Software
Houzz Logo Print
sayde_gw

What is a 'Normal' Level of Problems?

15 years ago

We have been at this DIY remodel for nigh on to a year. Not done yet. We have not had any flat-out catastrophes but we have had many problems -- some of our own making, some caused by others.

-When DH applied Waterlox to his hand-made gumwood cabinets, we were shocked to see that the new gumwood was several shades darker than the old original gumwood. It looked horrendous. We had to find sources for more old gumwood (old doors from salvage) and DH had to make veneers to cover all the new gumwood -- about 30% of the cabinets. Took about a month to correct. Problem solved, sort of. It looks fine now.

-Unboxed Perrin & Rowe faucet purchased last May and observed it is too tall, blocks casement window. My mistake. Rohl agrees to take it back, even 10 months later, with a 30% restocking fee since I am purchasing a different, shorter Perrin & Rowe faucet. Problem solved, expensively but with a good outcome. New bridge faucet looks very nice and I am trying to forget the faucet that was my first love.

-Hood arrives damaged in early February only we don't see the damage til we un-box the hood in March. We had stupidly signed off when the hood was delivered. Many letters and calls later, we are forced to face the fact that we have no recourse. Fortunately the damage to the hood is not major -- the duct cover is torqued and lifted away from the canopy. After talking to many people DH concludes it might work to put some clamps on and straighten/reseal using only clamps and plywood on the back to hold it all together. It works, except for one small residual dimple that is not visible once the hood is installed. The hood had been packed in what we feel is a too-flimsy box, but we were just stupid not to have checked the underside of said box when it got here -- if we had we would have discovered that a fork lift had punctured the box and ripped the duct cover away from the hood. Anyway, hood is up now, looks good. Motor not installed yet. Still some work there, as well as the ductwork.

-Marble installation is a disaster. Installer cracks the sink-- rather than take the marble back and recut, he hits the front of the sink (which is attached to the GD and drainpipe) to move it forward. Also, the honing job is terrible -- it looks like they just swiped some muriatic acid over the marble instead of using a buffing tool. There are rough spots -- it is just terrible. (Fortunately marble is beautiful and I love it). The fabricator has been awful and we still don't know if we will recover anything. But Rohl gave us a new sink -- it is as though some cosmic intelligence had sensed that we had been dished out a bit more than our fair share and decided to help us out a bit here. (But that is not really fair as in fact it is simply the fact that Rohl has treated us very well that has saved our A** on this.) And DH to the rescue again -- he will rehone, he will install the new sink and finesse the cabinet as required. Outcome still not known, but I am hopeful . . .

OK, so we get this guy over-- he did our bathroom and is an excellent contractor and sort of a friend at this point -- and his reaction is-- every job has problems, lots of problems. He really does not seem to think that we have experienced more than the average number of glitches, errors, and outright reamings than most people endure.

So may-be I should just chalk it up to business as usual in the world of kitchen remodeling.

What do you think? Is this high or just your every day expected quotient of distress and problems?

Comments (15)

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Forgot to mention -- Blue Star range arrived damaged-- ding in the side, broken oven rack, knobs don't sit right. They shipped us out a new rack and knobs overnight and also provided new skins for the whole range, patiently talking us through the long process of completely stripping the range and installing the new covers.

    I'm probably forgetting some other stuff too . . . .

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    ordered cabs they are installed- all but one is measured incorrectly. Cab Salesperson fault. I now have to change entire layout of kitchen because I can not return appliances, including expensive counterdepth ss fridge, that I have already purchased and they no longer fit in the original layout. Gone is the furniture like hutch that I really, really wanted etc. Cabs come for the second time there are a few mistakes but nothing as bad- they are in and beautiful. I did get almost 4000 in upgrades because of their mistakes although it put me back about 2 1/2 weeks in my schedule. I had to order 5 farmhouse sinks before one came that was not defective. That worked out okay because of my cab delay. The lighthing people have been super and they did not charge me a restocking fee because the new lights i needed for under cabinet were a stock item- again- everything is delayed so that works out okay.
    I am terrified that there will be problems fitting the granite to the sink and actually installing the sink but we are not there yet. So yes lots of problems. I feel like I am in way over my head but also very proud when I get something done and excited to see it all come together. Good luck with your project!

