Software
Houzz Logo Print
morgne_gw

Soapstone Sink Equals Cold Dishwater???

16 years ago

I've only had my soapstone sink up and running for a few days. It's a single bowl sink so I use a tub when I wash my dishes. The problem is that it seems like the soapstone just SUCKS the heat right out of the water. I start with very hot water but it's only about 5 or six items into washing that the water is noticeable cooler and by the time 5 minutes? has passed the water is almost cold.

Does anyone else notice that?

Comments (27)

  • 16 years ago

    I take it you didn't opt for the built-in sink heater?
    JK
    The stone's mass is a heat sink. What can be done about it? A dishpan, I guess.
    Or boil water for the warshin' up.
    Casey

  • 16 years ago

    I'm using a dispan now but it still sits on the sink floor. I wonder if using a sink grid would make it better.

  • 16 years ago

    I was planning on ordering my soapstone sink in about two weeks and this is a cause for concern. So if you just put hot water directly in the sink, does it cool even more rapidly? I live in Northern California where there are serious water issues. I don't want to have to run the hot water constantly to clean my dishes.

  • 16 years ago

    I'm sorry that you're experiencing this, but thanks for letting us know. I wonder if it's the soapstone or the size of the sink? I've always had double bowl sinks so have never experienced a large single bowl before.

  • 16 years ago

    Carecooks and pickle, I don't normally fill the sink (I've only had it up and running regularly a few weeks). I put a plastic tub in the one side with hot water and then use the other side to rinse. My soapstone sink is about 30 inches interior measurement so the tub is about 14x16.

    My last apartment had a porcelaine single bowl and I used a tub with no problems. My DH is normally the dish doer as I move through cooking so I've only gotten my hands wet, literally!, 5? times. Every time I've been floored at how quickly the water cooled down. With just myself and my husband we have almost no dishes. (in fact, we are still using up plastic spoons from the remodel so not even utensils). We wash 95% of the cooking dishes while we cook so at the end there are only a few items. I want to say that last time it was:

    2 glass mugs
    1 eating bowl
    2 choppping knives
    1 flexible spatula
    2 plates
    and one le creuset pan that had been used for mash potatoes.

    THAT's extremely close if not exact. I started out with hot, hot water and but the time I got to the last item, the pan, the water was too cold to wash a mash potatoe pan! A mash potatoe pan if you can believe it!

    I'm very concerned.

  • 16 years ago

    bump!

  • 16 years ago

    morgne, you've got the answer already.
    "... using a dishpan now but it still sits on the sink floor. I wonder if using a sink grid would make it better."

    Yes, absolutely. Just try it. Why not try this? To keep your thread active, be slow to bump and fast to try things out that you can report back on.

    To read more, in order
    to justify trying something out first, or
    to explain in other people's words why it works, here is a bit:
    1. on wikipedia go read one article and see the links to others :
    Insulation
    Heat transfer
    Heat sink
    Thermal contact conductance
    Thermal contact
    Thermal conductivity
    Conduction (heat) -- Heat conduction
    Thermal insulation
    Thermal mass
    R-value (insulation) - you'll see the R-value of air
    U-value (insulation)
    Building insulation
    Window insulation film
    Building construction

    2. (I hope this is accurate enough to pass the pick-apart test)
    The hypothesizing goes like this:
    a sink grid is a means to put some distance between the mass of hot water and the mass of "feeling-cold" stone. It separates these two masses more than before, by distancing them. No need for a specific product known as insulation, because distance alone will be a sufficient insulator for an average washing-up timeframe. Previously you had the wall of the dishpan only, and it was pressed against the stone. Now you have that dishpan wall plus some added distance. The mass of stone sucks heat because that is what stone does. Heat is transferred to stone (and to tile and ...) This has been referred to, indirectly, in all the posts about cold floors and cold counters. Greater pressure contact makes the heat loss greater than otherwise. The actual temperature is room temperature but it *_feels_* cold and acts as if it were cold (to warm things like lukewarm bread dough rising, and to people's skin, and to pets too) since it takes a lot of heat to warm it up, and secondly since it grabs heat instead of reflecting it back at you. It is known as a heat sink in the thermal vector field. Other masses and surfaces that reflect heat back at you always feel warm even if they are not. Take a big piece of styrofoam out of the fridge and within a tenth of a second it feels warm, but that is just its surface reflecting your own finger heat back at you.

    hth

  • 16 years ago

    David,

    I'm not really sure how to reply to your statement.

    It's unfortunate you think I bumped too soon. Carecooks indicated she was going to be placing her sink order soon so I wanted to put the thread front and center with the week beginning and everyone checking in. I'm mildly bemused that you felt it was your place to call me out on it.

    I'm not looking for a list of vocabulary words but I appreciate the time you put in to them. I was hoping to find out if the others here with soapstone sinks noticed this at first and either 1)became used to it and no longer notice it or 2)had it be less of a problem as time passed because the stone temperature finished come up to room temperature. It was also possible that they had other suggestions such as running the hot water on the stone for a few minutes before filling the tub or possible a double floored tub that has a built in air space. I understand the basic principles of heat transfer, thank you.

  • 16 years ago

    Whoops! Carecooks got another thread going. Let's abandon this thread and reply to hers!

  • 16 years ago

    morgne...I'm glad you brought this up--it's something I never thought of before! I'm also glad you bumped this thread today (not to soon at all!) since I didn't see it yesterday. Please update us on any solutions you try and whether they're effective.

