Software
Houzz Logo Print
belasea_gw

Is Job Expansion Common?

16 years ago

When you were remodeling your kitchen, did you end up fixing a lot more than you thought? We love our contractor, has nothing to do with him. It's just we have an old house. More necessary repairs are being found and things are breaking in the middle of the project that has nothing to do with them. Our furnace was red tagged and declared a hazard last night by PG&E. We knew it was coming, but what timing. I'm sure we can't be alone...

Comments (26)

  • 16 years ago

    Oh! I thought you were going to be talking about the "while we're doing it we may as well..." things! You mean like when the main water line to my house pretty much crumbled in the middle of doing the kitchen! That one that runs under the sidewalk and up through three terraced levels. My darling GC just sent a crew to dig it up. And a master plumber to replace the whole danged thing with copper. And a crew to cover it over again. Boy that was an expense that wasn't in the budget!!

    Or did you mean like when the wind blew down the bougainvilleas by the kitchen door, which brought down the outdoor light. My GC had the electrician out in the pouring rain taking care of the light, and his landscape crew out the first dry day to trim up the bougainvillea, plant it back down, and wire it to the wall. Act of God, but GC to the rescue. They couldn't have finished the tiling without something being done, anyway, so he made things happen fast.

    Answer is yes, and be happy you have a GC whom you love. It makes these things hard on the budget, but removes such a huge amount of stress!

  • 16 years ago

    oh wow plllog, that is a lot!! Three terraced levels! Geez, what a surprise that must have been. I knew that we couldn't be alone. Thanks for the good reminder that at least we love our GC. We are very grateful for him and it does remove a LOT of stress.

  • 16 years ago

    Naw, that seems to be fairly common with older homes. As soon as you open up a wall all kind of things start to show up.

  • 16 years ago

    No. You are the only one that has ever happened to. Really, you should be ashamed. ;-) :-D

    Shoot, I think just owning a house and working on anything begs something more to be worked on -- and perhaps all that is really needed it to start thinking about a project, because that often causes something else to go wrong and move up the priority list, delaying the original plan. My powder room with the drain pipe section that appeared to have never been glued in place and after 19 years finally filled with enough dirt to back the sewage into my master bath is one of the lovelier examples. Thank goodness my son's bathroom was on the other side of the drain line and we had one bathroom to use while that got fixed.

  • 16 years ago

    Yup, you are in good company, if not exclusive :-P

    On the first day of demo the crew pulled up the floor to find cracks running throughout the concrete slab foundation. Not little "curing" cracks, but cracks running from one side of the house to the other and through the footing to the exterior. We spent at least a week having foundation contractors and engineers come take a look, do testing and figuring out how bad the repair was going to be. Estimates were running from only simple repairs (3-5 days and $3-5K) to excavating the soil and supporting the foundation with piers at a cost of in excess of $50K and delaying ANY work on the kitchen for 2-3 months. Very stressful week! The running joke was how much this was going to eat into DS's college fund. A semester at State or 2 at Harvard? We were fortunate, like you to have a great GC who held my hand through the whole ordeal, doing all the electrical work while this was going on, meeting with the various foundation contractors and engineers. In the end the engineers report was as good as we could hope for and it didn't cost too much in time or money.

    So hang in there. Try to keep smiling through it. In the end it does feel better knowing that these things have been addressed and there isn't a safety hazard lurking in the walls.

  • 16 years ago

    We just opened a wall (from the other side of the house where I elected *not* to open it up) only to discover that the entire sill was, at best completely rotted and at worst, completely gone. And this is the sill for the load bearing wall, so structural and not an option.

    Renovating an old home is a harsh lesson in consequences ;-) and yes, the scope of work will expand. I'm just glad that for some reason, the Universe kept me from putting the deposit on my $20K inset Fieldstone cabinets, because my cabinet budget is the only major line item I have left to play with and try to "make up" some of the money from to pay for the sill repair.

  • 16 years ago

    Our home was built in 1906, right after the SF earthquake. Our contractor had worked on our house before and he was prepared to find things. We just thought it would be related to the kitchen, instead of whole new things :). We were going to do the windows, but will put those on hold for now. I feel like we're rebuilding the house one room at a time.
    grlwprls, I sure hope that you're able to get the cabinets that you want in the end!
    jreuter - foundation problems are scary! so glad that you got that fixed.
    Thanks for sharing all of the stories.

  • 16 years ago

    My first thought when I ready your post was "He/she's kidding, right?"... belasea, it happens to us every time! We've been living in our 1913 bungalow for 18 years, and we've been working on it nearly the whole time. Seems like every project has had "job expansion", and usually not the fun/pretty stuff... although we are pretty much past the "socks and underwear" repairs no one can see; all new systems, etc. (Crossing fingers, knocking on wood, praying, etc.) I could go on and on about what we've found and about how our GC probably thinks our house is jinxed! :-) Hang in there. I think living in an old house is so worth it; and lucky you - to have a 1906 SF home! (drooling here...)