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Sayde, sorry to hear you are having a rough time. I'm not sure whether my experience would be reassuring to you or not.
    I'm not DIYing. Nevetheless what should have been a 3 month job is now at one year.

    All along the way, things have gone wrong...though less with appliances and materials than with workmanship. Plumbing installed
    for deck mounted faucets when they are wall mounted. Gas pipes installed so that range can't push back to the wall. Cabinets painted
    the wrong color. Cabinets painted the wrong paint (latex vs. oil). Cheap drawer slides that aren't full extension installed.
    Plate rack looks like a kid made it in shop class...middle school shop class. Contractor hasn't shown up in months. With penalties
    negotiated for late delivery. He now owes ME about $4000, but the job isn't done. Some cabinet doors not installed. No lazy susans
    installed. yadda, yadda, yadda. It's now culminating in an official complaint and request for redress by the state home
    improvement commission. That, they said, could take 18 months.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Sayde,
    Your saga does not sound like a "normal" level of problems - but at least your DH is clever and can figure out how to fix the wrongs...Thank goodness Rohl came through for you twice! You certainly deserve some "sunny" days!! Had been thinking about you all and the sink & marble debachle. Hope your saga is over soon and you can enjoy your labor of love! The gumwood must be stunning!! (Hopefully, when things calm down, you can post an updated picture of your kitchen!)

    Beachpea

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I would have said that Sayde has about a normal level of problems, which she and DH are dealing with in a more competent fashion than most GC's.

    My kitchen reno was notable for a GC who needed to be kicked in the butt every step of the way, an expensive range that turned out to be a piece of junk and has needed multiple service visits, granite that spontaneously cracked soon after installation, cabinets that have now settled so much that the backsplash grout has cracked and needs to be redone, yada, yada.

    My bathroom reno took months longer than planned because various vendors couldn't seem to order the correct fixtures in a timely fashion, and the tile guy was repeatedly a no-show. I waited to have the idiot electrician's mistakes in the bathroom corrected by a competent one during the kitchen reno.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I haven't been on the kitchen forum for several years and was just perusing when I saw your post. This was my remodel several years ago if it makes you feel any better!

    Floor to ceiling cabs mismeasured & had to be cut onsite making toekick shorter than all the other cabs.
    Built in oven door had manufacturing defect and first door was replaced, then oven was replaced.
    Subzero had defect in hinge, hinge was replaced.
    New downdraft for cooktop defective out of the box, piece was replaced.
    Island pendants roughed in wrong location. Rewired after drywall and painting done so both had to be redone as well.
    Sub-floor not leveled correctly resulting in large island dipping down in 1 corner.
    Marble counter tops mismeasured on island and wouldn't fit. Uneven edges on all pieces. Had to sue contractor and have tops torn out and replaced.
    New oak floors cupped from too much moisture from painters leaving windows open. Had to wait 1 year, move out, have new floors resanded and finished. Resanding left dips and nicked cabinets.
    Skylight framed in crooked.
    My contractor has had houses on the cover of Metropolitan Home and Dwell so he's not a hack (just couldn't care less about my job).

    So, no, you are not alone. Hope it all turns out ok in the end. I'd rather have my husband on a job than another incompetent contractor!

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If that was normal, I would not still be in the kitchen remodeling business!

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You do not have a normal level of problems. You have fewer than normal.

    Your contractor isn't in jail, or in France with your bank account. Your garage isn't falling over, or your roof falling off, or your basement reenacting Titanic. Your lawn has not collapsed into a sinkhole and swallowed your sidewalk. You have reported no ER visits. No one is in a cast. It looks like you may finish before retirement.

    What more could you possibly want?

