from certain angles to find it. I think guests can't distinguish etching from the stone and it's natural color variations and patterns. I am sure dh can't.

    A ding in my cabinetry upsets me. The marble etching, not in the least.

  • 14 years ago

    Yay, Danby!

    Sayde and Westsider, do you have pics posted already?

    In my case, the visibility of the etching is a matter of sunlight. My island, which basically sits in a stream of sunlight from the kitchen window, shows the etching really obviously (at least to me).

    The perimeters, especially in the stove area which has the least sun, hardly show it at all.

    Re: stains, the slab used for my island actually did get a mysterious maroon-colored stain, before the marble was sealed well. The fabricator "tried everything" and couldn't remove it. I put a paper towel soaked in hydrogen peroxide on it, and it was 100% gone in a few hours. Then we sealed the heck out of it, and it's been incredibly stain resistant ever since.

  • 14 years ago

    mtnrdredux put it better than I possibly could have -- it takes years to get a nice patina, the first dozen mishaps will just look ugly. So true!!

    Also I have to admit to harboring an evil thought. We are the only one of our friends to have marble counters. Friends who are redoing their kitchens often ask about marble "how do you like it?.. should I go for it?" etc. I am a naturally honest person so I tell them how much I love it but I have been tempted to tell them it was a mistake. I fear marble becoming as overdone as granite. Any one else worry about this? Lilly

  • 14 years ago

    Are these the looks you love?



    If so, get it. If not, don't.

    Marble etches in contact with acid 100% of the time. How easily you can see it depends on the light in your kitchen and the finish on your marble, honed or polished. Whether it bothers you depends on you.

  • 14 years ago

    Madeline, Unfortunately, no pics yet.

    The marble install, again unfortunately, was the least satisfying part, along with the unwanted shininess of the floor, in my reno. I was sure that I arranged a different layout of the slab, than that which was done. But it was done and I was not happy with it but I was sick of the reno, and I couldn't deal with any more.

    It took me 2-3 months after everything else was done, to pick out a countertop. And I had been looking for months before that. And no one knows where I was and how I felt, like you guys.

    I question myself because I tried to do a modern kitchen and in my mind, marble goes with traditional. Strike 1. Then instead of having a sharply defined 90 deg angled edge, I had an eased edge, b/c I was afraid of chipping. Strike 2. And the install with no matching butt-ups, Strike 3.

    I still love it. 20-25 years ago, I had our tiny powder room floor and vanity top done in Carrara. Talk about etching. It's all etched in the middle and I love it. Tons of kids have trampled on that floor. It's beautiful to me.

    If I cared, I'd call a stone guy and they could strip the p.r. floor and also polish the countertop etches. But I love to slap my bread dough on the counter. Makes me feel like a real baker (I aint).

    We also have the original 50 year old black slate floor in the foyer. Every other house in this subdivision still has the original floor, except the few McMansions.

    I guess none of us think much of brand spanking new. Too lazy or cheap.

  • 14 years ago

    Madeline if you google "vintage gumwood kitchen" you will find an article my kitchen that was posted on Attic Mag. You can see the counters there. You can also look up Danby marble in this forum and I do think you will see some other photos.

    I really like it because it looks more rugged and less formal than Calacatta but it does have both grey and brown markings. There is a great deal of variability in the markings from slab to slab. Mine has gentle markings that have swirls and curves. Some of the other slabs I saw had more angular and dramatic markings. I chose my slab both for the color and markings, and because I was able to template it to accommodate my corner section without having any corner seam. The only seam in the entire installation is a 8 inch seam behind the apron sink and yet the entire installation came out of one slab. So when you choose a slab, think about how it will be templated for your kitchen.

  • 14 years ago

    Yes, Marcolo...those etches speak to me! I have to have that marble. LOL

    I do want marble in my baking area, but not on the main island (although I considered it) but I think everyone will be happier with wood :)

  • 14 years ago

    Yes, unequivocally. It is the only material that gave the look I wanted. I love them.

  • 14 years ago

    Marcolo is such a party pooper! It makes me wonder, if that happened to me, I would just pour the acid over the whole thing.

    Rococo, I pet my marble too! Ours is made to look old, so it is not perfectly flat but has gentle waves to it. Sometimes I find myself absent mindedly caressing those alabaster hillocks when I stand in the kitchen. Sad sad sign of TKO.

  • 14 years ago

    Others here are right, you need to go with your gut as to whether you'll be comfortable with the etching. The marble is polished in the first photo Marcolo posted, and etches + polished marble = unsightly.

    I think when you go to the stone yard you will either fall in love with your marble slab, or walk away thinking it's definitely not for you.

    I've had marble in my bathroom (18 years old, living there for 10); it was originally polished and I honed it. The etching doesn't bother me, and isn't that noticeable now that the surface is older.

    I cannot wait to stroke my marble in my new kitchen :-) And I am an OCD neat freak, but will cook and bake and make strawberry jam and not care about the etches and stains and chips (well, not after the first few ones).

    Good luck making your decision!

