Software
Houzz Logo Print
anele_gw

Clashing Decorating Opinions- DP Issues

18 years ago

Do you and your DP's (Dear Partner) decorating ideas clash? If so, what do you do?

On the whole, my husband could care less about how I decorate. He might not love it, but he forgets within a day-- with one HUGE (to me) exception: the TV.

I've been slowly working on the living room since last fall. One of the biggest obstacles is trying to make the TV wall work. I finally realized it's impossible. The TV is big, but too small for that wall, and I refuse to get a bigger one (it wouldn't really solve the problem anyway). The TV placement, since it is on the largest wall in the room . . .and the only wall with no window . . .affects major decorating choices in that room. If I got an armoire, then the whole wall would be a row of wooden furniture (bookcase, fireplace, armoire) and I don't think that would look right at all, esp. as the fireplace and bookcase are OK, but not showstoppers.

Anyway, I'm not so interested in help for my specific issue, but more for how you handle conflicts for these types of decorating issues in general, esp. when compromise isn't really an option?

Comments (33)

  • 18 years ago

    I live by this one golden rule:

    It is better to ask forgiveness than to ask permission.

    I find it particularly useful when it comes to interior decision of the home- and life in general.

  • 18 years ago

    Oh, this topic has been brought up before. Grab your favorite beverage and enjoy the show...

  • 18 years ago

    miles661-- trust me, if I could move the TV myself, that's what I'd do (it's bolted to the wall). I agree though . . .thinking about how DH and I do ask for permission about things (in general) is stifling for the both of us.

    pam-- link? Maybe the previous discussions would help me!

  • 18 years ago

    Mine is one of the few who likes to give me imput and be a part of the selection process. It has caused issues with the length of time on making a decision. He has good taste and is great with color but we don't always agree.

    This is one of the reasons we hired a decorator. He is our cushion. We may spend a little extra but boy oh boy it's made up in time.

  • 18 years ago

    Sorry, Anele, I don't have a link. It just seems to be one of those topics that can, at times, get a tad interesting. You'll have some that will agree with Miles (easier to ask forgiveness versus permission), or those that would feel it's disrespectful to make decorating decisions without consulting the other person.

    It's not a bad question to ask. It is interesting to see how other people handle this. For me, my DH isn't really interested in "inside stuff", including paint colors, so I pretty much have carte blanche. Too bad I don't have the funds to do all the ideas I have floating around in my head.

  • 18 years ago

    My DH has pretty much given me free reign to do whatever I please in decorating our home, although he has had a couple of pretty definite opinions that have surprised me. To that end, I've always made it a point to involve him as much as he wants to be involved in decorating decisions. Most things he hasn't given a flip about, but on those matters in which he's disagreed with me, I've acquiesced and done things his way. It didn't kill me to do so, our home aesthetic as a whole hasn't suffered, and he's felt valued. I mean, really - it's his home too, right? In my opinion, it is disrespectful to refuse to consider a partner's point of view, and I don't believe people can coexist peacefully and lovingly without compromise.

    /$.02. Keep munchin' that popcorn ...

  • 18 years ago

    Well, my husband used to be interested, but then I discovered something about him:

    My husband only seems to know one color. "Burgandy would be nice there." "Hmm, how about a rich burgandy color?" And so on. He finally, after several years of marriage, has realized that this is the ONLY color he seems to be able to say, so I finally have gotten more free reign to do what I'd like to do. ;)

    I do ask his opinion and won't make a huge decision without him at least getting a chance to say he hates something. If he hated what I wanted, absolutely hated, I wouldn't do it. If he's indifferent, than I go ahead if I'm sure it's what I want. Otherwise I wait and try a few more ideas before I commit to anything. This seems to work better all around...decorating wise and compatibility wise as well.

  • 18 years ago

    Just don't let a 6'4" man loose in a Lazy-Boy store with a blank check and a fabric swatch for reference.

    Like another poster puts it so well...I'm just saying.

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with Auntjen that it is disrespectful towards one's partner to make major decorating decisions without his input IF, indeed he actually wants input, some people don't. With my husband, I narrow down color choices to 3 to 5 colors, and ask him which one he likes the best. Then we discuss it, but since the colors I present to him are one's I already like, I have no problem acceding to his choice. This makes both of us feel empowered. One thing I've learned NOT to do is bring out the BM fandeck and have him look through that. When he sees the fandeck or a large stack of paint color chips, he runs out the back door.

  • 18 years ago

    My dh hates any kind of change - at first. Then after a year or so he'll say, "You know, that was a really smart idea..." After 19 years I'm starting to figure him out! So for the most part I do what Miles said.