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I thought it was me. My original remodel over twenty years ago was a nightmare. It was part of a huge project of a three floor extension to our house while we were still living in it. I had four young children at the time 11,9,5 and 1 yr old. I worked with a fancy kitchen company and a designer from them. They designed a nice kitchen for the space, but DH nixed the entire design and we ended up with one huge room 19 X 26 with cabinets on basically around the perimeter (my advice is that if your DH doesn't do the research, don't give him any say!)

    I liked the white oak (it was popular at the time) with a bit of white accenting. DH was not happy with the price of white oak and the designer and owner (who formerly worked for Smallbone) said that red oak would be less expensive and assured me that the color would just be "warmer". After showing me numerous doors with finishes that were not acceptable (read that PINK) I asked that we upgrade the wood to white oak and was informed that the frames had already been made in red oak, but they said that they would be sure to finish them so the color was toned down. Then never brought me another sample door.

    After several mishaps during the construction of the extension: foreman falling off roof, old foundation blowing out forcing us to evacuate and all SIX of us staying several weeks with friends who had no children(poor couple)
    We were finally able to move back into our house and the cabinets finally arrived and they were PINK, PINK, PINK!!!!!

    My nine year old daughter had already threatened suicide over the mayhem in the household and the boys were stir crazy, so I said-"Just put the d*mn things in. I changed the counter tops to a rose colored marble and had the other counter tops which were oak finished so many times that I finally said to the kitchen people - 'fine, make them the same color as the cabinets." They were cracked within the year.

    I still have the angry letter that I sent to them. I lived with that nightmare for twenty years and just painted the cabinets and changed the counters, and changed lighting. That not without glitches either. But now my children are grown and gone and I'm a bunch mellower, especially since now I no longer have a pink kitchen.

    BTW, the first one was six months past the expected finish date.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Oh wow, thanks for all the responses. I feel much better (I think) knowing I am not alone, though my heart goes out to you, mossfern norcalnancy, melissastar and warmfridge.

    Someone in another thread said, "no it does not get any better . . . but it does end." I am soooooo ready.

    Thanks again for the sharing and support -- so appreciated!!

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Oy. For some reason this thread reminds me of the joke about computer response time being defined as the length of time between when you hit return and kick the computer. The point being is it's all context-dependent. What's "normal" depends on what you're willing to accept. And for me, what I'm willing to accept is *really* dependent on all sorts of weird tangential external stuff like, say, how much sleep I've had, who's yelled at me recently and why, whether I remembered to eat ... or stop eating. etc.

    I don't mean to be flip, it's just that "normal" isn't really a defined parameter you can measure in this context or for which there is any set 'truth' out there you can reach. Whether the glitches on your remodel are acceptable really does depend importantly on you:

    Do *you* feel the number of glitches is unacceptable? Presumably so or you wouldn't have written. Or are you looking for permission to give in and go with what's happened (a little like boxer's dented fridge)? I think these are just sort of political or character decisions; there isn't a right answer, there's just a style of dealing with it.

    Basically, you can wear a filter that reveals mistakes through each of life's every day-to-day happenings, and you will likely find one associated with each and every thing out there. Literally. And this can drive you crazy. The same data can be read by the same person at a different instant differently.

    Good luck! It doesn't sound as if your experience is completely off-the-charts crazy and so then the question becomes how do you keep it from leaving you feeling so?