    Mtnrdredux, your kitchen and house is BEAUTIFUL. I always go back to your photos...just stunningly lovely. Wish I could move in :-)

  • 14 years ago

    Guess I didn't get the memo. I really don't consider my marble counters high maintenance. They are actually easier than the formica and tile counters I've had before them and they don't look anything like marcolo's photos after 4 years or so of teens, a messy cook and clean-up DH and me.

  • 14 years ago

    Thanks for all the responses. My gut tells me that the etching would bother me, and the chipping/scratching would DEFINITELY bother me. I'm a bit of a perfectionist/OCD that way.

    I'm hoping we'll be able to find something with a similar look that we like that's a little more "perfectionist friendly". I agree that granite is kind of becoming over done. Maybe quartz? We'll have to keep our options open, but something tells me that nothing will compare to the look of marble...

  • 14 years ago

    There's a fudge maker in Charlevoix, MI.
    They have probably 6, long marble tables upon which they make fudge. I think they make taffy, too

    I am remembering these from probably being 6 to 10 years old, so I was a baby. But these tables and their almost porous texture I still remember as beautiful. They seemed to have a translucent depth to them. Years and years of sugar, work, cutting, etc., gave them a beautiful patina that only time supplies.

    I don't bake or cook much, but I do drink and spill lots of red wine. [LOL] Some for ME, some for the COUNTER! So were I to find a marble that gives me the "THAT'S IT" moment, even with my known sloppiness, I'm gonna have it.

    I plan soapstone, but am open to suggestions. :)

    Christine

  • 14 years ago

    The 3 photos that Marcolo posted - they are all polished. Polished will show imperfections more than honed. Also, the worst possible scenario - the marble can be re-honed (or re-polished). There are companies that do this, and from my checking around, it looks like it runs $200-250. So if I have to re-hone every 5-10 years, I'm ok with that!

  • 14 years ago

    I'm not a granite or soapstone person either. I like the color of our Caesarstone-- it doesn't stand out, it just blends nicely with the other materials. And I love the no-maintenance, no-worry aspect. For me, it was the smartest choice in my kitchen project.

  • 14 years ago

    Honed marble etched:



    {{!gwi}}

  • 14 years ago

    Something tells me Marcolo owns stock in a granite quarry...

  • 14 years ago

    No, Marcolo has owned marble before.

    The right person to own marble is someone who can look at those pictures and say, if that happens, it won't bother me.

  • 14 years ago

    Or someone who can grab a sponge with a nylon scrubbie side and give it a quick buff -- fine sandpaper and a new wipe of the area with sealer if it's really bad. My installers showed me how they were using a 220 sandpaper to buff the seams -- he let me take the sandpaper and give it a try while he was still there, and that's the last concern I had about living with marble. In 4 years, I've only done it a couple of times. I had to scrub and bleach white formica on a regular basis and then add a toothbrush to the routine with tile. MUCH more work, but steph, if you are a self-proclaimed perfectionist/OCD about things like that, don't get marble.

    I compare living with marble to wearing linen and faded denim. If you love the feel and find a comfort in the uneven color and wrinkles that develop, marble may be your kind of thing.

    I knew girls in college who sent their jeans to the dry cleaners. They should not get marble.

  • 14 years ago

    I made my sample piece look like what Marcolo posted. I got rid of every stain (it was sealed) and etch except 1 (lemon etch). The 220 sandpaper WET works amazing wonders!

  • 14 years ago

    Wow! Those second pictures really didn't bother me. But again, I'm only planning to use marble for a baking counter, not in full view of any other areas. If I planned to have it on every countertop...then I think it would bother me.

  • 14 years ago

    The beauty of patina-ed anything, whether marble or soapstone, comes from the ravages of time. The first etch, scratch, or ding or second or third, are blemishes - but after 2-3 years and regular use, these battle scars blend together in a timeless, harmonious, homogenized form. I often think of it as the same kind of beauty or grace that we see on the faces of hardworking, but proud people. Sure they're scarred and wrinkled - but there's character and a story behind each and every "imperfection".

  • 14 years ago

    Or someone who can grab a sponge with a nylon scrubbie side and give it a quick buff

    There are some long threads here about people for whom the Scotchbrite or sandpaper solutions did not work.

    It's fine to like the patina, but people have to be realistic that they're going to get it, and they can't keep it off.

  • 14 years ago

    "I compare living with marble to wearing linen and faded denim. If you love the feel and find a comfort in the uneven color and wrinkles that develop, marble may be your kind of thing."

    *Looks down at my dark denim*

    Yeah, I should probably move on...

  • 14 years ago

    Have you considered going with the laminate version of it for a few years and then changing to real marble when the kids get older. Perhaps this would give you a change to test out the look and decide if you wanted to trade in some maintenance to get the true feel of marble.

    {{!gwi}}

    They do have different edges available. I believe a GW user has this or similar in her kitchen.

  • 14 years ago

    aa62579, wow, that is amazing! Definitely an option for us!

  • 14 years ago

    I think that may be Raincloud Corian? I took a cooking class once where they had it. It is very nice looking. I was surprised to find though, that it is not less costly then marble, fwiw.

    JCMcGowan - thank you!

  • 14 years ago

    The photos I posted were of Formica 180fx laminate.

    Click on the pictures on the left hand side to see the enlarged image.

  • 14 years ago

    uh oh...I totally had my jeans dry cleaned in a past life.