    The hard part for me is that there are some things that I am not strong/tall enough to do myself, or that require 2 people, and it's hard to get dh to help out with a project that he is not sold on, or worse, thinks is a complete waste of time. (We define "waste of time" very differently.) Or the projects that are going to cause a great deal of inconvenience (I'm waging a New Kitchen Floor battle at the moment.) Then I tend to put projects on hold and it is, like you said, stifling. ~sigh~

    I can't offer much advice, but I do empathize.

  • 18 years ago

    "Just don't let a 6'4" man loose in a Lazy-Boy store with a blank check and a fabric swatch for reference"

    LOL! Over the years, I have discovered that I can assuage my DH's desire to have input by narrowing the choices and asking him to choose the best out of 2-3 options (all of which I like). He gets to choose, I get what I want, we're both happy. :)

  • 18 years ago

    I make the decision, run it by DH just in case he has another significant viewpoint I hadn't thought of. Yes, it does happen from time to time. Then I go with it. I don't consult him on color matters. His perception of color is way off. LOL

    My DH ask for very little so I let him have his TV and I ensure he has a comfortable chair to fall asleep in. That's how easy he is.

  • 18 years ago

    "Over the years, I have discovered that I can assuage my DH's desire to have input by narrowing the choices and asking him to choose the best out of 2-3 options (all of which I like). He gets to choose, I get what I want, we're both happy. :)"

    Sheer brilliance!!!!

  • 18 years ago

    "Over the years, I have discovered that I can assuage my DH's desire to have input by narrowing the choices and asking him to choose the best out of 2-3 options (all of which I like). He gets to choose, I get what I want, we're both happy. :)"

    That's how I treated my toddlers....

  • 18 years ago

    "That's how I treated my toddlers..."

    And your point?

  • 18 years ago

    DH and I have similar taste. Well, when I'm not in one of my modern moods, anyway (I'm a design schitzophrenic). I enjoy more color than he does, but we always find a solution that works for both of us. I've only repainted one room at his request once. It was the dining room, and for some reason Pepto-bismal pink bothered him. So I repainted the next week.

    For us, design is a stupid reason to fight, argue, or waste energy bickering about. We never make major purchases without agreement, and that includes furniture, TVs, and other household items. And if I get a hankering to paint something a wild color he can't live with, I just repaint until we're both happy. As long as everything is serving its purpose, neither one of us is unhappy if it's a little "off" design-wise. One thing we both are in 100% agreement- those design shows where the owners state specifically that they watch TV in that room, and the finished design has NO seating facing the TV! Why put the seating in the room if you're not going to allow it to fulfill its purpose? Or the TV for that matter?

  • 18 years ago

    I had to laugh about turning your DH loose in a Lazy-boy store. But since we are both retired, we both enjoy kicking back our recliners and watching TV....we have worked enough years and are entitled to it now. I was shocked when we actually went to a larger city and spent a lot of time in a Lazy-boy Gallery.....and shock!!! we did find two recliners that "fit" both of us....didn't think this would ever happen. He is addicted to TV...we even have one in the bathroom...8 in the house....so that is "big" to him, so in the LR, we have it in a built-in cabinet...when I don't want to see that big black box, I just shut the doors on it....works for me~~

  • 18 years ago

    Like Meghane, my dh and I have similar taste. I always ask his opinion. Usually, he doesn't care: "Sure. Fine. Whatever you like." Every once in a while: "No. I don't like that at all." I just wish I understood why he doesn't like plaid?

  • 18 years ago

    My DH is high maintenance but thinks he's low maintenance. He thinks he's easy but, every once in a while, he'll come up with some surprise pronouncement that shocks me--and makes me go back to the design board.

    So far:
    "I don't like paisley."
    "You're not talking about something that looks like that hideous brown thing we saw earlier today, are you?" (Which, btw, was a brown tufted ottoman and was EXACTLY what I was talking about.)
    "Absolutely no reclining sofas."

    And the list goes on. He says he doesn't care but, in his heart he does. I just can't read his mind.

  • 18 years ago

    DH would have thought he died and went to heaven if he had a reclining sofa.

  • 18 years ago

    Interesting discussion. My DH and I have been married 33 years and still retain individual interests that may overlap at different times depending on attention spans. I'm a gardener and he loves to restore cars--which is fine if I can drive them.

    When I shop for fabrics, I'm on my own. His response to the projects varies depending on how much he has to do. In the last few days he has had to hang the new scarf in the dining room (the top of the window is 12 ft high and my scarf is 8 yd long). He won't let me on the 13 ft ladder--its a matter of my balance. I warned him that the installation was tedious and frustrating. No, he would do it. After 3 hours his back gave out. He is 6'3", I'm 5'2" and much smaller feet, luckily! The next day I climbed up the ladder and finished the details. He held the ladder. He loves the result .... I'm amazed in it. That fabric took on a life of its own. He didn't have an expectation of what the end result would be. I did and it didn't look like my eye's view. But it's pretty cool. I think.