  • 16 years ago

    We have a home built right around 1900. We have photos of our home being the only home in this large, open prairie. We have come to a point where the VERY firmly established saying in our house is "while we're at it". It happens every time.

    Hang in there.

    Rene

  • 16 years ago

    Oh do I relate to you all...the oldest part of our home was built c.1680 and the newest c.1955 - with about 330 years of "patch and a promise" along the way. In order to start "thinking" about our kitchen remodel..we have been told that "before you start"- you need a new roof so your new kitchen ceiling will not have any leaks......and "while we are at it"...replace the septic system(to be compliant with Title V - State Code)...and while we are talking code...if you are getting new appliances...best we check the electric and plumbing.... Belasea ...I know...it has a way of taking the wind out of your sails...but don't give up!!!!! It will be worth it in the end.... one day soon! Good Luck!!

  • 16 years ago

    Well, my car blew a head gasket. That is a big fat OUCH when it comes to the budget, at a time when I don't need any more OUCHES.

  • 16 years ago

    This is depressing..My house was built in 1985 and that doesn't seem to exclude us from the fixing and updating to code stuff! Well, I guess I can join this club:)

  • 16 years ago

    As previous posters have already commented, oh yeah in between the moans, groans and sighs!

    Our previous project on this house I signed a change order on the first day because the exploratory into why was the siding buckling was because of an improper roofing done. That led to three decks being redone and the roof all the way down to new plywood. We were able to just avoid having to rent a crane to take out and replace our 40 foot long up 25 feet in the air ridge beam.

    This project's "expansion" has included digging underneath our sidewalk and bringing our electrical up a hill for 40 feet and back underneath our house. That impacted our cable connection. We also needed to shore up 40' of foundation at the other end of our house. My kiln died while firing the first run of glass pieces I was doing for the kitchen and resulted in buying my new kiln a year ahead of schedule... Oh and we had to redo the frig section because we had planned it for our current 13 year old model and the new ones that met our needs were taller...

    Oh and our house is only 20 years old too...

    But it has been worth it because cooking with induction has been so much easier than our old gas range. :))

  • 16 years ago

    Oh, yeah. In the middle of planning my kitchen reno (upstairs), I experienced a frozen pipe and extensive water damage downstairs. The whole house is a mess and the work is all going to cost a fortune.

  • 16 years ago

    Our neighbors laughed at us when we said we'd be finished renovating sometime in the next year -- they all have old houses as well (all the houses on our block are 100+ years old) and have all been renovating for 20+ years. Now that we've gotten started, I see what they mean.

    First it was the bathroom, then the kitchen. And then the back porch needed to be rebuilt entirely. And then we're planning on adding a bathroom. Oh yeah, and the garage has to be redone. Did I forget to mention that we are planning on redoing the entire upstairs and adding two dormers? Also, the house was vacant for about a year, and the landscaping is growing out of control. And we're planning on busting up a bunch of concrete to return part of the paved driveway to a green space. If we ever decide to insulate the house, we'll have to re-do all the knob and tube wiring. And the water heater is leaking badly and needs to be replaced, but we just haven't gotten around to that yet. Oh yeah, and there are two windows that won't open, no matter what we do, plus all the other 100 year old windows that were installed before weather stripping was invented.

    Did I forget to mention all the woodwork that still needs to be stripped of (probably lead) paint?

    In all fairness, we knew when we bought a hundred year old house that it was going to need work. But boy, do those renovation projects ever start adding up!!

  • 16 years ago

    Yes! (If you Give a Mouse a Cookie . . .")

  • 16 years ago

    Well, it would be true for us except...we KNEW we were opening up a can of worms, so we had a huge list of "while we're at it's" to hand to the contractor for the initial proposal. So far we are only somewhat over budget on "Wow, we didn't think of that's". :-) Then again, we're not quite done yet!

    Relax, you are in good company. As long as you trust your contractor, you're golden.

    Cj

  • 16 years ago

    i can relate. first house, was a very enthusiastic first time home owner, am a project manager, i love projects! almost 70 yr old house, lots of "character". little did i know this would be ONE ENDLESS PROJECT!!! It started right away upon close of escrow and has not stopped:

    1. replace failing sewer lateral (thank god i ran a camera down it during inspection!)

    2. pull old cheesy awnings off house exterior. thank god no dry rot, that was a close call...

    3. attempt to repair failing gutters to discover they are original hollowed out REDWOOD LOGS!?!