  • 16 years ago

    Morgne,

    Thanks so much for understanding my "need for speed" in making a decision. Of course I agree that your post was totally bump-worthy. I'm reading the answers to both since they may vary in perspective (what to do if you already have the sink as in your case and whether or not the sink may work for me). I hope that good solution presents itself for you.

  • 16 years ago

    We've had a soapstone sink for 5 years and have never had a problem with water cooling off too fast in it, with or without a dishpan.

  • 16 years ago

    That's great to hear, Annaleef. Do you do most of your washing in the sink or dishwasher? I'm wondering if part of the reason I'm having such issues is that the kitchen part of the house is still not heated/cooled. Can you tell me what temp your kitchen is normally?

  • 16 years ago

    Morgne,

    Yesterday I called Florida Joshua because I was concerned about this. He said that this had never come up before as an issue. Then he said that if a room were really cold that it might happen. I also emailed another soapstone sink user whose kitchen I had admired. She also never had a problem. So I'm beginning to think that it's the combination of the stone and a really cold kitchen.

  • 16 years ago

    Is your sink on an exterior wall? What about sticking a silicone trivet between the tub and sink? Think of it as a cushion. :)

  • 16 years ago

    My sink is on an interior wall BUT that section of the house doesn't have heat yet. I don't think of it as being substantially colder than the rest of the house but maybe it is?!

    I'm going to spend some time over the next couple of days working on the problem. I'm going to try heating the room over the weekend with a temporary heat source to see if that creates a significant difference. I am hoping that it will get better and I AM looking for an insulated tub for the washing.

    I have to say that I don't think the problem will truly go away. We keep our house cooler than most people, sweater wearers the whole lot of us, so it's probably going to be an ongoing issue.

    LMAO. ON THE OTHER HAND! I'm against dishwashers on a lot of levels as you can see on other posts... but this may encourage me to get a dishwasher. SIGH.

  • 16 years ago

    I would simply set your dishpan on a cookie cooling rack. Raising it to allow air to act as an insulator should be the only thing you need to do.

    This property of the stone is why meat defrosts so quickly on the counter. It quickly pulls the cold away from the item. On the opposite spectrum, before you roll out pastry dough, set a bowl of ice on the counter. The counter quickly becomes very cold in a circle radiating from the ice and is great for rolling out dough. The same thing is happening with your dishpan set directly in the sink.

  • 16 years ago

    Soapstone holds the ambient temperature of the room. They used to use soapstone in New England farm houses because they would hold the temperature so well, they would boil the water & cover ,the water would remain hot all day. The problem is most likely the cold temperature in the room.

  • 16 years ago

    I have a single bowl farmhouse-style soapstone sink and it's against an exterior wall in New Hampshire. There is a bank of windows over the sink and they go all the way down to the soapstone countertop.

    This is in a lakehouse that we keep @ 50 degrees when we're away during the week. When we head up for weekends in winter we bring the heat up to 65 degrees.

    Unless I'm entertaining a large group, I handwash all my dishes. I use a Rubbermaid dishtub and rinse on the opposite side. I have never had a problem with the water cooling down while I'm washing dishes. I start with very hot water (I wear DW gloves) and usually end up with water that is, at least, very warm when I'm done.

  • 16 years ago

    How about a cold basement? What's the temperature inside the sink cabinet?

    Is it possible you've been kitchenless so long you've forgotten? :)

  • 16 years ago

    For what it's worth, I know soapstone is often used for woodstoves because it retains heat well. I would think that would be good for a tub of hot water, but I am no expert at thermal dynamics.

  • 16 years ago

    Okay. SO. We have a couple of things that are possiblilites.

    The first is that the room temperature IS very cool. Yesterdays high was 60 and the low was 40. The temperature in the kitchen IS the outside temperature right now if not slightly cooler because it's obviously in constant shade. I'm going to say that the soapstone is probably in the middle of that range somewhere, call it 50 degrees.

    The second is that I might be crazy. Lol. This is something we've discussed among ourselves. It has been a really long time. I mean really long. I haven't had a working kitchen in 3 years. It may be that I simply have become used to doing a quick rinse of something in hot water so I've become... distanced... from the reality of gradually cooling dishwater. DH says that he has not really noticed the issue.

    I'm going to chalk the whole thing up to dementedpolaricecapehouse... inasia. Thats a new medical term. Fortunately I'm managing to keep it in check with duelinginductiondemeyerecooktops... itis.

    Thank you all for reassuring me that I'm just a weirdo. That's EXACTLY what I need to hear.

  • 16 years ago

    Morgne,

    If I hadn't had a working kitchen for 3 years, I'd be over the bend. Enjoy your new kitchen when you get some heat. I know that I'll be enjoying my new soapstone sink!

    Care

  • 16 years ago

    Carecooks,

    I wanted to check back in and say after a pretty hot weekend here in portland (for April anyway) I got several times to wash the dishes and the problem is much less noticeable.

    So the problem should sort itself out. I'm sorry for worring you!

  • 16 years ago

    SO you're only a little crazy? Just wash faster! :)

  • 16 years ago

    Fori! Lol. My husband told me he can help me with my technique... I told him to do them himself!

  • 16 years ago

    Morgne,

    Thanks for getting back to me on this. We all get a little crazy with this kitchen remodel. And I think that getting your husband to to do the dishes is a great idea!