    When its furniture, we shop together. Our taste is close enough that we are comfortable with the other's selections. In shopping for a contemporary buffet, we ended up in the odds and ends room of a high-end retailer. He was shocked at my selection, but I signed the contract and he smiled. Mahogany next to the Italian marble. Guess so. Looks great. Lets just say they complement each other.

    Pick your battles and compromise when you must. It is a partnership!

  • 18 years ago

    My DH does not like curtains.

    I finally went ahead and bought some for my two guest rooms and he seemed fine with them, but refuses to let me put curtains in the living room, dining room and our bedroom, all of which desperately need them.

    When I saw a posting, on this board, about a sale on silk drapes at Jcpenney, I took a look and found the perfect style and color for my main rooms. They are really a bargain, but my DH said no! :(

  • 18 years ago

    Oh Newhomebuilder - that would definitely be cause for a huge battle with me. Does he not want them because you don't need them for privacy or because he doesn't want to cover up window trim? Is he against WT's that mount inside the window and can be pulled up during the day so they're not all that obvious?

  • 18 years ago

    It is better to ask forgiveness than to ask permission.

    I speak only for myself, but for the most part (with the exception of emergencies, and IMO absolutely nothing in decorating is truly an emergency), this is a really effective way to p*ss me off.

    Over the years, I have discovered that I can assuage my DH's desire to have input by narrowing the choices and asking him to choose the best out of 2-3 options (all of which I like). He gets to choose, I get what I want, we're both happy. :)

    Works same way in our house, I do the research and narrow down to a few options, all of which I like just fine, because he gets overloaded and grumpy. He is actually REALLY into this particular house and wants to be in on everything to some degree, and he's fanatically fussy about color (his mother was an artist and he practically absorbed color theory in utero). Sometimes, though, the things that he chooses out of the options I've given him are SO not what I would expect and are somehow just the ticket, so even after 14 years he can still surprise me. F'rinstance, the embroidered purple silk drapes ended up not working in our LR (*sob*) so I went to Country Curtains and loaded up on swatches. Frankly, I took one of everything that I thought would go with the rug we have, even some rather iffy ones, knowing how colors change in different lighting conditions. I unthinkingly left them on the coffee table, planning to weed them down later, and that evening entered the room to find DH going through them. He chose two options - both of them from my "dubious" category - for the LR AND BOTH WERE PINK (okay, more salmon-y, but they're still pink, d@mmit), and LACE for the DR! LACE, I tell you! I don't have them yet because of budgetary shufflings, but the CC clerk encouraged me to purchase-and-return and peculiar choices they may be, they're spot on. So instead of the more Victorianesque eggplant/olive/deep gold I had planned we're actually heading more toward an Edwardian/Aesthetic Movement salmon/sage/light mustard - still saturated (I loathe pastels) but not as dark. Verrrrry interesting.

  • 18 years ago

    pam14 - We have hardwood blinds and beautiful trim on all windows. I just want the curtains to soften the look. Basically, DH does not want to spend money when not necessary.

  • 18 years ago

    My husband can't visualize much so keeping everything the way it is seems safe to him. I tried the asking forgiveness and not permission route we were first married and it caused some of our biggest and only arguments. I now respect his desire to have a say even if he's clueless about what he is saying!

    So I also do the three choices and let him help pick. Most of the time anyway. He has also learned to trust my decisions and taste which leaves him uninvolved in the majority of decorating issues.

    Now, the price of things! That is another story. We adopt military policy here: Don't ask, don't tell.

  • 18 years ago

    Back to my OP with the TV issue . . .I tried convincing DH to move the TV (I cannot move it myself) to another wall, a corner, another room (convert the non-used playroom to a family room), and it was NO, NO, NO. It is really discouraging.

    I have come a long way since we were married. I used to think DH SHOULD have a huge say in how things were decorated. Heck, we put an offer on this house with me only seeing the pictures, and he was the only one who saw it in person. When we got a living room rug in our apt., he went and picked it out (asked me on the phone, what color do you want?). He had often more than an equal say in what we got, simply because it was easier for him to go out shopping than for me-- because then he'd have to stay with the children, and going out all together was tough.

    HOWEVER, that has all changed. Why? Because, as I said before, my DH truly does not notice the house unless it isn't functional. On the other hand, I notice EVERYTHING, and I am home all day. I am much more affected by color, lighting, decorating, etc. than he will ever be. Sometimes I think it is a misfortune to be that way.