    4. Replace roof and gutters. 3 layer tear off and new plywood - expensive! Roof work destroyed my just clinging to life cement driveway in the process due to the super cool super heavy hydrolic lift truck -still on list of things to be replaced

    5. Decided to do "some landscaping" which morphed into designing and installing a new irrigation system, installing new fence, removed the dead and dying shrubs, trees and grass in front yard, rototilling the entire front yard.... the front yard is now one big pile of dirt... i then developed a severe case of design paralysis so it is still a big pile of dirt....my neighbors are very eager for me to get over this paralysis i am sure!

    6. My neighbor asked me to house sit so I decided it was the perfect time to refinish the hard wood floors while i was at her place... (lesson learned - do this BEFORE you move into the house!) do you know how hard it is to move and fit all your crap into the attic and garage with virtually no notice, move yourself and 2 cats into a bedroom and keep the windows open to air out the polyurethane smell in winter??? granted this is CA, but still...

    7. paint the interior (lesson learned - paint first, then do the floors!)

    8. now i am on to kitchen remodeling...the insanity continues...glad to hear i am not alone...

    Future projects still on the list:

    bathroom remodel, EQ retrofit, bonus room remodel, new cement driveway, new garage door....

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks for the support and stories. I shouldn't be surprised. We did one other project and it too had unforeseen issues, but for some reason was taken aback by these surprises. We're getting an estimate for the new furnace tomorrow.
    Next on the list - new deck, windows, front stairs, replacing dryrot on outside overhang, painting the trim and sound-proofing the bedroom. hmmmm. First let us get through the kitchen (they finished the drywalling part!) and the new furnace. Our kitchen is so small that if I posted it here it would get laughed at, but I think it will be a huge improvement. Love gardenweb!

  • 16 years ago

    belasea said "Our kitchen is so small that if I posted it here it would get laughed at, but I think it will be a huge improvement. Love gardenweb!"

    Belasea, no way that's going to happen here. Post pics or layout as you wish. This forum has a remarkable number of intelligent, astute, knowledgable and happy to help folks. I've learned a tremendous amount and have appreciated input from those who pay way more attention to detail than I.

    Whew - some scary stories here.

  • 16 years ago

    I can understand why a 100+ year old house might have some crazy stuff, but I'm really scared by the 30 year old houses that have multiple big ticket problems! I think that's why I stopped watching Holmes on Homes.

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks rosiew, everyone here has been incredibly helpful and so supportive. What I meant when I said my kitchen would get lauged at is because it's so small. It's only one wall. There's not a lot to do with it, but we were able to squeeze out a little more cabinet space. Unfortunately we do not have any walls to break out to make it even remotely like a normal kitchen. It's not even a galley kitchen because it only has one wall, not two! lol. When our house was originally built 6 months after the earthquake, the whole house was only 300 square feet! It's been added too over the years, but unfortunately, no one ever added to the kitchen and now load bearing walls are on each side. It's more than we can handle! :) Good thing it's only me and dh - oh, and our cat.

  • 16 years ago

    OH how I know the feeling. My house was built in 1901 and the amount of work that has been done, that began with a small leak in the basement.

    Upgrading wiring for the 30s. When the walls game down electrical boxes open and with live wires sticking out. I'm so blessed there was never a fire. Open air vents in the kitchan and bathroom not hooked to anything.

    The best...my kitchen was built on dirt. No solid flooring. Now I know why my tiles kept cracking. Worse walls were dry rotting. Hense brand new kitchen, acutually brand new first floor.

    My GC I love this guy, he is working with me. He realizes what I can afford and can't but he has said time and time again "I will not leave this undone, or have a problem happen in the future". There was a point where he and his guys kept tissues available cause I've done a bunch of crying in the past months. Every problem found is fixed and lord knows there are alot of them. I can go on and on with the problems!

    All this from one small leak in the basement.

    MadamG2U

  • 16 years ago

    Luckily, we just started out purchasing our c. 1890 home with a fire-damaged roof and wall... :) Bones of this old house were just too good to pass up. Initially, we'll just replace a few things... one week later, total gut reno. 8/ However, it was OK and cheaper in the long run than fixing things half-way through the project, as when we found large leaks hidden in the wall ruining a support beam. So, we get to really start from scratch, including the kitchen, and do it right. We'll be here for awhile...

  • 16 years ago

    I hope so. I'm getting job expansion before my job has officially started.

    We had an old roof patch fail a few days ago which damaged the drywall and trim. So our GC will pull off the old roof (weird gravel stuff) and put on a new rubber roof. And then will fix the drywall and trim when he does that in the kitchen. So our scope is expanding, and it isn't even fun stuff!

    I'm glad to read that this isn't only because ours is an older home. I started doubting our choice to buy an older house. It needs so much work/money! (Though I still absolutely love its character...)

  • 16 years ago

    The three most dangerous words from your contractor:

    "What if we......"

    This has been the source of at least 4 weeks delay in finishing the kitchen and $20K worth of changes in my living room and dining room.