Software
Houzz Logo Print
sue2012_gw

Wolf or Thermador??

14 years ago

I am really having a hard time deciding between a 36" Wolf or Thermador Gas Range. I love the star burners. Wolf has many positives as far as performance and customer service. I have heard Thermador has stepped up on both recentley. Also, I am considering purchasing an all gas range instead of the dual fuel. Any thoughts? One more thing. I am also looking at the GE monogram advantium oven/microwave/speed cooker. This will resolve both a second oven and microwave issue. I don't have a lot of space and thought this could be a good solution. Does anyone own one or have any thoughts on this?

Thanks in advance for any suggestions or comments

Comments (16)

  • 14 years ago

    Thanks Madeline.. It is a huge decision. I am leaning toward Wolf. Are sealed burners better?

  • 14 years ago

    Well, that's a sticky subject on the forums, lol.

    I think true culinarians, as in pros, will always prefer sealed burners. You can really get a lot of responses from the experts on the appliances forum.

    Bottom line, as I understand it, is that the open burners allow for more precise flame control, for certain. The flame comes up from a variety of areas on the circumference of the burners, whereas with sealed, it's just a ring of flame, the size is what it is.

    It's often believed, and I happen to agree, that sealed burners are easier to clean. Many open burner fans, though, say that the open burners are just different to clean (you have to disassemble them). Also, the sealed burner model has a drip pan, where the drippings/grease/liquids drip down into a tray below the stove surface. You pull out the tray (which is ytpically lined with foil) and change the foil every so often. The sealed burners, on the other hand, are sealed, so nothing drips down. Instead, whatever spills lands on the flat burner plates around the burners, and you wipe it up.

    If you Google videos, there's a capital culinarian video that shows the process of cleaning open burners. The CC is more complicated than Wolf, but it will give you some idea.

  • 14 years ago

    Just curious why it is between these two specific brands? There are tons of great range manufacturers out there who make high quality ranges for much less money. I find my bertazzoni cooks just as well as my friends wolf 36. Other brands like bluestar, fivestar, capital, all make great ranges.

  • 14 years ago

    The reason behind the two is I am already driving myself and everybody else crazy. The more choices i have the longer it will take me to make a choice. Wolf has a great reputation. Thermador has the star burners and a great promotion (free dishwasher-bosch). I am open to any suggestions. I have purchased a subzero. I always wanted one and have so many friends that love theirs. The range is my issue. Also Gas or Dual Fuel? Leaning toward gas. I have been waiting 25 years to "update" my kitchen.

  • 14 years ago

    One more thing that I learned on the forum. If you go with all gas, it tends to be better for roasting (more humid in the oven, I think), whereas dual fuel is better for baking.

    The current Wolf all gas also has the infrared broiler, that heats up to some crazy temperature to make the best steaks ever, I've heard. It's also considerably less expensive than the DF.

    The DF Wolf has the cool blue enamel interior and the sleek pop-out digital control, as well as a larger oven window.

    Again, be sure to check on exactly what is changing and when if you decide to go with all gas.

  • 14 years ago

    Thanks.. I will check on the latest with the all gas. I am not much of a baker but i do roast and bake a lot.

  • 14 years ago

    I think Madeline meant to say that pro's usually prefer *open* burners, not sealed. Virtually all gas restaurant ranges are open and almost all residential ranges are sealed. The few companies that are producing open burner ranges these days also put out some wicked high BTUs, so thats another plus that can be attributed to open burners. In the end, it is your preference. Madeline did an excellent job describing the setup/cleaning differences between the two. If you decide that open burners are for you, and you are still only looking at Thermador and Wolf, then your decision will be quite easy as Wolf AG is the only open burner configuration among Wolf and Therm. And I might be burned at the stake for saying this, but I'm pretty convinced that the single largest factor in great baking/roasting results is proper temperature. No matter the range you end up with, buy a cheap oven thermometer. I have baked in both gas and electric, and have never once thought to myself "man, if only this dang gas oven were electric..." I have, however, burned a cake or two due to oven calibration.