    Example: he happily installed a horrible little LED light the other day in our living room . . .it cast a terrible blue light-- made it look like we were growing plants. Very cold. Ick! I said no way, we have to take that light back. (In the past, I would have left it, and said, "Things should be equal.")

    Now as I tell my DD, fair doesn't mean equal. If DH is buying something for the computer, or some other technical gadget, I defer to him-- he has the knowledge, and he actually cares. I do not. Should I have an "opinion" and a say even though I have no knowledge and am utterly unaffected by the decision? That would be silly.

    The TV thing for us boils down to the classic form vs. function, only in this case, even the function is up for debate, which I think is what makes it a hard call.

  • 18 years ago

    My DH is a sweetheart and says my tastes are better than his so do what I like. Also, he's too busy to be bothered with "trivial" decorating decisions. BUT -- he has worked his rear end off to make a nice lifestyle for us, so as a courtesy, I always run it by him whenever I want to make a big expenditure. And if he says he doesn't want to spend the money right now, then I put the project on the shelf.

  • 18 years ago

    Newhomebuilder - Here I was thinking your windows were absolutely bare - glad that's not the issue. I think you have the classic husband attitude (or, my husband's attitude, at times) - "Why replace something if it's still working?" "Ummm, because I'm sick of looking at _______ (fill in the blank), because we've had it for 15 years." If it's a matter of spending money, I have had very good luck buying high quality custom window treatments on eBay for a fraction of their original price. Case in point - I bought custom draperies from someone who had them in her home for about a year. She said she paid about $2000 to have them made. Her reason for selling...she had very high windows in her family room and these window treatments were made to be hung in a manner that didn't cover the window all the way to the top. Well, her husband complained that because they didn't cover the windows completely, they didn't block the glare from the sun and the glare hit the TV (funny how this is a TV issue, huh?). Sooooo, instead of moving the TV, it was okay with him that she sold them on eBay. I got the whole set for about $500 (had to pay a seamstress $100 to hem them). So they flushed $1500 down the drain because of the TV! Of course, I didn't mind, because now I have beautiful window treatments (and she threw in 4 matching custom pillows, to boot). In a million years, my husband would never agree to pay $2000 for window treatments. There are two more panels than what is shown in the pic below.

    Anele - I know in your original post, you said you weren't looking for help with your specific situation, but it sounds as if you're frustrated and could use some new ideas as to what to do with that space. I bet if you post a pic of the space, you'll get some wonderful ideas from the people on this forum.

  • 18 years ago

    My DH resists change. He's also an architect's son, so he thinks he's more aesthetically aware than I am. (His father really likes lots of mustard-gold walls and/or ceilings, just to give you a sense of the specifics. I don't.)

    Whenever I shift things in the house, DH balks. We fight about it. Then, a month or so later, he tells me ruefully that he likes it. Then he starts claiming to friends (with a wink) that it was all his idea in the first place.

    Happily, we mostly agree on furniture, and he has saved me from some expensive and hasty purchases in the past. He's also been very patient with driving all over hither and yon for Craigslist wild goose chases.

    So, IRL, here's how it works. I am our decor shopper; I bring possibilities (lamps, paint swatches, curtains) home for him to veto. Sometimes I override his veto, but rarely. We shop for furniture together, and we collaborate well on that. He has really good ideas for home renovation stuff: if it weren't for him our tiny DR and tiny LR would still be divided by massive, ugly pseudo-oak bookcases. I do much of the legwork in terms of finding contractors; he does most of the supervising. That kind of thing. Not without conflict, and sometimes we both feel stifled and/or impatient with the slowness of a collective as opposed to an individual, but overall the collaborative model works well for us.

  • 18 years ago

    I find that humor is the only thing that helps at a time like this.

  • 18 years ago

    My friend almost got divorced because her DH wouldn't let her paint the house. She cried she whined she threatened she left him (for couple days). This girl has been living with white walls for 10 years (the duration of their marriage) and got so fed up w/ it. So I can sympathize your feelings of frustration.

    WE used to fight like cats & dogs a/b remodeling issues but now DH has come to realize it's pointless to stop me from this 'madness'. :-) He said he doesn't care enough a/b decorating to risk our marriage (or a good dinner) for it. :-)

  • 18 years ago

    I can tell you that dh and I often have very different ideas on how things should be done. Sometimes I put ideas out there and give them time to grow on him. Some times I tell him how important something is to me and often times he is willing to experiment and get out of his comfort zone. Sometimes he absolutely does not agree. During those times, I look myself in the mirror and tell myself I have to let it go and find some other way to meet the challenge.

Sponsored
Wannemacher Interiors
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars26 Reviews
Customized Award-Winning Interior Design Solutions in Franklin Cnty OH