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Sayde, that sounds about right to me. We're DIY-ing a major house renovation, and my list of problems is long. I won't bother to type them all here (I don't think I could even remember everything) but here are the highlights:
    - Most recent: Our kitchen cabinets, installed in fall 2009, have a major defect: the corners of all end runs (4x on the island) were designed with 2 sides recessed toekick, per the cabinet rep/KD's advice. Those corners are sagging/warping/bowing and the corners are dropping, which is jeopardising the marble countertop... it's now torquing and I'm afraid it will crack. This is especially frustrating because the kitchen isn't even officially finished yet (but was mere weeks away when we discovered this.) Luckily, the cabinet company is going to fix it.
    -Thermador range hood blower was so ridiculously loud we would never have turned it on. Had to buy additional remote blower and insulated ducting and install in the attic.
    - Master bathroom wall tile (translucent white glass) installed with too-grey thinset so it looks blue. That completely changed the carefully designed color palette.
    - Master bathroom marble mosaic shower floor showed wet spots after a couple weeks of use. Had to be torn out and rebuilt.
    - Master bath floor tile grout BADLY stained before ANY use, by neutral all-natural cleanser when cleaning construction dirt off tiles. (Still not rectified.)
    - Master bathroom vanity sconces (expensive ones from Restoration Hardware ) are incredibly dim. I have to take my makeup to my daughter's bathroom to apply in better light.
    - Daughter's bath reno: brand new tub suffered quarter-sized chip when a wrench was dropped on it while installing shower valve trim.
    - I templated for the marble vanity top before sheetrock was installed, and assumed the wall corner would be square. Not even close. So we had to do MAJOR surgery to both the vanity and the wall to install the vanity, as well as totally change the tile installation to cover the huge gaps.
    - Kitchen range problems fixed under warranty.
    - One of the few things we did not DIY was the rough framing of an exterior wall with multiple window/door installations. Almost ALL of the windows/doors were SO badly installed that they leak cold air badly in wintertime. They are racked in weird ways, no where near plumb/square/level.
    - Dovetail drawers for pantry ordered 1/4" too wide (my fault). We're out of money so cannot re-order. DH will have to build them himself if we want drawers :(

    That's probably about 1/4 of the total list of problems, disappointments, badly designed or built products, etc. So.... I think your list sounds about right. And that you're rectifying things in a much more conscientious manner than most contractors would. My guess is that on big projects with GCs there are lots of issues like this that the owners never hear about, or never notice.

    Hang in there.... You'll get through it! And it'll be beautiful in the end.

    Stacey

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Of the four issues listed, the first three are, to me, your responsibility/fault. Mismatched wood is accidental but your husband was making the cabinets so that's not anything that can be 'blamed' elsewhere. You ordered a faucet that didn't fit-and the company replaced it. You didn't check the hood till it was too late to do anything.

    Anyway, as many others have pointed out no remodel goes perfectly smoothly. I honestly think it's more about how one handles the inevitable problems that will occur. Good luck and lucky you to have a husband who is so into the process and doing so much. Believe me, an unwilling spouse is a problem that dwarfs most of the other f*ck-ups that will come along!

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks everyone. It really helps to know that others have bumps along the way. It's also nice to hear that that people eventually get past all the sturm and drang and go on to have a life after the remodel.

    I do indeed count myself lucky to have a husband who is able and willing to do so much. He has made things all over the house that I asked for and designed, but the kitchen is his "masterpiece." It is far from perfect but it is all handmade and has his "fingerprints" all over it.

    I had a horrible contractor on the bathroom (we had to fire him and finish with someone else) so I have had my share of problems with contractors and I do know how awful that can be. In fact I think the bathroom remodel experience was one of the factors that made us decide to try DIY on the kitchen.

    With all the mistakes we have made, I still think we have been extremely lucky to have had the expert guidance from GW -- we have avoided many pitfalls because we had the benefit of others' experiences. Two that come to mind right away -- getting the extended flange for the sink, and putting the gas outlet behind the Blue Star range in underneath so that the range can slide all the way back. Also, it has made me able to just face up to things and deal with them a little bit better.

    I am also extremely grateful for the support, which came at times that I was just ready to crawl into a hole, and really cheered me on. When I posted about the marble fiasco, there were 11 responses inside the first half hour and ultimately nearly 50. I read them all to my DH and they made a world of difference. (He especially liked the ones that commented on how lucky I am to have him!) If someone had died in my family I would not have nearly that number of expressions of consolation. Garden Web is truly an exceptional community.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Didn't read all the comments -- will go back and do that, but my initial response is "just a bit more than you think you can handle and just a bit less than you really can" -- so you must have a high ability to deal with "issues." ;-) Hang in there!