  • 14 years ago

    i have the 30 inch wolf all gas and love it! highly recommend, one of the best things about the kitchen. the infared broiler is fantastic!!!! much cheaper than dual fuel. unless you are really a baker think the ag would be fine.

  • 14 years ago

    Very informative thread. I learned a lot by reading it. I did not know what open burners were.

  • 14 years ago

    Thanks Madeline,
    I never really thought about how the all gas vents out. Does anyone have that issue with the venting with an all gas. I thought the ventilation would take care of the smoke and grease. Maybe i should rethink gas to begin with. Originally i looked at induction. Any thoughts?

  • 14 years ago

    Great thread, thanks.

    Does anyone know more about when the Wolf redesign is happening?

    I wonder if that will impact current stove pricing - maybe they would reduce them to clear? Or maye that's why they are running the current Wolf/ Subzero promotion?

    Hmm, things to think about....

  • 14 years ago

    I have a sealed burner Wolf range top. DH hated the look of the open burners. He really wanted the flat grates, so we went with sealed. I think I might have liked the open, but I didn't feel strongly about it and the control of the sealed is not a problem. I can melt chocolate directly and not have any problems. The flame is just small enough for my smallest (and least often used) saucepans.

    My ovens are Wolf wall ovens and the electric ovens do a great job roasting. The convection roast cycle is amazing. Sears the surface to seal in juices and cooks quickly. My first turkey was done an hour early, but once you make the adjustment, it's really nice. I think a chicken is about an hour and a 12 lb turkey was less than an hour and a half. I used to turn the temp up to sear, then turn it down -- now I just hit convection roast and let the oven take care of it.

  • 14 years ago

    Hi,

    I have a 15 year old thermador duel-fuel range. Electric is supposed to be truer for baking. That is why I purchased the duel-fuel. I have really like my Thermador. The only problem I have had in all that time is the light went on my oven panel. I am now purchasing a cooktop for another kitchen and I went with Thermador. I am sure the Wolf has a simmer burner, but since I was so happy with my previous Thermador, I went with that. Two different animals, a range and a cooktop,but my experience with Thermador has been good.

  • 14 years ago

    I used to have a thermador gas cooktop and now have a wolf AG range. If you are trying to choose between the two, my best advice would be to talk to the people who service these high end cooking machines. They can give you real life feedback on which appliances are the most dependable, the ones that they have repeat service calls to and those most expensive to repair...all without the bias of a salesperson. That's what I did, and that's why I have a Wolf. My range and refrigerator (subzero) are two of my favorite things...no fancy digital screens or doodads...just solid performance.

  • 4 years ago

    We bought a Thermador duel fuel range about 4 years ago. Almost immediately after it was installed we started having problems. Two of the burner would continue to try to ignite the burners after the valve was turned off. After multiple calls to Thermador, service appointment were scheduled, canceled and then rescheduled, usually with little or no prior notification. The problems have not been resolved. I will say that some of the issues were during the height of the COVID pandemic. On a couple of the repair appointment, the service tech did not have parts required. After about the 5th time that service was requested to fix the same problems, Thermador tried to pass off the repairs as "now that should be covered by your extended warranty". We pointed out that while we indeed do have an extended warranty, the problem has NEVER BEEN FIXED CORRECTLY while under manufacture's warranty and feel that it is a manufacturer issue. Today again the service appointment was canceled and rescheduled for a day 2 weeks in the future 'some time between 8am and 5pm' followed by 'the tech will call 24 hrs before'.

    We really like the range, but can not recommend given the horrible customer service provided by Thermador.

Sponsored
Snider & Metcalf Interior Design, LTD
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars25 Reviews
Leading Interior Designers in Columbus, Ohio & Ponte Vedra, Florida